This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Question Of A Representative Democracy: Where Should The Power Go

1200 words - 5 pages

The Founders were confronted with a multitude of concerns in the establishment of an American democracy, a fundamental one being how to best apportion power in order to avoid the rule of a “tyrant” individual person or group. The Founders answered this issues with conflicting ideals, and through their experiences in the Revolutionary War and the Articles of Confederation, arrived at a compromise, ratifying the U.S. Constitution
The manner in which power in America was balanced was a direct result of being subject to British rule. Authority in the English system was highly centralized, with the power predominately held by crown and parliament. Due to salutary neglect, the colonists had at first became accustomed to managing their own affairs, but in the years prior to the Revolution, had lost the ability to do so when the national government stepped in to exert more control. The colonists dissented, subject to the wishes Grenville ministry, an ocean away, rather than their own. Thus, it was the actions such an overbearing national authority that resulted in the spreading of the notion of independence, creating a climate hostile to a large central bureaucracy, leading to the Revolution and the establishment of the United States under the Articles of Confederation, an attempt to set a framework opposite that of England.
“The American War”, Thomas Jefferson claimed, had ended, but that this was “far from the case with the American Revolution” The young America would undergo radical shifts in regards to its structure. In America's first years, the Revolutionaries predominantly wished for a decentralized government. Having fought opposed an overbearing national authority from England, they had no desire to establish such an all powerful bureaucracy in Washington. Thus, the first attempt to formally organize the states came in the form of the Articles of Confederation. Under the Articles, America was not the single unified nation it is known as today; rather, it was, as the Articles suggested, a confederation of independent states, reflecting the Declaration of Independence, which was considered an act not by one body, but by “thirteen United States”. These autonomous states were loosely connected through a weak federal government; there was only a legislative branch at the national level, Continental Congress, with no provision from the Articles for an executive department or a national court. The only roles of Congress were to coin money, deal with foreign nations, and operate the postal system. Furthermore, the states overshadowed Congress in regards to the first two roles, each issuing currencies and drafting armies of their own. With no set currency and no overarching leadership to regulate commerce, the economy of the states was unstable. Congress could not easily enact laws, dependent completely on the will of the states. Congress required nine out of thirteen votes from the states, a system which represented the public unequally, giving each...

Find Another Essay On The question of a representative democracy: where should the power go

US Senate Vs. The House of Representative

540 words - 2 pages agreements, and nominates and receives ambassadors. The role of chief legislator includes recommending legislation to Congress, lobbying for the legislation, approving laws, and exercising the veto power. The president also has statutory powers written into law by Congress. The president is also leader of his or her political party. Presidents use their power to persuade and their access to the media to fulfill this function. Presidents have a variety of special powers not available to other branches of the government. These include emergency power, executive power, executive privilege, and impoundment of funds.

Where Should the Buck Stop? Essay

931 words - 4 pages Where Should the Buck Stop? Marijuana became illegal with the passing of the Marijuana Tax Act in 1934. The Marijuana Tax Act required individuals who wished to sell or distribute marijuana to first register with the government and then pay a special tax. These requirements along with extremely strict government controls effectively criminalizing the medical or recreational use of marijuana (Schlosser). In 1938 The Federal Food, Drug and

The Lord of the Flies: A Representative Example of Society and Government

1703 words - 7 pages leader. Everything began as a civilized and democratic group led by Ralph. The first decision made was the way everyone would get a chance to speak and contribute ideas to the group. This is when the conch was found, it was a symbol that represented democracy. “We've got to have rules and obey them. After all, we're not savages. We're English, and the English are best at everything” (Golding, Lord of the Flies, 1954, Chapter 2) stated Ralph

The transformation of English government: The development of a representative rule

667 words - 3 pages Continual breakdown of the Feudal Society As previously stated the feudal society began its decline prior to the year 1215 however the Magna Carta furthered this process. There were new restrictions placed upon the feudal relationship in a variety of contexts; in turn this would disperse power from the nobles to those lower in the hierarchy. One of the largest areas of impact of the Magna Carta in terms of the feudal relationship was placing

Democracy: A Unique Form of People Power

1126 words - 5 pages The word democracy is derived from the Greek words of “demos”, referring to people and “Kratos”, meaning power . The Greeks are credited with developing the earliest forms of democracy around 2,500 years ago. India, Russia, Japan and many other nations have only recently become democratic. Therefore, despite its lengthy history as a concept, democracy has only really become a global reality during the latter half of the 20th century. Democracy

'And Then There Were None' by Agatha Christie as a representative of the detective genre

646 words - 3 pages The novel 'And Then There Were None' by Agatha Christie is a good representative of the detective genre. The following criteria, that this novel fulfils, classifies it as a detective novel: There is a crime or mystery to be solved, One person (or a group of people) is either a detective or an adult or young person who has set themselves the task of solving the crime or mystery, Information about the perpetrator is revealed, discovered or

How Representative Are Social Media Datasets of the True Population: A Case for London

1491 words - 6 pages creation of such a population register for Greater London at borough and electoral regions levels, the methods used to assess its representative capability, and finally present preliminary results of this analysis with a discussion as to its potential strengths and weaknesses. Proving successful, the methodology proposed will be applied to further countries, as yet not included in the WND. Figure 1: Coverage of the World Names Database

The Rise of a Liberal Democracy

1636 words - 7 pages has no structure to protect basic rights. Basically a ruling of the majority with no safe guards in place; people are inherently evil therefore this is the worst form of government between the two. It is based on the fact that the masses are capable of governing themselves, which is entirely wrong; people are evil and dumb and should not be allowed to have unrestricted access to power. That is one reason illiberal democracies have a tendency toward

This essay will seek to explore the question of how and why Prussia emerged as a great power - History - essay

1596 words - 7 pages ."[footnoteRef:1] However, Prussia was a relatively new nation state as it had been composed of independent territories that were politically fragmented until the 17th century.[footnoteRef:2] This essay will seek to explore the question of how and why Prussia emerged as a great power via the analysis of academic sources, contrasting the arguments made in order to arrive at a credible conclusion. The analysis will focus largely on the Seven Years' War of

Life of a Sales Representative

1179 words - 5 pages Life of a Salesman People tend to shy away from a sales career due to the fact they lack self-confidence or they don’t want to be the stereotype of being pushy or dishonest. A career as a successful sales representative requires a positive attitude and the ability to be creatively persistent to sell a product without forcing it on the customer. According to Alliance (2013), “sales representative jobs have the potential to be dynamic, exciting

Should We Go Gentle Into the Night?

985 words - 4 pages Courtney Willis Professor Dursema English 1010 10 November 2014Should We Go Gentle into the Night?Imagine no longer being able to get out of bed, to eat, or to go to the bathroom without assistance - needing someone to clothe and bathe you every single day. Can we really call that living? When it's your time to leave this earth, is that dying with dignity? Let's say, for example, that you have been diagnosed with a terminal or chronic illness

Similar Essays

The Xeno Mouse: The Case Of Where The Business Should Go

1019 words - 5 pages John De Garmo, Section 002, 4/8/14, ID: 931-426-635 The XenoMouse: The Case of Where the Business Should Go 1) What are the pros and cons of Abgenix collaborating with a partner on ABX-EGF in comparison to going solo? A partner to the business brings an advantage of providing additional capital, resources, and other material to develop the ABX-EGF drug program, all the while limiting the amount of risk that Abgenix takes on. For example

The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Representative Democracy

886 words - 4 pages majority of the people would argue that we are all equal and we should all have an equal say in all matters. After all, democracy is defined as "A form of government in which political power is exercised by the citizens".Another argument for Representative democracy is that it is very practical and quick. Some people think that other kinds of democracy are more efficient like direct democracy because the whole country would vote on every issue and it

Examining The Ways A Pressure Group Contributes To Representative Democracy

826 words - 3 pages electorate. However many are unsatisfied with their representation and join pressure groups to make their views heard. The question is, is this good or bad for our democracy? Pluralism is the way in which the electorate joins groups to have an effect on government. Many pro-pluralists believe pluralism exists to stop the perceived failures of a representative democracy. They think pluralism contributes to representative

Are Referendums A Sensible Mechanism For Making Decisions In A Representative Democracy? University Of Reading Essay

1572 words - 7 pages Are referendums a sensible mechanism for making decisions in a representative democracy? A referendum is a general vote by the electorate on a single political question which has been referred to them for a direct decision . In contrast, a representative democracy is where citizens within a country elect representatives to make decisions on behalf of them in the form of mp’s as is the case in the UK. Although the UK occasionally incorporates