The Role And Structure Of Greek Tragedy In Philip Roth’s Eli The Fanatic

1784 words - 7 pages

The Role and Structure of Greek Tragedy in Philip Roth’s Eli the Fanatic

When one’s in pain—physical, mental, or emotional—one always believes it is worse than everyone else’s. Yet when an acquaintance bemoans a bad day, one still manages to wave it off: it could not be worse than one’s own pain. Even if it is a past pain and there are only scars, those scars are tenderer than the friend’s current sores. Individuals forget that anguish can be shared and another’s intervention can diminish it. This theme has been around for millennia and was particularly explored in the works of Greek tragedians. In Eli, the Fanatic Philip Roth employs structural and thematic elements of Greek tragedy to illustrate that human beings can be responsible for each other’s suffering.

One of the essential elements of Greek tragedy, that of the chorus, can be filled in by Ted, Shirley, and even Miriam. They are the residents of Woodenton who call Eli. Traditionally, the chorus plays an active role and can be a sounding and advising board for the protagonist. Ted in particular tries to advise Eli and, like the customary chorus, he represents the masses, the people, in this particular case the town of Woodenton. As Ted informs Eli, “The Jewish members of the community appointed me, Artie, and Harry to


see what could be done” (276). The Greek chorus, in Greek tragedy, represents the masses and often serves to counterpoint the protagonist, and Ted’s near-fanatical grudge

against the Yeshiva certainly counterpoints with Eli’s growing benevolence toward them. In Roth’s context, the residents of Woodenton, the Chorus, also serve as a

counterpoint to Eli’s guilt. Eli becomes concerned over the Greenie’s happiness and goes so far as to plead with the Greenie to allow him to help. “Tell me, what can I do for you, I’ll do it” (291). Eli is manifesting his guilt, the guilt of many American Jews who were did nothing during the Holocaust. The chorus, however, are unmoved by the Man in the Hat’s past suffering. They demand he change, and while Eli tries to help him not just through clothes but by offering any other services he might provide, the chorus is too concerned with the Greenie’s outward appearance and unwilling to compromise. Roth takes the Greek chorus, modernizes them, and generalizes them to suburbanites who ignore the suffering of others.

Roth also employs the stichomythia and episodic nature of Greek tragedy to further explore the interactions of different people and misery. For example, one tradition within tragedies is that they are episodic, as they go from strophe to antistrophe and repeat the cycle. The shift from strophe to antistrophe and back again is often interrupted by the chorus, and Eli, the Fanatic fits the pattern. In this sense, the structure of Greek tragedy highlights the disparity between the Yeshiva and Woodenton, as the strophe can be seen to be the former and Eli moves into the latter...

Find Another Essay On The Role and Structure of Greek Tragedy in Philip Roth’s Eli the Fanatic

Friar Laurence’s Role in The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet

769 words - 3 pages William Shakespeare’s play, The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, tells of two lovers who sacrifice their life for each other throughout their family’s feud. Throughout the play, Shakespeare utilizes the Nurse and Friar Laurence to offer guidance to Romeo and Juliet. The Friar, in particular, is considered “a holy man” because he is a monk and is particularly thought of for his noble counsel (5.3.269). In The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, Friar

The Role of Fate in Greek History

788 words - 3 pages The Greek believed strongly in knowing yourself, retributive justice and being able to see things as a whole. They also arranged their social life to provide them with a maximum degree of freedom; freedom form political and religious domination. Despite their strong beliefs in freedom , they always had the belief on fate and usually consult the gods regarding their fate, so that they may live according to their fate. Fate is the inevitable

The Structure and Role of Proteins in Cell Membranes

1564 words - 6 pages The Structure and Role of Proteins in Cell Membranes Cells are the building blocks of which all living organisms are composed. There are lots of different types of cells that make up living organisms but they are all similar in structure. All cells are surrounded by a cell membrane (or plasma membrane), which controls the movement of substances into and out of the cell. Cell membranes are described as partially

The Role of the Chorus in Ancient Greek Plays

726 words - 3 pages The Role of the Chorus in Ancient Greek Plays *Works Cited Not Included In ancient Greek plays, the role of the chorus was to sing lyrical passages. The lyrical passages were set up by the writer and the chorus would then perform dance movements to compliment those lyrics. In today's day and age, it is the cast members in many musicals who depict the role as the chorus. However, in some cases, the chorus also helps assist the modern

The Role of Fate in William Shakespeare's The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet

2807 words - 11 pages The Role of Fate in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet 'Romeo and Juliet', the first romantic tragedy was based on a poem translated from the French 'Novella' (1595). Romeo Montague, who is in love with Rosaline, goes to a party in an attempt to take his mind off her. At this party he meets Juliet Capulet and immediately falls in love with her. Later he finds out that she is a Capulet, the rival family of the

The Role of Paradoxical Structure

1579 words - 6 pages structure in which they coexist while Johnson formulates her position through the use of apostrophe to show the polar positions of abortion as it pertains to rights and power. Their use of paradox highlights the construction of their arguments while showcasing their ideas by comparing them to the extreme critiques at their respective poles, thus allowing them to play off the poles without having to toe the same lines. Michael Foucault

The Role of Women in Ancient Greek Art

920 words - 4 pages be women.The role of women in Greece can be studied by reviewing how women are portrayed in art. Ordinary women are portrayed as well as goddesses and more mythological creatures. It is interesting that so many of the monsters of Greek myth are women: Sirens, Sphinx, Gorgons, Scylla, Charybdis, Chimera.Both men and women are displayed as sex objects. Statues of Aphrodite are often in this vein. But the people portrayed are often indiviualized

Law of Religion vs. Law of Man in the Greek Tragedy, "Antigone#

669 words - 3 pages Whatever your religion there is usually one thing in common, the laws of the religion must be upheld in all situations. With this in mind there could be many situations; it could mean to stand your ground under peer pressure, it could be if one is faced by tragedy, or even if one must stand against the laws of man. This theme is shown in the courageous acts of Antigone in the Greek drama "Antigone" where she stands against a law made by her

My Son the Fanatic

1018 words - 4 pages to get through to his son with violence. Parvez kicked him over. Then he dragged the boy up by the front of his shirt and hit him. The boy fell back. Parvez hit him again. The boy’s face was bloody. Parvez was panting; he knew the boy was unreachable, but he struck him nonetheless. The boy neither covered himself nor retaliated: there was no fear in his eyes. He only said, through his split lips. So who’s the fanatic now? Many people think of

“My Son the Fanatic”

1601 words - 7 pages fanatic now? (386-392) Although this is the end of the story, the reader can assume that the two have “lost” any hope of rekindling their relationship. In the final line Ali asks his father “who’s the fanatic now?” Many people think of the word fanatic as someone who is extremely into something such as a religion, and in turn would only label Ali as the fanatic. However, both Parvez and Ali could be considered fanatics, at the end of the story

Writing in the Style of Philip Larkin

961 words - 4 pages his long fingers grip the throat of the man in the back. I yell out “What’s Happening?!” “Its not good, Hurry” she replies. I can hear her doing CPR. The soft banging of her hands on his chest. The whir of the oxygen machine. Death is smirking at me. He is coming and he isn’t going to stop this time. It must be said that "Ambulances" is one of Philip Larkin's successes. He has described our own venerability and lack of knowledge. He

Similar Essays

The Importance Of Structure In "The Agamemnon" Is A Classic Greek Tragedy Written By Aeschylus

1586 words - 6 pages The Agamemnon is a classic Greek tragedy written by Aeschylus in which he entails the continuation of the curse on the house of Atreus in the time period following the end of the Trojan War and the return of King Agamemnon. This play tells of the murders of Cassandra and Agamemnon-by-Agamemnon's wife Clytemestra. Throughout the play many aspects have a profound effect on the structure. Things such as the chorus, audience, the use of common

Analysis Of Various Greek Plays, Including Antigone. Discussing The Role Of Greek Tragedy Westview/Hillview Essay

1393 words - 6 pages Ancient Greek Tragedy Every good story that speaks to the human spirit has conflict. The best stories have various kinds of conflict, and some of those struggles are internal, rooted in the psyches of fascinating characters. The Greeks developed internal conflict within their main characters so well that the the tragedies themselves are riveting. Unlike modern literature where characters are typically torn between a choice of what is right

The Role Of Parenting In Henry Roth’s Call It Sleep

1404 words - 6 pages The Role of Parenting in Henry Roth’s Call it Sleep In the novel Call it Sleep, by Henry Roth, one of the hardest tasks is to truly understand the character of David Schearl. Written from the perspective of a young child, the reader has to wade through rambling streams of consciousness filled with significant meaning, as well as, well-developed mature thoughts. However, you cannot truly comprehend a character like David unless you

The Role Of Greek Gods And Goddesses In Ancient Times

1250 words - 5 pages The Role of Greek Gods and Goddesses in Ancient Times With all of the interesting aspects of the Odyssey, I am only going to touch on one of them. The gods and goddesses in the Odyssey of all of the deities mentioned I am only going to focus on a few. The first and most powerful of these is Zeus. Then we have Hermes, the messenger god. Last but not least of these would be Athena, the goddess of warriors. Zeus, Ruler of the gods. "Zeus