The Pros And Cons Of The Tribunal System

1271 words - 5 pages

Advantages and Disadvantages of the Tribunal System


In order to identify the advantages and disadvantage of the tribunal system and the court system it is necessary to firstly identify what they are, their purpose and then what the advantages and disadvantages of these two systems of dispute resolution are.

The courts are the formal courts of law that have been established over many years. Their purpose is to uphold the law of the land as dictated by statute and impose this law over those who appear to be in contradiction of these laws. A traditional court proceeding involves to opposing parties who present the facts of the case to the court and the presiding judge or sheriff rules in favour of one of the parties. Their judgement is based upon previous rulings and statutory interpretation normally however other factors can be taken into consideration.

A tribunal is not entirely dissimilar to the court system in the way that it works. However it is important to note that 'Tribunals are not ordinary courts, but they are neither appendages of Government Departments' . Tribunals were created to provide an alternative form of dispute resolution independent of the Government Department concerned. A Chairman who listens to the case put forward oversees tribunals. They are aided by Wing members who represent opposing sides of the argument being put forward. The case is presented and with the aid normally of expert opinions from the likes of Doctors and Chartered Surveyors, a decision is made based on the merits of the case.

The courts have been in place for a number of years they have a lot of precedents which means that all cases should be treated in the same way thus allowing the court system to be fair to all. It is possible when seeking redress for a specific incident to gain Legal Aid for the case when proceeding through the courts; this is no Legal Aid

for Tribunals though it is the intention for them to be much cheaper than the court system. It has been shown however that having legal representation at the tribunal can substantially increase the likelihood of success. In the Social Security Appeal Tribunal research showed that an applicant's chance of success rose from 30per cent to 48 per cent when they had legal representation. This casts some doubt about the system, which is supposed to be fair for all but has been proven that if you have a lawyer representing you the chances of success are greater.

The advantage of choosing the tribunal system is that it is not strictly bound by the restrictions of rules of evidence and precedent. Although, tribunals are to some degree bound by the decisions of other tribunals they have a greater degree of flexibility in their decision-making powers. This in itself means that tribunals can give the appellant a greater chance of success especially since tribunals can admit evidence that a court might perhaps refuse to listen to, for example hearsay evidence.

The use of...

Find Another Essay On The Pros and Cons of the Tribunal System

The Pros and Cons of Social Media

1082 words - 5 pages , and take advantage of others (The Pros and Cons). Additionally, there are a large number of children being harassed and stalked by online predators. “They target both boys and girls of all ages and use the anonymity of the internet to their advantage, since they can be whoever they want. Many are master manipulators with skills that can cripple any child’s sense of awareness (The facts About Online Predators).” Lastly, less face-to-face

The Pros and Cons of Capital Punishment

906 words - 4 pages The Pros and Cons of Capital Punishment Since the mid 1900’s, capital punishment has brought many individuals into many diverse view points throughout the years. Capital punishment is a way of punishing a convict by killing him or her because of the crime he or she committed. Capital punishment will always have its pros and cons. There are opponents who absolutely disagree with capital punishment. And then there are advocates who

The Pros and Cons of Imperialism

531 words - 2 pages hand, the new imperialism was the period between the years “1870-1914”, where Europe became more focused on expanding their land into Asia and Africa. Imperialism had many pros and cons. In addition, it also had many causes led by the feeling of nationalism. Several significant causes led to the rise of imperialism in Europe. Economy played a role in the rise. For instance, many nations demanded more natural resource that they did not have on

Pros and cons of the promotional mix

972 words - 4 pages which is advertising, personnel selling, sales promotion and public relations tools. No matter how good a strategy or a plan is perform; advantage and disadvantage are surely to exist. The main purpose of conducting this literature review is to precisely identify the advantages and disadvantages of the four elements. One of the most popular promotional elements that company usually us is the advertising, but before we look into the pros and cons

Pros and Cons of the Industrial Revolution

1345 words - 6 pages been treated very poorly. Not only that the amount shillings they make, barely makes a difference for their family to survive. Urbanization has increased between the times of 1800’s and the 1850’s, as urbanization increase there is more numbers of population and many diseases. But the industrial revolution also had its pros, like for example the increase number of new technology. The Spinning Jenny which helps weaves and thread garnet together

The Pros and Cons of Gay Marriage

1346 words - 5 pages part in the gay marriage legalization process. Same-sex marriage is a major controversial issue in the United States; specific examples would be the views of Americans, pros and cons of same-sex marriage, and the reality of it in the United States. The views of Americans are extremely different from one another. The people of America have many different opinions about gay marriage. In 1996, 27 percent of United States citizens approved of

The pros and cons of immigration

1400 words - 6 pages American Society 2013/2014 Zuzana Ďuržová Mid-Term Essay - The pros and cons of immigration Immigration is the movement of people between countries. People are moving from their home country to search for better opportunities, career or education a chance for better life. People are looking for business opportunities, experience, or may have personal reasons such as family or marriage. If I we are talking about positive and negative aspects

The Pros and Cons of Genetic Engineering

820 words - 3 pages to create the perfect race, was dolly the sheep just a stepping stone to improved biological weapons. Genetic engineering seems to have the pros and cons, but the cons are basically assuming the worst or are being used for the destruction of mankind, rather than the saving of mankind. The reduction of the gene pool also seems to be a huge risk to take. If recessive genes are erased from an organism, then the gene pool will be reduced resulting

The Pros and Cons of Standardized Testing

1348 words - 6 pages pressure to the educators and the students. The added pressure can cause health problems with the students or the educators. If health problem come from the stress of the tests it could negatively affect the student’s ability to learn (Pros and Cons, 2013). The test itself is a problem as well. The test is supposed to be unbiased based on the grade level but in most cases the test is not. As much as they try the people that produce the test may

the pros and cons of globalization

2175 words - 9 pages Explain globalization. Include the pros and cons of globalization and provide examples to support what you identify as pros and cons. Globalization can best be defined as the shrinking of our world. As technology advances the gaps between Countries is closed, and our society as a whole becomes more integrated. Globalization is something that has been occurring for thousands of years, with one early example of Globalization being the use of

The pros and cons of DNA profiling

875 words - 4 pages Does DNA profiling in its current state offer foolproof identification? What needs to be in place for it to be error-free? Should all incarcerated criminals be forced to give samples? Should convicted juveniles? Should the general public be required to give a DNA sample? The pros of DNA profiling are that it can be used to quickly eliminate a suspect, saving time in searches for perpetrators. And it can provide compelling evidence to support a

Similar Essays

The Pros And Cons Of A Managed Health Care System

1679 words - 7 pages and identify why such variations actually happened (Harken, 2008). This inculcates the habit of review in all the process and also inculcates discipline amongst the group members as they are now afraid of their actions being reviewed and they being answerable for all their activities (Penna, 2009). Hence we see that the Managed Health Care system has a great degree of advantages involved. Cons (Disadvantage / Negative Aspect) of Managed

Pros And Cons Of Integrating Knowledge Management System And Crm Solution

1239 words - 5 pages integration project. In an attempt to be realistic in his approach to present the value of CRM and KM integration, the author presented some obstacles and possible solutions and justifications. This is a good technique in the sense that presenting the pros and cons will result to greater understanding of the challenges and great rewards, however I think he failed to back up this points by way of citing researched evidence. CONCLUSION This paper

The Pros And Cons Of The Internet

1219 words - 5 pages The computer has had a tremendous impact on society as we know it. It gives a voice to those who cannot speak and those who cannot breathe on their own receive mechanically computerized help. The computer has given us many wonderful things used for wonderful purposes, but there are vast ways in which these things have been misused by our people. One of these things is the internet and a common way it is misused is by way of plagiarism

The Pros And Cons Of Social Media

1719 words - 7 pages use of social media does not turn into social dysfunction. Works Cited Birnie, S. A. and Horvath, P. (2002), Psychological Predictors of Internet Social Communication. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication. Carey, Dachary. "Online Social Networking Pros and Cons." Life123. Web. 16 Feb. 2014. . "Conformity: The