The Removal Of Prayer From Public Schools

4929 words - 20 pages

The removal of prayer from public schools is a very controversial and misunderstood debate. This paper will address the history of the debate, common myths and misunderstandings, and the current trends.

History of the Debate:

Public schools originated in 1647 in the Massachusetts Bay Colony and soon spread across New England. They began with an elementary school for every fifty families and a Latin school for every one hundred families. Their mission was to “ensure that Puritan children learn to read the Bible and receive basic information about their Calvinist religion.”1 By 1840, conflict was at a climax in New York City. The public schools had taken on a “common school” education that included a nondenominational course of religious instruction. This meant “students would recite a few basic prayers and read passages from the Protestant, King James Bible without commentary or interpretation.”2 This did not please the some 200,000 Roman Catholics within the city who had serious objections to Protestant “non-sectarianism”2.

In 1842, New York City attempted to decentralize the issue by mandating that “no sectarian religious instruction was to be offered. All public schools would now educate students in the three R’s and leave religion to the churches.”2 This action led to the creation of church-led Sunday school’s, that were to give religious instruction.

By the 1950’s, Americans began to grow concerned about the morality of their children, especially since “the common school inculcates all Christian morals; it founds its morals on the basis of religion; it welcomes the religion of the Bible.”3 School boards across the region began to investigate ways to teach moral and spiritual values within the classroom. The Educational Policies Commission, which was a joint venture of the National Education Association and the American Association of School Administrators, drafted guidelines for a public school “common faith” using the Golden Rule, which was claimed by Protestants, Roman Catholics, and Jews. New York City adopted a 22-word Regent’s Prayer as part of their Statement on Moral and Spiritual Training in the Schools.

In 1962, the United States Supreme Court was called upon to interpret the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment to the United States Constitution citing the Regent’s Prayer in violation (Engel v. Vitale). In a 6 to 1 decision (with 2 remaining neutral) the Supreme Court decided that the Regent’s Prayer, which was to be said aloud by each student in the presence of a teacher at the beginning of each school day, was unconstitutional: “Almighty God, we acknowledge our dependence upon Thee, and we beg Thy blessings upon us, our parents, our teachers, and our Country.” Mr. Justice Black delivered the opinion of the court:

The State’s use of the Regents’ prayer in its public school system breaches the constitutional wall of separation between...

Find Another Essay On The Removal of Prayer from Public Schools

Prayer In Public Schools Essay

788 words - 3 pages been removed from public schools (with the exception of the Pledge of Allegiance), and I am glad that this has happened. School prayer still occurs during school sporting events. I do not understand why schools think that just because they are not holding the prayer in the actual building they are not infringing upon the rights of the students and spectators. As America becomes more and more diverse and we begin to speak out for what we believe

Prayer In Public Schools. Essay

1152 words - 5 pages You Have the Right to Pray OutsideOne of the most controversial topics debated nowadays is whether or not prayershould be allowed in school. The concept of having prayer at school is a process which Ivehemently oppose. I will first define what type of prayer we are concerned about so thatwe can establish what it is that people debate about. The type of prayer I will discuss isone within a public institution. I will specifically target public

Prayer in public schools

881 words - 4 pages went through all of the city and state courts, who did not agree with her. Eventually she had to go to the highest court in the country, the Supreme Court. Months after the outrage from O'Hara, parents all along the country started complaining about it also. After months of deliberation Supreme Court ruled that mandatory prayer in public schools was a violation of the Bill of Rights. In Engel v. Vitale it was said that "the use of prayer in

Supporting Prayer in Public Schools

1068 words - 4 pages to choose not to participate. A teacher or a government official cannot stop someone from praying silently. Public schools are for all children, regardless of their race, sex, or religion. Schools are supported by all taxpayers. The U.S. Supreme Court has replaced freedom of religion, guaranteed by the Constitution, for freedom from religion. To ban school prayer diminishes the religious freedom of students who would like to pray and forces them

Voluntary Prayer In Public Schools

2611 words - 10 pages side their morals. Also, all students, no matter race, religion, or background, have the same rights to meet, before, during, and after school with their various organizations. The most important reason for prayer in public schools is that the First Amendment of the Constitution allows it. Many people would think that this is the first time that prayer has been banned from public schools, but it is not. In 1962 the Supreme Court made the same ruling

Prayer in American Public Schools

780 words - 4 pages religious services in comparison with Hinduism, Atheism, etc. Overall this shows that the more involved that an individual is with their religion, the higher their disapproval rate was to Congress’ decision of banning prayer in school. Though Congress banned prayer in school, a majority of American’s disagree with this action regardless of where they are living, their age, or their religion. Religion in American public schools is a topic that will

This essay is about Prayer in Schools. It covers the two controvercial sides of public schools vs. private schools.

2211 words - 9 pages religion from the beginning, with the Protestant, Catholic and many other religions that have been fleeing religious persecution to find religious freedom. The controversy over public prayer in schools began when the Catholic immigrants objected to required readings of the Protestant King James Bible and the recitation of Protestant prayers in most public schools. A bitter conflict erupted, including riots, and expulsion of Catholic children from

Vote No on Prayer in the Public Schools

820 words - 3 pages . Instigated in large measure by conservative and fundamentalist Christian groups, the drive for a constutional amendment to bring back religion in the classrooms (make no mistake, it is no less a proposal than that) is full steam ahead. I, for one, oppose the roposed amendment because I am firmly of the opinion a constitutional amendment requiring prayer in the public schools would contravene the intent of the constitution's framers, subject the

Prayer Should Be Allowed in Public Schools

1832 words - 7 pages Prayer Should Be Allowed in Public Schools School prayer is a very controversial issue in today’s society. The issue of school prayer is about whether the public school systems should let the students pray, at the start of the school day, as a class. The issue of school prayer began in the late sixteenth century when people in England did not approve of the way one religion was forced upon them, so the Puritans, known as the Pilgrims

Prevent Coercive Prayer in Public Schools

1406 words - 6 pages , but when religion has a home in public schools, it singles out the students who disagree with the theology being taught. Prior to the Supreme Court's decisions against school prayer, it was standard practice to put the students who didn't agree with the theology being taught in places of detention during Bible readings and prayers.One argument in favor of the practice of school-organized prayer draws its basis from the belief that students must

It's Time to Bring Back Religion and School Prayer in Public Schools

1996 words - 8 pages        Benjamin Franklin once declared, "Only a virtuous people are capable of freedom. As a nation becomes more corrupt and vicious they have more need of masters." In nineteen sixty-two the Supreme Court of the United States pronounced that a prayer recited in the public school was abusing our freedoms . In the court's opinion this was an act in violation to the first amendment, which calls for "a separation of church and state.'' This

Similar Essays

The Constitutionality Of Prayer In Public Schools

751 words - 3 pages agreement between the school and the state and making a public school hold a formal prayer would violate this because public schools are funded and run by the state. Public schools are not allowed to hold prayer at all because of the mixed religions that are present in the schools. It is hard from stopping people from prayer because some people are extremely devoted to their religion and they follow strict guidelines to their religion. One major

Prayer In Public Schools Essay

1048 words - 4 pages seen when every session of Congress opens with a prayer. Why are the governing bodies of this nation allowed to pray daily, but schools are prohibited? Although prayer should be reinstated because it is an important part of our American heritage, other reasons exists for re-instating volunteer prayer in public schools. Another reason for reinstating volunteer prayer in public schools comes from the fact that since prayer has been

Prayer In Public Schools Essay

1487 words - 6 pages believe the polar opposite. This subject is very controversial. Religion, location, and party affiliation are some dynamic factors in determining how a person forms their stance on public prayer in schools. Rhonda Reedy, an independent party member from Ohio, disagrees with prayer in public schools. She attended church growing up and still does today. She is a Christian, yet disagrees with this type of prayer. Like many other people, she feels

Prayer In Public Schools Essay

1605 words - 6 pages The United States has continued to be a country where religion plays a major role in the lives of American citizens. Depending on the type of school students attend, organized prayer is mandatory, allowed, or banned. In the United States, organized prayer in public schools is prohibited because it goes against the Constitution’s separation of church and state (Jinkins 123). The United States promises religious freedom, but is yet to define the