This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Effects Of Aristotelian Teleological Thought On Darwin's Mechanistic Views Of Evolution

2159 words - 9 pages

The Effects of Aristotelian Teleological Thought on Darwin's Mechanistic Views of Evolution

     The need to understand organisms has been a much sought goal of
science since its birth as biology. History shows Aristotle and Charles Darwin
as two of the most powerful biologists of all time. Aristotle's teleological
method was supported widely for over 2,000 years. One scientist remarks that
the Aristotelian teleology "has been the ghost, the unexplained mystery which
has haunted biology through its whole history" (Ayala, 10). If Aristotle's
approach has frightened biology, then Darwin, who actually nicknamed himself
the "Devils Chaplain," and his idea of natural selection has virtually dissected
Aristotle's ghost. While Aristotle explained biology through a plan and a
purpose, Darwin debated that randomness and chaos are responsible for the
organic world as we know it. Guiseppe Montalenti, an Italian geneticist and
philosopher of biology, wrote that Darwin's ideas were a rebellion against
thought in the Aristotelian-scholastic way (Ayala, 4). In order to
understand how Darwinism can be considered a revolt against Aristotle, we must
first inspect Aristotle's ideas and thoughts about biology.
Aristotle used teleology to explain the harmony and final results of the
earth. Teleology is the study of the purpose of nature. Aristotle believed
that scientists should follow the plan adopted by mathematicians in their
demonstrations of astronomy, and after weighing the phenomena presented by
animals, and their several parts, follow consequently to understand the causes
and the end results. Using this method, Aristotle constructed causes for body
parts and processes of the human body, such as sundry types of teeth.
Aristotle elucidated on this topic: "When we have ascertained the thing's
existence we inquire as to its nature…when we know the fact we ask the reason"
(Evans, 82).
     Despite Aristotle's frequent teleological explanations, he did warn
against teleology leading to misinterpretations of facts. In a short writing on
the reproduction of bees in Generation of Animals, Aristotle was troubled that
there were insufficient observations on the subject, and warns that his theory
is dependent on facts supporting the theory. One twentieth century biologist
believes that Aristotle did not often enough follow his own advice. Ayala
printed that Aristotle's "error was not that he used teleological explanations
in biology, but that he extended the concept of teleology to the non-living
world."(56)
     Some biologists say Aristotle used teleology so often because order and
purpose, both in the universe and life, were immensely important to him.
Aristotle thought it was both ridiculous and impossible that chance, which is
not linked with order, could be used to explain occurrences in biology. In one
of his...

Find Another Essay On The Effects of Aristotelian Teleological Thought on Darwin's Mechanistic Views of Evolution

Charles Darwin's Scientific Theory of Evolution

1485 words - 6 pages Conor McAvoy Professor A.J. Rocke HSTY 202 25 March 2014 Charles Darwin is well-known for his groundbreaking work on evolutionary biology. Among his many contributions, The Origin of Species is the most associated with his name. He introduces the scientific theory of evolution and suggests that species have evolved over a period of many generations through a process called natural selection. Darwin's theories have created much controversy among

Compare Darwin's Theory of Evolution to Lamarck's Theory of Evolution

614 words - 2 pages , each generation will pass on their traits of having a longer neck than the previous generation, accounting for the evolution of the giraffe from being an animal with a shorter neck and legs, to one seen today with its long neck and legs. Darwin's theory relied on a process of natural selection. In his theory, at the start there would have been many giraffes of varying heights, which would be so due to the variations in organisms through

The Effects of Culture on the Evolution of Language

1601 words - 7 pages changing of the daily vocabulary, experts say that the evolution of language has in fact slow its pace during the last centuries. The creators of this theory did not only look to the development of new words, but also they observed the changes produced on the popular phrases, the writing style and many other factors. Thus, they concluded that in the past centuries it was more likely to find big changes between decades, but in the present times those

"Adoption of Unrelated Children". Essay is about adoption and the its effects on the society. Includes Darwin's theory

1927 words - 8 pages reduce the reasons that cause stress in their lives by adopting children. Although these hypotheses might be correct, tests can be conducted that may prove otherwise. Collecting data on adopted children that have gone to jail and can not provide for their families or data on what effects pet have on stress can provide more reasonable hypotheses on the matter of adoption of unrelated children.

An Essay Summarizing and Supporting the Concepts of Darwin's Theory of Evolution

997 words - 4 pages Evolution is defined as genetically based change from generation to generation. That means the only way evolution has not taken place is if you look exactly the same as both of your parents, who would look exactly like their parents and so on. So, even going back to the beginning of life (however you define that beginning), one cannot honestly say that evolution has not occurred. Assuming that all humans were born on this planet and are

Daniel Dennett's Darwin's Dangerous Idea: Evolution and the Meanings of Life

1002 words - 4 pages Daniel Dennett's Darwin's Dangerous Idea: Evolution and the Meanings of Life Science can give us as good a moral code as any religion. Or so Daniel Dennett claims in his book, Darwin's Dangerous Idea: Evolution and the Meanings of Life. Dennett provides the tools to explain human morality, and inadvertently leads the way to the conclusion (which he does not share) that science can clarify how human morality came about, but not serve as a

Aristotelian Rhetoric: An Evolution of Sophist’s Discredited Methodology

2089 words - 8 pages teachings disdained by ancient orthodox philosophers and some modern scholars. Examined readings of his theory on the art of rhetoric demonstrate his elaborate use of many of sophistic perspectives. Thus, the Aristotelian rhetoric, at heart of the development of our modern studies in this field, can be considered an evolution of the Sophists’ rhetoric, which has lately been the center of study by many scholars who called for a re-evaluation of the

Public Outcry and Acceptance to Darwin's theory of Evolution

2152 words - 9 pages , and discrediting perhaps best summed as, "Darwinism means the gradual evolution of grave philosophers from spectacled baboons." (Theology On The Defensive 1). Despite such attacks on the premise of evolution, many readers of Darwin's theory rose in defense of the subject. Evolution discredited due to it lacking presentable physical evidence was rebutted in the form of recalling previous theories, once thought illegitimate because of lack of

Thomas Malthus, Charles Lyell and Charles Darwin's Theory of Evolution

554 words - 2 pages Thomas Malthus and Charles Lyell were two figures who influenced Darwin's theories. Malthus was an influence through his book on the population principle. Darwin had a parallel thinking in the concept of individual struggle in natural selection. Lyell's influence on Darwin was from his book "Principles". Darwin agreed with Lyell's uniformitarian theories, and the uniformitarian understanding helped Darwin explain the elements of natural

Confirming the Character of a Teleological System

735 words - 3 pages its parts. The teleological principle takes on added meaning when applied to biological evolution or the evolution of the universe. It introduces a change in the principle of necessity, since it says it is by necessity that evolution borrows the path it takes. Of course, the teleological principle can be formulated in various ways and the modern teleology does not resemble the teleology of the seventeenth century. The sources of the

Charles Darwin's Theory of Evolution by Natural Selection

787 words - 3 pages Charles Darwin's theory of evolution centres on the idea that species compete to survive, and favorable characteristics are passed on from one generation to the next. Darwin said that evolution took place by a process of natural selection or survival of the fittest. This meant that the animals and plants best suited to their surroundings survived and were able to pass on their genes to their offspring. The ones that

Similar Essays

Darwin's Theory Of Evolution Essay

814 words - 3 pages plants and animals. (Port, 2006) Thomas Robert Malthus was born on February 13th, 1766, at Dorking, a town south of London. His theory about population was that population growth usually exceeds the amount of food produced for that particular area, so we should try to limit the growth of our population. In his book An Essay on the Principle of Population, As it Effects the Future Improvement of Society, he said that “Overpopulation tends to be a

The Platonic And Aristotelian Views On The Role And Status Of Women In Society

3397 words - 14 pages will analyze the Platonic and Aristotelian views on the role and status of women. Although Plato and Aristotle had distinct beliefs on what women could contribute to the collective well being of society, they shared similar opinions about the genuine status that women had in comparison to men. The Platonic view advanced the idea that secluding women to the home was counter-productive to the community as a whole. As such, women should be afforded

Darwin's Theory Of Natural Selection And The Evolution Of Animals

953 words - 4 pages it comes into competition…natural selection will not produce absolute perfection.” Darwin presumed that evolutionary change would on the whole happen relatively slowly over periods of hundreds or thousands of years. However there are reasons to why some aspects of behaviour seem to change more than others during evolution (Grier +Burke). Any behaviour that allows the most effective way to use the available resources

Evolution Of Thought Essay

1229 words - 5 pages Evolution of Thought It is interesting to contemplate a tangled bank, clothed with many plants of many kinds, with birds singing on the bushes, with various insects flitting about, and with worms crawling through the damp earth, and to reflect that these elaborately constructed forms, so different from each other, and dependent upon each other in so complex a manner, have all been produced by laws acting around us. –Charles