The Role Of Credit Rating Agencies In The Subprime Mortgage Crisis

1338 words - 5 pages

1. Introduction
Midway through 2007 financial markets began to collapse on news of heavy write-downs by major financial institutions. The housing market in the United States (US), which had been experiencing consistent growth since 1975, began to contract in the third quarter of that year while the delinquency rate had been rising since 2006 (Mortgage Bankers Association, 2008). Investors were uncertain how severe the losses would be but it was becoming more likely by the end of the year that a financial crisis was imminent: the amount of subprime and collateralized debt obligation (CDO) losses had surpassed US$120 billion and were expected to increase in 2008 (Gaffen, 2008). As economic conditions turned from bad to worse investors, academics and practitioners began to wonder how such a crisis could have been precipitated in the first place. Blame was placed on mortgage originators, the Federal Reserve and on the investment banks, to name a few. The credit rating agencies (CRAs), seldom in the spotlight, were also heavily criticized for their role in causing the crisis. CRAs certainly do play an important part in financial markets and Thomas Friedman, the Pulitzer Prize winning New York Times columnist, once remarked that there are two superpowers in the world: the US and Moody’s (Lowenstein, 2008). But did the CRAs really deserve blame or were they being held as scapegoats? In the past the agencies generally avoided significant criticism for their rating of corporate debt and government issues, but their role in the burgeoning structured finance market in the early 2000s was characterized by conflict of interest issues, poor risk modeling and ineffective government regulation. As a result low quality ratings proliferated the market for mortgage-backed securities (MBSs) and CDOs on the false pretence of low credit risks. Therefore the agencies should be held partly responsible for one of the most profound market crashes of the century. Several remedial measures have been taken by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in the US which will likely have little impact, but academics and practitioners have recommended some very thoughtful solutions. The most insightful proposal comes from John Hunt of the Berkley Center for Law. He suggests that the agencies should disclose their belief
that ratings for structured finance products may not be accurate or disgorge profits if they turn out to be wrong. This solution addresses the core issue with the CRAs’ role in the subprime crisis: their inability to accurately assess the risks of structured financial products.
2. Background
2.1 Overview of Credit Rating Agencies
CRAs offer ratings which indicate the likelihood that financial obligations will be repaid. Almost all agencies issue ratings on an ordinal rather than a cardinal basis, meaning ratings are relative, not absolute. The CRAs emphasize that the ratings are simply opinions and should not be misconstrued as investment advice. They rate...

Find Another Essay On The Role of Credit Rating Agencies in the Subprime Mortgage Crisis

Critically evaluate the role of the major news agencies in the production and flow of international news.

1699 words - 7 pages 9. Critically evaluate the role of the major news agencies in the production and flow of international news.As the news media has rapidly developed into a modern, high-tech mass communication industry, it is playing an increasingly important role in different aspects: political, economy, social life, the development and peace between nations. Culture and beliefs flow across territorial boundaries, people in different countries can share ideas

The Housing Crisis: A Result of Sub-Prime Adjustable Rate Mortgage Loans

1159 words - 5 pages While tax cuts, refinancing and subsidized federal loans can temporarily solve a housing crisis, it can never take out the roots of the weed out of the ground. What was it that threw us into a foreclosure meltdown in the first place? Did people suddenly lose all their money? Perhaps the government failed in some way? No. The fact of the matter is that people began to borrow money through a sub-prime, adjustable rate mortgage loan and then

The Value of Enviornmental agencies

1009 words - 4 pages most unique and diverse lands in the world. Chris Park Senior lecturer in the Department of Geographer at Lancaster University states, "The available statistics are impressive and... the rainforest's claim to fame as the richest ecological zone on earth"(26). In order to efficiently restore and protect the damaged land, animals, and people environmental agencies' must be valued.By destroying the forest, we are creating an open-door policy for

Discussing the Credit Card Debt Crisis

3403 words - 14 pages -limit fees, In 2007, lenders collected over $18 billion in penalties and fees” (7). She adds that “Discount rates for banks are at an all-time low, yet few have passed these rates on to the consumer” (14) in this blast to the banks she also brings in the mortgage crisis and its parallel similarities to the credit card debt crisis. She accuses the banks of "gouging," saying, "the list of questionable actions credit card companies are engaged in is

Credit Cards and the Foreclosure Crisis

1535 words - 6 pages economies suffering. According to the US census, there are about 21,500,000 teens. So the million I have just mentioned is only about 5% of the teenagers in America. So, while the home loans devastated the banking industry, the credit industry was also becoming under fire. In the end, it all came back to the Stock Market, which lead to the recent collapse. When the debt hit the stock market and the companies, investors saw what was happening and pulled

Credit Crisis in Greece

1826 words - 7 pages has interconnectedness with the global financial system. Therefore the economy of Greece is one of the influential economies to the world’s economy. Greece has attracted a large number of investors in the banking industry (Hubpages 2011). At the moment Greece is faced with a credit crisis. There are several reasons that are believed to be the cause for the economic crisis in Greece (Hubpages 2011). Greece is facing the biggest credit crisis in

Debt Ceiling and SP Downgrade of US Credit Rating

2250 words - 9 pages social-security payments would have been lower. Thus the need to spend billions on stimulus measures would have been irrelevant. A slow growing economy makes our economy unsustainable. Another factor that contributed to the recent debt crisis is the housing bubble. A rapid increase in property value to unsustainable levels, followed by a decline in value created a devastating crisis for subprime, mortgage, credit, and collateralized debt obligation

Use of Credit in the U.S.

560 words - 2 pages house. Or maybe credit may supply the capitol for a small business start up. The problem many people have at this point is that they now owe the money lent to them and do not realize the amount of debt they are in. You are required to make a monthly payment and to pay interest on the amount loaned. The amount of interest you pay is also determined by the amount of your loan, your credit history and the economy. The interest in most cases can

The IMF’s Role in Financial Crisis

2606 words - 10 pages The IMF’s role in financial crisis Introduction In this age of change, the international financial is progressing promptly on various fronts, such as the International Monetary Fund (IMF) play a pivotal role in international financial system. Yet at the same time, many criticisms point out that IMF are not efficient enough to react to settle the problems that have accompanied with this trend. This issue has drawn widespread attention in recent

Parallels Between The Causes Of The 1929 Wall Street Crash And The Current Credit Crisis

1283 words - 5 pages dramatically and interest rates were set higher, resulting in even more people being unable to refinance. Foreclosures accelerated in 2006 /07 hitting the mortgage lenders with high credit risk first. The increase in securitization over the last decade meant that major banks and other financial institutions began to make major losses (of approx $435 billion by July 2008). Stock markets adjusted to fit the reality of low to negative growth. The

Subprime Loans: The under-the-radar loans

1832 words - 7 pages stability. The constant effort to propose fixes in one area, to problems in another, will only make matters worse in both sectors. The root problem inside the subprime crisis remains; that the collateral cannot support the loans and the borrower is basically improperly qualified. The quicker one realizes the losses, the quicker the mortgage markets will regain their feet. The sooner the government gets out of the loan stimulation business, the less

Similar Essays

Identify The Risks Of Holding Debt Securities. Analyze The Role(S) Of Debt Securities That Led To The Current Credit Crisis.

1427 words - 6 pages from its complicated structure and packing. Investors would not be able to recognise the risk until something went wrong, such as the subprime borrowers started defaulting on their mortgages. When the defaults and foreclosures on sub-prime mortgage reached record levels, investors suffer lost. Usually each bond has its own credit rating, is used as indicators by investors. Credit rating is an independent verification of the credit worthiness of

Bank Of America And The Mortgage Crisis

1002 words - 4 pages derivatives such as collateralized debt obligation get the AAA grade while only 7% are given BBB or other lower grades (Zhu, 2013). This illustrates that credit rating companies are not independent, objective, prudent and accurate in performance of their duties (Zhu, 2013). Misled by the overly optimistic rating results, many investment institutions such as funds and commercial banks invest heavily in sub-prime mortgage bonds and its derivatives

Spillover Of The Us Subprime Loan Crisis To Australia In Relation To The Banking Industry

4012 words - 16 pages ( sub prime mortgage market has obviously been hard hit by the crisis. Banks have been forced to reduce risky loans and reduce applications for credit cards, insist on bigger deposits for house purchases and look more closely at applications for personal loans. For individuals, it is getting more difficult to get sub prime mortgages, as the availability of credit is strictly limited now by banks and lenders. This, in turn

The Role Of Federal Agencies In Fighting Digital Crime

781 words - 3 pages process to gain an upper hand in fighting digital crime. In addition, state and local law enforcement expressed concerns about resource constraints and apprehension regarding expertise and jurisdictional authority. State and local agencies are having difficulty in establishing their own role in solving computer crimes. Higher-profile cases of computer crimes are rarely handled at the local level, because federal expertise and resources are required