The Effects Of Peer Feedback On Vietnamese Secondary Students’ Writing Competence And Students’ Attitudes

1461 words - 6 pages

Research question 2: What are secondary students’ attitudes towards peer feedback?
a. The majority of students find providing peer response difficult due to in care of fellows’ feeling as well as lack of confidence in knowledge and assessment.
In the post interview, when being asked if students found providing peer comments difficult or not, 70% students admitted that they felt awkward to assess their friends’ writing texts even when they had scoring rubric, another 30% told that they felt a little bit hard but interested in experiencing teacher’s role. Those 70% students said that they tried to follow the criteria in the scoring rubric, but they still wondered and concerned whether their comments were qualified, supportive and useful for their friends’ revisions. As the result, they usually tried to imitate teacher’s comments because to student in general “teacher has skills and is qualified, teacher also knows the exact problems of students’ writing” (Quan, personal communication, Dec 2013). In addition, these participants were still afraid of hurting their friends. Even though students were fully aware of that giving critiques helped build up their friends’ writing ability, they did not want to add more writing anxiety into their friends (Quynh Anh, personal communication, Dec 2013). This was also stated in Hosack’s study with Japanese university students (2005).
On the other hand, 30% students who felt interested in providing peer feedback reasoned that peer feedback gave them a completely new way of studying writing. With this approach, students were the center of learning and teaching process (Mangelsdorf, 1992), and they “participated in the learning” (Uyen, personal communication, Dec 2013). Moreover, they were already “bored with sitting still and only listening to the teacher” (Tu, personal communication Dec 2013).
b. Students had more faith on teacher’ comments even though they did not reject peer response.
Students’ drafts with peer comments and teacher’s comments, and their revisions were collected to see teacher or peer feedback was used by the students to edit their writing. The number of peer response and teacher response included in students’ revisions was indicated in table 4. As seen in this table, of 19 students, fifteen included > 50% teacher response and ≤ 50% peer response, one included > 50% both teacher response and peer response, and two included ≤ 50% both teacher and peer response, but none included ≤ 50% teacher response and > 50% peer response. These statistics told the fact that students incorporated peer reviews in their revisions, but more importantly their preference for teacher feedback became evident. This finding was in the same vein with Tsui & Ng (2000), Saito (1994) and Zhang (1995) (cited in Tang & Tithecott, 1999), Nelson & Murphy (1993) and Carson & Nelson (1998) (cited in Kitchakarn, 2012).
Teacher response
Peer response > 50% ≤ 50%
> 50% 1 0
≤ 50% 15 2
Table 4: The number of peer response and...

Find Another Essay On THE EFFECTS OF PEER FEEDBACK ON VIETNAMESE SECONDARY STUDENTS’ WRITING COMPETENCE AND STUDENTS’ ATTITUDES

The New Zealand Government's Failure to Recognise Dyslexic Secondary Students.

2390 words - 10 pages Zealand teacher is going to confront dyslexic students in their classes. IMPACT IN SECONDARY SCHOOLS Dyslexia would not be a problem if it didn't make for trouble at school. The meta-curricular nature of the skills of reading and writing have grave implications for students who battle to decode and encode large amounts of complex subject content on a daily basis. (XXX) Teachers predominantly do not suffer from dyslexia, as they have already

Raising Awareness and Prevention of Drug Misuse in Secondary School Students

2426 words - 10 pages may arise. To increase knowledge on the harmful effects of drug misuse. To increase confidence and change attitudes towards experimenting with drugs. OBJECTIVES Educating staffs and student on the risks of drug misuse. Emphasizing the need to view drug misuse as a health issue and not just a moral or criminal issue. Addressing the issue of improving the curriculum to include classes on drugs and mental health. Discussing with the stake holders

Helping Students Meet the Challenges of Academic Writing

2268 words - 9 pages worker should be encouraged to have a reflective feedback/opinion on the industrial hygiene of a workplace. Thus, allowing the internal and external auditors to improve the health and safety system as a whole. Works Cited Fernsten, Linda A.; Reda, Mary "Helping Students Meet the Challenges of Academic Writing", Teaching in Higher Education, v16 n2 p171-182 Apr 2011 http://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ917785 Bartholomae, D. 1986. Inventing the

Critical Review of Helping Students Meet the Challenges of Academic Writing by Fernsten and Reda

1389 words - 6 pages group they have focused on feel inferior academically. It is insufficient to assume they feel inadequate due to their struggles in writing and can be elevated due to a simplistic strategy of reflection. Cultural bias in teaching and the classroom must be considered in developing an inclusive environment that scaffolds off the students cultural knowledge and skills. According to

Motivating Students in Writing Curriculum

2350 words - 9 pages have a legitimate excuse that prohibits them from performing satisfactorily in the classroom? Which students are just trying to take advantage of a sensitive and compassionate teacher? And it is fair to other students to make exceptions for students with seemingly extenuating circumstances? Teaching writing has a way of forcing me to evaluate my principals and ethics on a daily basis. This is an exhausting task. While it could be argued that

Perceived Erotic Value of Homosexuality and Sex-Role Attitudes as Mediators of Sex Differences in Heterosexual College Students'

6668 words - 27 pages Perceived Erotic Value of Homosexuality and Sex-Role Attitudes as Mediators of Sex Differences in Heterosexual College Students' Research on attitudes toward lesbians and gay men commonly shows that heterosexual women hold similar attitudes toward members of the two groups, whereas heterosexual men hold more negative attitudes toward gay men than toward lesbians. We tested the hypothesis that one reason for this sex difference is that

Research: Political Efficacy and Expected Political Participation among Lower and Upper Secondary Students

2029 words - 8 pages the role of the child’s understanding of politics and act upon those assumptions in order to better further the political system in a positive way.  References Schulz, Wolfram. "ERIC - Political Efficacy and Expected Political Participation among Lower and Upper Secondary Students. A Comparative Analysis with Data from the IEA Civic Education Study, Online Submission, 2005-Sep." ERIC - Political Efficacy and Expected Political Participation

EVALUATION OF STRESS MANAGEMENT FOR HIGHER SECONDARY STUDENTS IN SALEM DISTRICT-TAMIL NADU

2621 words - 11 pages EVALUATION OF STRESS MANAGEMENT FOR HIGHER SECONDARY STUDENTS IN SALEM DISTRICT-TAMIL NADU 1 Introduction Stress is the body’s General response to any intense physical, emotional or mental demand placed on it by on self or others. Anything can be stressor if it last long enough is perceived as stress. Stress is any situation that evokes negative thoughts and feelings in a person. Being a student can be the most interesting time of one’s life

Summary of Secondary Students with Learning Disabilities in Reading: Vocabulary Development

1249 words - 5 pages Summary of Secondary Students with Learning Disabilities in Reading: Vocabulary Development Vocabulary is an important building tool of a child’s reading skills. Students have to understand what the words mean in order to comprehend the story as it is presented to them in the classroom. Unfortunately, that skill is rather ignored in middle school and is expected to be taught in elementary school. When those students do not grasp the

Attracting Non-Traditional Students in Post-Secondary Education

1304 words - 5 pages ). Today, the reality is that 63% now require post-secondary education (Gonzalez). The immense number of job losses in the last few years due to the declining economy has had a large impact on the non-traditional student population. With this growing trend in education, universities need to compete for this type of student. Many schools offer enticing packages for non-traditional students; however, others fall short in their offerings to make

Teaching Writing to Students with Autism

2393 words - 10 pages concepts and writing skills needed. Students with autism lack the same learning abilities as other students, so it is important to “show them all of the ways you read, write, listen, speak, and represent ideas, including some that you might previously have taken for granted” (Kluth and Chandler-Olcott 47). This will ensure that students will be able to effectively learn writing skills based on their individual needs. It is also important to

Similar Essays

The Attitudes Of College Students Toward Slimming

1847 words - 7 pages getting a healthy body. Not only will losing weight help give you the slim and lean body you've always wanted, but it will also keep away a number of obesity-related diseases you may have acquired due to being overweight.The paper is designed to offer some tangible evidence to present the results of a questionnaire on the attitudes of college students toward slimming so that we can find out whether we have some views and misunderstandings in the

Peer Influence: The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly This Is A Research Paper On Peer Influence On Middle School Students

1387 words - 6 pages abstinence form drugs and alcohol." (Ormrod). On the other hand, negative peer influence can "encourage aggression, criminal activity, and other antisocial behaviors" (Ormrod). Illegal drug and alcohol use, promiscuity, bullying, and loss of identity can all result from negative peer pressure. Teachers need to be educated about these things. They need to know what occuring outside of their classrooms is in order to make a difference inside their

Students’ Attitudes And Tactics Toward Savings

1637 words - 7 pages / attitudes of the respondents toward saving, budgeting and usage of items. The researchers were able to survey 40 respondents all from the college department. The results of the survey were as follows: As seen in Figure 1, 60% and 47.5% of the students said they were always saving and budgeting money respectively. There might be some factors that affect their behavior on how they save and budget their money

The Use Of Punctuation In The Writing Of Libyan Students

1958 words - 8 pages ?” but “How do I punctuate X?” Therefore, unfamiliarity with some grammatical concepts hinders students’ attempts to use punctuation effectively (Mann, 2003). To sum up, on the one hand, as of the great resemblance among rule books, one might presume that punctuation has become consistent (Cronnell, 1980). On the other hand, differences among writers and genres, say fiction and technical writing, show that punctuation has not been completely