This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Rationale Of Suicide In Bartleby

970 words - 4 pages

The Rationale of Suicide in Bartleby 

   One of the most strikingly confusing details of Herman Melville's "Bartleby" is the repetitive use of the specific form of his refusals; he "prefers" not to comply with his employer's demands. Bartleby never argues for his convictions, rather he refuses on the grounds of his preference. Such a vast repetition, along with its inherent perplexity, leads me to believe that the actual wording is symbolic in nature.


     When someone is asked for his/her preferences, the question is directed to the individual's inner motives and desires. Any question addressed as a preference question, usually grants the consideration of the innermost inclinations. The lawyer never asked Bartleby whether he would like to comply or not, yet the latter keeps answering with the same term of preference; a choice of word that comes to show that Bartleby does not regard the demands laid upon him as intrinsically valid, he rather questions them in light of his inclinations and answers accordingly.


    The lawyer, on the other hand, does view his demands as intrinsically valid. The lawyer represents society with all its requirements and demands. Society expects us to work for our living under the terms and conditions that it sets, but what if we choose not to? *  The lawyer does not make much of Bartleby's choice of words, he does not recognize the real problem; namely, Bartleby is neither interested, nor subjected to the rules of society


     Bartleby's state is further clarified by the symbolic use of the walls and the dead letter office described in the epilogue. First, throughout the story he is depicted time and again as facing and staring at a wall. Staring at a wall can mean one or both of the following options: either looking for an answer as in staring at a blanc card, or the possible end of the former; actually looking at a dead end when no answer is found.


     It appears that Bartleby is hopelessly searching for something that he would actually "prefer" to do; an assumption backed by his symbolic open-eyed death at the end, and also by his reference to his interests while discussing other job options with his boss: "I would not like it at all" (par. 204) is the answer he repeats in different wording when offered five different lines of work. In other words, he is connected to his inner inclinations (our pure will that can incline us to either take an action or refrain from it), yet they do not incline him to do anything.


     The reference to the dead letter solves the mystery; a letter that lacks an address is a dead letter; an address is the letter's direction; for the lack of direction a letter dies.


The immediate...

Find Another Essay On The Rationale of Suicide in Bartleby

The USe of Secrets as a Thematic Device in Bartleby

1541 words - 6 pages The Use of Secrets as a Thematic Device in "Bartleby"Secrets are an important theme in many stories. Secrets may be kept from the reader, from other characters in the story, or a character may be in denial, thereby keeping secrets from him or herself. These secrets could also be shared, with other characters, or with the reader. Ultimately however, it is the narrator of the story, through which the author speaks, that chooses to divest or

Allusions in Bartleby the Scrivener Essay

660 words - 3 pages fictitious world of this short story. One of the biggest allusions in “Bartleby, the Scrivener” is the comparison of Bartleby to Jesus. In the story the narrator is confronted by the new owner of the law offices. He asks the narrator if he knows who Bartleby is. The narrator replies with “I certainly cannot inform you. I know nothing about him” (Melville 29). In this instance the narrator is denying knowing who Bartleby is to keep himself from the

The Rationale for P.E. in the Curriculum

1031 words - 4 pages This essay is about analysing the Rationale for P.E in the curriculum and discussion the subject’s approach to the National Curriculum. Within this essay, you would notice discussions being made for the reasons why Physical Education is to be considered as a core subject from key stages 1-4 (ages 5-16) and how it could be integrated to other academic subjects. Looking through research, the term Physical Education could be defined as “a

An Analysis in the Caltech Rationale

1036 words - 5 pages , or formulas, without understanding the reasoning behind them. I think it is for this reason that, were I hypothetically forced to pick a humanities course as a major, I would select economics, because, although the consequences of actions in the national and international economies and markets may be disputed, the theories that suggest different results, such as Classical versus Keynesian economics, follow a set rationale that proves better to

Isolation and Society in Bartleby, the Scrivener

702 words - 3 pages Isolation and Society in Bartleby, the Scrivener         Herman Melville's Bartleby is a tale of isolation and alienation. In his story, society is primarily to blame for the creation and demise of Bartleby.         Throughout the story, the characters -- Bartleby in particular -- are isolated from each other or from society. The forester's office, which can be

Social Deviance in Bartleby the Scrivener

684 words - 3 pages Social Deviance in Bartleby the Scrivener           Bartleby the Scrivener is a story that takes place on Wall Street, peopled by workers of a common mold.  Being a non-conformatist of the most extreme type,  Bartleby is eventually suffers a death of attrition.  The message that Melville intends for the reader is how society has little tolerance for social deviance

Transcendentalist View Of Bartleby The Scrivener's Actions

595 words - 2 pages Transcendentalist View of Bartleby the Scrivener Actions The Transcendentalists and the Dark Romantics were the two major literary groups of America's literary coming of age. The transcendentalists believed in transcending everyday, physical human experiences and objects, in order to determine the reality of God, the universe, and the self. Transcendentalists, led by Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau, believed in the good of man, and

The Plight of the Common Man in Herman Melville's Bartleby, the Scrivener

4414 words - 18 pages individual sovereignty in his short story "Bartleby the Scrivener"; through the actions and the attitudes of the elite narrator in the story, the deceptiveness of democracy is evident. The ideology of democracy purports that all men are created equal and are equally represented in the voice of government. Yet, the scriveners as common men are separated from the elite narrator who creates the walls of exclusion in order to perpetuate the myth of

Plot, Setting, Point of View, and Tone in Bartleby the Scrivener

1362 words - 5 pages although he is not aware of this. Bartleby contrasts the lawyer through his existentialism and completely non-materialistic identity. Charles G. Hoffmann comments, "Traditionalism in the form of usefulness and methodology, self-interest in the form of ambition and survival: this is the rationale of the world into which Bartleby has entered" (109). Bartleby cannot survive in such a world where conformity is a necessity for survival. Bartleby believes

The Epidemic of Teen Suicide in America

1086 words - 4 pages      Every year, thousands of youth die in the United States, not by cancer, car accidents, and other diseases, but by their own hand. These people make the choice that they want to die and they take their own life. Suicide, the term given to the act of killing oneself, is the third leading cause of death among people that are 15 to 25 years of age. It is estimated that 500,000 teenagers try to kill themselves during the course of one year

The Dangers of Conformity in Bartleby, the Scrivener and A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings

1765 words - 7 pages The Dangers of Conformity in Bartleby, the Scrivener and A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings     Authors can use various concepts to enhance or dictate the progression of their work. Ambiguity is one such tool that has the power to influence a story. In "Bartleby, the Scrivener" and "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings," Melville and Marquez utilize ambiguity to develop their story's theme. Both authors focus ambiguity around the main

Similar Essays

Point Of View In Bartleby, The Scrivener

957 words - 4 pages . It is their, “persona.” The voice of the narrator in this case confirms that he is truly taken aback by Bartleby. His attitude reflects why he gets upset with him. He just can’t figure him out. He tells Bartleby again that he needs copies made. Bartleby emphasizes, “I would prefer not to.” “For a few moments I was turned in to a pillar of salt, standing at the head of my seated column of clerks. Recovering myself, I advanced towards the

The True Intentions Of The Lawyer In “Bartleby, The Scrivener”

807 words - 4 pages The lawyer, also the narrator, hires Bartleby to work as a scrivener at his business that involves bonds, mortgages and titles. The lawyer thinks he has all of his scriveners behaviors “on lock”. Although Bartleby started as a hard working employee, he eventually and in a calm manner refuses to do any requested work by the lawyer by simply saying, “I would prefer not to”. The lawyer doesn’t fire Bartleby after he declines to work, instead he

Rationale For The Position Of: Essay

904 words - 4 pages The following points are the core of my rationale for the need to have a Program Assistant position in the Financial Aid Office. • Provide consistent and reliable information to students, parents, staff and general public. • Improve fiscal accountability and liability of all financial aid funds. • Improve services to the Omak campus. One of WVC core theme is Support for Learning: The Objective is that WVC’s non-instructional programs and

Themes Of Hopelessness In Herman Melville’s Bartleby The Scrivener

1231 words - 5 pages We can never be one hundred percent certain of the validity of our literary analyses. This is especially the case with Herman Melville’s “Bartleby the Scrivener”. Critics have been trying for decades to make sense of the text and most will describe it as “inscrutable”. I don’t claim to know better than the critics, but instead offer my own interpretation of the work. Based on my observations and analysis, Melville’s use of many elements in his