The Problem Of Vouchers And School Choice

1138 words - 5 pages

The Problem of School Choice

Is it right to force students to attend the schools prescribed for them by geography? Is it fair to deny students who live in poorer neighborhoods the chance to go to better schools with better facilities, better teachers and safer conditions? Should we allow our tax revenues to leave our school districts for greener pastures? Should we permit schools poor in both resources and performance to wither on the vine, an acceptable casualty of competition?


Because of dissatisfaction with many public schools, particularly those in large urban settings, a movement to allow students to choose alternatives to their assigned schools has sprung up in various parts of the country and abroad. Proponents argue that competition for students (and their attendent tax revenues) will automatically make all schools better. They point to towns in Vermont who have no schools of their own and allow all their students to pick from surrounding public and private schools, applying their tax dollars to those entities. They talk about the successes of magnet schools and charter schools and link the school choice concept to our basic rights under the Constitution.


What kind of American would argue with that? What kind of capitalist would disagree with the beneficial effect on performance brought about by competition? Who wouldn't love the idea that students could pick their schools based on quality or experience of teachers, special offerings or curricula? Who doesn't cringe when they see images on television of graffiti-scarred inner city schools with bars on the windows and fear in the eyes of their students? Wouldn't we all want to see students escape these schools?


Of course we would. But let's consider why some schools in some neighborhoods have fallen so far. One problem is that our society has stopped seeing public education as something that benefits the whole community. As our populace ages, especially in small, old towns, more and more voters begrudge spending on schools, students and teachers. School board candidates, knowing who votes, campaign as "taxpayer advocates" much more often than they run as "student advocates." The voters want to pay as little as possible and get acceptable results. For many of them, acceptable results means graduating most of their students with as few problems as possible. Innovation is seen as an expensive, unproven luxury that taxpayers on fixed incomes cannot afford. Buildings are maintained at the lowest possible functional level; aesthetic improvements rank very low in budget priorities.


In inner city schools, a smaller proportion of the cost of educating students comes from local tax revenues; more comes from state sources. If there's one iron-clad truth it's that, as much as taxpayers dislike paying taxes to support their local schools, they hate their tax dollars going to schools outside their community even more. So the impoverished schools are...

Find Another Essay On The Problem of Vouchers and School Choice

School Vouchers: Parents Need a Choice

4626 words - 19 pages choice for students and parents. School vouchers will level the educational playing field in many communities across America. Voucher systems are designed to give parents a choice when considering schools for their children. With many of our public schools considered failing, parents will receive a certificate for a predetermined amount to supplement educational costs for parochial/private schools. It is my strong opinion that school

Vouchers and School Choice - First Step Towards a Discriminatory Educational System

1936 words - 8 pages School Vouchers:  The First Step Towards a Discriminatory Educational System On November 9, 1998, Jennifer Marshall, Education Policy Analyst for the Family Research Council, declared in a press statement: "Parental choice in education just got a green light from the Supreme Court." Her statement came as a response to the decision made the same day by the Supreme Court to deny a petition for a writ of certiorari in Jackson v. Benton, a

The Effectiveness of Private School Vouchers

1358 words - 5 pages higher in public schools. Professor Sarah Lubienski states that for year’s studies have shown that being in a private school with a smaller setting would make students more successful but that in all honesty that could be the problem because they are missing out on many of the things that public schools have and offer (US Public Schools). Could it be that private schools do not follow the same curriculum that public schools follow? The U.S

The Problem of Free Choice

1586 words - 6 pages The problem of free choice is in essence a fundamental question of whether we have the ability to make choices or not? Though the answer may seem simple at first glance, the answer is much more complicated than it may intuitively seem. To support this claim, although this problem can be traced back to the Greek and Roman era, today it remains in virtually the same state as it did back then, and is still without an adequate solution. Therefore

Pros and Cons of Inner City School Vouchers

1812 words - 7 pages by the government to send their children to a school of choice, whether that school is public, private or religious (School Vouchers). In effect, it separates the government financing of education from the government operation of schools. Sweden and the U.K. both have an educational voucher system in place (School Vouchers). Another form of vouchers is the means tested school voucher program. “Within the United States Cleveland, Milwaukee

School Vouchers are the Solution

1673 words - 7 pages present system is unable to grant the education that it has always promised and much of the money utilized in bringing about improvement is wasted. This is where, I feel, the market-system, with its abundant, competitive suppliers of education can bring about a change, where modern tuition vouchers will take care of any financial assistance crucial to keeping the system going. School vouchers are a form of scholarship, which transmits the flow

School Vouchers are NOT the Solution

1178 words - 5 pages that the Establishment Clause requires that “no tax in any amount large or small… be levied to support any religious activities or institutions.” (School Vouchers: The Wrong Choice, 2001). However, in a recent ruling, the Supreme Court found that the school voucher program in Cleveland does not infringe upon the constitutional separation of church and state. This ruling is detrimental to opponents of voucher programs. Vouchers use taxpayer money

The Problem of School Violence

916 words - 4 pages Columbine High School, April 20, 1999 was the scene of a massacre, but in wake of this massacre America experienced an epiphany. Tragically, this was not the last we would here about crimes of a similar nature to this one. From 1996 to 2000 an unprecedented slew of violence occurred. There were twelve incidents which received national coverage and left many millions more questioning what happened, what went wrong, where did this come from. This

School Choice is the Future of Education

785 words - 3 pages As a proponent of school choice, I see it as one of the reform movements that has a real chance of changing education for the better here in the United States. School choice, if implemented correctly, would give parents and children the opportunity to choose the type of school that they feel best meets their educational needs. They would also be in a position to demand excellence in every way from that school. School choice is a much debated

Examining Causes of School Violence and Solutions to the Problem

1766 words - 7 pages , especially in school. Did you ever wonder why schools have so much violence? But people always want to know what really cause children to fight and argue? It’s really because children take violence into their own hands. Usually the innocent children are the ones involved in the violence. Instead of solving the problems students will fight. All the dangerous places in the world, such as places with wars and violence, you would think that a place

The Admissions Committee would like to learn why you are a good fit for your undergraduate school choice (College of Arts and Sciences, School of ...

635 words - 3 pages While in high school I watched a Biomedical lecture of Yale University and recalled the professor saying that most people of today benefited from living longer when compared people alive in the early 1800s or prior to that time. He mentioned that due to the lack of technology and hence scarcity of research and knowledge people died of many illnesses which would have been curable in today’s society. This was the first time I have heard this

Similar Essays

Vouchers And School Choice Beats No Choice

842 words - 3 pages maximize their learning success.   The ideal choice program, in my opinion, would comprise vouchers, drawn from the child's home district and not exceeding the average amount spent locally per student. A voucher or draft is awarded upon the completion of an in depth interview of both student and parents, guardian or assigned mentor and an interview board consisting of school board and local business representatives, and nominated tax payers

A Case For Vouchers And School Choice

1063 words - 4 pages the country, and Washington must consider school choice as a remedy for the ailing public school system.   The author of this article feels confident in asserting that the public school system in this nation is failing miserably in its attempt to prepare youth for competition in the twenty-first century. Half of the nation does not feel that a high school diploma is a guarantee of the recipient's basic skills in reading and math. In fact

School Vouchers: A Harmful Choice Essay

3089 words - 12 pages in the 1930's. Problems remain over time, but their source is not public education (Lewis 203). While choice seems beneficial in theory, school choice through the use of vouchers will only worsen the condition of public schools in the long run. Vouchers have become a diversion, as they do nothing to absolve class size, teacher training, outdated and overcrowded buildings, and unequal funding (Voucher Talking Points 1). For every voucher used

Vouchers And School Choice More Effective Than Affirmative Action

797 words - 3 pages based on equality of opportunity. The best way to accomplish this is to implement a nationwide program of school choice.   A school choice program at the elementary and secondary level would produce revolutionary results. The underclass (all races) would gain the opportunity to develop the skills necessary to enter the middle class. A school choice-based educational system would help break the cycle of poverty and give parents the