This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Problem Of Silicon Breast Implants

2381 words - 10 pages

The 30 year long silicon breast implant litigation saga is as upsetting to learn about as it is hard to believe. Considering the scale and the scope of legal awards that exceeded 4.2 billion dollars in total, and the fact that it brought one of Americas largest corporations to the brink of bankruptcy, it is hard to conceive that this all transpired over a voluntary, elective surgical procedure with no medical value whatsoever.
The first anecdotal reporting of breast augmentation comes from Japan after the second world war. Japanese prostitutes were reported to have injected themselves with paraffin, sponges, and non medical grade silicon, believing that American soldiers were attracted to women with larger breasts. It was not until the sixties that the first medical silicon breast implant was developed for plastic surgical use (Angell 1513). Throughout the sixties and early seventies, silicon breast implants were used safely with few reported problems, with the exception of some reports of localized scar tissue hardening in some cases. Silicon was also regularly used (and still is) to lubricate syringes and in many food processing applications. It was generally believed that silicon was safe for the human body, and, by the time that the FDA began to look into it in 1976, there was no clinical data to support or contradict this. Implants were presumed to be safe as they had been on the market for years with few reported problems as had been the many other medical devices containing silicon that were also being used(Angell 1514-1515)(Worthington, Stallard, Price, Goss 163-164)
It was not until the 80's that some anecdotal reports of illness related to the use of silicon in breast augmentations began to trickle in. It was mainly from overseas and regarding the direct injection of silicon, as opposed to the use of implants, but it was the first reporting of any link between silicon and connective tissue disease. This again raised the attention of the FDA which began to require implant manufacturers provide evidence of their safety in order to keep them on the market. It was perhaps with this gap in evidence, along with the first award of damages to plaintiff Maria Stern for the amount of $211,000, that opened the door to the feeding frenzy of litigation that was to follow. A San Francisco jury found her autoimmune disease to have been caused by her silicon breast implants though there was no scientific evidence to support this (Angell 1514)(Worthington, Stallard, Price, Goss 164-165).
In Maria Stern's case, and in the cases to follow, there was little more than anecdotal evidence and questionable science to back up the claims, but the jury in her case, and those to follow in thousands of other cases were convinced to find against the makers of implants. As related in a paper by legal and medical scholars Worthington, Stallard, Price, and Goss:
“Starting with a 1982 case from Japan, a series of reports hypothesized that
silicon breast...

Find Another Essay On The Problem of Silicon Breast Implants

Nano Computing & the Future of Silicon

1232 words - 5 pages trying to just research the other computational technologies is because we know what we can do with silicon and we know it can be commercially available and cheap to use. The positive effects of using multi-core processors are we can keep adding additional cores to increase processing capabilities once the limits of scaling traditional silicon have been reached. Summary of the Determination of Main Points & Discussion We have also learned

Overview of the Treatment of Breast Cancer

2269 words - 9 pages Introduction In the United States, breast cancer is one of the most commonly occurring cancers in women. Within the year of 2011, 230,480 new cases and 39,520 deaths related to breast cancer were reported (National Cancer Institute, 2011). However, death rates from breast cancer have declined steadily since 1990, resulting in an increase in survivors. The American Cancer society reported in 2011, that there were around 2.6 million breast cancer

The breast place of the highest priest

9485 words - 38 pages the scripture seems to speak of them as things well known; and an inquiry into them is nowhere forbidden; therefore we shall attempt it at this time.There has been a variety of opinions concerning them, which particularly to enumerate, and enter into the consideration of, would be both tedious, and to little purpose, one thinks that these two words, Urim and Thummim were engraven on a stone, or a plate of gold, and put into the breast-plate, even

The Issues of Breast Cancer in Nigeria

1616 words - 6 pages problem present in Nigeria. Looking at the HIV/AIDS crisis in Nigeria, the awareness of the problem and its solutions were the very first step used in tackling HIV/AIDS in Nigeria. Health organisations in Nigeria held thousand of seminars and talks in schools, on radio stations and television programmes to discuss the ABC (abstinence, be faithful and the use of condom) strategy (Bola, 14). Why aren’t similar strategies used to tackle breast cancer in

The Risk Factors of Breast Cancer

1557 words - 6 pages person’s life is altered forever. Breast cancer does not discriminate and can happen to anyone at any age. To prevent this disease, one must take the necessary precautions to lower the risk factors. In fact, there are several local and national events to remind people of breast cancer’s existence. Many people do not know this, but there are numerous ways that they can protect themselves against this disease or find the ailment early enough that it

The properties of glass explained by the bonding of Silicon and Oxygen

556 words - 2 pages The properties of glass lie within the bonding structure of silicon. Silicon cannot form strong ð bonds with oxygen by using its valency 3p orbitals. This is because of the large nuclear radius of the silicon atom and its orbitals which results in a less effective overlap with the smaller oxygen orbitals. The silicon atoms then form four single bonds to satisfy the octet rule. Therefore, instead of forming a SiO2 covalent molecule, it will form

The AC Electrical Characterization of Au/Porous Silicon/p-Si Structures

670 words - 3 pages The AC electrical characterization of Au/porous silicon/p-Si structures is presented. The low porosity Porous Silicon layers were prepared by electrochemical etching in p-type silicon <100> with two resistivities. The AC electrical measurements capacitance – conductance – frequency were performed from 5Hz to 10MHz, at room temperature in the DC range of ± 2V. We studied two structures; first a conductor type Au/PS/Au and second diode type Au/PS

The Problem of Aliteracy

2245 words - 9 pages the United States. The thought of reading for pleasure is an unquestionable idea to most of the young generation who would rather spend their time with other faster stress relieving tasks, or they are a slave to their reading or homework assignments. Aliteracy is an unknown problem facing most young adults, but what makes a person aliterate is it having alternative methods of entertainment, or finding reading boring, and what are the reasons

The Problem of Evil

5631 words - 23 pages this tradition, does not exist - for, if He did, He would prevent the evil. This inference is called the Problem of Evil by those who profess one of the religions in the Judaeo-Christian tradition, and their attempts to 'solve' the problem have given rise to a labyrinth of sophistry. Put briefly, the solution most commonly espoused to the Problem of Evil is * Some suffering is caused by others' misuse of their own free-will (as in murder

the problem of induction

813 words - 4 pages From the observed to the unobserved: David Hume The Problem of Induction. According to Hume, this style of reasoning is logically valid. Logically valid inferences state that if the premises are true then the conclusions must be true. Or better yet, if you accept the premises, you must accept the conclusions. There is no way for the premises to be true and the conclusions to be false. However, this is not really the case because using a priori

The Problem of Evil

2030 words - 9 pages The problem of evil has been a question that philosophers have been trying to answer for centuries. It simply states that if God exists and is perfect and all-powerful then why evil does exist in our world. Two great philosophers named Gottfried Leibniz and Nicolas Malebranche attempt to answer this question with their own unique solutions. Although they both answer the same question they have drastically different views. Specifically, they

Similar Essays

Silicon Or Saline This Essay Debates The Current Event Issue Of Which Breast Implant Is Safer, Silicon Or Saline, And If The Fda Should Lift The Ban Off Of Silicon Implants Completely

1179 words - 5 pages Recently, the Food and Drug Administration has recommended that silicone breast implants should be allowed back on the market. A ban was put on the implantation of silicon breasts about eleven years ago because of the initial health problems that were resulting from them. This issue has become one that is very controversial because many women are not sure if they should take a chance and embark on the new silicone gel-filled breast implants or

"The Role Of The Media In The Public Understanding Of Health Issues" Breast Cancer & Silicone Implants

2020 words - 8 pages In this paper, the writer shall debate the issue of whether or not the media play a significant role, in contributing to the publics' education of breast and other cancers, due to silicone gel breast implants, and the strategies used, if any, to promote public awareness. The reason for the writer's interest in this subject is that writer had silicone breast implants, which leaked, whereupon a second operation was undergone to remove them. The

The Development Of Biomedical Implants And Prosthetics

1465 words - 6 pages designed to provide basic functionality and more pleasing appearances, advancements in biomedical technology have paved the way for futuristic bionic prostheses. The incorporation of microprocessors, computer chips, neural sensors and robotics have revolutionized the prostheses industry by creating bionic implants that can not only restore function and motility to amputees but also increase the range of human physical ability which in turn expands

Nano Computing And The Future Of Silicon

2135 words - 9 pages We are coming to the end of advancement in traditional silicon-based computation; therefore we should utilize non-traditional silicon. While there are other alternatives, currently none of them are commercially available or developed in any realistically usable way like silicon is. Currently we have been able to successfully prototype a variety of methods for non-traditional silicon based technologies such as 3D chip stacking and multi-core