The Rich Diversity Of Meanings Of The Pardoner's Tale

5636 words - 23 pages

The Rich Diversity of Meanings of the Pardoner's Tale

Chaucer’s innovation in the Pardoner’s performance tests our concept of dramatic irony by suggesting information regarding the Pardoner’s sexuality, gender identity, and spirituality, major categories in the politics of identity, without confirming that information. Our presumed understanding of the Pardoner as a character lacks substantiation. As we learn about the Pardoner through the narrator’s eyes and ears, we look to fit the "noble ecclesiaste" (l. 708) into the figure shaped by our own prejudices and perceptions, as any active reader must do. But the Pardoner, ever aware of his audience, does not offer clear clues to his personality. This break between what the other characters say about the Pardoner and what the Pardoner says about himself has been a major source of tension for all readers of the Tales and especially critics who search for substantiation of their views beyond the Chaucer’s own language. The general tone of the Canterbury Tales is comic. After all, the pilgrims are traveling to the shrine St. Thomas Beckett in a public act of holy reverence, but the Tales take a darker turn when the Pardoner is brought to the foreground. The whole Canterbury Tales is a collected set of performances, stories told about telling stories. As Joseph Ganim has written, theatricality, by which he means "a governing sense of performance, an interplay among the author’s voice, his fictional characters, and his immediate audience," is "a paradigm for the Chaucerian poetic" (5). This paper shall endeavor to show that the major effect of the Pardoner’s presence in the Tales is to focus the reader’s attention to questions of performance and performativity, literary perception, and the unstable relations between language, and more specifically art, and the self. This essay will be as much a critical discussion of Chaucerian criticism as an interpretation of the Pardoner for much of our current understandings of the Pardoner and his performance come from nearly six hundred years of scholarship on the subject.

What exactly do we now about the Pardoner? Much of our understanding of him as a literary human being rests on several key descriptive statements in the text, most about his appearance. They fail, however, to paint as full a portrait as we would like, but these descriptions amount to a generally negative picture. The General Prologue offers a first impression of the Pardoner which has affected his interpreted characterization to this day. The narrator, having met with each of the pilgrims and learned something of their characters, offers a portrait of each of them before the tales begin. In his description of the Pardoner, the narrator notes his traveling companion, his most prominent physical features (including his questionable sexuality), his "newe jet" fashion (l. 682), his relics, and his professional status.

One focus of much criticism of the past fifty years has been the...

Find Another Essay On The Rich Diversity of Meanings of the Pardoner's Tale

The Different Meanings of White Essay

2253 words - 9 pages civilization into the "savage," "primitive" and "backward" peoples of the nonwhite world (Reddy 2007). It was not until the Second World War, in which the Nazi regime used similar "scientific" arguments to justify their campaigns of mass extermination, that these arguments fell out of favor in America (Marable 2007).In addition to these pseudo-biological connotations, whiteness also entailed many moral and religious meanings for much of American history

Exploring the Meanings and Morals of Fairytales

2078 words - 8 pages your own life. Stories allow us to expand our imaginations and gives us hope in creating our own fairy tale endings through the characters strengths through the difficult situations they are shown in. Fairy tales are important because they give you a sense of desire for freedom, which most children can relate to in society. Many individuals can compare their lives to fairy tales which allows them to better understand the direction the story is

Definition Essay - The Many Meanings of Community

548 words - 2 pages Definition Essay - The Many Meanings of Community Community is a common tool of the English language to categorize people and put unique individuals into a single group.  However, what is the real meaning of community?  Community can be used as a noun or an adjective and it has a plethora of meanings in the dictionary. The Oxford English Dictionary defined the word community in two pages worth of different meanings.  The earlier

The Innumerable Meanings of Moby Dick

829 words - 3 pages The Innumerable Meanings of Moby Dick Call me Ishmael. The first line of this story begins with an assertion of self-identity. Before the second page is reached, it becomes quite clear to me that within this assertion of self-identity lay an enticing universality. Ishmael represents every man somehow and no man entirely. He is an individual in his own right, while personifying a basic human desire for something more, something extraordinary

Individuality: The Colourful Meanings of Chrysanthemums

818 words - 4 pages There are hundreds of unique and intricate petals which make up the chrysanthemum flower. The soft curving of the petals show how there is complexity within the flower's entirety. The complexity of the flower is often similar to myself because there are many aspects within my life that define who I am. There are different characteristics that symbolize me, depending on the colour of the flower blossom. The white blossoms

The Meanings and Effects of ConlineBill 2000

3844 words - 15 pages AbstractIt is said that the issues with regards to carriage of goods at sea often arises whenever there are disputes over cargo damage; whether or not to apply certain limitation as per Hague or Hague-Visby Rules, or the US Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1936, etc. But since delivery of goods by the Carrier is an indispensable part in the contract of carriage of goods by sea under the Bill of Lading, this paper will try to understand the meaning

Humanity's ability to act foolish, a theme in "The Pardoner's Tale" from Chaucer's "The Canterbury tales"

1028 words - 4 pages out many inherent flaws of human nature, all of which still apply today. Many things have changed since the fourteenth century, but humanity's ability to act foolish is not one of them. Perhaps the best example of this is illustrated in "The Pardoner's Tale." His account of three rioters who set out to conquer Death and instead deliver it upon each other, as well as the prologue which precedes the tale, reveal the truthfulness of the

Whether or not Geoffrey Chaucer intended to retract "The Pardoner's Tale" in THE CANTERBURY TALES.

689 words - 3 pages ," (l 46).In my opinion, Chaucer did not intend to retract this particular tale. "The Pardoner's Tale," is a story that teaches the wrongfulness of gluttony, swearing, and avarice. In "Chaucer's Retraction," Chaucer makes the statement that "Al that is written is written for oure doctrine," (ll 6-7). "The Pardoner's Tale" along with the prologue gives the reader examples of avarice "So that ye offre alway newe and newe/ Nobles or pens whiche that

Ethics And The Pardon Of Mark Rich

643 words - 3 pages Last Minute Clinton Pardon Ethical? Enter one President and one fugitive from justice. In 1983 Marc Rich was charged with illegally buying oil from Iran while it was under a trade embargo. He was thought to have been trying to avoid oil price controls, evading nearly $50 million in federal taxes. After fleeing to Switzerland he was placed on the America's Ten Most Wanted List. 17 years later in the last hours of the Clinton presidency

A summary Report on "The Pardoner's Tale" from the Canterbury Tales. Includes interpretation.

789 words - 3 pages 1) Geoffrey Chaucer, "The Pardoner's Tale," c. 13862) Main Characters:Three Rioters: these are three drunken Flemish boys who are also obviously very greedy.Old man: no one is really sure who he is. Some say he is just an old man and he is not important to the story. However, he could also be either death or the devil, either one luring the boys into their demise.3) Setting/Significance: Bar in Flanders, and a tree in the grove, undertone of

The Rich Cost of Poor Mathematics Education

932 words - 4 pages America’s economy has been slowly crumbling before our very eyes. The nation has gone from a frivolous society to one of ever increasing frugality in the past decade alone. It has been said numerous times that the current generation of high school and college students may be compared to their predecessors who lived through the Great Depression. The focus on Algebra in high school is beneficial to a meager portion of the student population but

Similar Essays

The Pardoner's Tale Canterbury Tales Essay

799 words - 3 pages Essay on the Pardoner's Tale A couple of days ago, there were robbers in England that planned to steal a priceless collection of jewelry. However, Scotland Yard, the British equivalent of the FBI, stopped and arrested the thieves red-handed. It was greed that led the robbers to their arrest and prison. Greed is what leads the three rioters to their death in "The Pardoner's Tale". In the prologue of the Canterbury Tales, Chaucer describes the

Chaucers: The Pardoner's Corruption Tale Essay

861 words - 3 pages hypnotize the Host; that he is a glutton and a typical tavern reveler is revealed by the fact that he calls for cakes and ale before he can properly relate a moral tale. (Curry) This small detail of the Pardoner desiring cake and ale is a significant clue that, despite his outwardly appearance of caring for the sinful, his first concerns are only for himself. One of the more unsympathetic characters in Chaucer's tales is the Pardoner, who

Revolt Of The Rich Essay

1241 words - 5 pages controlled by a wealthy elite, as explained by Mike Lofgren in his article "Revolt of the Rich". Lofgren proposes that the wealthy elite in America are transitioning into separating themselves from the common population.Mike Lofgren's "Revolt of the Rich", published on August 27, 2012, describes how the financial elitists in America have seceded from the country. Mike Lofgren explains "I do not mean secession by physical withdrawal from the

The Real Meanings Of Jihad Essay

2563 words - 10 pages educate ourselves. Works Cited Church, Kenneth. “Jihad.” Collateral Language. Ed. John Collins and Ross Glover. New York: NYU Press, 2000. 109-123. Engineer, Asghar Ali. “The Real Meanings of Jihad.” December 2001. 4 October 2012. Husaq, Nina. E-mail to the author. 19 October 2012. Juergensmeyer, Mark. Terror In The Mind Of God. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2003. Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary. merriam