This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Russian Revolution At The Kronstadt Navel Base

3517 words - 14 pages

The Russian Revolution at the Kronstadt Navel Base

Most popular uprisings in recent history have been characterized by a brief period of incredible potential and hope, only to collapse in failure and despair. Even the supposedly 'successful' Russian Revolution of 1917 followed this pattern. Revolutionaries threw off centuries of imperial rule and oppression in order to create a new world of freedom, peace and equality... only to end up with Stalin, purges, gulags, dekulakization - and ultimately decades of Bolshevik1 rule and oppression. Although it can sometimes be disheartening to review this long history of failure and oppression, valuable insights can be gained by investigating these past revolutions. The achievements and promise of the revolutionaries can be studied and their strengths marked. The weaknesses that led to their eventual defeat and decay must also be understood, so that the same mistakes are not made again. This article will address these themes in the context of the Russian Revolution at the Kronstadt navel base.2

Kronstadt deserves special attention for several reasons. The workers, soldiers and sailors at Kronstadt used the Revolution to build "a bustling, self-governing, egalitarian and highly politicized Soviet democracy, the like of which had not been seen in Europe since the days of the Paris Commune."3 This was the great promise of Kronstadt, which Trotsky praised as "the pride and glory of the Russian Revolution."4 Nowhere in Russia, however, was the failure of the revolution so dramatically illustrated as at Kronstadt. After the Bolsheviks consolidated their control of the base in mid-1918, Kronstadt made one last "desperate attempt to restore and reactivate its radical Soviet democracy."5 This was the notorious 'uprising' of March 1921, in which Trotsky condemned the Kronstadters as "counterrevolutionary mutineers."6 In the short battle that followed, Kronstadt was crushed by the Red Army, its soviet disbanded, hundreds of its revolutionaries interned in prison camps and thousands more executed.7 The course of the Soviet Union in later years is, as they say, history.

Any complete history of revolutionary Kronstadt can begin no later than 1905, when the Kronstadters joined in the wave of local uprisings sweeping Russia. Angered by decades of "bad food, maltreatment by officers... and humiliating prohibitions"8 the sailors and soldiers rose up and demanded: vodka. Leaderless and with no conscious goals, the revolt quickly disintegrated into nothing more than "arson, pillage and drunken orgy,"9 which ended after a few days. All this made quite an impression on "the few Social Revolutionary [SR] and Bolshevik activists there, who... saw to their horror how a spontaneous and leaderless mutiny could degenerate into an 'imbecile, wild and drunken pogrom'."10 Although they were impressed by the power of Kronstadt's masses, they were dismayed by the destructive and ultimately futile uses to which that power was...

Find Another Essay On The Russian Revolution at the Kronstadt Navel Base

The Russian Revolution Essay

734 words - 3 pages Jordan 1 Daniel Jordan Ms.Martel English IV 10 April 2014 The Russian Revolution Czarist Russia was a terrible place to live in, controlled by a power hungry csar named Nicholas II. Nicholas II was a power hungry ruler that didn’t care about his people in his country. He became ruler in 1917, before him the Russian royal family had controlled the throne for over 300 years. He would let emotion come in the way of ruling. On May 18, 1868, in

The Russian Revolution Essay

2885 words - 12 pages The Russian Revolution Here are some of the causes of the Russian Revolution in March 1917: ~Failures in the War ~The mutiny in the Army ~The Tsarina and Rasputin ~Food Shortages ~Strikes PREFACE: In 1904 The Tsar of Russia (Nicholas II) embarked on a war with Japan, hoping for a quick and glorious victory that would unite the country, decrease support for the Tsar's opponents and gain control over Korea and Manchuria

The Russian Revolution

939 words - 4 pages . Anytime Russia tried to expand they were oppressed. Also, the "revolution" of 1905 was a major break to Russian culture. When a group of radicals protested outside the palace and another group of peasants asked for bread and coal, the groups got mixed. One Tsar sent the Cossacks to suppress the crows. On this "Bloody Sunday," the Cossacks cut down the citizens, killing some of both groups. This was very unjust and led to rising emotions.After all

The Russian Revolution - 564 words

564 words - 2 pages become a totalitary dictatorship.In the mid 1800s, Karl Marx, a German philosopher, founded communism, and wrote a book on what it was. Many Russian men read the book and set up little Communist groups throughout Russia. By the late 1800s, a man named Vladimir Lenin adopted the ideas of communism and began to make it popular in Russia.In the early 1900s, Russia was ruled by a dictatorship led by Czar Nicholas II. Governing Russia badly, Czar

The Iranian Revolution and the Russian Revolution

2056 words - 8 pages The Iranian Revolution of 1979 was a religious uprising that involved the collapse of the longstanding Monarchy in Iran. In this essay, I will compare and contrast the background and ideology of the Iranian Revolution with the Russian Revolution of 1917. I will then outline the major differences and similarities between the two. In the 1970’s Iran, under Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi was a very centralized military state that maintained a close

The Russian Revolution of 1917

1213 words - 5 pages . At first it was difficult trying to establish independence in my mother's house, but after a while it seemed as if I had won the battle. Unbeknownst to me that battle would be short-lived and ultimately my mom won the war. Basically, I had constructed my own crazy revolution against my mother. You see a revolution is “a fundamental change in political organization; especially: the overthrow or renunciation of one government or ruler and the

Causes of the Russian Revolution

984 words - 4 pages Causes of the Russian Revolution Consider the following causes of the October 1917 Russian Revolution: Poor Living and Working Conditions Effects of the First World War The Appeal of Lenin and the Bolsheviks The Limitations of the 1917 Provisional Government Was any one of these causes more important than the others to the Bolsheviks’ seizure of power in 1917? Explain your answer. A1

Causes of the Russian Revolution

752 words - 3 pages During the reign of the last Tsar of Russia, Nicholas, the Russian Revolution broke out. It is a revolution which changed the lives of many and left alone a few. Even the ruling class which had ruled over Russia for centuries can't escape from the changes. People are repressed for years and are trying to find a way to escape and the only solution is to rebel. There are big and small events, all reasons which led to the outbreak of the Russian

Catalysts for the Russian Revolution

784 words - 4 pages The emancipation of the peasants in its hope to rectify the flaws within Russian government and society and substitute political instability eventually converted its motive in becoming a catalyst for rebellion. Thus the statement that “The year 1861 begot the year 1905” that led to the Russian revolution is notable in its stance to be misguided, inefficient, altogether disastrous and temporary that opened unrest and revolution. When the terms

The Causes of the Russian Revolution

728 words - 3 pages The Russian Revolution in 1905 was important in Russian History. The Economic problems, the Russo-Japanese war, and problems with the Czar Nicholas II were the major causes of the Russian Revolution.After the Russo-Japanese War ended, economic problems in Russia started to kick in. The Russian armies suffered a number of defeats in the battlefields because they were poorly trained, badly-armed, and ill-equipped. The food supply decreased and the

The Fundamental Causes of the Russian Revolution

1652 words - 7 pages The Fundamental Causes of the Russian Revolution The fundamental causes of the Russian Revolution were the direct consequence of a dreadfully long period of suppression of the Russian people combined with a prolonged instability of the Russian government. For centuries, czarist regimes forced their strict demands upon the populace by exerting their unilateral power, with no moral consideration for human life or freedom. At the same

Similar Essays

The Russian Revolution Essay 1210 Words

1210 words - 5 pages The Russian Revolution of 1917 had multiple events in imperial Russia. The establishment of the Soviet state that became known as the USSR, had a high part of the revolution. The two successful revolutions of 1917 are known as the Russian Revolution. The first revolution overthrew the autocratic imperial monarchy. It all started with the revolt on February 23 to 27, 1917. In October 24 and 25, the second revolution opened with the armed

The Russian Revolution Essay 1210 Words

1210 words - 5 pages The Russian Revolution of 1917 had multiple events in imperial Russia. The establishment of the Soviet state that became known as the USSR, had a high part of the revolution. The two successful revolutions of 1917 are known as the Russian Revolution. The first revolution overthrew the autocratic imperial monarchy. It all started with the revolt on February 23 to 27, 1917. In October 24 and 25, the second revolution opened with the armed

The Russian Revolution Essay 1147 Words

1147 words - 5 pages that would stop and bring down the monarch rule of the Czar and will improve their lives, so was born the Russian revolution. The Russian revolution was divided to two separate revolutions, one revolution was at the end February 1917, and the other was at the beginning of October that same year.The February Revolution At first, the workers tried to gain economical advancement by democratic means, but they were opposed by the Czarist regime, which

The 1905 Russian Revolution Essay

968 words - 4 pages 1905 Russian RevolutionThe causes of the 1905 revolution in Russia can be traced back as far as 1861. The Tsars who ruled in Russia were firm autocrats in an era where the nearby Europe was transforming to liberalism and republicanism. The influence of these groups, as well as internal problems and foreign policy were all causes of the revolution. Although the outcome of the revolution saw the settings up of the Duma, these were controlled to