The Pros And Cons Of Alternative Dispute Resolution

3748 words - 15 pages

This essay will provide a detailed examination of what Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) is, particularly mediation, the various techniques of ADR, the advantages and disadvantages of ADR; and whether or not courts should have the authority to compel individuals into undertaking mediation or other forms of ADR. This essay argues against courts having the power to compel litigants into mediation but may be afforded powers to encourage parties to go through mediation at first instance. This essay will base its arguments on whether courts should compel civil litigants to follow the ADR route upon the perceived advantages of ADR and its success rate. The contention of this essay is not that mediation is inappropriately used to settle disputes, but that court-ordered mediation is inappropriate.

I will begin with a brief overview of Alternative Dispute Resolution, its advantages and disadvantages and focus primarily on mediation. The next section will explain the process of mediation and then go on to give reasons as to why court-ordered mediation is inappropriate.

ADR is a term generally used to refer to informal dispute resolution processes in which the parties meet with a professional third party (not a judge in his professional capacity and sometimes more than one third party) who helps them resolve their disputes in a way that is less formal and often more consensual than is done in the courts . Goldberg, Green and Sander , identifies four separate goals of ADR; to relieve the court congestion as well as undue cost and delay; to enhance community involvement in dispute resolution process; to facilitate access to justice; and to provide more effective dispute resolution. The concept of ADR is extremely broad. Defining ADR is difficult because an infinite variety of procedures properly fall into a category of “not a trial.” For instance, if dispute arises and is resolved short of a courtroom, in a sense that resolution is ADR.

Nevertheless, certain categories of ADR have been named and understood to involve the use of particular means and methods to produce the desired end result. These procedures include: negotiation, mediation, arbitration, med-arb, early neutral evaluation, settlement conference and conciliation to name a few. However this essay will concentrate on mediation as a form of alternative dispute resolution.

A potential advantage of ADR is that because parties voluntarily involve themselves in the process, and in most cases agree to the outcome there is rarely a difficulty with enforcement. Enforcement is a much greater potential problem of litigation where a party who has lost in court may be unwilling to meet judgement. At the same time, individuals have pointed to the advantages of the type of settlement which could be achieved by ADR over the costly and divisive nature of litigation.
Nonetheless ADR also has its disadvantages, according to Fiss “ADR implicitly asks us to assume a rough equality...

Find Another Essay On The Pros and Cons of Alternative Dispute Resolution

Alternative Dispute Resolution Essay

3377 words - 14 pages Alternative Dispute Resolution Resolution in the courts is not the only method of dispute resolution. If the parties can resolve their own differences then there would be no need to use the court system which would benefit all parties being the claimant, defence and the civil justice service. Although the court service is a good and fair way of dealing with civil disputes in might not be the ideal way in getting the

Alternative Dispute Resolution Essay

1312 words - 5 pages Alternative Dispute Resolution Consider carefully the facts of the case study and advise Eagle Aviation Ltd. and Aircraft Ltd. of the alternatives to litigation in the ordinary courts and the advantages and disadvantages of each alternative form of ADR. This submission will identify and define each form of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) including each of the forms advantages and disadvantages. It will also compare and contrast

Alternative Dispute Resolution

1889 words - 8 pages Alternative Dispute Resolution There are various ways of settling disputes without using the civil courts, these are knows as Alternative Dispute Resolution, or ADR which are used mainly in construction, family, commercial and employment issues. There are 3 main types of ADR: conciliation, mediation and arbitration, this essay will explore how they work and what is involved in each process. Mediation A

Alternative Dispute Resolution

808 words - 3 pages repairs came to around $9,000. The Smiths sent a demand letter to the sellers, which they denied that they misrepresented any of the information in the disclosure form. The Smith’s sales contract specified that any disagreement between the seller and buyer must be dealt with by mediation. MediationMediation is one method of an alternative dispute resolution (ADR). ADR methods are used for resolving disputes other than litigation. ADR aims to

Alternative Dispute Resolution

567 words - 2 pages "Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) is a process in which a third neutral party assists in resolving disputes by using various techniques to reach a resolution acceptable to the parties" (The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, 2005). I will be going over an Alternative Dispute Scenario about a female employee who just graduated from college, who claims that an older male worker (with 30-years of outstanding service to his company

Alternative Dispute Resolution Research Worksheet

2682 words - 11 pages of control they have in this situation. The loss of money, time and documents begins to take place the second they get in front of a jury.M-Core should take advantage of the lessons that Toro learned from choosing mediation as an alternative dispute resolution approach. Using this pre-litigation mediation, they just could resolve the issues causing the three homeowners who are holding out affording the company to get back on track with their

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) at work

739 words - 3 pages The use of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) was positive but there were three conclusions made the way the company handled the situation. The driver’s point of view, the executives point of view, and the fellow dispatcher’s point of view. The company would be better off not using ADR until they are more developed in that area or have the correct resources. Here is an example of how this company misused ADR to create different point

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)clause that can be used by a learning team to resolve disagreements among the learning team members

751 words - 3 pages Alternative Dispute ResolutionAlternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) is an increasingly popular option that allows people to resolve disputes outside of court in a cooperative manner. ADR can be faster, cheaper and less stressful than going to court. Most important, the use of ADR can provide greater satisfaction with the way disputes are resolved. The writer will discuss how ADR clause can be use in the learning team.The learning team is an

The Pros and Cons of the Internet

1219 words - 5 pages The computer has had a tremendous impact on society as we know it. It gives a voice to those who cannot speak and those who cannot breathe on their own receive mechanically computerized help. The computer has given us many wonderful things used for wonderful purposes, but there are vast ways in which these things have been misused by our people. One of these things is the internet and a common way it is misused is by way of plagiarism

The Pros and Cons of Social Media

1719 words - 7 pages use of social media does not turn into social dysfunction. Works Cited Birnie, S. A. and Horvath, P. (2002), Psychological Predictors of Internet Social Communication. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication. Carey, Dachary. "Online Social Networking Pros and Cons." Life123. Web. 16 Feb. 2014. . "Conformity: The

The Pros and Cons of Social Media

1082 words - 5 pages , and take advantage of others (The Pros and Cons). Additionally, there are a large number of children being harassed and stalked by online predators. “They target both boys and girls of all ages and use the anonymity of the internet to their advantage, since they can be whoever they want. Many are master manipulators with skills that can cripple any child’s sense of awareness (The facts About Online Predators).” Lastly, less face-to-face

Similar Essays

The Basic Principles Of Alternative Dispute Resolution

4367 words - 17 pages AbstractThe basic principles of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) are reviewed and discussed in relation to actual business disputes that were resolved through ADR.Alternative Dispute ResolutionAfter a review of the usefulness and purpose of alternative dispute resolution (ADR), this paper examines represenative examples of business disputes that were resolved without recourse to court proceedings. The sample cases are examined by way of

Benefits Of Alternative Dispute Resolution Essay

2283 words - 9 pages The purpose of this paper is to discuss what Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) is and how it came about, what different types of ADR there is to choose from and how ADR benefits both parties compared to litigation. ADR can quickly resolve almost any minor issue regarding most civil cases family, neighbors, employers, contractors, etc. ADR includes mediation (also known as conciliation), arbitration and settlement conferences. Some of the

Alternative Dispute Resolution Essay 953 Words

953 words - 4 pages for and damages.Based on the facts, the value of the damaged system repaired and sold as used and the potential cost of a court case the OEM wanted to settle the dispute amicably. Alternate dispute resolution was the preferred method to resolve the problem. The freight company obviously tried to hide the fact the system was dropped by repairing the crate in a different manner than when it was originally packed and failed to notify any of any

Alternative Dispute Resolution Essay

672 words - 3 pages Alternative Dispute Resolution PAGE 1 Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) has become an increasing popular option, which allows individuals to resolve issues outside of a courtroom. The ADR process can be a much faster, cheaper, and less stressful for all involved. This process can also be an effective tool when it comes to teams. At the University of Phoenix, the learning team has become a great help for students to achieve their academic