The Relationship Between The 6th Ammendment And Police Interrogations

1603 words - 7 pages

The Relationship between the Sixth Amendment and Police Interrogation

CJBA 361
Professor Ingber
March 27, 2014

BREWER v. WILLIAMS (WILLIAMS I), 430 U.S. 387, 97 S.CT. 1232, 51 L.Ed 424 (1977). The deceased, Pamela Powers, was on a family vacation at the YMCA in Des Moines, Iowa. A search was made in the attempt to find Powers when she did not arrive back from her trip to the washroom. The defendant, Robert Williams, was an escaped mental patient who resided in the YMCA where Powers’ family went for their vacation. A witness spotted the defendant carrying a large bundle with two white legs sticking out. The defendant’s lawyer stepped into a De Moines police station where he informs the police officers he received a phone call from Williams on what he had done. The lawyer, Henry McKnight, advised Williams to turn himself in which he did the next morning. He was booked and charged by Davenport authorities and given his Miranda Warnings. Williams had council in Davenport as well. Police Detective Leaming was ordered to pick up Williams from Davenport and bring him to Des Moines. Both lawyers urged Williams to not speak about Pamela Powers with the officers in the car ride until after consulted with McKnight in Des Moines. An agreement was made between McKnight and Detective Leaming that Leaming would not question the defendant without counsel regarding to the deceased during the trip. Both Leaming and Williams were reminded multiple times to not talk about Ms. Powers until council was present. During the trip back to Des Moines, Williams tells the office that he will tell the whole story when he sees his lawyer. The Detective used his knowledge of the defendant’s religious background to deliver his “Christian burial speech.” This speech suggested that Williams should confess where the body of Powers was so that her family can have a proper Christian burial. After this speech the defendant directed the officer where the body could be found.
One of the questions that was brought to the court was whether or not the Christian burial speech tantamount to an interrogation which entitled him right to counsel, such that with the absent of counsel violated his sixth amendment right (Kamisar, LaFave, Israel, King, Kerr & Primus,2012, p.741). The court replied yes, the Christian burial speech was tantamount to interrogation (Kamisar, LaFave, Israel, King, Kerr & Primus,2012, p.741). William’s lawyer suggested to accompany his client on the ride to Des Moines but was denied by the detective (Kamisar, LaFave, Israel, King, Kerr & Primus,2012, p.740). The officer was reminded multiple times by the defendant’s lawyer to not speak of the deceased until William’s lawyer from Des Moines was present. The officer purposely said the Christian burial speech in hoping to find out as much information he can get in the car ride (Kamisar, LaFave, Israel, King, Kerr & Primus,2012, p.742). The officer was aware that the defendant was initiated to an...

Find Another Essay On The Relationship Between the 6th Ammendment and Police Interrogations

The Relationship Between Substance Abuse and Crime

1656 words - 7 pages criminal acts. The statistical association between alcohol or drug abuse with crime seems to be convincing when examined at the first glance; however, it is not possible to make a conclusion concerning a distinct cause and effect association between the two aspects. Accordingly, this paper will examine the relation between Alcohol or drug abuse and Crime. One may ask the exact nature of the relationship between substance abuse and crime. As

The Relationship Between Social Class and Delinquency

1451 words - 6 pages note that crimes committed by African Americans may be more likely to come to attention of the police and that African Americans offenders are more likely to be arrested than their white counterparts. Early self-report data found little or no relationship between race and delinquency. Later self-report studies found that African Americans and whites commit similar levels of minor delinquency, while African Americans are more likely to engage in

The Relationship between Church and State

1573 words - 7 pages Question #2 Separation of the church and state is not a new concept. Within the past two thousand years of Christian history however the strategies and ideas of Christian leaders have changed several times. During the time that Christ walked the earth we can anecdotally perceive a very adversarial relationship between Jesus’ ministry and the local Jewish and Roman governments. This type of relationship continued for the first three centuries of

The Relationship between Organizational Management and Unions

1628 words - 7 pages Management and Unions The relationship between unions and organization is a touchy one. Dating back to the start of unionization in the 19th century, the two bodies have held opposing viewpoints. Unionization was formed from the opinion that organizations took advantage of workers and some form of a negotiating agreement was needed. There were documented events of workers working long taxing hours for insignificant pay; no healthcare coverage

Analyzing the Relationship Between Brands and Consumers

2128 words - 9 pages How do contemporary promotional cultures construct a relationship with consumers through brands and how active are consumers in this relationship? Illustrate your answer with examples. This paper provides a framework for the relationship formed between brands and consumers; It will attempt to discover what this relationship looks like from an annalist point of view, additionally it will be touching upon brand management, this will be applied in

The Relationship Between Othello and Desdemona

1469 words - 6 pages The Relationship Between Othello and Desdemona We first learn of there being a relationship between Othello and Desdemona when Iago and Roderigo are telling Roderigo (Desdemona's Father), that ''an old black ram is tupping your white ewe''. This is referring to Othello and Desdemona having sexual intercourse, and shortly after hearing this, we become informed that Desdemona is ''Tying her duty, Beauty, Wit, and Fortunes

The Relationship between Delinquency and Drug Use

2017 words - 8 pages The Relationship between Delinquency and Drug UseIn my attempt to discover if delinquency and drug use, or the sale of drugs were correlated with one another, my research lead to a positive correlation, especially when there was gang membership involved. The theory I have chosen to tie in with my review of the articles I found is the social learning theory of Edwin Sutherland known as differential association theory. According to Britannica

The Relationship Between Education and Health

880 words - 4 pages ). For instance the cross-sectional and over time analysis of the relationship between health (self-reported health and physical functioning) and education by Ross and Wu (1995) demonstrate a positive association between the two and further elaborate the reasons for it. Ross and Wu (1995) group the reasons into three different categories as follows: (1) work and economic conditions, (2) social-psychological re and (3) health lifestyle. The study

The Oedipal Relationship between Hamlet and Gertrude

1160 words - 5 pages Throughout William Shakespeare's Hamlet, Shakespeare portrays Hamlet with the same types of behaviors and frustrations in humans that Sigmund Freud saw at a much later date. When the relationship between Hamlet and his mother is analyzed Freud's oedipal complex theory comes to mind. The oedipal complex is a theory created by Freud that states that "The child takes both of its parents, and more particularly one of them, as the object of its

The Relationship Between Mothers And Their Children

1006 words - 4 pages Author's Last Name PAGE 3 [Author's Name][Professor's Name][Course Title][Date]The Relationship Between Mothers And Their ChildrenIntroductionIn Tillie Olsen's short creative writing story I Stand Here Ironing, Ideological State Apparatuses persuade the social standings of equally of the major characters, the Mother and the eldest child Emily.The mother is hailed as a distinctive housewife. What's added, she is also a solitary mother, and is

Relationship between Cultural Change and the Environment

972 words - 4 pages Relationship between Cultural Change and the Environment The association between culture and human technologies is central to the issue of today’s worldwide environmental degradation. This relationship is often viewed as quite simple: as a culture develops, needs arise and are met by new technologies. The culture is then transformed by the effects the technologies have on the people’s way of life. It seems logical that new technology would

Similar Essays

Interrogations, Confession And Admissions In The Criminal Justice System (Interrogation Policies Used By Police Today)

1843 words - 7 pages often a tool utilized by law enforcement to obtain a confession. There are many methods used by police investigators in attempts to obtain a confession during an interrogation. The foundation of interrogations, in my opinion, aimed at finding the truth. There are certain limitations in determining whether the confession obtained was voluntary.The limitations governing the police relate to the due process test and that of confessions obtained

The Second Ammendment Essay

1570 words - 6 pages because they are not even suitable for sport and it only takes one shot to warn off someone attaking you not 14 as many weapons can hold. Even though steps must be taken to curb gun violence people must get more involved with the system to insure that limits do not go too far. It is after all the people who control politics, not politicians.In conclusion the Constitution holds the basic rights for which we exercise each day. Our basic rights are guarenteed by the Constitution, and if they abolish the Second Ammendment we would not enjoy the result, no crime but at the cost of a police state. This is not America.

Understanding Police Use Of Force, Interrogations, Deceit And Trickery

1308 words - 6 pages utilize any type of force comes from a multitude of recourses; department policies, training, situational variables and ethical systems. There are three major categories in which an officers use of force is categorized under; justifiable, excessive and deadly; with a thin line between justifiable and excessive. Cases where excessive force has been used, has lead to injuries, deaths, civil damages, officers convicted and sentenced to jail and police

The Relationship Between Humans And The Environment

1364 words - 5 pages The Relationship Between Humans and the Environment Nearly everything that a human does is in response to the environment. Our lives are defined by what is around us and what we find in front of us, whether this means accepting, dealing with or changing it. This has been the pattern since primates first stood up and became Homo erectus, and has continued until we considered ourselves doubly wise. The shape of the land affected where humans