The Pros And Cons Of Privatizing Government Services In Canada

2955 words - 12 pages

Municipal control or an alternative delivery method? This is the question that has intrigued all levels of local government and created intense debates between taxpayers across municipalities. The services that municipalities provide are often vital to the existence of a local area. The issues of accountability, cost savings, quality of service and democracy often arise when choosing the best options to deliver services to a municipal area. In recent years the concepts of privatization, alternative service delivery and public-private partnerships are often promoted as ways cut down on overburdened annual city budgets and promote a higher quality of service to citizens. Municipalities have historically always provided basic services such as fire protection, water purification/treatment and recreational facilities. However, would private companies or another municipality be able to better deliver the same services more efficiently or at a lower cost? The city or town often provides a political grass roots approach to most local problems. Municipalities are better positioned and have a wider scope to provide services to their constituents in order to ensure quality of service that does not erode accountability and transparency, or drive the municipality deeper into debt.
The new public management states that, “cities are growing more and more like corporations referring to citizens as customers in the sense that they are providing product or goods (services) to the customer (taxpayers).” This had led to an increased demand for better quality at the lowest cost to the taxpayer. When looking at cost saving and alternative delivery municipalities must make a hard decision when choosing to contract out essential services.
An example arises from the municipality of Thorold. Thorold is a small municipality in the Niagara Region with a population of 18,000. Recently this year the city council paid for a Fire Services review to be done of the municipality’s fire and emergency services. The city is split in half by the Welland Canal that runs through the region, meaning that the city is broken up into 4 fire districts providing fire coverage for the downtown district, east and west sides of the canal and a smaller hamlet of Port Robinson in the south end. To add to the geographical divide Thorold has a divided workforce in a composite fire department made up of 20 fulltime firefighters and 110 volunteer/part time. The city council and the taxpayers in Thorold are faced with $3.2 million dollars in operating and administrative costs annually to its fire service. These costs are much higher than other municipalities in the region with a similar population. “The fire review was done to measure cost savings for the city and to improve the quality of the service overall.”
There were several options provided to council that included closing stations and contracting the service out to Thorold’s neighbour St. Catharines. “Under these models St. Catharines...

Find Another Essay On The Pros and Cons of Privatizing Government Services in Canada

The Essay Is About The Pros And Cons Of Various Economic Systems And The Governments Influence Within Them. The Title Can Be Stated As: To What Extent Should The Government Regulate The Economy ?

1671 words - 7 pages forward economically at any price even the death of its citizens. This type of government presence in the economy should not be promoted due to the serious problems it can cause.In a system that promotes Reagonomics, lower end families get less social services due to less government intervention. In the 1980's in the United States, Ronald Reagan was elected president and vowed to cut taxes, reduce government intervention in the economy and balance

The Pros and Cons of Standardized Testing in the US

1508 words - 6 pages Most students, by the time they reach college, have taken numerous MCA tests (Minnesota Comprehensive Assessments), NWEA tests (Northwest Evaluation Association), and either an ACT test (American College Testing) or SAT test (Scholastic Assessment Test), depending on which region of the United States they are from. Webster’s defines a standardized test as “any test in which the same test is given in the same manner to all test takers.” Every

The Pros and Cons of Women Leaders in The Workforce

2064 words - 8 pages was a more feminine leadership behavior. Consistent with these findings, Yukl (1999) also showed, using factor analytic techniques, that corporate and government employees (nonmanagerial staff) saw behaviors such as providing encouragement and support, along with rewarding subordinates for effective performance, as part of a relationship-oriented dimension of leadership. Given the stereotypic attribution of relationship-oriented traits to women in

Pros and Cons of Using L1 in the Classroom

1331 words - 6 pages 2. THE DEBATE The idea to include L1 as part of the language teaching system has been debated upon in recent years. The strong anti-L1 suggest on a complete prohibition of L1 in classrooms, while many others see L1 as a tool to better students’ learning of the TL. This section will highlight the pros and cons arguments for using the L1 in classrooms, along with further evidence supporting the advantages mother tongue bring to the language

The Pros and Cons Of Bilingual Education In Malaysia

823 words - 4 pages Earlier this year, Singapore’s former Prime Minister, Lee Guan Yew told the press (SinChew Daily, 2013) that he would like to urge all the parents in Singapore to let their children to receive bilingual education as soon as possible as it deliver more pros than cons for the development of the children. Traditionally, bilingual education was perceived by experts as “damaging” to children early language development as it may cause them to confuse

The Pros and Cons of Protest in American History

1113 words - 4 pages whole new group of Vietnam protesters. They would sit on lawns and sing protest songs, and dance. John and Yoko’s words inspired peaceful protests instead of violent protests that had ended in disaster. (Cashmere) Most protests during the Vietnam War were peaceful. The draft was still in effect during the Vietnam War so many protests included burning of draft cards, or fleeing to Canada. Many college age students enrolled in college just to

The Pros and Cons of Illegal Immigration in America

754 words - 3 pages should show them what is means to have freedom. All they want is the “better” life. Although many states have illegal immigrants, the majority of them reside in California and Texas. According to the US Citizenship and Immigration Services “California has 2,209,000 and Texas at 1,041,000 as of the last census in 2000. The next leading state is New York with 489,000. The state with the lowest amount is Hawaii, with only 2,000. The

The Pros and Cons of Migration in London

854 words - 3 pages Introduction This essay seeks to investigate the negative and positive effects of migration in London. As the London Migration Observatory claim London has the largest number of migrants among all regions of the United Kingdom (UK). About 37% of the UK’s foreign-born population was in London (LMO, Dr.Rienzo and Dr.Vargas-Silva). Furthermore, According to the Benton-Smith statistic, London is the 5th International city in the world after New

The Pros and Cons of Using Information Technology in Teaching

517 words - 2 pages hard to grasp the concepts and develop the skills of using information technology. The government has laid down the policy of requiring all the teachers to learn information technology and make use of the technology in teaching. The problem is, many teachers find it hard to squeeze time from their overloaded work schedules to attend courses and later on to practice the new skills. In addition, it is difficult for a teacher to monitor the

The Pros and Cons of Classification Systems in Psychiatry

1606 words - 6 pages Classification refers to the procedure in which ideas or objects are recognized, distinguished and understood. Currently, two leading systems are used for grouping of mental disorder namely International Classification of Disease (ICD) by World Health Organization (WHO) and the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental disorders (DSM) by the American Psychiatric Association (APA). Other classifications include Chinese classification of mental

Pros and Cons of the Atomic Bomb in WWII

1007 words - 4 pages that they were suicidal, with their kamikaze pilots and no real hope of defeating the allied nations. America has always, and most likely will always place a high value on American lives. In order to protect these lives and to insure that the world is safe for democracy, American leaders had to make a very tough decision, whether or not to drop the atomic bomb on Japan. This act would essentially be trading Japanese lives for American lives

Similar Essays

Pros And Cons Of Migration Mobility And Culture In Canada

999 words - 4 pages TOPIC: PROS AND CONS OF MIGRATION, MOBILITY, AND CULTURE IN CANADA the-u-s-walks-the-diversity-walk/ In this essay I will be providing some information about the pros and cons of migration, mobility, and culture in Canada. Migration by definition is to “move from one place to another with the purpose of settlement and improvement of living

Comment On The Pros And Cons Of Privatization Of Social Welfare Services In Hong Kong Society. Use The “Link Reit” As An Example To Illustrate Your Answer

4273 words - 17 pages Topic 6: Comment on the pros and cons of privatization of social welfare services in Hong Kong society. Use the "LINK-REIT" as an example to illustrate your answer.IntroductionThe Link-Reit (Real Estate Investment Trust) has long been a controversial issue ever since its launch. The issue in fact concerns the privatization of welfare services. The purpose of this paper is to review the worthiness of privatization in the midst of conflicts of

Canada: Discuss Pros And Cons For Joining The Trans Pacific Partnership

1286 words - 6 pages countries that would want to do business with Canada is that there would be enhanced services that could be offered. Canadian government wants to, “make sure that service suppliers are transparent, predictable... (Trans 2013).” The chemicals and plastics manufacturing exports market is near the top of Canada’s list. Having the ability to be able to produce Econ 305 Rose Schaufele, Jesse Long more of their products to those Trans-Pacific Partnership

Dating Services Have More Pros Than Cons

886 words - 4 pages "Dating Services have more Pros than Cons"Well I have a lot of different ideas about dating services. First of all I don't think that they are good for everyone to use. There are certainly a lot of precautions you must take when dating but that applies to all dating. You need to use common sense and do not be naïve when it come to meeting new people. Also I think that the best kind of dating service is the internet type. The news papers and