This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Role Of Desire And Value In Glaucon’s Comparison Of A Just And Unjust Life.

1932 words - 8 pages

Book two of Plato’s Republic begins with Glaucon's argument for favouring an unjust life over a just life. Glaucon compares a perfectly just life to a perfectly unjust life to show that the perfectly unjust life is the happier life. I will define Glaucon’s views on the nature of justice and human motivation, and then summarize his metaphorical story of Gyges’ ring, to show how he combines these premises to come to the conclusion that the unjust life is happier.

I will assert that in order to complete the argument that an unjust life is happier, Glaucon must make the implicit assumption that if and only if we desire something, will that thing be valuable. With respect to my implicit assumption, I will argue that the most questionable step in Glaucon's argument is imposing that a perfectly unjust life is more valuable than a perfectly just life, because it is full of desires. Finally, I will consider a possible objection from Glaucon, and then provide a response to solidify the argument that one can value something without necessarily desiring it.

Glaucon begins his argument, for favouring an unjust life over a just life, by describing the nature of justice. He believes that being unjust is intuitively more favourable than being just (358e – 359). However, one that has both suffered from injustice and benefited from treating others unjustly concludes that suffering from injustice is far worse than the goodness gained from treating others unjustly (359a). Thus, it is better to act justly to prevent being treated unjustly, than to act unjustly and leave one’s self open to being treated unjustly. Glaucon proposes that those who cannot act unjustly establish agreements with each other (359b). Both parties agree to refrain from acting unjustly to one another so that they do not have to suffer from injustice themselves. (359b). Thus, from this agreement, laws and regulations arise and to abide by these laws and not harm others is to be just (359a-b). Therefore, Glaucon concludes that those who cannot do injustice to others create justice as an agreement to avoid being treated unjustly (359b).

Nevertheless, Glaucon says that treating and being treated justly is the intermediate between the best option and the worst option. Where acting unjustly and being treated justly is the best option, or perfect injustice, and acting justly and being treated unjustly is the worst option, or perfect justice (359c). Perfect injustice is the best option, as it allows one to achieve goodness by taking advantage of others, without suffering from being taken advantage of, thus fulfilling one’s desires to the fullest (358d, 359d). Therefore, motivation to act unjustly is to fulfil one’s desires, such as the desire for power, money, sex, respect, and so on (360c). Thus, to achieve one’s desires to the fullest, one must be perfectly unjust.

Glaucon uses the allegorical tale of Gyges’ ring to show a case where acting perfectly unjust benefits one more than the...

Find Another Essay On The Role of Desire and Value in Glaucon’s Comparison of a Just and Unjust Life.

The Unjust World of Segregation in American Apartheid by Douglas S. Massey and Nancy A. Denton

1202 words - 5 pages themselves. In addition, they would only harm themselves if some political disaster were to occur. Relatively few would desire to become partners with the blacks in a political coalition under these circumstances, unless it was another group of minorities. This restricts the potential of black political influence and forces them to adhere to unwritten rules. In essence, blacks do not involve themselves in politics to preserve their own well-being. The

A Comparison of the Role of Women in Homer’s Odyssey and Iliad

3409 words - 14 pages . Another role of goddesses is as forces and natural phenomena which bear their names. Aphrodite can just stand for "sexual desire" in the Iliad, the force which brought Helen and Paris together and caused the war. Muses stand for "inspiration" and the poet invokes them when he begins telling his stories. Artemis and her "gentle darts" can stand for a death of natural causes. The Dawn is personified as a goddess in both the Iliad and

A comparison and contrast of the role of Merlin in Arthurian Mythology

960 words - 4 pages , including his birth and role in the Begetting of Arthur and other famous stories, and also explain how and why his role changes in different retellings of the stories.Merlin is the beginning of much of the known Arthurian stories. The origins of his story are found deep in Celtic and Welsh traditions. He is a paradox; A wild man of the woods yet a bringer of culture, "associated with the devil yet in the service of God." (Judith L. Kellogg, The

The Value of a Life

1097 words - 4 pages to a park with kids playing, seeing baby clothing in a department store, or when a friend or loved one recently has a child, can trigger this thought. “Some women suppress the feelings for a time, and initially report that they feel "relieved" — but sooner or later the consequences come out in a host of areas of her life” (Kaufman, 2006). She will always think about the future that could have happened with her baby, which will remind her that

One Day In the Life of Ivan Denisovich: A Comparison of the Film and Novel

2990 words - 12 pages cover of the book may not mean anything good or bad but those bright alert hawk-like eyes in an old wriggled up face tells a lot of stories about the social circumstances than the image of the prison camp in the film, which was brought forward in the beginning and then fades away in the end. All in all, the title is also significant in the sense that although it happened in only one day of the prisoner's life, the general Russian peoples

A Comparison of Attitudes Towards Life in "The Catcher in the Rye"and "Dead Poet's Society"

1491 words - 6 pages In this world, there are many attitudes towards life that one can possess. This attitude can range from nihilism to ignorant idealism depending on the human being. The works entitled "Dead Poets' Society" and "The Catcher in the Rye" hold a variety of stances on life. However, the novel, "The Catcher in the Rye" mainly paints the mind-set of idealism because it is about an adolescent named Holden Caulfield who is highly idealistic. The novel

Preschool and the Role and Value of Play

1084 words - 5 pages In today’s preschool culture, the role and value of play is very important for children; a rich environment filled with playmates, opportunities to learn how to share, take turns, self-regulate, and make life-long friends only scratches the surface of why play is central for children’s development. Parents aren’t seeing what is happening: what they see as random play is actually being utilized to help the child grow socially, emotionally, and

A Comparison of Butler's Life and Kindred

1915 words - 8 pages A Comparison of Butler's Life and Kindred   What lies in the mind of an author as he or she begins the long task of writing a fiction novel? This question can be answered if the author's life is studied and then compared to the work itself. Octavia E. Butler's life and her novel Kindred have remarkable comparisons. This essay will point out important events of Butler's life and how they link to the mentioned novel. Octavia Estelle

A Comparison Contrast of 1984 and A Brave New World, no comments, just an "awkward" comment in the transition between the 4th and 5th paragraph

2277 words - 9 pages nostalgic. In the end Winston and Julia could not control their own lives, just like society where no one has a control. Bernard didn't have a nostalgic apartment, what he had was a way of life contrary to others. No one in his world wanted to worry about anything. They would drown their worries in the pleasure drug Soma. What Bernard would do is think about his problems, tell them to his friend, and find other ways to deal with them. Bernard

Shakespeare: A Comparison Of The Role Of Women In His Plays, And In Society At The Time

2041 words - 9 pages but, will rather reveal the attitudes toward these women, anxieties about them, and conflicts in their roles as shown in the plays.Marriage is perhaps the one institution that most significantly shapes women's lives. Their role in the plays, as in the period, is defined by their place in the structure of a family, maid/wife/widow. When we look at Renaissance discourses, these three roles reveal conflict and anxiety about women's status, their

The Concept of the Happy Life; A Comparison in Epicurean and Stoic Philosophies

1170 words - 5 pages very similar to the condition of apathy the Stoics believed was ideal (Matson, 195). Though they existed concurrently, the similarities between the two philosophies ended there; the philosophical arguments presented by Stoicism and Epicureanism differ greatly in terms of religious beliefs, fatalistic existence, and how one might be able to live the happy life.While here is little mention of the religious aspect of a happy life in the Stoic and the

Similar Essays

Just And Unjust Laws: Should The Unjust Laws Be Obeyed?

742 words - 3 pages unjust laws undermines the interests of the pubic, we should also recognize the value of laws, deeply respect it and behave strictly as the just laws. Otherwise, a society without the limitation of laws would undoubted come into disorder and chaos. In conclusion, it is indeed every one’s responsibility to respect and obey just laws. But whether to disobey unjust laws calls for a prudent consideration about whether it is for any higher purpose.

Just And Unjust Speech In Aristophanes' "Clouds"

578 words - 2 pages considered to be newfangled and cynical towards the old. While the defeat of Just speech by Unjust speech does not render Pheidippides the ability to overcome Strepsiades, it is a parallel that may be compared with many other instances in Mythology and real life. The dialogue between the Just and Unjust speech was handled very skillfully on the part of the Unjust speech. Although the points that the Just speech made were what many would consider to

Analysis Of Just And Unjust Wars: A Moral Argument With Historical Illustrations

1178 words - 5 pages Analysis of Just and Unjust Wars: A Moral Argument with Historical Illustrations Michael Walzer first wrote Just and Unjust Wars: A Moral Argument with Historical Illustrations in the years following the Vietnam War, and unfortunately its premise on morality in war will always remain as relevant as it was then as it is now, with conflict between states forever existing. Michael Walzer is one of the most prominent social

Illusion And Reality In "A Streetcar Named Desire" (Williams) Is Illusion Necessary To Life? Discusses The Role Of Illusion In The Play

1351 words - 5 pages I believe that illusion is not necessary to everyone's life but rather it helps them to avoid the harsh realities that they may have to deal with in their lives. I also believe that a major theme of this play was how our lives can often experience a fierce battle between these illusions. In the case of 'A Streetcar Named Desire' there are many examples where the characters are simply hiding in or behind illusions and where the characters may try