The Romanticization Of War Essay

1589 words - 6 pages

“War is Hell.” The often quoted phrase by General William Tecumseh Sherman is an appropriate objection to romanticized ideals of war. General Sherman understood that in order to be victorious, he must make war as horrible as possible for the enemy so that he may not wish to continue fighting. All too often the popular media produces works of fiction such as movies, books, and television shows that idealize war (Gabriel, 46). The Red Baron is a World War I film drama that tries to tackle this issue. The Red baron realistically portrays the misguided notions that war is somehow noble, but as the story progresses the reality and horror of war reveals itself
The works of Richard Gabriel and George Mosse contribute to the argument. Gabriel argues from a psychological standpoint. He proposes that throughout history, war has always been so horrible. In fact the ability of man to endure the psychological impact of this horror is so low that most soldiers that survive are in some way mentally damaged by the experience. Mosse argues that the idealization or romanticization of war can be traced back to how war is portrayed by writers and how it influences idealist. These idealists later become the leaders of the military and agitate for war. Both authors talk about how the media inaccurately portrays a romantic image of war.
Gabriel’s main argument is that war has always been horrible. It is so horrible that people are deathly afraid of it. He states, “fear and madness have been mans companions in war since the beginning of recorded history.” Humans have such a low mental capacity for dealing with the horrors of war that in ancient times, wars were often times decided in a single battle. He states, “accounts of past battles seem so often to offer examples of individual heroism and courage and all too seldom reports acts of cowardice and fear”. Gabriel cites an example from the Ancient world, more specifically Sparta. The Spartans, thanks in large part to the recent film, and renowned for their military prowess and courage in the face of battle. They apparently faced one million Persians with a force of just 300 warriors. In the film 300, we see an extended exposition of how Spartans are raised from childhood to be warriors skilled in the art of soldiery. They learn hand to hand combat, forging off the land, and finally how to fight with sword and shield. They are in a sense the perfect soldier. However, the reality is that there was more dissention in the ranks than portrayed in the movie. “That men broke and ran was a fact of military life and it still is”. There are accounts of soldiers wounding themselves and complaining of injuries or illnesses that just happen to come up right before the battle.
Gabriel continues his argument with an analysis of the phrase, “That is a million dollar wound.” This is a famous phrase that originated during World War I which basically meant that you received a wound that is not life threatening but is serious enough...

Find Another Essay On The Romanticization of War

The Sorrow of War Essay

1331 words - 5 pages It can be hard to fully comprehend the effects the Vietnam War had on not just the veterans, but the nation as a whole. The violent battles and acts of war became all too common during the long years of the conflict. The war warped the soldiers and civilians characters and desensitized their mentalities to the cruelty seen on the battlefield. Bao Ninh and Tim O’Brien, both veterans of the war, narrate their experiences of the war and use the

The War of 1812 Essay

572 words - 2 pages The War of 1812 “In view of the wants and needs of an infant United States (1783-1812), the War of 1812 was extremely successful in its results.” The War of 1812 is significant to United States history in a number of ways. The War, and our not losing it, reaffirmed American Independence. Second, the war showed the Americans that a stronger military was needed. It strengthened our isolation by giving us courage. The war also served to

The Horror of War

1147 words - 5 pages “Let him turn away from evil and do good; let him seek peace and pursue it” (1 Peter 3:11). In the historical fiction novel All Quiet on the Western Front, Erich Maria Remarque relates the life of a soldier struggling to do “seek peace” in the midst of a brutal, gruesome war. Remarque’s personal experience as a soldier in World War I validates the anti-war polemic he presents through the novel. The story juxtaposes the civilian’s misconstrued

The War of 1812

1295 words - 5 pages The War Of 1812 The War of 1812 took place while president James Madison was in office. Madison was born in Orange County, Virginia in 1751. He attended the College of New Jersey, which is now well known as Princeton. Madison did many significant things both before and after he was in office. He participated in the framing of the Virginia Constitution, served in the Continental Congress and he was also a leader in the Virginia Assembly. One of

The War of 1812

1676 words - 7 pages The War of 1812 On June 18, 1812, the United States declared war on Great Britain. The peace treaty to end the war was signed in Europe, 1814. The war lasted from 1812 to the spring of 1815 because there was a delay in communications. It was fought along the Canadian border, along with several sea battles. By the time the war was over the United States lost 2,260 soldiers, and the British 1,600 soldiers. The war of 1812 was a very significant

The War Of 181

704 words - 3 pages The War of 1812 For many students of American history, the War of 1812 is a subject of great controversy.The war of 1812 was war between the United States of America and Great Britain allied by the Indians. Most citizens of the United States did not wish it, and the British government, at war with Napoleon, certainly did not want it. In an article “The War of 1812“ by Thomas Carson it stated that “The war of 1812 had just as much to do with

The Effects of War

1289 words - 5 pages Death by the millions. War; caused by the petty disagreements of those in power; fought by the brave young men that had no other choice. No one truly wins a war; it does not decipher who is right, only whom is left. The horrors of war are devastating; both mentally and physically. The horror is not only ever present during life on the Frontline, it lives on in the survivors guilt. I believe the horror of war is not only represented in the

The War of 1812

1145 words - 5 pages The War of 1812, sometimes referred to as “The Second War of Independence,” was one of the bloodiest, yet most pointless wars in American history. After 32 months of Americans fighting for a change in the relationship between Britain and the U.S., the war ended with a treaty that left many of the original conflicts unresolved. Although the war had no obvious victor, it boosted American nationalism and patriotism, something much needed after

The War Of 1812

2056 words - 9 pages 1812, twenty-nine years after the signing of the Treaty of Paris of 1783, which ended the Revolutionary War between America and Britain, was the year that marked the beginning of a new conflict that would last America the next three years, the War of 1812. On June 16th of that year, President James Madison declared the start of a war that would greatly impact the future of our country. Britain, still one of the world's greatest superpowers

The Immorality of War

1169 words - 5 pages many different reasons: Landconflicts, Religious disagreements, and independence conflicts. Thisis a story about my grandfather's experience in World War II. It washorrifying and gruesome, but the story is not as bad as it was in reallife.In 1991, my grandfather, Mike Sabetai, was taken from his homeby the Nazis, with 17 members of his family. He was taken to a warcamp where he and other divide into groups. There were groups ofpeople who could use

The War of Rebellion

1558 words - 7 pages The Civil War was a very significant war that resulted in making the nation and the government stronger. Peculiarly both sides had very different views on what caused the war, what they wanted out of the war, and what the war meant resulting in what is considered the bloodiest war in America’s history, around six hundred thousand Confederate and Union soldiers died in battle. What did they all die for though? Depending on whether you were from

Similar Essays

The Immorality Of War Essay

1263 words - 5 pages The Immorality of War Wars are immoral. The distinction between the rights and wrongs of war is a significant concern to many people. It is difficult to determine whether a war is right or wrong. Many wars shared the idea that both sides believed they were right. It appears that President Truman was right to drop the atom bomb onto Hiroshima to end World War II. Truman claimed that the purpose of bombing was "to shorten the agony of war, in

The Horrors Of War Essay

965 words - 4 pages Unending exchange of bullets coming from rifles of the soldiers, a mother lamenting for the death of her young boy who goes to war, and great toll of loss life both of the soldiers and civilians- all these are not enough to describe the horrors brought by the war, but, these are enough to illustrate the price, expensive price, paid in war. The First World War that broke out in Europe on August, 1914 definitely created a lasting effect in the

The Purpose Of War Essay

1434 words - 6 pages Renowned author Napoleon Hill once said, “War grows out of the desire of the individual to gain advantage at the expense of his fellow man.” Ever since the creation of man there has always been conflict and over time that conflict resulted in anger and hostility. War is simply put is basically just a major clash among multiple countries or groups within countries. War can be caused or motivated by the desire for resources, land, and power. It

The War Of 1812 Essay

1092 words - 4 pages The War of 1812 was fought between the United States and England. Ending in 1815 with the Treaty of Ghent, the war did not accomplish any of the issues it was being fought over. For the US, the War of 1812 seemed to just be one failure after another. Although the military suffered great failure during the war, these were the direct consequence of the failure of the citizens to unite for the causes of the war. Because of these failures, it is