This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Reasons Behind Bloody Sunday Essay

3245 words - 13 pages

The Reasons Behind Bloody Sunday

Both of these sources are primary as both were written at the time,
but Source B is an account written by someone who was actually within
the workers of the strike whereas Source A is the account of events as
the Tsar saw them or heard about them. This however does not make
Source B more useful than Source A just because it was written by
someone within the crowd. This source could have been written possibly
some hours after the march and some details may have got confused or
to make the report sound more interesting the writer's imagination
could have come in to use.

Source A is the Tsars version of events on what happened on Bloody
Sunday. Even though the Tsar was the leader of the country the
information about Bloody Sunday was relayed to him because he was not
present to witness the goings on. We can tell this as in his diary he
says he went out for a walk and lunch. This could mean that the
information he was told was information he wanted to hear and not the
actual details. The person who told him could not have told the Tsar
everything to make sure the events didn't sound as bad as they were.
This however could not be true and everything he wrote in his diary
was true as it was probably him that ordered the troops on the crowd.
In his diary he also writes how he feels about the events: 'God, how
painful and sad!' But then he swiftly moves on to the other events in
his day. This makes it seem like he does not really care about what
happened and what is written in his diary could all have been for
show. This also explains why his diary doesn't go into the accident in
detail.

Source B although it seems more useful than Source A it may not be. I
think this because the writer of this article could have easily
tampered with the correct details of that day. The report seems to be
quite biased towards the marchers and because the writer was only in
one place he only saw the events in one place whereas the Tsar would
have been told what happened everywhere.

Despite this I personally would find Source B more useful therefore I
would say a historian would find this more useful. Although the report
may have some parts that are slightly exaggerated it has the basic
events in it whereas the Tsars diary could have easily been written in
mind that if it was found there must be bits in it where the Tsar
expresses his shock so he was not accused of not caring, also the
information given to him was probably not the whole truth.

b) How far does Source D agree with the impression of the marchers
given in Source C?

The way that the petition is written would suggest that the marchers
really are at their last straw and are very desperate. I think that
this image of desperation and suffering portrayed by the requests in
the petition link in with...

Find Another Essay On The Reasons Behind Bloody Sunday

The reasons behind the war with Iraq

1080 words - 4 pages be obvious to everyone that he has no intention of ever fully co-operating with the United Nations Council. We are twelve years behind schedule in taking action against this type of political manipulation. The time has come to finally eradicate this proverbial pain. ( United Nations Security Council 2 )The world would be a much safer place without Saddam Hussein because his chemical and biological weapons pose a threat to every kind of life form

The Reasons Behind the 1920's Boom

1761 words - 7 pages The Reasons Behind the 1920's Boom Introduction: This essay will mainly examine the main reasons for the boom of America in the 1920s. Boom can be referred to as the increase in economy, industry, population and different other factors. Moving out of the poor lands of Europe and Asia, there was a place found at last where one could find Happiness or more precisely MONEY. This glorious land was the 'richest country in

Reasons Behind the Nazis Coming to Power

2030 words - 8 pages Reasons Behind the Nazis Coming to Power In January 1933, Hitler became chancellor of Germany, there are many reasons for him and the Nazis coming into power. They are long term and short-term cause, which can be classed under 3 main headings: weakness of opposition, strengths of Nazis and economic factors. The weaknesses of the opposition helped the Nazis come into power because Hitler took advantage of them. The

Serial Killers - The reasons behind their crimes

2640 words - 11 pages ; Ayneswarth, 2000, p.V). In other words, we can only come to understand the minds of these people to the extent that they'll allow us to, and only they will ever truly know the meaning behind their crimes.The FBI has created what you could almost call a "requirement list" to what makes you a serial killer. They define serial murder as: a minimum of three to four victims, with a "cooling off" period in between; the victim is usually a stranger making

Reasons Behind the Failure of the Provisional Government

1337 words - 5 pages Reasons Behind the Failure of the Provisional Government The provisional government was brought about after the fall of the Tsarist government collapsed. This was done purely because of lack of support for the Tsar and being the only major party. They were in power for 8months and after making five serious errors; they were removed from power by force. Kerensky ran the provisional government and it was his lack of

The Reasons Behind the Deaths of Romeo and Juliet

2111 words - 8 pages The Reasons Behind the Deaths of Romeo and Juliet "From forth the fatal loins of these to foes A pair of star-crossed lovers take their life; Whose misadventured piteous overthrows Doth with their death bury their parent's strife." From the opening scenes of the play it is made clear that these two children of the feuding families were destined to fall in love and eventually die together, but was it the

The reasons behind the development of need for achievement

1294 words - 6 pages The Reasons behind the Development of Need for Achievement Introduction In this essay the author will be showing how a life experience that happened right when she was born made her grow up with a high need for achievement, relating to the theories self-actualization, self- efficacy, and locus of control. According to S. E. Wood, E. G. Wood, and D. Boyd, authors of Mastering the World of Psychology (2011), the definition of need for achievement

Sherlock Holmes: Explore the reasons behind the enduring popularity

3435 words - 14 pages Sherlock Holmes: Explore the reasons behind the enduring popularity. One of the main reasons for the enduring popularity of Sherlock Holmes from the time it was written to the present day was the way that all the stories were told through the eyes of Dr. Watson. This showed how incredible Sherlock Holmes was when his own powers of deduction could see a lot more clues and evidence from the same hat as we the reader could see. Also with

The Reasons Behind the Development of Women's Suffrage Campaign

3266 words - 13 pages The Reasons Behind the Development of Women's Suffrage Campaign Ans.1: From 1837 to 1901 Britain, reached its highest power, and was ruled over by a female monarch. Queen Victory ruled over a society in which women were denied the same political rights as men, in employment they experienced exploitation, whilst the doors to professional careers remained closed to them. Society expected women to be wives and mothers and

Reasons behind Obesity in the United States of America

1116 words - 5 pages lkar English 1201 Research paper May 2 2014 Reasons behind obesity in the United States of America United States of America is one of the most leading obese countries in the world, and the reasons are fairly understandable. We can observe that on our own. We have fast food chains on every block, where the foods are very cheap and unhealthy. Besides, we have more and more technology to make our lives easier. Hence people are getting lazier. All

The Reasons Behind Puerto Rican Migration to America

2570 words - 10 pages The Reasons Behind Puerto Rican Migration to America As a Puerto Rican who was born and raised in Hartford, I did not think much about how or why my parents are here in the United States. It was after reading the articles in Hist 247 Reader: Latinos in the USA that I began to question the reasons and conditions of my grandparent's migration. Many think that Puerto Ricans began to migrate to the United States after 1898 when the United States

Similar Essays

The Bloody Sunday Essay

1708 words - 7 pages The Bloody Sunday On 30th January 1972, 13 Catholics were killed when soldiers of a British paratroop regiment opened fire during a civil rights march in Londonderry. The day became known as Bloody Sunday. Its impact led to a resurgence of violent opposition to the British presence in Northern Ireland. Although the details of what took place that day remain controversial, many of the basic facts are not disputed, 14

The Meaning Of Bloody Sunday Essay

1680 words - 7 pages The Meaning of Bloody Sunday Bloody Sunday was an incident of January 22, 1905 where unarmed demonstrators marched to the Winter Palace present a petition to the Czar. They were gunned down by Imperial guards in St. Petersburg. The event was organized by Father Gapon, a paid agent provocateur of the Okhranka, the Czarist internal secret police. Father George Gapon founded the Assembly of Russian Factory and Plant

The Effects Of Bloody Sunday Essay

1870 words - 7 pages The Effects of Bloody Sunday Bloody Sunday marked the day of a out lash of great hatred which burns strong even today. Bloody Sunday started when the Catholics started a march for civil rights; better housing and comparative costs for the housing as Protestants had better housing for the same rent as the Catholics did even when they had the worst housing. The march also focused on Interment, and the infringement

Reasons Behind The Industrial Revolution Essay

3264 words - 13 pages Reasons Behind the Industrial Revolution The Industrial Revolution was the widespread replacement of labor by machines driven by water wheels, windmills and later by steam power. This change called the Industrial Revolution was a process, which began in the 18th century and continued well into the 19th century. The Industrial Revolution was the result of interrelated changes, which transformed agricultural economies