The Role Of Art Vs. The Role Of Science

1609 words - 6 pages

The Role of Art vs. the Role of Science

“art upsets [and] science reassures.” - Georges Braque

Before beginning, it is important to clarify that the quote is referring to shock as causing anger or upset. In using reassuring, Georges Braque is referring to comforting. That said, this statement by Braque is true to a point, because the statement also works in reverse. Throughout the history of man, art has been a method for communication, and in the process it has alternatively shocked and soothed the world. Similarly, science has also disturbed and reassured society. This much is evident through an evaluation of both studies.

Recently in the news, art in the form of photography have had a tremendous effect on people. Pictures of the World Trade Center collapsing, people jumping out of them, the Pentagon in flames, and Arabic children celebrating in the Middle East all shocked us. To most, it was incomprehensible that anything like this could happen. The stunning photographs taken pulled the viewer into the scene and they could try to comprehend the enormity of the situation at hand.

Going back slightly less than 30 years, we again see the power of photographs to shock us. The world watched, through a camera lens, as a South Vietnamese security agent killed a Vietcong soldier in the streets of Saigon. This picture appalled a sense of justice in the viewer, and support for any government that would do such a thing dwindled. Later, when pictures of a young girl running from American bombs hit the press, we questioned how we could ever do such a thing.

If one travels back another 15 years or so, one can examine the effect of news reels and photographs on people. As pictures of Nazi atrocities like the Holocaust filtered out people were shocked at such brutal mistreatment of their fellow humans. Anger boiled up that moved us to call for a trial specifically for these crimes against humanity. Were it not for these images, leaders of the free world may not have pushed as hard for a trial of the nation’s leaders.

However, at the same time, photographs have served to calm the anger, and reassure Americans. In reference to September 11th, photos of National Guardsmen in airports reassured travelers that security was being stepped up, that something like this would not happen again. Interfaith services showed us that this was the work of Muslim extremists, and tempered the anger in some at the religion of those who had committed the atrocities.

Going back to WWII, shots of those same concentration and death camps reassured the western Allies that they were doing the right thing. World War II became a moral cause, one in which we morally obliged to wipe out this great evil. We became certain that no matter what else, we had a moral duty to stop the Nazis and those that aided and abetted them.

Art as literature has also had the power...

Find Another Essay On The Role of Art vs. the Role of Science

The Role of Women in Ancient Greek Art.

920 words - 4 pages The investigation of the role of women in the Art of ancient Greece is complex because artists were affected both by the art of the past and the women that they saw around them every day. There is one certainty and that is that the influence of the various roles evident produced some of the greatest art ever. The purpose of this page is to investigate the various influences that women had and provide information to help the understanding of this

The Role of Science in Technology, and The Localization of Science-Technology Linkages

1983 words - 8 pages base could produce many inventions and demand is the one responsible for making that particular innovation and not other possible ones. Later on economists realized the role of firms in technology and R&D, because the firm need to be a participant in the ever-advancing research frontier to be able to innovate and develop. 2. The Relationship Between Science And Technology The historian Toynbee imaged in his book A Study of History, S&T’s

Pre-Columbian Art: The role of art in the Aztec Religion

978 words - 4 pages For my topic, I chose to study and critique Pre-Columbian art at the Baltimore Museum of Art. The collection of Art of the Ancient Americas represents 59 artistic traditions ranging in time from 2500 B.C. - A.D. 1521, and features works from the widely recognized Aztec and Maya of Mesoamerica, Chimú and Muisca of Andean South America, and Nicoya and Atlantic Watershed of Costa Rica. Notable objects include a finely worked serpentine

the role of a critic in defining a piece of art

3336 words - 13 pages critic's interest in value judgments and formal beauty of a given work distinguishes him from a scientist engaged in cold and impersonal fact finding analysis. Literary criticism, therefore, cannot be reduced to science. And the ideal of complete objectivity in critical response is almost a vanity of vanities.WORKS CITEDOscar Wilde: The Critic as an ArtistJanine Marchessault: Marshal McLuhanT.S. Eliot: The Function of Criticism, The Perfect Critic, The Frontiers of CriticismDavid Cote: Role of Theatre CriticismTerry Eagleton: Functions of CriticismDavid Daiches: Critical Approach to LiteratureF.L.Lucas: Tragedy in Relation to Aristotle's Poetics

Women´s Role in Society in Antigone, Aeneid, and The Art of Courtly Love

1272 words - 5 pages , more roles within the church became available to women. Women were given opportunities to escape child bearing, acquire literacy and learning and play a more active religious role in society. From my point of view Catherine did not rebel against the laws of society. She just grabbed the opportunities that came her way and showed the world that women can also be good rulers. In The Art of Courtly Love written by Andreas Capellanus and in The Lais

Atraction/Repulsion A criticism paper/statement from an art school student discussing the role of attraction and repulsion using examples of sculptors working in the 1970's.

737 words - 3 pages Attraction/ RepulsionI believe that something can be both attractive and repulsive at simultaneous moments. The last fifty years is filled of art that possesses this quality. In the sixties art was challenged again this time by the "anti-form". Minimalism left an unsatisfied need for direct matter. Performance art became a good arena for expression. Carolee Schneeman's Meat Joy (1964) was a performance with half naked figures covered in animal

Art for Art's Sake: discusses the views of James Baldwin and Ralph Waldo Emerson Ellison regarding the role experience and social agenda do/should play in the creation of art.

635 words - 3 pages A great 20th century author once said, "our humanity is our burden" (23). It is this encumbrance, however, that shapes the literature of two of the most powerful and influential authors of this era, Ralph Ellison and James Baldwin. Though they have opposing views on the role experience and sociopolitical agenda should play in art, both writers recognize the importance of these two factors and have been very vocal on their opinions about the

The study of management is a new science. When did this start and who were the leading people in developing theories of management? What is the role of management in a modern organisation?

559 words - 2 pages The availability of powered machinery during the Industrial Revolution transformed manufacturing and mining processes. Entrepreneurs faced the issue of how to organise their production and administrative activities to exploit these advances profitably. Although domestic and export demand for manufactured goods was high, so was the risk of business failure. Economic and social considerations probably motivated their search. Incomes were very low

Women's Role in Science and Technology

2454 words - 10 pages Women's Role in Science and Technology Women have played an important role in the development of science and technology, but there is an insufficient number of females in those career fields. Technological change has affected the roles of women and gender role ideas. Women without doubt came a long way improving the numbers and increasing the percentages in the workforce of Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM

The Role of Nature vs Nurture

631 words - 3 pages The Role of Nature vs Nurture "We used to think our fate was in our stars. Now, we know, in large part, that our fate is in our genes." ---James Watson While social research has been steady and ongoing, our biological knowledge has advanced disproportionately in recent times. As we discover more about the role of genes in pre-determining who we are, the nature versus nurture debate seems headed for a tilt of the biological over the

Science and Technology played an important role during World War

520 words - 2 pages Science and Technology played an important role during World War 1, and post war. Life during World War 1 was very tough on the Americans, since they had so many loved ones fighting in the war. Science and Technology made not only life in America easier for them, and the many advances helped the war.The science and technology that was used during the world war are of many. One of the most significant modifications was the building of the Panama

Similar Essays

The Changing Role Of Science Fiction

2577 words - 10 pages    Science fiction means a lot of things to a lot of different people, thus a variety of definitions have arisen to allow for this. Perhaps the most simple of these can be found in the The Merriam-Webster Dictionary, which states that science fiction is "fiction dealing principally with the impact of actual or imagined science on society or individuals" (652). Most of academia, however, prefers an extended version from Darko Suvin, who

The Role Of Gender In Art

2144 words - 9 pages historians in the latter part of the twentieth century. It will then discuss two pairs of mutually contemporary works of art whilst attempting to introduce concepts into the discussion of the works themselves, in order to point to differences or similarities in technique, form and style, and ways to approach an analysis of the work. Finally a conclusion will be drawn on the importance of the role of gender arising from the discourse. Gender

The Role Of Science, Ethics, And Faith In Modern Philosophy

3577 words - 14 pages The Role of Science, Ethics, and Faith in Modern Philosophy ABSTRACT: Curiously, in the late twentieth century, even agnostic cosmologists like Stephen Hawking—who is often compared with Einstein—pose metascientific questions concerning a Creator and the cosmos, which science per se is unable to answer. Modern science of the brain, e.g. Roger Penrose's Shadows of the Mind (1994), is only beginning to explore the relationship between the

The Role Of Practical Work In Primary Education Science

2666 words - 11 pages The aim of this essay is to discuss the role of practical work in the science curriculum. This essay will analyse how practical work can play an integral role in enhancing children's learning in science, whilst also looking at how it can become used ineffectively without purpose. This essay will look at the issues surrounding practical work and its role in the classroom; something which I will explore in depth with the aid of vital research