The Problem With Determinism And The Benefits Of Taylor's Theory Of Agency. 900 Words. Bibilogeraphy

922 words - 4 pages

In Metaphysics Richard Taylor outlines the different views on the concept of freedom.The traditional view is that of the compatibilists which states that freedom is the ability to act, or not to act, according to the determinations of the will. It is so defined to make it compatible with the theory of determinism, which essentially states that all actions have a causal explanation due to the state of the world in the moment previous.However, the definition is clearly inadequate due to the fundamental flaws of determinism and its failure to account for deliberation or personal choice. A superior alternative is offered by what Taylor calls the theory of agency, but is more commonly known as libertarianism.In discussing a theory one must start with some data in order to prove the validity of the theory, and in discussing determinism this is no different. Two suitable criteria dealing with the decision making process are: firstly that we at times deliberate with the view of making a decision , and secondly regardless of whether I deliberate I sometimes have a personal choice in the decision making process. These criteria are ideal because they are both things that we as individuals are fairly certain of so any acceptable theory must account for them in some way. For common sense, a virtue in argumentation, suggests that it is easier to accept the veracity of partial self-determination in the decision making process than an abstract philosophical theory. To asses the applicability of the data to determinism a more in depth examination of determinism is needed, which Taylor defines as having three tenets: Firstly, that the theory of determinism is true. Secondly, that voluntary behaviour is free unless constrained, and finally that causes of voluntary behaviour are certain states, condition, decisions, and desires. The principle problem of determinism is precisely this last tenet, for what are the causes of the inner states that cause my actions? Where do they come from? Are they under my control? If determinism is true then the problem of infinite causality arises for the causes of the actions must themselves have causes. When applied to the two original data the infinite causality of determinism renders these data false. Take deliberation as an example. I can deliberate only about future actions, but there are always causes to everything I do making the outcome of the deliberation inevitable and the process itself irrelevant. The incompatibility of determinism and deliberation does not bode well for the second datum, as if I am to have a personal choice in an action then I must be able to concretely execute any of the options associated with the action. But if determinism is true there can again only be one...

Find Another Essay On The problem with determinism and the benefits of Taylor's theory of agency. 900 words. Bibilogeraphy

Sight Words and the Dual Coding Theory

941 words - 4 pages , concepts of print, vocabulary development, comprehension. Without these reading skills, one would struggle to be independent in our society. Learning to read sight words helps with both fluency and vocabulary development. Children’s exposure to the world of print happens well before they begin kindergarten or pre-school. Children as young as nine months show interest in books, by looking at pictures and enjoying the melody of the rhymes. According

Saving Morality: The Implications of Hard Determinism

1333 words - 6 pages conclusion, and evaluating the results of a steadfast adherence to the theory this paper serves to show that moral nihilism is not the inevitable end to morality in a hard determinist framework. Instead morality, if not wholly, at least partially, is capable of being maintained by the hard determinist. Determinism is the philosophical theory that for every action there exists antecedent conditions from which that action necessarily follows and these

Linguistic Determinism: Words and Thoughts

2198 words - 9 pages determinism and the support of the semantic studies in order to understand words and sentences produced in human mind when the cultural and social pattern it is taken into account. Yet “knowledge an individual speaker of a language possesses which makes it possible for them to communicate with one another.” (Riemer, 2010: 13). Semantics is a theory of languages, natural or artificial, and it is part of grammar from those languages. In

Helping with the Chronic Problem of Homelessness

2374 words - 10 pages genuine problem in America, no matter what the cause-there are solutions that the government can put into place to decrease it. In America, The national rate of homelessness was 20 homeless people per 10,000 people in the general population. It isn’t uncommon to see someone living under a bridge or a panhandler hustling at a red light in Baltimore. It isn’t enough places to keep these people and for multiple unique reasons they are there. More

The Power of Words

2008 words - 8 pages perception and illustrate its "treacherous and powerful" nature using examples from Areas of Knowledge including human science, ethics, history and mathematics. Linguist Edward Sapir's theory holds the view that language has the power to shape people's views. Peggy Rosenthal in her book Words and Values concurs with Sapir's philosophy that words have the power to lead people's behaviour and thoughts. Words can have both a

The Triumph of Words

1331 words - 6 pages Allende illustrates that the power of words is the strongest and most lasting form of power through the actions of Clara, Pedro Tercero, and Alba in her novel, The House of the Spirits. Clara proves that the power of words is stronger and lasts longer than physical power through her conflicts with her husband, Esteban Trueba. Clara keeps journals all of her life. At a young age, “she was already in the habit of writing down important matters, and

The power of words

739 words - 3 pages John 1:1-2 (NIV) says, “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was with God in the beginning.” This verse displays that words hold power and can influence minds. Words were with God in the very beginning. God created the universe using words. How can anything be more powerful? In the play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, the power of words is a conquering theme throughout. To begin, Brutus spoke words

The Power of Words

627 words - 3 pages how they say it, instead of playing on the computer, checking my myspace I would study the thesaurus by putting random words and finding other uses for it, and other routes for the word. Having an extinctive vocabulary makes you experience more things that life has to offer, like being able to have a conversation with out anyone ridiculing you, and being able to converse to someone and actually understand them. To walk out side and not be

The Power of Words

2217 words - 9 pages same song could become a listeners favorite song that brings joy and comfort when hearing it because it got them through hard times and over a break up of their own. “Funny the way it is, Whether right or wrong, Somebody's heart is broken, And it becomes your favorite song” (“Pandora” np). There are made up fictional stories with powerful words that can drive plots and evoke the readers emotion, there are songs that are listened to everyday that

The Authority of Words

1001 words - 4 pages defensive. Antony continually repeats that Brutus is an honorable man and then follows with examples of why Caesar was not ambitious. It gives the effect that Brutus is an honorable man, but murdering Caesar was not noble of him. Ethos creates the tone that Antony is a trustworthy person and that Brutus is respectable person, but what he did to Caesar was unjust. In addition, he uses logos to support Caesar’s actions and to prove that he was not

The Power of Words

1212 words - 5 pages Joseph Addison once said, “Words, when well chosen, have so great a force in them that a description often gives us more lively ideas than the sight of things themselves (416).” I like this quote because it shows the importance of words and how powerful and influential they can be. Illustrations are used the same way, they hold the attention of readers, communicate content of information, and give insight of a particular event. There are eight

Similar Essays

"Richard Taylor's Paper "Freedom, Determinism And Fate" Explores The Necessity For Society To Adopt A View Of Fatalism

1286 words - 5 pages "If two-way communication across time is possible then it must be possible to know in advance what one will do and what will happen. If so, Taylor's story of Osmo could be realized- fatalism is unavoidable."It is believed by many that time travel is physically possible. Such a belief brings with it a plethora of paradoxes, and importantly, brings into question conceived notion of human freedom. However as Aubrey Townsend, in his paper "Time

How Does Giddens Solve The Problem Of Agency Versus Structure?

857 words - 3 pages Giddens theorizes that structure and agency are a duality that cannot exist apart from one another. Human practices create both their consciousness and society. Because individuals make up society’s activities and structural conditions, they can choose to change it. Giddens calls this relationship between knowledge and practices the double hermeneutic. The daily routines and practices of individuals interacting with each other is what shape

Compare And Contrast Bourdieu's Approach To The Agency/Structure Dichotomy With That Of Giddens

2876 words - 12 pages COMPARE AND CONTRAST BOURDIEU'S APPROACHTO THE AGENCY/STRUCTURE DICHOTOMYWITH THAT OF GIDDENSIn recent years, several authors have attempted to deal with the problem of the relationship between agency and social structure. This has manifested itself in the theory of structuration. Anthony Giddens' structuration theory is one of the best-known and most articulated efforts to integrate agency and structure. His theory proposes a duality of

Write A Creative Writing Peice To Do With Tradgedy And Triumph. Aprox 900 1000 Words

950 words - 4 pages Martin, had suffered the misfortune of having part of his brains blown away. The man lay with arms outstretched and eyes staring blankly at the clouds. His jaw was slack. His breath came in ragged gasps; each exhalation was accompanied by bloody froth foaming from the mouth. Strings of brain matter hung loosely from a deep crease in the top of the soldier's head. The face was vaguely familiar. Martin felt he might have recognized it when it if it