This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Rigour Relevance Gap Essay

1435 words - 6 pages

Introduction

An ongoing discussion within the field of management research is the rigour-relevance gap. This gap can be described as the lack of connection between rigourous scientific research to relevant managerial practice. I.e. scientific research is expected to be rigourous with references, theories and models based on logical arguments or empirical analysis, while managerial practice searches for relevant, applicable theories and models.

Different aspects of the rigour-relevance gap are subject to the discussion: (1) the relevance of the gap itself (BRON), (2) the need for bridging the gap (BRON) and (3) potential solutions in order to bridge the gap. (BRON) Most researchers agree on the existence of the gap (Kieser & Leiner, 2009; Tranfield & Starkey, 1998), but they do not all assume bridging the gap as possible and desirable. Kieser & Leiner (2009) for example, refute the possibility of developing a bridge between scientific research and managerial practice. They argue that both fields are surrounded by different systems, which cannot be directly linked to each other. Another argument against bridging the gap is about undesirability to do so. Objectivity is an important aspect of academic research, as stated by Kimberley (Walsh et al., 2007).

However, other researchers argue that the gap of rigour and relevance is bridgeable. Different approaches of creating such a bridge are explored within academic research. On one hand, academics suggest that collaboration with stakeholders will contribute to the applicability of research to managerial practice (Tranfield & Starkey, 1998; Tushman, M.L., O'Reilly, C.A., Fenollosa, A., Kleinbaum, A.M. & McGrath, D., 2007). Collaboration with stakeholders can be incorporated by taking advantage of interdisciplinairy research methods (Tranfield & Starkey, 1998) and/or by providing executive education (Tushman et al., 2007).

On the other hand, researchers suggest a solution based on the provision of scientific theory. Suggestions are made in terms of combining descriptive theory with prescriptive theory might minimalize the gap between rigour and relevance (Van Aken, 2004) and providing a language of concepts and symbols, rather than tools or instruments (Astley & Zammuto, 1992).

This paper examines the bridgeability of the rigour-relevance gap within the field of management research by outlining four main perspectives. Two perspectives which claim the bridgeability of the gap will be discussed, followed by two perspectives which assert either impossibility and undesirabilty of bridging the gap. Rather than just describing various perspectives on the topic, the perspectives are integratively discussed in the final section. This section also argues an extent of bridgeability of the rigour-relevance gap within the field of management research.

Bridging the gap by providing useful theory
As some researchers state, the rigour-relevance gap is bridgeable by providing useful...

Find Another Essay On The Rigour-Relevance Gap

The Gap Inc Essay

1794 words - 7 pages advertisements fail to create any kind of emotion attachment being that they have no relevance to the customer. The Gap brand stands for nothing. The store with white walls and wooden shelves is boring, and the commercials are pointless and dull. 6. Analysis of business-level strategy The Gap competes on the basis of both cost leadership and differentiation. This hybrid strategy was implemented based on the high level of competition in the retail

Critically evaluate the claim that discourse analysis could become the dominant paradigm for psychology in the future

1189 words - 5 pages and intentions have no scientific rigour as they cannot be directly observed. The validity of both theories is argued and supported, yet they are derived from contrasting paradigms, supporting the notion that paradigms do exist in social sciences (e.g. psychology). Social scientists have coined the phrase “paradigm shift” to detonate a change in how an individual society organises and understands reality. A "dominant paradigm" refers to the

Social Awareness

871 words - 3 pages relevance of sports because athletic departments and teams don't use traditional curricula or processes of evaluation that document learning and teaching in terms allowing them to see "education in operation. " Athletic department administrators and coaches feel that faculty do not understand what and how they teach and cannot do research that would assist them in meeting the expectations that dominate their lives. The width of the academia

Cognitive Ability-Demand Gap analysis with Latent Response Theories

733 words - 3 pages the confidence interval, response latitudes revealed general correspondence of gap in the item calibration patterns. Some items showed also a slight misfit. Based on these results, the phrasing and targeting of some items should be considered. Relevance to assistive technology design guide line. The dichotomous Rasch model is useful in identifying gap, cognitive dissonance and useful in assistive decision support systems. Polythomous (extended

Journal Article Critique - Bougainville Copper: A Case Analysis in International Management

2377 words - 10 pages the overall contribution of the article to future research in International Management.2.Summary (Key Findings and Arguments)There have been few researches having been done regarding the MNEs involved in less developed countries. Tonks and Dowling filled up the gap by publishing their research article in 2002 about their research on studies of the management of Bougainville Copper Limited that operated in less developed country (In Papua New

TITLE: THE USE OF EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY TO FACILITATE STUDENT SELF-DIRECTED LEARNING IN A HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTION

1509 words - 7 pages learning are evolving swiftly and students are increasingly depending on personal technologies, such as mobile phones and tablet devices to manage not only their lives but also their learning (Ling and Donner 2009:78; Pachler, Bachmair and Cook 2010:3). This study therefore is of both academic and professional relevance for this researcher, who is the Registrar of the institution being studied. As part of his statutory responsibilities, the

Contemporary Art: Marina Abramovic

1511 words - 6 pages that of the gallery. If the house is synonymous with the body, this ‘rational’ space could be read as a visual manifestation of Marina`s physical and psychic state during the performance. The gap between the extreme conditions informing her physical and mental state and the quotidian sensibility of the viewers was thus actualized not only by the rigour of her performative actions but also by the stripped-down symbolic space of her body/house

Is British politics undergoing a process of Europeanisation?

2137 words - 9 pages used to analyse the dynamics of European integration, how it occurs and more importantly how it impacts on the domestic politics of member states. Some academics believe that the two definitions are interchangeable and the term Europeanisation should be scrapped so as to avoid further conceptual confusion.I think all the five definitions have some relevance in helping to conceptualise the term but I particularly think that an analysis of 1) and 2

Discuss how The Joy Luck Club deals with the generation gap between mothers and daughters

588 words - 2 pages do love each other, by quoting one of the mothers telling Jing - Mei "Your mother is in your bones" meaning that even though they had problems, there was still a part of her mother in her, acknowledging my point.To conclude, I opine that there is not much relevance in the generation gap between mother and daughter, it's more about the cultural difference, because, as you can see, mothers and daughters from the same culture don't differ as much as these do, they do have misunderstandings, but about less significant things such as cloth, relationships and food. Not about almost everything like the mothers and daughters in The Joy Luck Club did.

Twenty One Aspects of Strategic Planning

3463 words - 14 pages of action that are selected subsequently (the strategies) are the ones that can (ideally) best exploit the opportunities in the environment utilizing the organizational strengths while minimizing treats and weaknesses.1.4 Action : NowIn the absence of strategic planning and strategies, organizations stagnate. They habitually perform routine activities without clear purpose or rigour. Strategies compel organizations into action in order to achieve

Womens work versus males work

879 words - 4 pages being involved with the household duties. • Hierarchy of work existed, with men at the apex and were seen as superior and more ‘valuable’, women in the centre, so therefore were not seen as important as men, and then with children at the base. Write in full sentences to explain the relevance of article/book chapter to diverse whānau families in Aotearoa New Zealand. (200 words in total) Austrin, T. (1990). Work. In D. Pearson, I. Shirley & P

Similar Essays

Young People And Type Ii Diabetes In Sub Saharan Africa

998 words - 4 pages CRITICAL APPRAISAL Critical appraisal is the process of judging the trustworthiness and the relevance of the evidences (Chambers 2004) presented in a research paper (Carnwell and Daly 2001). A critical appraisal can also be carried out as part of data collection, nevertheless its ultimate aim is to further exclude articles with poor methodological quality. It is important to use appraisal tools that are evidence based. A quantitative and

What Factors Are Involved In The Increasing Prevalence Of Type Ii Diabetes In Adolescents Living In Sub Saharan Africa?

1706 words - 7 pages involve months or years of follow-up of participants. CRITICAL APPRAISAL Critical appraisal is the process of judging the trustworthiness and relevance of the evidences (Chambers, 1998) presented research paper. The following questions should be considered as the essentials of appraising an article: - What are the results? - Are they significant? - Are the results valid? - How was the research done? - How will these results help me answer my

Physical Activity Levels Among Student Nurses

1119 words - 4 pages and make decision for behavioural change, while they keep their positive healthy lifestyle. Recent evidence demonstrated the relevance of regular physical activity in preventing chronic diseases and improving the health of the population (McElligot, 2007) A study by Shriver and Scott-Stiles, (2000) argued that, health care professionals should strive to be outstanding role models for their clients. Likewise, Holt and Warne (2006) revealed that

Refocusing The Gap Essay

1720 words - 7 pages to want to wear gap clothing. As it stands right now gap commercials in my opinion have no relevance to their clothing and are really annoying.Where Gap really went wrong is when they concentrated all its advertisement toward the preppy genre, now that the fad with khakis is starting to fade out Gap has been left scratching their heads not knowing where they went wrong. The reality is that the generations of children ranging from ages eight to