The Relationship Of The Court With The Special Master

2578 words - 11 pages

THE PAST AND PROSPECTS OF SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE

by Viren Bansal

The nature of cases the International Court of Justice (hereinafter interchangeably referred to as the ICJ/the Court) deals with, either by adjudicating or providing advisory opinions, can be interpreted as an indicator of ‘unfavorable behavior’ in international law. The ‘unfavorable behavior’ that the ICJ has increasingly become subject to is trans-boundary conflicts over environmental pollution and natural resources. The submission of such disputes to the ICJ creates a sort of reluctance amongst the judges due to the vast amounts of complex evidence submitted by either side, which discounts their role of factual ...view middle of the document...

This paper will discuss the manner in which Courts initially made use of the Special Master (hereinafter, referred to as the Expert) and then discuss a recent case where the Special Master was utilized in a manner more suitable to the ICJ.

The apex court of general jurisdiction for conflicts between states has repeatedly not answered calls for reforming its practice in evidence. Consequently, this is creating an impediment in its jurisprudence over a docket of disputes it is yet to adjudicate upon, which include boundary disputes, Columbian discharge of aerial pesticide and the Japanese whaling. Water resources and climate change conflicts are going to continuously increase in the future. The coming of the Pulp Mills Case brought along with it severe disapproval of the ICJ by its very own judges. The said case observed a conflict on a shared river over industrial development between Uruguay and Argentina. When dealing with cases that involve environmental quality and natural resources, though thoroughly reviewing the factual evidence is important, it is not exclusive to conflicts of such a nature. The question the judges framed and answered in the final judgment was how should complex scientific evidence, that is a deciding factor in the case, be dealt with by the judges. This question draws out a dichotomy between the actual function of judges as the guardian of the court in allowing the submission of scientific evidence and the extended-judicial burden the judges took up by answering such a question. This was extensively studied in the (Daubert) rules of admissibility of the U.S. Supreme Court. This problem of putting too much emphasis on scientific evidence was hinted at by another judge in the said case. This hinted response had still failed to adequately answer the need for reformation that has been recommended, since the ICJ began to hear disputes of such a nature.

There are pragmatic concerns Courts have with hampering their role in adjudicating over cases; or they may have overlooked their available options. Judge ad hoc Vinuesa’s opinion, in the Pulp Mills Case, does imply that the ICJ may have not appointed an expert to deal with the scientific evidence in order to prevent a delay that would have been caused otherwise. Though cost is a seminal concern for any court, given the financial resources that are dedicated to such cases, it is not the only barrier for the entry of scientific experts. While there exists adequate authoritative discourse on judicial partialities on evidence, common law and civil law practices of judges, it would be best to explore other reasons to understand why international courts do not avail of their recourse of scientific experts.

A concern judges may have about introducing expert evidence is that it may adversely affect their adjudicative mandate. This point was shortly raised by Judge Yusuf in the Pulp Mills Case, where he states:

“The question arises as to whether there is a risk...

Find Another Essay On the relationship of the Court with the Special Master

Master of the Farm Essay

1706 words - 7 pages the farm. He is able to use his skills of speech to manipulate the animals and cleverly allows the pigs (and the pigs alone) to prosper. Additionally, he is clever enough to start with smaller matters so the animals do not notice the change until it is too late. To introduce this cunning scheme into the animals’ lives, he starts with simply explaining to them why the pigs were the only ones who were permitted to eat apples and milk by saying

The Master Of Tragedy Essay

583 words - 2 pages had one great competitor when it came to his writing. This man's name was Aeschylus. Both Aeschylus and Sophocles both knew exactly what to say. "The commencement of his dramatic career was marked by a victory in competition with Aeschylus, under exceptional circumstances" (Bates). These men were at battle, but Sophocles made his mark more so than Aeschylus.We must realize some more about what Sophocles did during his lifetime. He did not just

Hamlet - The Master of Deception

1842 words - 7 pages she had no intention of carrying out, there is no justification for her deception. She being a grown girl should be well aware that was she agreed to do was wrong, and the fact that she still went on with it shows inconsideration. Through Ophelia, Shakespeare shows how one deceptive act can lead to a demise of a whole relationship. Hamlet can be considered the master of deception. Every form of deception that occurs in the play ties to Hamlet in

The Visit of Master Nocturne

3938 words - 16 pages . The doors at the end of the room opened and a figure stepped in. He was armored from head to foot. Red eyes shone in the shadows beneath his helmet. “Master Nocturne” Jon said, delivering a nod his way. The man stood for a moment, piercing Jon with those pupil-less red eyes. “You are summoned to the main hall” he said, his voice low and growling. “My presence is not required at the ceremony” Jon said, annoyed. “True” the man stated, “but it is

Relationship of Buddhism with the Tang Government

1134 words - 5 pages Relationship of Buddhism with the Tang Government Since the introduction of Buddhism into China, it was not well received by the population as its foreign beliefs clashed with pre-existent principals of Confucianism and Taoism. On top of that, it was alienated by the Confucianism-based government in the late Han Dynasty. All in all, Buddhism was not a common nor a popular religion throughout China at first. Nevertheless, this all changed

Relationship of Buddhism with the Tang Government

2069 words - 8 pages that Buddhism and the Tang administration under Wu’s reign formed a critical symbiotic relationship with one another. Buddhism played a pivotal role in justifying Empress Wu’s rule. She enthroned herself as the monarch of China, an extraordinarily difficult achievement for a woman in a male-dominant society, by associating herself with Buddhism: proclaiming herself as the Maitreya and that she will bring an utopian era for the Chinese. (Smarr, 17

The Relationship of Muir with Nature

887 words - 4 pages reader to experience nature and Muir truly did a remarkable job of using his relationship with nature to the point that it would not deter the reader completely but only educate him of the dangers of nature. This makes the reader feel as though Muir is now compelled by nature after he has experiences his rejuvenation to help others seek theirs. Through “Calypso Borealis” we truly see the rejuvenation and new perspective Muir gains from his

The Misunderstanding of Humans Relationship with Nature

2259 words - 10 pages inorganic body, that is to say nature in so far as it is not the human body.” (Marx 328) This ideology toward nature is destroying the nature we live in and depends on to survive. The thesis of this paper is to describe how humans misunderstood their relationship with nature and what changes they need to make in order to save it. The world population is growing and growing rapidly, and as the population increase, we require and consume more of the

The 'Special Relationship' Between The US and Britain

1350 words - 6 pages viewing the relationship between the US and the US as anything except ‘special,’ it was not necessarily evident in 1945. However, it was clear to the United Kingdom a relationship with the United States could prove entirely necessary in the conflicts with the USSR during the Cold War. At the end of World War II, communist Russian forces had effectively pushed into Berlin, Germany as well as a great majority of eastern Europe. As a communist state

A Special Relationship Between the United States and Israel

1391 words - 6 pages The relationship between the State of Israel and the United States of America has blossomed into a significant bilateral alliance. The ‘special relationship’ between the two countries has been the driving force behind much of the progress of the United States’ push into middle east democracy, and has helped place Israel in the company of countries who will stand by her in times of trouble. As of late, there have been increasing pushes by the

Court cases dealing with the 14th amendment

3406 words - 14 pages ruled that the flag salute was mandatory. The Court stated that the flag was an important symbol of national unityCox v. New HampshireArgued/Decided-194114t amendment- assembly, and worshipSome Jehovah's witnesses were convicted for being a part of a public parade without a permit. They gathered at their church and separated into smaller groups that marched along sidewalks with signs and they gave leaflets announcing a later meeting. They then

Similar Essays

The Master Slave Relationship Essay

1252 words - 5 pages also a part of managing the household; for no man can live well, or indeed live at all, unless he is supplied with the essential items needed to survive. When surviving, workers must have sufficient tools or instruments to accomplish their work. Instruments come in types such as living and non-living. A possession is an instrument for preserving life. So in the household where the master-slave relationship is considered the slave is a living

The Special Relationship Lives Essay

818 words - 4 pages the war. No country was as favored by the US as Britain was, both through Marshall Aid, of which the UK received in total $3,297 million from 1948 to 1951, or through loans outside the Plan (Leigh-Pippard 1995) (Ovendale 1998) (Gardner 2001). The US and UK special relationship has been kept strong by trade. The US and the UK are both each other’s highest foreign investors, and US companies employ around 1.4 million workers in Britain, with the

The Relationship Between Slaves And Their Master

1377 words - 6 pages mistresses whose husbands’ engaged in these illicit affairs. In conclusion, the slave could not expect to enjoy a fulfilling relationship with the master. The very essence of slavery was cruel and demeaning, making it difficult for any meaningful and mutually satisfying relationship to exist. Introduction This paper explores the relations that existed between slaves and their masters as portrayed by Jacobs . It will explore the perceptions of

Master Of The Farm Essay

1821 words - 8 pages ” (Orwell, Animal 133). The trimmings of freedom, although a stellar idea for any transitioning society, are mocked through the ambiguity of “equal.” Equality, in the tightest definition, places all members of society at the same socioeconomic levels. The “more equal than others” connotates that equality can be added like a unit, and equality can essentially become unequal. The revolt’s later ideals do not align with the original idea of equality