This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Reichstag Fire Essay

2400 words - 10 pages

The Reichstag Fire

1. Source A was written by Rudolf Diels, who was the head of the Prussian political police at the time of the fire. In his account of events, he explains that he caught Van Der Lubbe red handed, the suspect was alone and there was no evidence that he could see that involved other people, even other communists. He strongly disagreed with Goring and Hitler's theory that Van Der Lubbe was aided in some way, and that the whole affair was a communist plot to seize power. During the trial of Van Der Lubbe in 1933, he openly confessed to setting fire to the building, but denied that he had been helped. His statement in source B shows that he was adamant that he had worked alone. This would seem to prove Diels' theory, however, Van Der Lubbe could easily have been lying in order to protect the other arsonists, who would have probably been high ranking members of the communist party according to Goring's theory, and therefore much more valuable than a simple member, although extremely devoted, who was mentally unstable. If he was lying, he could also be covering the tracks of the Nazi party, who could have set it all up and, as they did, place the blame on the communists. All of this causes great confusion for anyone trying to uncover the truth. Rudolf Diels' account could be seen as reasonably reliable as he seems to have considered all the evidence and come to a thought out and unbiased opinion. Unfortunately, Van Der Lubbe is not a reliable source as he could be protecting any amount of people; there is also evidence that he was mentally unstable, and this means that his evidence is even more unreliable.

2. Source A, Rudolf Diels' account of the fire, although coming from a high ranking Nazi official, seems to disagree with Goring and Hitler's theory that it was a communist plot with many operatives. This is evidence that Diels wasn't acting simply on obedience to Hitler and the Nazi party, even though it was published after the war and Hitler's death (its likely that Diels would never have dared speak a word to contradict Hitler before the end of the war, for fear of being killed). As the head of the Prussian political police at the time, Diels was one of the first people called to the scene, so he was able to investigate at the scene, only minutes after the crime had been committed (he also headed the full investigation afterwards). He claims that he found Van Der Lubbe alone in the Reichstag, out of breath and dirty; he also relates other evidence that seem to prove the possibility that Van Der Lubbe started the fire alone, he studies the architecture and materials that where found in the Reichstag, all of it was mostly wood, old furniture and heavy curtains, all of these were highly inflammable. He says that Van Der Lubbe could have easily set fire to the Reichstag as he ran around the long corridors, waving his shirt around and lighting every thing possible. Even after a consultation with Goring and Hitler, during which...

Find Another Essay On The Reichstag Fire

To what extent was the dawes plan a turning point? - The Dawes plan - Essay

1379 words - 6 pages night was not the most important, that the most important night was the one of "The Reichstag Fire". Hitler was already Chancellor of Germany, but now he had to take takeover Germany, gain the people's support and trust. He called an election on March 1933 with the ai of finally getting overall majority in the Reichstag. Hitler didn't change any of his tactics that he had used in past elections; speeches, rallies, processions and street fighting, the

Hitler's Story Essay

1221 words - 5 pages allowed Hitler to increase his control over Germany. On 27th February the Reichstag caught fire. When they police arrived they found Marinus van der Lubbe on the premises. He confessed to starting the Reichstag Fire. However he denies that he was part of a Communist conspiracy. Hermann Goering refuses to believe him and he orders the arrest of several leaders of the German Communist Party

Structural Problem of the Weimar Republic

1448 words - 6 pages ties are also placed under suspicion. Lastly, one of the arsonists that was arrested admitted to having ties to the Social Democratic Party. “This confession clearly establishes that the Communists and Social Democrats quite obviously built a united front. ” In response to this Hitler and the German parliament took drastic action, by passing what is known as the Reichstag Fire Decree, which among other things suspended civil liberties. This

The Establishment of Hitler's Dictatorship and Its Legality

1313 words - 5 pages policy can be broken into three phases beginning with 1933-34. During these years, Hitler consolidated his authority through the destruction of all other political parties, "co-ordination" of all aspects of German life, and the liquidation of dissent among Nazis and conservatives. After taking office as chancellor, Hitler quickly out maneuvered Papen and the conservative nationalists. The Reichstag Fire, February 1933

Was hitler's dictatorship established by legal means

1082 words - 4 pages . During these years, Hitler consolidated his authority through the destruction of all other political parties, "co-ordination" of all aspects of German life, and the liquidation of dissent among Nazis and conservatives. After taking office as chancellor, Hitler quickly out maneuvered Papen and the conservative nationalists.The Reichstag Fire, February 1933A new Reichstag election was scheduled for early March 1933. Only a few days before the

Hitler's rise to Power

670 words - 3 pages Weimar Republic he needed a 2/3 majority in the Reichstag. The elections which followed were bitter and the Nazis held many parades in order to gain popularity amongst the people who were impressed by the Nazi demonstrations and Hitler's ability to speak in public. In February the Reichstag was burnt down and the Communists were blamed for causing the fire. Hitler declared the fire to be part of an international communist plot and so civil liberties

Significance of the Night of the Long Knives for Hitler's Power

2117 words - 8 pages many saw simply as "brown trash". On February 27, 1933, the Reichstag building burned down and a retarded Dutch boy Van de Lubbe claimed he worked for the communists and was arrested for arson. There is evidence to prove that the Nazis themselves had set the fire, but in any case, this event had appropriate timing which furthered the Nazi election campaign concerning the "Communist Threat". Hitler used the incident to

thgvfledf

1074 words - 4 pages Hindenburg to dissolve the Reichstag and call for new elections. The cornerstone of what was to become a 'decretal', rather than a 'legal' revolution, was laid with the Reichstag Fire decree on 28th February which suspended civil liberties and provided for the creation of 'protective custody' facilities for the arbitrary imprisonment of any political detaineeHitler set out his stall on 23 March 1933, the day of the Enabling Act, when he declared to the

Hitler's Becoming a Dictator

1367 words - 5 pages into power was the Reichstag fire, which the Nazis blamed on a communist and this affected the 1933 Election in their favour. The fire also allowed Hitler to pass the “Enabling act”, which basically meant that no one could oppose him and Germany had to do what he said without question. To aid this un-challenged state, Hitler killed a lot of members of the SA, who up until then had been a branch of the Nazi party. But they

Study Notes on Hitler and the Holocaust

878 words - 4 pages three things.a)It was the parliament for the Holy Roman Empire, the North German Federation and Germany until 1945.b)The Reichstag Building, in Berlin, was the original house of the German parliament, from 1894 till 1933. It again became the house of Parliament in 1999.c)The Reichstag fire was a huge event in establishing Nazi Germany. On the 27th of February 1933, a man named Marinus van der Lubbe set fire to the Reichstag building. The day

How the Current Times in the US Reflect Early Nazi Germany

750 words - 3 pages and uncertainty, people will follow their government at large costs in exchange for the feeling of security. This has been proven in many situations, and politicians know and feed off this fact. On February 27, 1933 the Reichstag fire that burned down the German Parliament building was blamed on communists and used as a stepping stone to take away civil liberties. The day after the Reichstag fire President Hindenburg and Chancellor Hitler invoked

Similar Essays

Who Started The Reichstag Fire? Essay

1183 words - 5 pages between Karl Ernst of theSA and Lubbe has never been proved.So, on the 27th February the Reichstag is empty as it had been in recess since December. At around 20:30 one of thecaretakers checked the building and found nothing unusual. At 20:50 a postman passed the entrance to the sessionchamber and noticed nothing.At 21:05 a student saw a man carrying a burning brand on the first floor. By 21:14 the fire alarm was received by thelocal firestation

Nazi Revison Essay

614 words - 2 pages Date Event 27 Feb 1933 Reichstag Fire - the Reichstag building is set on fire. A Dutch Communist, van der Lubbe, is caught red-handed in the burning building. 5 Mar 1933 General Election - only 44 per cent of the population vote for the Nazis, who win 288 seats in the Reichstag. 23 Mar 1933 Enabling Act - the SA intimidates all the remaining non-Nazi deputies. The Reichstag votes to give Hitler the right to make his own laws. 26

Who Burned Down The Reichstag Essay

631 words - 3 pages On the cold, blustery evening of February 27,1933, a week beforethe end of a bitter campaign especially between the nazi's and thecommunists, the Reichstag building was burnt to the ground. A halfwitted Dutchmen, Van Der Lubbe was arrested and shot for thecrime of arson, though it is unlikely that he had the intelligence orthe equipment to start such an effective fire in a public building.The burning took place a week before polling day

By The Autumn Of 1934 Hitler Reigned Supreme In Germany. Using At Least Five Of These Sources, And Other Relevant Information, Describe The Steps By Which Hitler Achieved This

724 words - 3 pages thirds majority in the Reichstag to pass the Enabling Act. The way he did this was quite unplanned. In February 1933 a communist set fire to and destroyed the Reichstag building. Hitler persuaded Hindenberg to declare a state of emergency, by which he limited other parties propaganda and he arrested Communists and Socialists. In the March election the NSDAP was less successful than hoped. Hitler therefore banned the Communists from the Reichstag