This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Problem Of Free Will Essay

2334 words - 10 pages

In the following essay I will describe the problem of free will and explain several different responses to the problem. These responses will be derived from the determinist, libertarian, and compatibilist views. I will end the essay by arguing that the compatibilist view seems to best address the problem of free will, but does not necessarily solve it.
The problem of free will arises from two conflicting ideas. The first idea is that people have free will. Having free will means that people have the ability to choose and act on what they would like to do. Most people seem accept this idea easily and live their lives believing that to some extent they are in control of the choices they ...view middle of the document...

Concerning determinism, the absence of free will seems to result in people like Bob being stuck on “pre-determined paths” with no control over their future, decisions, or actions (Conee and Sider 113). Therefore under the idea of determinism we could not blame Bob earlier for cheating because he did not actually choose to cheat on his own. Instead, determinism would trace his choice to cheat backwards. For example, maybe Bob was not paying attention when the professor said that notes would not be allowed on the test and that is why he used his notes. Perhaps, Bob was not paying attention to his professor because he was very tired. Perhaps he was tired because he could not fall asleep the night before because his neighbors were playing loud music all night. Determinism could go back even further than that reason because it assumes there are no uncaused events.
Determinists and libertarians respond to the problem of free will by accepting only one of the two ideas discussed earlier. The determinist response holds that the idea of free will cannot be true if “every event has a cause” (Conee and Sider 113). The determinist Paul Rée argued for the idea of every event having a cause by relating examples of a stone, donkey, and murderer. For his stone example, Rée explains how a stone laying on the ground has many “potential states” such as going into the air, becoming dust, or moving along the ground, but for any of those things to happen something must throw the rock in the air, crush it, or force it to move (Rée 337). He also describes how a donkey standing between two haystacks also has “potential states” like the stone (Rée 337). The donkey could choose to eat hay from left or the right haystack, but that would depend on a number of things. For example, one haystack might have smelled better than the other, or one haystack was slightly closer to the donkey. Therefore, the donkey’s choice of one haystack over the other was not caused by the donkey freely choosing it, but rather from others causes, such as the placement of the haystack. Rée argues that people are much like the rock and the donkey, in that, people’s actions are caused by other things. He uses an example of murderer by explaining the cause of the murder could have been influenced by a number of things, such as the murderer’s physiological state (e.g. blood temperature) or how the victim looked at the time (Rée 337).
According to Rée and other determinists, people cannot be praised or blamed because their actions are not done freely and are caused by other factors. Although, currently society still blames and praises people for their actions (Conee and Sider 118). This is a drawback to the determinist response because it would mean all people would have to stop blaming or praising others. Ultimately, society’s justice system would need to be restructured because it would have no grounds to determine a person guilty or innocent. Also, another drawback is that all people would have...

Find Another Essay On the problem of free will

The Free Will of Macbeth Essay

816 words - 3 pages The Free Will of Macbeth      Destiny "Destiny is not a matter of chance, it is a matter of choice; it is not a thing to be waited for, it is a thing to be achieved." (William Jennings Bryan) Are we in control of our own destiny, our own fate, or are our lives really already planned and mapped out for us? Does Macbeth willfully choose evil in order to achieve his "destiny"? Or, is his "destiny" doomed by the witches' prophecies

The Problem of Free Choice Essay

1586 words - 6 pages , in this essay I am not attempting to make the rather bold statement of offering a solution to the problem of free choice, but rather, to offer a description of two main contemporary positions in the problem - which will be determinism and compatibalism - and to state which position I find more attractive, and the reasons as to why I am attracted to it.Before a description of the two positions however, there must be a mutual understanding of what

Destiny, Fate, Free Will and Free Choice in Oedipus the King - The Paradox of Free Will

1315 words - 5 pages A Paradox: Oedipus's Free will in the Play Oedipus Rex William Shakespeare once wrote, "Who can control his fate?" (Othello, Act v, Sc.2). A hero and leader must acknowledge above all else his honor, and the pride of his image.  In ancient Greek beliefs, a hero was a man who stood taller than the rest; he was able to better any conflict.  He did this not for himself or for any token award that may be given to him, but for the security of

The Question of Free Will Versus Fate

1164 words - 5 pages The question of free will--the idea that we are free to make decisions unhindered by external forces--is very disconcerting to deal with because most people are not willing to accept that we are not in control of our lives. It is also controversial because it wrestles with the idea of a world possibly without moral responsibility. If there is no free will how do we hold a person responsible for molesting someone or for stealing? If someone

The Imposition of Law as Free Will

3668 words - 15 pages The Imposition of Law as Free Will The Myth of the Social Contract The Social Contract is defined to be the method by which a people agree to the systematic limitation of their rights for the purpose of gaining governmental protection. It is the theory that all people agree to the imposition of law and the restriction of their personal freedoms in exchange for safety. The founding tenet of the Social Contract is that people agree to the

Critiquing the Notion of Free Will

1488 words - 6 pages Free will is defined as "the partial freedom of the agent, in acts of conscious choice, from the determining compulsion of heredity, environment and circumstance" ( this paper I will ultimately attempt to show that the concept of free will as it is previously defined is in fact a false premise. The free will of any person to make any truly "free" decision is merely an illusory concept. To prove this position, I

Existence of Free Will

1636 words - 7 pages will. Preference of knowledge over ignorance is meaningful only in the context of propositional logic and choice. Thus, free will along with propositional logic form the basis of human knowledge. If some statement contradicts to free will, that would be a problem of that statement and not of free will. Much of our common sense is contradictory. Paradoxes are solved by removing false common-sense assumptions. One paradox is that of logical

Lack of Free Will

1375 words - 6 pages In Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness one important theme in the novel is predetermined fate. The lack of free will that Marlow exhibits points to a driving sense that he has only one way out of the jungle. Marlow's only mission is to find Kurtz. Tunnel vision captures Marlow's psyche and his want of destruction is only rivaled by his need to find Kurtz. Heart of Darkness exemplifies the absurdist and existentialist viewpoints that reside in

The Free Will

1328 words - 6 pages If the above mentioned cognitive skills are impaired, it is assumed that the person is unable to express her free will. This condition is called mental or neurodegenerative disorder. Many disabilities are caused by apoplexy, organic (Alzheimer's disease, Korsakoff's syndrome) or traumatic damages or by lesions of the cerebral cortex of different localization. But most often they arise from the frontal lobe pathology, acompanied by changes in

Compatibility of Free Will in The Tenseless Theory of Time

2424 words - 10 pages , The debate between free will and fatalism has existed since the conceptualization of time. On one hand, in everyday life, time flows in a uniform fashion. People experience time in which there is a past, present, and a future. Yet, physicists and philosophers see time as something completely different. In fact, they see time as an illusion. Called the tenseless theory of time, time does not flow but this theory views time as a fourth dimension

Damn the Fates - the question of Free Will

1452 words - 6 pages D.T. Suzuki, a renowned expert on Zen Buddhism, called attention to the topic of free will in one of his lectures by stating that it was the battle of 'God versus Man, Man versus God, God versus Nature, Nature versus God, Man versus Nature, Nature versus Man1.' These six battles constitute an ultimately greater battle: the battle of free will versus determinism. Free will is that ability for a human being to make decisions as to what life he or

Similar Essays

The Problem With Free Will Essay

1602 words - 6 pages ( some events must be uncaused) hold a possible demonstration of free will, the problem occurs with the determinist theory of how cause and effect is applied to every action that takes place, if preceding events or ideas influence everything then how can free will exist?. Indeterminists will however point out that some advances in physics may give an indication of a refutation of determinism. They claim that " the work in quantum mechanics

What's The Problem With Free Will?

1007 words - 5 pages Free Will This planet contains many forms of life from the birds in the air to the fish in the sea and everything in between. Each with their own set of instincts governing functions, primarily those of reproduction and survival. As humans, we believe that we are different; that we posses a capacity for higher-level brain function that allows human activity outside the parameters of primal, base instinct. As evidence, mankind has been able to

Addressing The Problem Of Evil In On Free Choice Of The Will By Augustine

2268 words - 10 pages In “On Free Choice of the Will”, Augustine indicates the importance of his beliefs and opinions of human nature and of God. He thinks as greatly of God as possible and centralizes his thoughts of goodness with the concept of being/form (God); he also gives a description of how God’s rightness can be interpreted clearly through the evil doings of the world. One of the biggest and most difficult problems facing people is the problem

The Illusion Of Free Will Essay

1180 words - 5 pages independent decision is known as free will. Some biologist say that free will is just an illusion like Cashmore. What you call a conscious intention is more predictable than a cause of your behavior. When you have a conscious experience of deciding to move our hand or feet, the behavior is already starting to happen. Other biologist and philosophers reply that you do make decisions, in the sense that something within you initiates the action. Even though