The Qeustion Of Equality Essay

1126 words - 5 pages

Its a fact! Very very good!The Question of EqualityEquality is the fundamental demand of the rebellion of the poor: it should be the ideological force behind the new society. How this egalitarian demand is understood is crucial to the distinction between the Democratic Revolution and the Marxist-Jacobin Revolution.The Marxist answer to the egalitarian demand is the dictatorship of the proletariat, which Maurice Duverger shrewdly describes as an accurate continuation of the Jacobin theory of terror:'. . .Man is born but capitalism corrupts him: In order to destroy the system of oppression, exploitation and alienation development by capitalism, violence must be used. Violence against the state, in the first palace, so long as it is in the hands of the exploiting classes: This means revolution. Next, when the working class has taken power, the force of the state is directed against the exploiters and used to destroy every trace of exploitation: this stage is the dictatorship of the proletariat.'In a society such as ours, in which the rich are too few and the poor too many, the Marxist-Jacobinist approach has a ringing appeal. With the term proletariat, one simply substitutes the poor. By 'expropriating the expropriators,' or eradicating the rich, equality is achieved with one bold stroke.The trouble with this formulation, however, is that the dictator-proletariat is itself dictated upon by an all-powerful Party, while even among the poor there is a hierarchy of classes, beginning with the 'advanced' proletariat, followed by the peasantry, the intellectuals and the petite bourgeoise. Moreover, there is a contemptible class, the lumpenproletariat, a term reserved for 'the scum of the earth.'Stated, therefore, in Marxist-Jacobinist terms, the rebellion of the poor is self-contradictory: it is unable to approximate the egalitarian idea.The reason for this lies in the heart of Marxism itself equality is exclusively regarded as a relation between social classes, hence, the solution to bourgeoise domination is proletarian dictatorship. In sum, while the domination is proletarian dictatorship. In sum, while the domination of one class is oppressive, the domination of another is not. But the egalitarian principle states that all men are equal, however their class, color, or creed; it is thus a condition of each and every individual in society. A man is not just a worker, a farmer, a teacher, or a capitalist: he deserves to be treated justly and equally as the rest not because of these social functions but because and simply because he is an individual human being. But the Marxist-Jacobinist equality depends on class, on status, which is contrary to the human concept of equality. It is for the reason that man in a totalitarian state is defined arbitrarily and persecuted arbitrarily by assigning him to a social class.How could this logical practical contradiction gain so much power and appeal? Partly because of coercion and pertly because of the fascistic...

Find Another Essay On The Qeustion of Equality

The Right of Marriage Equality Essay

801 words - 4 pages , the laws have changed significantly, but in majority of Country’s, people are being punished by not being able to marry the love of their life. People view gay marriage as unacceptable, preposterous, and horrendous, but those people are wrong. Men and women of the same sex should have the right to marriage equality because they are just like every other human on this earth. They are no different from any other person; therefore they should have

Equality Is the Center of Society

1237 words - 5 pages People of the Revolutionary generation frequently spoke of equality and how the concept related to their own lives. Noah Webster stated that “equality… is the very soul of a republic” (Webster) and this thought was echoed by many of his contemporaries, but their statements were not in favor of full equality. When most people of the Revolutionary generation spoke in support of equality they spoke about equality for the group they belonged to

"On The Equality Of Men And Women"

584 words - 2 pages As I read the first paragraph of On the Equality of Men and Women by Marie Le Jars de Gournay, I had to go back a page to see when de Gournay lived. This writing seemed like something that would typically have been published in the 1990s. During the Enlightenment, women did not speak their opinion about their equality (or lack there of) with their male counterparts. It was not considered proper. It would even raise eyebrows is a man voiced his

The Significance of Equality: Civil Rights

1662 words - 7 pages under the judicial system. Hence, Brown V. Board of Education set the precedent for all civil rights, and serves as the foundation for equality because it served as a catalyst towards integrating all races. In order to completely understand the Brown v. BOE case, it is essential that one is aware of the various legislatures and violations the judicial system came up with to cause an imbalance in equality, making life more difficult for African

Equality vs The Tyranny of Majority

3673 words - 15 pages recognize equality as how Tocqueville saw what a democratic society is (Mill, 1840). Mill proposed that the influence of the predominant middle class in both America and England in pursuing their wealth as the main problem because “whenever any variety of human nature becomes preponderant in a community, it imposes upon all the rest of society its own type; forcing all, either to submit to or to imitate it” (Mill, 1840). Therefore, Mill recommended a

The ACLU of Pennsylvania: Fighting for the Equality of All

1501 words - 6 pages rights is a core civil liberties issue. It's not about ‘special rights’—it's about fundamental rights. It's about fairness and equality for all” (“LGBT Rights”). It is for this reason that they organized the LGBT & AIDS Project. The LGBT & AIDS Project was founded in 1986 and their main goal and focus was to give the LGBT community the legal equality and justice the organization believes they deserve. Moreover, the point of the Project was to

Birth of Equality and the Death of Chivalry

1394 words - 6 pages The Birth of Equality and the Death of Chivalry "...And now it's time for girls on trampolines!"  Adam Corolla of The Man Show shouts at the end of the insipid program supposedly providing men with "manly" entertainment;  "We give men what they want to see."  This show involves beer guzzling at its best, childish antics involving midgets and the degradation of women in many forms.  It seems as though chivalry may truly have died.  In the

Taxation and Equality: Examining the Foundations of the French Revolution

1268 words - 5 pages upper estates, provided the work force that kept France going, which lead members like abbe Emmanuel Seyes to conclude that the Third Estate had everything the French government needed and that the upper classes were “a burden upon the Nation.” 10 In short, while taxation was one factor of the Third Estate's grievances, it was by far the least of their concerns. What the commoners of France really wanted was equality – and by their lack of

The Struggle of Equality for Blacks in the 21st Century

2460 words - 10 pages The Struggle of Equality for Blacks in the 21st Century On December 29, 2004, Richard Blakey was applying for a job interview at the very prestigious Public Relations firm, Ketchum, in Pittsburgh Pennsylvania. He was the only black man applying for the job. Little did he know that he had no chance of getting the job no matter how qualified he was for the position because he was a black man and his counterparts were white. He went into the

The Declaration of Independence and the Struggle for Equality DBQ

1246 words - 5 pages “The Declaration of Independence and the Struggle for Equality DBQ” “In what way and to what extent does the Declaration of Independence serve as a benchmark for the actions of disenfranchised or otherwise oppressed citizens of the United States of America?” The Declaration of Independence, since July 4th, 1776, has continued to always become a guideline to protect those who are oppressed. “We hold these Truths to be self-evident, “that all Men

The American Revolution: The Beginning of Independence And Equality

1035 words - 4 pages kind of significance. This ensemble of factors caused the British to fail. The colonists had been unfairly taxed and had no been allowed to represent their opinions in Parliament so they sought justice for the inequalities they endured. The revolution was the institution of the independence and equality of our democratic country, the United States of America. Without the problems that arose in the late 18th century causing the revolution to take place, there might not be the openness of sovereignty there is now.

Similar Essays

The Pursuit Of Equality Essay

1024 words - 5 pages rights, writing two prominent literary works: The Equality of Men and Women (1622) and The Ladies’ Grievance (Les femmes et Grief des dames, 1626). Scholars have claimed that these two works have helped to shape the proto-feminist movement, which led to the integration of rights for women into society. Another radically egalitarian woman is Alice Stokes Paul. Born in 1885, she was proud to challenge the subjugating, Victorian standard of extremist

The State Of Equality Essay

790 words - 4 pages Before there was a women’s movement, every facet of society suppressed women to second-class status. Women were under the control of their husbands and needed their permission to get a job or even obtain a credit card. Poorly portrayed and stereotyped in stage and film roles, women were banned from obtaining an education and from many professional fields of work. But despite the success of the fight for women’s equality over the last 100 years

The Tyranny Of Equality Essay

723 words - 3 pages their ideology onto their citizens, and in so doing destroyed them. Lenin played a crucial role in taking down the tsar and bringing equality to the people of Russia. However, after his death, Russia was left in desperate need of a leader. Stalin was eventually victorious over the other candidates, but with this new leader came an era of abusive dictatorship. A myriad of peasants rebelled against the seizure of their land by destroying their fields

Equality Of The Sexes Essay

3063 words - 12 pages Equality of the Sexes What is the real difference between men and women? Is sex merely an anatomical difference, or are gender roles based on actual mental and emotional differences? Regardless of whether gender roles are socially constructed or naturally inherent, they exist and have since Adam and Eve.      The history of gender roles has been long and varied, frequently switching from near equality of the sexes to complete inequality