This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Roles And Significance Of The Anthologies: Man’yoshu Vs. Kokinshu

938 words - 4 pages

The poetic anthology Man’yōshū, compiled in ca. 759, is well known as an outstanding masterpiece of the Nara period, following the two chronicles: Kojiki (712) and Nihon Shoki, or Nihongi, (720). As its title describes, Man’yōshū (collection of ten thousand leaves) is an anthology of as many as almost 4,500 poems by writers from various backgrounds and different periods, in which I see this anthology significant. The composers include such prominent poets as Kakinomoto Hiromaro, Ōtomo Yakamochi, and Yamanoue Okura, as well as the noble, soldiers, and peasants, suggesting that the volumes teach us different aspects of those eras, or perspectives not only of the educated or rich but those of commoners. Perhaps, that no specific writing styles, both choka and tanka, were yet to be regulated enabled the huge collection in a variety of composers.
Another point regarding the contents of Man’yōshū that somehow struck me is that men didn’t hesitate to express their emotional parts and weakness, as seen in the pieces by Kakimonoto Hitomaro and Ōtomo Yakamochi:
“…I thought myself a strong man. But the sleeves of my garment are wetted through with tears” (Kakinomoto Hitomaro)
“…then I think of my far-off home – sorely do I grieve that with my sobs” (Ōtomo Yakamochi)
Consequently I assume that there might have been some connections between the era as being pre-Confucian and gender roles in the society; that is, perhaps, the concept that “Boys don’t cry” was yet to come in later time of the Japanese history. Speaking of Kakinomoto Hitomaro, he is known for his good use of such poetic devices as makurakotoba, joshi, and on’in; especially his use of makurakotoba was extensive, using over 140 makurakotoba, half of which is alleged to be his creation (Wikipedia). Following are examples of his makurakotoba in the piece from Anthology of Japanese Literature starting with “In the sea of Iwami” (p. 34):
Tsunosaha’u  Iwami / Isa’eku Kara no saki / Ha’u tsuta  wakare / Kimomuka’u  kokoro / Oohune no  Watari no yama / Tsuma kakuru  Ogami no yama / Shikita’e  koromo
Along with the non-prescribed forms and classless collections of poems, the writing system employed in the anthology is a distinctive feature of Man’yōshū: Man’yō-gana which is composed of combinations with Chinese characters representing Japanese phonemes, such as 知々 (ちち, father) and 波々 (はは, mother). In Nara period, Japan actively conducted diplomacy with China again, after the 40-year halt. Still the culture of the period remained uniquely Japanese:
The Chinese writing system was adopted, but the Japanese language remained intact. Furthermore, by using Chinese characters in a free and imaginative manner, the Japanese added greatly to the richness and subtlety of their language. (Hatano, 2004)
This fact reminds me of how Japanese people, especially within younger generations, creatively play around the writing systems on text messages in a similar way to Man’yō-gana:...

Find Another Essay On The Roles and Significance of the Anthologies: Man’yoshu vs. Kokinshu

Man’yoshu vs. Kokinshu Essay

1117 words - 4 pages , also developed based on the poems in the Kokinshū and became a part of Japanese tradition. The content of both these anthologies helped jump start their creation of art, in the form of poetry, because the topics that were highlighted and considered of great value became an important part of Japanese society during that time and even carries on to today. The themes of nature and love commonly seen in both the Manyōshū and Kokinshū reinforce

Man’yoshu and Kokinshu Essay

1482 words - 6 pages Man’yōshū is also known as the collection of ten thousand leaves but in a more literary and poetic sense could be portrayed as ten thousand generations. It is also seen as the earliest official oldest and greatest anthologies of Japanese poetry. Regardless of its name (could be seen as ten thousand poems) it actually only is composed of about 4,500 waka or 20 poem books. One distinction that could be made despite its popularity is it has no

Man’yoshu and Kokinshu: National Identity

1320 words - 5 pages In Japan, two poetic anthologies, the Man’yōshū and the Kokinshū, are highly revered as literary embodiments of the Japanese spirit. Though both are similar in their purposes as literature, the intent behind compiling each anthology as well as the legacy each has left behind differ greatly. With its inclusion of poets from all classes and embodiment of makoto or sincerity, the Man’yōshū helped the Japanese form a national identity through its

Diference in Writing Man’yoshu and Kokinshu

1085 words - 4 pages This paper will discuss and compare the anthologies of Manʻyōshū and Kokinshū, which were the earliest poetry collections of the classical period in Japan. Manʻyōshū was the earliest anthology of poems and included both long and short forms. It was compiled in the 7th century. Kokinshū was a collection of short poems known as tanka, consisting of 31 syllables. It was compiled in the 8th-10th century. The Kokinshū became the poetry standard

Comparing the Manyoshu and Kokinshu

534 words - 2 pages Looking at the anthologies, one can observe that despite the fact that they were compiled within two centuries of each other, differences and similarities exist between the two, creating the distinction between the Manyoshu and Kokinshu. From the earlier to the later anthology, the progression of poetic form takes place in Japanese literature from the influence of China and the conversion of native thinking. Thus, these changes in literature

Spring in the Kokinshu

1829 words - 7 pages anthology. By having each poem put into the context of another, a sense of organization emerges within each section. Every poem contributes to the meaning of a group of poems. The images used are meant to evoke a specific point in each season from the snow to the blossoms to the falling of the blossoms. Since each poem stands alone and has no true plot they lack the significance than if they were put into the context of other poems. Together the

The Significance of Gender Roles in Julia Alvarez's Novel In the Time of the Butterflies

849 words - 3 pages restricted or thought lower than men because of gender roles. They could be adored and treasured as much as they want, but that does not change the fact that they are still limited to only so many options. Women are just as brilliant and capable as men are, however they are not given the opportunity to flaunt these feats. It is because women are also a part of this world, they should be recognized what who they truly are not what they are just expected to be. Humankind must be aware that females can do just about anything a man can do, and they can do more than just spend hours in the kitchen. Works Cited Julia Alvarez's In the Time of the Butterflies

The significance of Library and Archives Canada

1001 words - 5 pages Thesis The significance Library and Archives Canada is the preservation of Canadian history. Introduction Without the protection of Library and Archives Canada, Vital documentation of Canadian History Act could be lost. The significance of the Library and Archives of Canada is that it holds every important document this country was built on and more including the Census of Canadian citizens all the way back to 1871 in addition to a military

The Power and Significance of Congress

1838 words - 7 pages The Power and Significance of Congress Firstly it is important to look at the power and significance of congress as a legislative body. This includes the creation of law, and the scrutiny of the executive. Because the US federal system is ruled by 'separation of powers', it is important that the legislative - congress - acts as a good check and restraint on the executive - the president. The most significant power

The Significance of Family and Kinship

669 words - 3 pages The Significance of Family and Kinship One of the most important and essential things that everyone must have in order to live a great and joyful life is family. One must follow values to be successful in life, and one must also support their family to keep that success advancing toward the future. In David W. McCurdy’s article, “Family and Kinship in Village India,” it discusses the significance of how a successful family is formed by

The Meaning and Significance of Baptism

2741 words - 11 pages The Meaning and Significance of Baptism Baptism is a very important part of the Christian faith, in the Roman Catholic Church it is the initial sacrament of initiation, the other two being Holy Communion and Confirmation. It is the start of the religious journey through Christianity. By being baptised it is showing a commitment to the Christian faith it is both a public as well as personal commitment and declaration to

Similar Essays

Man’yoshu Vs. Kokinshu And Their Significance

1260 words - 5 pages differed in authors, poetic style, and writing style, both anthologies proved to be very significant in distinguishing the developing society of Japan from the powerful and influential nation of China. Unlike the Kokinshū, the Man’yōshū contained the works of poets from a wide spectrum of social backgrounds¬–peasants, low and middle class citizens, stately court men, and even individuals from the royal family–even though the very aristocratic poet

Manyoshu Vs. Kokinshu: Roles And Significance

1253 words - 5 pages commoners, but the use of dialect and familiar imagery contrasts with the strict poetic diction imposed during the 10th century. The diversity of themes and poetic forms also distinguishes the Manyoshu from the more polished but narrower verse of later times such as its successor the Kokinshu (The significance of the Man'yoshu). This gave the anthology, as a whole, a more general feel when it came to being a Japanese piece of literature as is had not

Man’yoshu And Kokinshu Hallmark Of The Japanese Poetic Form

1133 words - 5 pages the Kokinshū (Wixted 3). When considering the roles and significance of both anthologies in the context of their respective times, it is clear that both works are useful examples of the world in which they were compiled. Furthermore, both anthologies were obviously products of their own time: the Man'yōshū contains some complicated poems and and some simple verses (even drinking songs), while the Kokinshū contains poems with the most subtle

Man’yoshu Vs. Kokinshu Essay

1571 words - 6 pages Man’yoshu and Kokinshuu are some of the earliest anthologies of Japanese poetry to be considered literary canons. The Man’yoshu dates back to the 8th century and contains 4,516 poems. Man’yoshu, which is translated as “Collection of Ten Thousands Leafs”, was compiled from a wide range of Japan society, where many of the authors remained anonymous. The Kokinshuu appears later in Japan’s history and is an anthology from 905 AD that contains a