The Potential Impacts Of Upcoming High Stakes Testing On The Teaching Of Science In Elementary Classrooms Research Article Critique

1165 words - 5 pages

This research was both preliminary and exploratory, with intent to explore the effects of standardized tests in the area of teaching and learning science. The purpose of the research was clearly stated under a sub-heading. The goal was to collect data to indicate teachers’ perceptions and concerns about the high-stakes standardized science testing being implemented in the elementary school. Data of a qualitative nature was collected through surveys.
Data about previous standardized testing instruments used in the district and a rationale and brief history of the teaching of science in the district was presented first. A significant amount of primary research regarding standardized testing, test preparation activities, science teaching methods, and student achievement were addressed in the literature review. The review was comprehensive, germane to the topic, and essential to fully appreciate the research. Information was analyzed, evaluated and used to support the collected data in the conclusion portion of the paper.
The variables addressed included the impact of the independent variable, impending high-stakes science testing, and its effect on the teaching of science, which was the dependent variable. This data was focused on teacher concerns and perspectives of the issues. They were not operationally defined in the initial stages of the study, but were defined through the collection of data. The study contained no hypotheses.
The researchers appeared to have the knowledge and skill to conduct the research. Two research professors from the University of Florida who specialize in educational science research conducted the study, published in the journal Research in Science Education. Contact information was also provided for the research team.
Since this was an initial study the researchers chose to use a convenience sample, which is a non-probability sampling method. They used a sample of 10 suburban Florida schools within one district. These schools were selected due to accessibility and ability to obtain permission from principals and school boards. The researchers also believed that using schools from one district would decrease variability that might exist due to local policies. There were 100 teachers given samples with 38% returning valid responses. It was noted that the limited sample was problematic. The sample represented teachers teaching 1st to 5th grade, with 1 to 10 years of experience (with an average of 7.6 years), and educational backgrounds including all with undergraduate degrees in education, twelve with masters degrees, 2 with additional specialists degrees, and one participant with a doctoral degree.
Data was collected using a questionnaire that was designed by the researchers. The procedures used to create this instrument were not included in the study. However, it was noted that time was a factor that prevented piloting and validation of the questionnaire. Details of the instrument included that it was a...

Find Another Essay On The Potential Impacts of Upcoming High-Stakes Testing on the Teaching of Science in Elementary Classrooms-Research Article Critique

High Stakes Testing Essay

1272 words - 5 pages ). There have been many studies in which students take the same test on different days, and their score varies greatly. High stakes testing does not give any consideration to these errors. High stakes testing increases drop out rates. Texas adopted a test much like the AIMS in the 1990-91 school year. TAAS (Texas Assessment of Academic Skills) testing has produced a very astounding number of minority dropouts. The Arizona Standards study

High Stakes Testing Essay

1385 words - 6 pages reduce enthusiasm toward learning. A study prepared by the Arizona Standards organization claims that, “students in states with high stakes testing programs are more likely than those in states where tests have low or no stakes to score below average in math and science…”(http://www.azstandards.org/protestmaterials.htm). Those opposed argue that this form of testing places too much pressure on students and teachers, and that they should be

High-Stakes Testing in American Schools

1618 words - 6 pages The NCLB Act has obligated the government to find a way to keep track of progress, which, in their minds, is administering high-stakes tests. High-stakes testing is scrutinized all the time, since some believe it is the only indicator of tracking students and teachers. They seemed to have been ridiculed by many and favored by few; nonetheless there are significant disparities in the public’s and government’s opinion. According to Dunne (2000

Is High-Stakes Testing Effective?

1541 words - 6 pages tests will disappear from the curriculum, especially in schools with low-performing students. (David 2011) In the study of “Negotiating Identity and Science Teaching in a High-Stakes Testing Environment” the focus is on an individual elementary teacher. It demonstrates the amount of stress she undergoes due to the pressures of high-stakes testing. The study concentrates on the identities of teachers and how high-stakes tests affect these identities

Standardized and high stakes testing

1797 words - 7 pages classrooms. "To demand that teachers be instantly accountable for challenging new content standards when we have not invested in the relearning teachers require if they are to meet those standards" (Sirotnik and Kimball 212) is an irresponsible and unfair act on the part of states and the educational testing community. If schools and teachers are to take on these high-stakes responsibilities then the policy makers must ask the public to put their money

Potential Environmental Impacts of Utilization of ConocoPhillips Fuel Efficient High Performance (FEHP) Lubricant Applications in the Automotive Indu

2695 words - 11 pages Potential Environmental Impacts of Utilization of ConocoPhillips Fuel Efficient High Performance (FEHP) Lubricant Applications in the Automotive Industry In some shape or form, nearly all aspects of American life contribute to unnecessary exploitation of natural resources. The automobile is a staple of American life and culture, and perhaps best exemplifies Americans’ dependence on gross quantities of raw materials. On any given day

Teaching Elementary School Science

1305 words - 5 pages subjects.î This sums up what teachers need to be doing un their classrooms to teach science. The traditional textbook only and work sheet teaching of science is clearly not recommended with inquiry and hands on experiences. Standard B shows representations of methods to use not only in the teaching of science but other subject areas. The best way to teach elementary school science is to use a variety of methods. If the teacher uses a variety of

The logic of "The influence of race and social class on "high stakes" test performance in the 1990s"

550 words - 2 pages 1.The main purpose of this article is to allow the reader to draw his or her own conclusions on and explore the theories that have been presented as explanations for the reasons and ways that race, social class, and ethnicity are believed (by a number of researchers) to influence the educational outcomes as measured by standardized, "high stakes" performance tests.2.The key question that the author is addressing is an accumulation of many. In

The Impacts of Science on Human Life

708 words - 3 pages Technology is evolving and scientists are frequently developing new concepts and theories, improving our life style and making the world ultimately a better place to live in. Science has led to many extraordinary inventions, filling our human mind with vast amount of knowledge and intelligence. For example, many types of new planets have been discovered recently. Although people have been living in the world for a very long time, it is quite

The Benefits of Teaching Foreign Language in Elementary School

1462 words - 6 pages The Benefits of Teaching Foreign Language in Elementary School The ultimate goal in many classrooms is to communicate in meaningful and appropriate ways (Slavit 1998). In the United States, American students get the opportunity to learn a second language in high school, yet it has been proven that children learn better when they are young. Some schools are taking this opportunity to teach a foreign language to elementary students. The

The Upcoming of Powerful Women

1745 words - 7 pages Macbeth was not showing any mercy for anyone that stood in the way of her success her strength for knowing what she wanted gave her power. On the flip side Lizzie and Laura had an understanding even though Laura wanted to venture out to do what no one has done before she was still there by “cheek to cheek and breast to breast / Locked together in one nest.” (197-198). this how she was there holding Laura through her pain as she was slowly dying. At

Similar Essays

High Stakes Testing In Schools Essay

633 words - 3 pages allowed, even encouraged, to teach the standards in a way that engages their students and makes school as fun as possible. Couple this with increasing the comfort level of students with the format of the HST and some test taking strategies and test scores will increase. High-stakes testing does have some drawbacks. One of the major requirements of a successful school is community support. If a school routinely fails to perform as expected on the

High Stakes Testing, The Standardized Classroom, And The Marginalization Of Multicultural Education

1864 words - 7 pages their low-income and minority peers. However research over the past 10 years has found that the high-stakes testing policies have not improved reading and math achievement across states, and have not significantly narrowed national and state level achievement gaps (Au, 2009). In fact, the high stakes testing and standardization of classrooms has hurt the very students it set out to help. According to Haretos (2005), “the volatility in test scores

High Stakes Testing Essay

1250 words - 5 pages that high stakes testing carries many casualties with it. High stakes testing effects minorities, teachers, disabled students, teaching structure, and students lives. High-stakes testing does not evaluate teachers or students knowledge, it test the memorization skills of students and the brainwashing abilities of our teachers. High Stakes testing should be removed from secondary education in order to properly educate the nations number one

High Stakes Testing Essay

3377 words - 14 pages , that all of these statements are likely to be false a good deal of the time. And in fact, some research studies show exactly the opposite of the effects anticipated by supporters of high-stakes testing.Cons of High Stakes testingCritics of testing often argue that the test scores can sometimes provide an inaccurate measure of student progress and that the growing importance of the tests has led teachers to distort the curriculum by "teaching to