This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Relation Between Sex, Gender, And Moral Behavior

1526 words - 6 pages

The Relation Between Sex, Gender, and Moral Behavior

Our history is an account of changes, struggles and progress. It mostly contains writings and deeds of great 'men'. However, in this century, many nations' talent pools have been doubled by the introduction of Women's Suffrage. With that event women in many societies have been able to elevate themselves to a point where they can work towards gaining recognition in domains in which they used to be viewed as 'inferior'. One such domain is ethical theory. The following is a discussion on the following gender related ethical issues: Is there a gender-based difference in ethical perspective and reasoning? and, If there is, what is the cause of this difference?
In the late seventies, and early eighties, psychologist Carol Gilligan identified some interesting patterns in women's discussions about their moral conflicts. After analyzing the patterns, she formed the following hypothesis: "(1) that there are two distinct modes of moral judgment-- justice and care--in the thinking of men and women; (2) that these are gender-related; and (3) that modes of moral judgment might be related to modes of self-definition." (Mapping of the Moral Domain; Ed. by C. Gilligan, J. V. Ward, J. McLean Taylor, B. Bardige; Pub. Harvard University Press, 1988) Throughout the history of ethical theory, women were often viewed as 'morally inferior' to men, as Freud noted. Justice has been viewed as the 'higher' moral perspective, and Lawrence Kohlberg found that women had difficulties reaching this stage of moral development (Ethics - Theory and Contemporary Issues; By Barbara MacKinnon; Ed. 2; Pub. Wadsworth Publishing Company, 1998). Partly, this reasoning could be a consequence of ethical studies focusing primarily on men and their perspective.
To shed some light on these issues, we can examine some empirical data. Research has been done in which hypothetical moral dilemmas have been presented to subjects of both sexes, for the purpose of determining whether a difference in perspective exists. Some studies have been specifically designed to test Gilligan's hypothesis. In one very typical experiment, Jake and Amy, two eleven-year-olds have been faced with the following moral dilemma "...a man named Heinz considers whether or not to steal a drug which he cannot afford to buy in order to save the life of his wife." (In a Different Voice - Psychological Theory and Women's Development; Carol Gilligan; Pub. Harvard University Press, 1982) Jake decided very quickly that Heinz should steal the drug. He took a rational approach by mathematically weighing the value of human life over property. Relying on a social consensus on moral values, Jake decided that stealing the drug would be 'the right thing to do'. Amy's response, on the other hand, was rather evasive and illustrates a failure of simple logical deduction. She held that Heinz should not steal the drug, but that his wife should not die either. While Jake's...

Find Another Essay On The Relation Between Sex, Gender, and Moral Behavior

'Sex' And 'gender' And The Relationship Between Them

1839 words - 8 pages In psychology many different perspectives seek to explain the differences between males and females. In societies they play distinctive roles and are treated and viewed differently. They behave differently too. To compare and contrast the accounts of sex and gender we need to define the terms sex and gender. To examine further we need to examine the key aspects of the biological, evolutionary, social constructionist and psychoanalytical

Recognising the distinction between sex and gender is vital, in order to comprehend structured social inequality between both men and women

1484 words - 6 pages Syed Naqvi 16455263 Recognising the distinction between sex and gender is vital, in order to comprehend structured social inequality between both men and women. The word 'gender' is often used in the wrong context, i.e. assuming sex and gender are the same concept. However this is not the case. The first person to recognize this distinction was Dr Robert Stoller. He stated that 'sex' is the biological makeup which defines the differences

The Relation Between Identity and Language

1834 words - 7 pages beliefs. All of these factors will affect individuals in different ways and will be the makeup to one’s overall identity. The First and most obvious physical blueprint to one’s identity are their age and gender. Gender makes up identity not only in physical appearance, but behavior as well. Believe it or not, gender also influences on speech. As author Jennifer Coates simply puts it, “Men speak one way, women speak another” (Coates, 1998

The Relation Between Learning and Wisdom

806 words - 3 pages The Relation Between Learning and Wisdom   "But aren't love of learning and love of wisdom the same?" Socrates asks Glaucon in Book II of Plato's Republic. "Yes, the same," Glaucon answers. And the dialogue passes on to the next point. Today, outside utopia one might question whether these two are the same, since we so often see the one pursued in the absence of the other. In an essay of no more than 750 words, take up the problem of

Understanding the Relation Between Judaism and Christianity

935 words - 4 pages fact, he was the “Messiah/ the anointed one” for years to the Jewish and the Christians, makes the ties between the two religion close to each other. Jesus was proclaimed to be the Savior of the Jews. The Jews and the early Christians called him the Son of God. The preaching of Jesus was not limited to strictly to Christians. Historically, Seduces were the only group who were against the Jesus and him being the anointed one. Another aspect that

The Relation between Comedy and Tragedy

631 words - 3 pages The Relation between Comedy and Tragedy   On the surface, comedy and tragedy seem to be complete polar opposites of each other. In terms of the actual narrative, examining the consequences of the character's actions reveals the biggest contrast. In Oedipus Rex, Oedipus' 'sin' of not listening to the Gods and trying to avoid his fate assisted in his downfall. Not only does his internal blindness result in him marrying his mother

The Relation Between Birds and Dinosaurs

993 words - 4 pages The Relation Between Birds and Dinosaurs One question that has stumped many paleontologists for centuries is, “Are birds dinosaurs?” Paleontologists have argued back and forth trying to prove or disprove each side of the theory. So far, advocates have supported their side through the facts of similar bone structures, bone organization, and the idea that dinosaurs had feathers. A common reaction that some people might have about the question

The Relation Between Fashion And Eathing Disorders

2029 words - 8 pages . An average model weighs approximately twenty - three percent less than the average woman (Lovett). The average model has a Body Mass Index (BMI) of 17.1 (Lasseck), meeting the requirements for anorexia. A healthy BMI is between 18.5 and 24.9 (“Ideal Weight”) Beverly Johnson, a model at the height of her career in 1991, was between a size four and a size six. Ms. Johnson is considered a plus - size model by today’s standards (Lovett). The

The Theories of Sex and Gender

2892 words - 12 pages The Theories of Sex and Gender Sex and gender are two very separate factors in the debate of how gender acquisition occurs. Sex is a biological fact determined by the chromosomes inherited from parents. Gender however, refers to the behaviour, beliefs, attitude and sense of identity that society perceives as being appropriate for either a male or a female, and therefore gender is regarded as a social fact

Sex And Gender

1705 words - 7 pages The World Health Organization refers to sex as “the biological and physiological characteristics that define and differentiate men and women”. Although gender is now widely referred to the more social and cultural side of this “[differentiation]”, accepted cultural perspectives on gender often conflate with sex, dictating that women and men are naturally and unequivocally defined categories of being, with distinctive psychological and

Sex and Gender

1813 words - 7 pages Sex and Gender The terms employed most frequently to describe the differences between men and women are 'sex' and 'gender'. Sex refers to the differing physical attributes of women and men (Lee, Shaw). The categories of sex are male and female. In every society sex differences are given social meanings. Social identity, which is

Similar Essays

The Relation Between Religion And Prosocial Behavior

2935 words - 12 pages ; Rand et al., 2014). Thus, generosity and altruism are more common in religious societies which have big Gods, namely; İslam, Christianity and Judaism (Norenzayan, 2013). These religions have big Gods who are also concerned about morality of humans which is also thought to lead to prosocial behavior. There is a body of research on the relation between religion and prosocial behavior coming from generally priming literature. For instances

Relationship Between Sex And Gender Essay

2114 words - 8 pages married” (McGennisken, J. p.4). The social expectation has changed dramatically in relation to the 21st century context therefore the norms and attitude within the Australian context should reflect upon tackling sex discrimination. The report on Social Trends provided by the Australian Bureau of Statistics makes evident that the social expectation has differed over a fourteen period and that gender roles have changed. “Between 1992 and 2006

Differentiating Between Sex And Gender Essay

1169 words - 5 pages boys’ and girls’ ability that later impacts children’s thinking about the distinction between sex and gender. Girls are required to sit quietly, pay attention, and do careful work by society. Boys on the other hand are required to ask numerous questions, and those who do not follow the rules while working on the problems are seen to possess high intelligence. (Schools and Hidden Curriculum, p.143) This leads to a loss of confidence and an increase

The Relation Between Gender Equality And Economic Growth

3772 words - 15 pages employment rate matters for GDP and GDP-growth. If the answer is yes two other questions have to follow: 1. What strategies and actions have to be taken in order to “exploit” the economic potential there is in rising female employment and 2. How to fulfil these actions. The aim of my essay is to discuss the relation between gender equality and economic growth, formulated in three questions, and to illustrate this relation on the example of the