This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Public's Right To Know Vs The Individual's Right To Privacy

1899 words - 8 pages

The Oscar Pistorius murder trial has brought to light the ever-present tensions between an individual’s right to privacy, especially when they are a public figure and the media’s right to freedom of expression especially when the information is in the public interest. South Africa as a country with a history of discrimination always strives to uphold all the rights of its citizens so in a case such as Pistorius’ where there are two rights in contrast, it is never clear which one should be wavered in favour of the other. Everyone, be he public figure or not, is entitled to some form of privacy; the aim then for the media, and the courts is to find out how far the privacy of individuals can be ...view middle of the document...

The cameras must be installed in such a way that they do not interfere with proceedings. No camera operators will be allowed in the courtroom to control equipment, to prevent disruptions… Mlambo allowed the opening argument for state and defence, expert evidence, and the testimony of police and all consenting state witnesses to be broadcasted… Prosecution witnesses may elect to have their testimony withheld from video cameras.
Pistorius’ defense argued against the broadcasting because they believed that it would lead him to getting an unfair trial. But Judge Dunstan Mhlambo said that because the trial was in the public interest, broadcasting it would ensure that more people were able to have access to the proceedings “’particularly those who are poor and who have found it difficult to access the justice system, they should have a first-hand account of the proceedings involving a local and international icon.’” (chibba: 2014).
The constitution of South Africa dictates that every person in the country has certain rights. These rights may not be broken or compromised unless in conflict with another seemingly more important right. Only the court of law can say when a right may be compromised. According to The Bill of Rights, “everyone has the right to privacy.” (SA Constitution: 19). In Jones’ ‘When the Public Interest is not what interests the Public’ (169),
A person, who, by his accomplishments, fame… or profession… which gives the public a legitimate interest in his doings, his affairs, and his character; has become a ‘public person.’ Where a person’s way of life is directed to seeking publicity and he is viewed by the society in which he lives as a celebrity, for instance… [a] professional sportsman… he is considered, to a certain extent, to have forfeited his right to privacy.
According to this definition, Oscar Pistorius is a public figure. He is known both locally and internationally. He is a professional athlete, dubbed ‘The blade runner’. The public has a legitimate interest in him as he is a double amputee who competes in both able-bodied and amputee athletic events. His publicity is what led him to be sponsored by big brands like Nike. Pistorius is already ‘newsworthy’ as a person and the murder of his girlfriend, Reeva Steenkamp made him even more so. If a normal citizen had done the same he would have probably garnered some attention but not to the extent that Oscar Pistorius did; but, that is because he is a public figure. The reason why a normal south African would not get the same amount of international media scrutiny had he been in the same situation, is because he is not as newsworthy to other countries; their public would not be as interested in him because they do not know him as they do Pistorius.
The Bill of Rights also states that “everyone has the right to freedom of expression which includes- freedom of press and other medias… This right… does not extend to propaganda for war, incitement of imminent violence; or advocacy...

Find Another Essay On The Public's Right to know vs The Individual's Right to Privacy

The Right to Privacy Essay

1170 words - 5 pages The Right to Privacy by Ellen Alderman and Caroline Kennedy examines different privacy cases throughout history that has set precedents in today’s courts. The first section focuses on ‘Privacy v. Law Enforcement’ and examines three different cases dealing with three different aspects of privacy when it comes to law enforcement. Strip search, drug interdiction, and school search are the three types cases that Alderman and Kennedy decide to shed

National Security vs. the Right to Privacy

3061 words - 12 pages future, enter your street address at You will see a satellite picture nearly good enough to show a car parked in your driveway, or mine” (106). It is situations such as these that begin to compromise the privacy that the United States has boasted about since it was formed. Rita Cain, a law professor at the Bloch School of Business and Public Administration, debates that, “The constitutional right of privacy…, however

National Security vs. the Right to Privacy

790 words - 3 pages rethinking will concern law-how we will balance understandable demands for improved security with our right to privacy, our freedom to travel, our free speech, our policy of welcoming immigrants, and our commitment to a tolerant society. Once we learn how the terrorists learned to fly these Boeing planes, should we place new restrictions on pilot training? Access to flight simulators? First Amendment experts may rightly be concerned about such

The Right To Privacy in India

3981 words - 16 pages people living in a sparsely populated and remote village in Himachal Pradesh find acceptable, assuming that we leave alone the standards employed by the Scandinavians. Can there be a common benchmark for privacy, at least in India?What cannot be denied, however, is that privacy is important. Warren and Brandeis, two American lawyers, in their seminal paper called 'The Right to Privacy', published in 1890 in the Harvard Law Review, could not have

The Right to Privacy via Electronic Transmissions

2185 words - 9 pages The right to privacy, via electronic transmissions to include the internet, is an ever present issue that does not and most likely will not ever have a solution that will not only satisfy the wants of citizens but the security needs of the nation. When issues of privacy arise we refer to a non-evolving, interpreted document called the Constitution written over two centuries ago. In order to maintain national security, citizens must surrender

Our Right to Privacy

693 words - 3 pages Most people in society think they don't have anything to hide. Everyone has the Right to privacy in technology, medical, personal life and many more areas. Its all has been an issue, sense as far back as anyone can remember. Most people in society don’t realize that it’s a much bigger issue than what it sounds to be. As many of you may not know but the 14th amendment has been involved in may cases that had to do with the Right to Privacy. The

Celebrities' Right to PRivacy

1106 words - 5 pages celebrities life’s from our life every day there either around the camera or hiding from it. Many say that celebrates know right from wrong, just as they know left from right. So why shouldn’t they know lights and a camera go with being famous? Celebrities should not have any privacy due to the fact that there famous! They know there giving up a part of them when they become famous, but on the other hand some people think yes they are famous yes

A Right to Privacy

856 words - 4 pages situation. Therefore, anyone who cares about this problem must contact their representative with their opinion on this matter. Furthermore, citizens must be educated and informed about their rights, and the duty of the government to protect them. An individual’s right to privacy is a fundamental right, and therefore, must be protected fiercely. As Marlon Brando once said: “ Privacy is not something that I’m merely entitled to, it’s an absolute

Right To Know

1137 words - 5 pages limits of the duty of care? The case of clinical genetics.” Personalized Medicine 5.2 (2008): 101. Web. 7 March 2014. Burr, J. and P. Reynolds. “Thinking Ethically about Genetic Inheritance: Liberal Rights, Communitarianism and the Right to Privacy for Parents of Donor Insemination Children.” J Med Ethics 34.4 (2008): 281-284. Web. 7 March 2014. Daniels, Ken. “The Controversy Regarding Privacy Versus Disclosure Among Patients Using

Right to Privacy as a Basic Right

1265 words - 6 pages The government should not invade the privacy of American citizens because although everyone has come to embrace social networking, it is not right or appropriate for the government to watch its citizens like Big Brother. Privacy rights are very important to the United States citizens. The fourth amendment protects some of our rights. No officer of the law can search any person’s property or belongings without a search warrant approved and signed

The Right to Privacy for Employees and Their Email

888 words - 4 pages , direct access by the employer to the employees? messages may amount to violation of an individual?s right to privacy guaranteed under Article 31 above. In the absence of court rulings concerning this matter, it shall be extremely difficult to assess the validity of such an argument. To our knowledge, there are no court decisions concerning this issue in the UAE as yet? (Qudah).In conclusion, although privacy litigation may alter the way

Similar Essays

The Right To Privacy Essay

1236 words - 5 pages      In this report I am going to talk about the rights people have to privacy and about the laws that go with privacy. Privacy is the thought that information that is confidential that is disclosed in a private place will not be available to third parties when the information would cause embarrassment or emotional distress to a person.      The right of privacy is limited to people who are in

The Right To Privacy Essay

1031 words - 5 pages privacy is not written word for word in any one amendment. It is through the collective wording of the First, Third, Fourth, Fifth, Ninth and Fourteenth Amendments that we, as Americans, are given the most important right to ensuring the existence to freedom. The first major Supreme Court case to address the issue of the right to privacy was Lochner v. New York which was ruled in 1905. This case was brought to the courts to rule on the

The Right To Privacy Essay

1856 words - 7 pages Individuals are born with certain liberty and freedom. Some freedom are being protected by the Bill of Rights, like freedom of religion, speech, press, and assembly, and some are not. Privacy is one of the rights that was not mention in the Constitution. The definition of the right to privacy is the right to be left alone without government’s intrusion. Throughout history the Supreme Court has been ruling in favor of the right to privacy like in

The Right To Privacy Essay

1297 words - 6 pages Since the founding of the United States, our outlook on the way it treats its citizens has not changed very tremendously. Apart from the abolishment of slavery, and various other corrupt practices which were fixed, well for the most part. The concept of birthrights and unalienable rights is not very farfetched, yet our government continuously attempts to impede these rights in an attempt that should not be tested. The right to privacy is a very