"The Reader" By Bernard Schlink About Post Ww2 Germany.

2173 words - 9 pages

More than just a book, The Reader reminds that the concepts of guilt and responsibility are not clear-cut ideas, and even more so during the Nuremberg Trials. Guilt is simply one of the many human emotions, but the feeling of guilt is unique to everyone and there is no one meaning for guilt. Though guilt is such a strong feeling, judgments must not be made simply on how "guilty" one feels for their actions. If that is so, then Hanna would never have gone to jail at all. Judgments should instead be made on the actions of a person and whether the person was right or wrong in what he/she did. This is the concept of responsibility. How responsible a person was for their actions should determine how "guilty" a person is for their crimes. But responsibility is such a difficult question to resolve and deal with because how can you judge how responsible a person is for their actions? In the case of Hanna's trial, how was responsible? The powers that be made the decisions, but people under them carried out these decisions. So who is responsible? The people who made the decisions, or the people who carried out the decisions? It seems that the person who holds the knife must be the one responsible. But fortunately and rightly so, justice is never so easy.Guilt and responsibility, being human emotions can never be pinned down, because it is human nature to be fickle and therefore there will always be a gray area when it comes to determining the true meaning (if there is such a thing) of guilt and responsibility. The problem is that we have come to believe that guilt and responsibility is the same thing, but in reality they are poles apart. This misunderstanding comes around due to the fact that courts often give the verdict "guilty" or "not guilty." But just because a person have been proved without any doubt that they are responsible for the crime, it does NOT mean they feel any remorse or sadness for committing the crime. Two different eras, two different circumstances and two different philosophies. Hanna is the product of her illiteracy and a time where orders were made to be followed not discussed. Hanna's illiteracy has led her to be "socially isolated" and therefore she has distorted view of what is right and wrong. On the other hand, Michael is the results of a more well educated and informed generation that believed they clearly understood the distinctions between right and wrong. Been of different eras and circumstances, Hanna and Michael both have different opinions of "responsibility", but just because Michael comes from a philosophical and well-educated background does not mean he is right in his thinking. Contrary to beliefs, a university education does not give you a better understanding of the raw human emotions and feelings, which are displayed in The Reader. Guilt has no less an ambiguous meaning than responsibility. Guilt should never be dealt in court as some people believe, but instead must be resolved internally. Responsibility should...

Find Another Essay On "The Reader" by Bernard Schlink about post WW2 Germany.

The Natural by Bernard Malamud Essay

1463 words - 6 pages for the ball but it was already in the catcher’s mitt” (181). In this description, Roy strikes out in the “foggy” climax of The Natural. This is the biggest turning point and disappointment the reader has to face in the book. The author deceives the reader by making him or her believe Roy is a perfect player. Malamud also uses great imagery when writing about Roy’s accomplishments. The narrator says: “The third ball slithered at the batter

The Fixer by Bernard Malamud Essay

1559 words - 6 pages and existential trauma. It offers a paralysed hope for human beings, however man has to wrestle with his sufferings to attain a miniature amount of happiness and sufferings which mold us to be good human beings. The role of conversion would not have taken place without the act of suffering. This vital concept is powerfully handled by the Jewish-American writer, Bernard Malamud in his novel, The Fixer. The Fixer is a classic example for the

The Natural by Bernard Malamud

859 words - 3 pages Untitled The Natural The novel The Natural, by Bernard Malamud, is about a young, talented, athletic, but naive baseball player, Roy Hobbs. Roy, at the age of thirty-four, finally achieves his dream of being a superstar baseball player, but his inability to control his appetites for food, women, and wealth, threatens to undermine his performance and cost his team the pennant. Roy's life is packed with tragic events from his

The Early Struggle of post- WWI Germany.

860 words - 3 pages democratic system that's introduced to Germany. The constitution was ineffective because no one listened to the government. The states have too much power, which cause them to ignore the government. The army was not fully under the government's control, because it is led by the right-wing General Hans von Seeckt. The German army had failed to help the government during the Kapp Putsch and the invasion crisis of 1923. Another thing that makes the

The Magic Barrel Anylisis by Bernard Malamud

1918 words - 8 pages further twelve thousand. Also, she has a new car, wonderful clothes, talks on all subjects, and she will give you a first-class home and children?” Leo is very confused by this point, questioning himself if he should settle for the wife that will benefit him “usual selling points and constructs flimsy excuses for rejecting many of the candidates.”(Enotes) He is creating any excuse to create more time to think about what he wants. Alternatively, if

"The Best Revenge" by Stephen White book report, web of characters bringing about different perspectives to the reader.

1723 words - 7 pages over again" (144). While Tom is a free man, he feels like he continuously has to watch his back against possible dangers against him. Even though Dr. Gregory believes that Tom is an innocent man, the reader is left still contemplating on whether he is or just received a string of luck. Reading about a man who got a break and was released from prison can leave the reader feeling various ways, either for or against it. But the way Tom relates about

Question: To what extent was the policy of appeasement shown towards Germany the main cause of WW2?

2477 words - 10 pages Untitled History Essay Question: To what extent was the policy of appeasement shown towards Germany the main cause of WW2? "An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping it will eat him last". This quote by Winston Churchill illustrates the views and beliefs towards the policy of appeasement demonstrated by many politicians during and after the war. Appeasement, after the World War Two ended was seen by many historians

Analysis of Arms and the Man by George Bernard Shaw

950 words - 4 pages Analysis of Arms and the Man by George Bernard Shaw "Arms and the Man" starts with gunfire on a dark street in a small town. The romantic and willful Raina is about to begin her true-life adventure by sheltering the handsome fugitive Bluntschli, enemy of her equally handsome fiancé Sergius The setting of the play is in war-torn Bulgaria, and focuses not only on the romance between the young people of the play, but the atrocities

Post First World War Revolutions in Germany and the Former Habsburg Empire

2132 words - 9 pages revolution. These soldiers comprised the core of post-war revolutionaries in Germany, as they had seen firsthand the horrors of war and had become convinced of communism being the correct path to reform. The push for communist reforms can be further evidenced still as, “A local Räterepublik was declared in Munich on 7 April (1919), led by a motely coalition of anarchists, independents, and Socialists. The KPD developed strength in the local trade

Analyze how the American way of waging war during WW2 influenced the United States in the conduct of limited warfare in the post-World War Two era.

976 words - 4 pages Question:Analyze the American way of waging war compared to the Japanese and German conduct of war in World War Two and how that experience influenced the United States in the conduct of limited warfare in the post-World War Two era. Address the societal aspects of the United States as they influenced its way of war. Be specific in your answer by discussing technology, tactics, formations, organizations, weaponry, training, doctrine and

This essay is how the neo nazi skinhead movement came to be and its effect on post WW2 Europe and America.

3720 words - 15 pages had been outside of his isolated life he meet Teddy Boys, Hard Mods, Rockers, Punks, and the very few first generation of Skinheads still left. Out of all these groups Stuart felt that Tumbling Dice and the Skinheads shared the same ideas about watching out for yourself. In 1977 Stuart changed his band's name to Skrewdriver, having a Punk characteristic by not spelling it the right way. Stuart performed with reggae and punk bands but found them

Similar Essays

"The Reader", By Bernhard Schlink : Guilt And Shame

1054 words - 4 pages "The Reader", by Bernhard Schlink is set in postwar Germany and tells the story of fifteen-year-old Michael Berg and his affair with a woman named Hanna, who was twice his age. After some time, she disappears. When Michael next sees Hanna, he is a young law student and she is on trial for her work in the Auschwitz concentration camp. Their feelings of guilt and shame lead to Hanna's tragic death near the end of the story. Bernhard Schlink is

The Theme Of War Guilt In Bernard Schlink's, "The Reader".

732 words - 3 pages The Reader Bernhard Schlink ThemesWar GuiltOne of the main ideas in The Reader is German war guilt - guilt felt by both the war-time generation and the post-war generation. The post-war generation, to which the author, Schlink, belongs, has struggled to come to terms with the war crimes committed by the previous generation. The novel begins with a sick Michael being comforted by the maternal Hanna. This is an obvious symbol for the idea that the

Perspectives On Love In Bernard Schlink's The Reader

1355 words - 5 pages tragic end to their relationship. This resulted in Michael’s sadness throughout the whole story. Michael always reminisced on the unforgettable moments of his relationship with Hanna. Thus, love was a major theme throughout the whole story and was successfully portrayed by Bernhard Schlink. In summary, Bernhard Schlink is portrayed as a proponent of love. Works Cited Schlink, Bernhard. The Reader. Trans. and Carol Brown Janeway. New York: Random House Inc. 1997. Print.

Lessons That Spencer Morgan Learned From The War: Reader Response From "Soldier Boys" By Dean Hughes. Describes 2 Lessons Spencer Learned From Ww2

658 words - 3 pages Reader Response: Spencer's lessons in the War from "Soldier Boys" by Dean HughesMany of the men who enlisted in World War Two were not actual men, but merely boys, wanting to be heroic and do something to support their country. One of these boys, Spencer Morgan, was only seventeen when he enlisted. He, like many others, wanted to prove himself, to be a hero, even if he was known only in his little hometown of Brigham City, Utah. Spencer soon