This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Right To Life For Embryo

1027 words - 5 pages

In this paper, I will investigate the right to life for an embryo based on Carl Sagan and Ann Druyan’s article “Abortion: Is it Possible to be both “Pro-life” and “Pro-Choice”?” My conclusion is that an embryo is a potential person then it has the right to life. Sagan and Druyan argue that an embryo does not have human characteristics, thus it is acceptable to abort it. I will show that an embryo is a potential person thus it has the right to life.
Is an embryo a person? If the “person” means, in biology, is a member of Homo sapiens, then after 14 days when primitive streak or after 16 days when gastrulation (Damschen, Gómez-Lobo and Schönecker), an embryo is a person without doubt, because ...view middle of the document...

So far I want to convince that someone who has personhood may not be a Homo sapiens, it could be another species, or even beyond the existence. Some members in Homo sapiens, by the biological definition, is not necessarily a person. Hydatidiform mole, anencephalic, Siamese twins, even fetus-in-fetu, or some fetuses develop to a certain stage and discontinue, and even some patient presented in brain-dead state(unlike vegetative), these are all the members in Homo sapiens, all of them can be formed biologically as Homo sapiens, but they would not be considered as a person.
Notably, even in today’s general understanding, avoid using substance or essence of rationality to talk about the person, but rather with the way the matter has rational function to determine whether it has the personhood. However the concept of personhood, in fact, is inseparable from the meaning of some kind of metaphysical entity. It is more obvious when discussing about personal identity problem, that personhood at different points in time all have the identity, the same person cannot have more than one identity with two different individuals.
Finally, and perhaps most crucially, “what is a potential person” or “who has the potential to develop into a person”. A potential person is a vague and ambiguous semantic expression, it could mean “someone is a potential person, if and only if he/she is already a person right now, and has some causal possibility to manifest his/her qualities as a person in the future”. The biggest issue in this argument is that it treats an embryo directly as a person, like unreasonably treating chicken eggs as chicken. It considers every generation changes are changes of phenomenon, and do not involve changing the entity.
Based on the conceptual analysis of potential, it is nature rather than physical, it must be attached to a certain entity. Which means the potential is the potential of something. Thus, when we are talking about “an embryo is a potential person”, it implies an argument “an embryo is a person”.
But this argument is actually wrong...

Find Another Essay On The right to life for embryo

Animals' Right to Life Essay

1116 words - 4 pages For decades, animal rights activists have attempted to advocate the notion that animals, as with humans, have an implicit right to life. Such premise is reasonable and often easy to accept, especially where everyone that owns a pet knows the great sensation it is to get home after a stressful day at work and be received by your playing dog or cat. For many, it is easy to recognize that dogs and cats for example, are living and sustainable

The Right to Life Includes the Right to Choose How Your Life Ends

1131 words - 5 pages In this paper, I will be arguing for the position that active euthanasia should be legal in the United States. A patient’s suffering should not be prolonged, doctors should be able to ease their suffering and help their patient to the fullest extent. I believe this issue is important for discussion because the suffering individual has rights and the right to live should give them the right to choose to end that suffering. I think that some of

Who Has the Right to Take a Life?

1189 words - 5 pages Who Has the Right to Take a Life? Conforming to the correct rules of conduct, or moral values, reflect an individual’s views about life. Morality draws the dividing line between what is right and wrong. When developing an opinion toward the death penalty, one immediately drifts toward a certain side. Introduced to world justice systems early on, the death penalty became a means of punishment for those who committed crimes deemed as morally

Abortion Issues: Right to Life

933 words - 4 pages ratio was 228 abortions per 1,000 live births (Pazol, Creanga, Burley, Hayes & Jamieson, 2013, p.1). That means 228 lives are being killed for every a thousand live births. Children never had the choice to ask to be born, but creating lives is purely an option that only adults can decide. If adults have created lives, then they should not take them away. Every human being is granted a life. No one has the right to take away an unborn

How Does the Embryo Take Form and Differentiate to Become an Organised Organism?”

1481 words - 6 pages a control cell pellet that acted as the control (Levin & Johnson et al, 1995). This led to the discovery of nodal in the chick embryo, which Levin concluded could be responsible for asymmetry in the formation of the heart (Levin & Johnson et al, 1995). He also discovered that activin expressed on the right side, and SHH expressed on the left side led to the reversal of organ asymmetry, and that it was a cascade of genes, and not just any one

How to Evabgelize Using the Right Method for the Situation

1276 words - 6 pages A person can evangelize many different ways. There are intellectual methods, relational methods, and confrontational methods. There is no right or wrong way to evangelize only the right method for the situation. In this paper, I will be discussing one way of evangelizing for each of the different methods. This paper will include the Romans Road method, the Friendship evangelism method, and the Door-to-Door evangelism method. The Romans Road

How to Have the Right Pool for Your Property

701 words - 3 pages Every home owner wishes to have a pool in their property. Aside from adding to its aesthetic value it can be used in many different ways: as a place where the whole family can enjoy a sunny day, a place where one can exercise and even a place where guests can be entertained. Picking a pool for a property though is not as simple as buying a TV for your living room. There are a few considerations you need to make to ensure you choose the right one

The Right to Privacy for Employees and Their Email

888 words - 4 pages management does business in the next decade, harassment lawsuits and threats of lawsuits changed the face of the workplace in the 80?s and 90?s. The privacy controversy has not yet been settled in court, but in instances where there is good cause for monitoring or some legal obligation, the company has a right to monitor employees e-mail. The company must follow procedures reasonably designed to establish and to assure that any monitoring is limited to

Malala Yousafzai: A Voice For the Right to Women’s Education

1014 words - 5 pages Being shot in the face and seriously injured, did not stop Malala Yousafzai from pursuing her dreams. She did not morally agree with her government’s treatment of women, so she fought for her beliefs. Malala grew up in a rural village in Pakistan and was forced to follow customs she did not believe in. Swat Valley changed to a strictly ruled village with discrimination towards women. Malala created awareness around the world of the

Prolife is the right life

730 words - 3 pages “abortion” is extremely controversial is when it is talked about ethically. Many Americans who are against abortion believe that it is ethically wrong. Even if they do not have religious beliefs, some feel that it is wrong because of the process of abortion or just the thought of it. But others are for it in certain cases. For instance, if a young girl is raped and becomes pregnant, she would be so embarrassed and wouldn’t want to keep the baby. Other cases that may cause a young woman to want to get an abortion are a handicapped baby or it causes her own life to be in danger. Those are the reasons that are considered “ok”.

Te Right Friends for the Right Future

798 words - 4 pages Each year new people are meet, new friends are made and new cliques are formed. At first, when looking for friends on campus, many college students associate with whomever seems easiest to connect to. Often times these students are more socially forward and open with others, although this is a wonderful attribute for a person to have, these are not always the most well-behaved or reputable individuals. It is important for a student to associate

Similar Essays

Weighing The Right To Own An Embryo By Mike Mc Kee

1302 words - 5 pages Writing to a Legal Audience Mike McKee’s article, "Weighing the Right to Own an Embryo," made the front page of the Recorder, a daily legal newspaper published in San Francisco reporting on legal advice and interests of attorneys and legal practitioners. How did he make his article such a success? What made it front page worthy in the eyes of this legal audience? McKee’s article, "Weighing the Right to Own an Embryo," appeals to a legal

The Right To Life And The Right To Liberty Analysis

1868 words - 7 pages Most countries around the world agree on two basic rights: the right to life and the right to liberty. Outside of these most basic human rights, what else do we deserve? And do human rights apply to animals as well? The ethics system of Universality seeks to answer these questions. Not only should human rights be increased worldwide, but we must also make an effort to improve the lives of the animals that we share this planet with. Whether it is

"Euthanasia Against The Right To Life"

1382 words - 6 pages the pain. The fact to aspire not to see ourselves placed in circumstances that inspire pity and compassion before the eyes of others, establishes an attitude in life, which is called dignity. If we truthfully care about ourselves, we will never aspire that we be sympathized for our state of misery and of pain. That is how we have the right to live with dignity and therefore it is also assumed that we also have the right to die with

Euthanasia: The Right For The Right To Die

1681 words - 7 pages individual who is in bad health gives consent for the Euthanasia. How could you let a person who is most likely going through a tough period of their life and most likely being in a lot of pain, make such a decision to take their own life? They just aren't in the right mental condition to make such an important and grave decision. In cases where the patient isn't responsive there should be no question in administering euthanasia, no way should another