The Pros And Cons Of Managed Mental Health Care

1456 words - 6 pages

Abstract
This paper will discuss the different effects managed care has on the quality of mental health care for its clients. On the positive, managed care has increased availability to a cliental that would otherwise not be able to afford mental health care. On the negative, there has been a reduction in quality in order for managed care corporations to keep costs low and still make money. Proper implementation of managed mental health care would likely result in high quality, low cost mental health care.

Introduction
Two decades ago hospitals were for the physically ill and asylums were for the mentally ill. With the stigma fading from mental illness and a movement toward deinstitutionalization, this paradigm of segregation of mental and physical health care does not hold true today. A direct effect of the paradigm shift is a greater willingness on the part of the public to seek help for mental health problems. (Madonna, 2000, ¶ 6) Managed care has stepped up to fill the increasing need for inexpensive mental health care coverage.
Each year, 52 million Americans have some form of mental health problem and out of those patients 60% are members of a managed care group. (Madonna, 2000, ¶ 8) Managed mental health care’s successes and failures now bear directly on the mental wellbeing of 32 million particularly vulnerable Americans. Initially managed care was intended to be a “comprehensive approach to healthcare that included balancing cost, quality, utilization, and access.” (Madonna, 2000, ¶ 23) In theory, this is an optimal approach to the delivery of health care and it has proven somewhat successful in the area of physical health, but it has not provided the same success in the area of mental health. Mental health is still being treated as a separate and less important aspect of health care despite the fact that some mental health disorders, such as schizophrenia, have shown higher success rates than those of common medical procedure, such as angioplasty. (Etheredge, 2002, ¶ 6)
The Cons
First and foremost managed mental health care is a business and good business often prevents good medicine. Theoretically, a well implemented managed care could work well, but in order to make their stockholders happy, managed care companies do not always implement policies to help the patient. An example of this would be the common policy of company personnel making treatment decisions instead of mental health treatment providers. This organization of power raises concerns with patients and treatment providers alike. Historically managed care organizations have not switched mental health patients to less costly forms of treatment, they have just reduced care in general, restricting access to costly medical procedures. (Madonna, 2000, ¶ 12)
One reason a stigma is placed on forms of managed care, such as health maintenance organizations (HMO), is a highly publicized practice of providing material incentives to doctors to control the amount of costly tests and...

Find Another Essay On The Pros and Cons of Managed Mental Health Care

Managed Health Care Essay

2284 words - 9 pages coverage over the course of the past two to three decades.One of these factors is the introduction and rapidly increasingenrollment in managed health care insurance plans. Managed carehealth insurance plans can, in most cases, help to alleviate therising costs of effective medical coverage. Another importantfactor that has affected health care costs is the invention andimplementation of new medical technologies. As prominentresearchers and

Managed Health Care Issues Essay

3241 words - 13 pages When one examines managed health care and the hospitals that provide the care, a degree of variation is found in the treatment and care of their patients. This variation can be between hospitals or even between physicians within a health care network. For managed care companies the variation may be beneficial. This may provide them with opportunities to save money when it comes to paying for their policy holder’s care, however this large

Mental Illness and Health Care for the Mentally Ill

1259 words - 5 pages ) of the United Nations have developed mental health policies that assist those who are burden with high cost, as well as informing governments about mental illness and their prevention, treatment, and civil rights (Mental, 2008). Reasonable populations are covered by these sources, providing nearly most individuals with either full or partial coverage and usually with benefits. Managed care, as previously mentioned, has been an efficient tool

The role of occupational therapists in mental health care

782 words - 3 pages "The role of occupational therapists in mental health care"One of the main reasons why it has become necessary to look in more detail at the role of occupational therapists in mental health care is the changing role of health care professionals in general which has taken place in the past decades and which has led to a re-structuring of the health care industry as a whole. As Thorner (1991) and Lloyd et al (1998) have pointed out, there have

Mental Health Care Assessment

1623 words - 6 pages communication and mental health nursing” Journal of Psychiatry & Mental Health Nursing. 10 (6) 678 – 682. Chambers, S. (2003). ‘Use of Non-Verbal Communication Skills to Improve Nursing Care’ British Journal of Nursing. 12 (14) pp 874-878. Department of Health (1999), National Service Framework for Mental Health: Modern standards and service models. 1999. Department of Health (2008) Service Users & Carers and the Care Programme Approach

Mental Health Nursing Care

4160 words - 17 pages Untitled Running Head: MENTAL HEALTH NURSING CARE Mental Health Nursing Care Mental Health Nursing Care Introduction Thе tеrm powеr diffеrеntiation includеs thе notion of limits, linеs or bordеrs (Avis, Drysdalе, Grеgg, Nеufеldt, & Scargill, 2003). Profеssional rеquirеmеnts for practicе arе mеt whеn thе rеgistеrеd nursе dеmonstratеs thе knowlеdgе, skills and attitudеs of thеrapеutic

Legal and Ethecal Issues that impacted on the delivery of mental health care

2214 words - 9 pages This essay explore the ethical, legal, and professional issues that impact upon the delivery of mental health care delivered to a client, it will also refer to recommendation for change in practice regarding the delivery of such care. The rational for choosing this client was because of issues relating to the fragmentation of his coping mechanism; perception; and support, which led to his crisis situation, which resulted in him threatening to

Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act: Pros and Cons

1672 words - 7 pages Medicare (The Pros and Cons of ObamaCare 1). This will help reduce the burden of uninsured health events on the taxpayer, which would occur when the uninsured individual needs emergency care, but can’t afford to pay the bill (The Pros and Cons of ObamaCare 1). Obamacare reduces the instances of this by expanding coverage and requiring all citizens to have healthcare. The addition of preventive care as an essential health benefit and requirement on

What role do diseases and longevity play in policy development? What has been the role of managed care and attempts at reform in health policy?

948 words - 4 pages becomes a major issue in terms of disease and longevity because, as with any aspect of a society, if it is to succeed it must be well planned. Planning, in terms of a society, is achieved and addressed through public policy. And just as the needs of a population change, as it ages, the policies must as well. The greatest issues pressing for reform in United States health care are diseases, mental health, an aging population and/or the need for more

Dangers of Budget Cuts on Mental Health Care

1549 words - 6 pages Continuing budget cuts on mental health care create negative and detrimental impacts on society due to increased improper care for mentally ill, public violence, and overcrowding in jails and emergency rooms. Origins, of mental health as people know it today, began in 1908. The movement initiated was known as “mental hygiene”, which was defined as referring to all things preserving mental health, including maintaining harmonious

Mental health what it is about, an insight into the nursing care of a depressed patient

1178 words - 5 pages This insight is about mental health, "mental health is the balance between all aspects of life - social, physical, spiritual and emotional. It impacts on how we manage our surroundings and make choices in our lives - clearly it is an integral part of our overall health" (youth healthne.ie 2003)I have chosen to look at depression, which comes under mental health illness. My insight is on a female who 80 years old.Geriatric depression is a very

Similar Essays

The Pros And Cons Of A Managed Health Care System

1679 words - 7 pages and identify why such variations actually happened (Harken, 2008). This inculcates the habit of review in all the process and also inculcates discipline amongst the group members as they are now afraid of their actions being reviewed and they being answerable for all their activities (Penna, 2009). Hence we see that the Managed Health Care system has a great degree of advantages involved. Cons (Disadvantage / Negative Aspect) of Managed

The Pros And Cons Of Health Screening

2471 words - 10 pages doctor for check ups and that individual behavior is less important. In Australia, health screening has had some impact on the way people think about health and disease. Public misconception about the purpose of screening programs has been demonstrated and a reduced sense of personal control over health has been shown to be associated with poorer self rated health, more episodes of illness, and less self-initiated preventive care (Tymstra , 1988

The Pros And Cons Of Health Screening

2257 words - 9 pages The Benefits and Disbenefits of Health Screening and the Contribution of Psychology in Health Screening. Health screening, according to Durojaiye, (2009), is a systematic application of a test or inquiry to identify individuals at risk of a specific health problem. This enables further investigation or direct preventive action, among individuals who have not sought medical attention on account of their symptoms of that problem. The

Managed Health Care Analyzed Essay

1843 words - 7 pages The health care industry in the United States is very diverse and dynamic. The continued growth of managed health care is influenced by the economy, the need, and the regulatory regulations set forth on the industry. If one of these forces changes, it can affect the entire group; this causes the managed health care industry to be at the mercy of its roots and the industry’s need for it. What started out as a simple idea has turned into a complex