The Scared Straight Program Essay

1993 words - 8 pages

The Scared Straight Program

The recent media obsession with the scared straight program, juvenile boot camps and other scare tactics has lead to the question as to whether they actually are beneficial or not in treating adolescent criminal recidivism. On television programs like Maury (Pauvich) the answer to treating the troubled young girls who are brought to the show is boot camp. Those in charge take these girls to prisons, dangerous streets at night and often morgues to make a visual argument as to where they will end up as a result of the path they've taken. They also go through a rigorous run with drill sergeants to break down their egos. Of course it only last one day as opposed to any length of time a judge would sentence, but they get a small taste of it. Without surprise, at the end of every program of this nature, all the girls are rehabilitated and promise to go back to school, quit drugs, stealing, prostituting, and stop the abusive behavior.
Adolescent criminal acts, which include but are not limited to murder, rape, armed robbery, violent assault, mugging, arson, vandalism and robbery are a large portion of the crimes represented in the media. Alternative options to throwing these kids in juvenile detention centers is a rehabilitative boot camp where they have no control over even their own bodies or programs similar to scared straight where they see possible consequences to their actions. The importance of the success or failure of these programs is important because right now it is the popular solution. If these programs are going nowhere, time should be invested in creating new ideas and methods to treat these children before they become adults in the prison system.
This paper will address mainly the James Finckenauer study of the Scared Straight program created by the Lifer's Group in the Rahway State Prison in New Jersey. Many of the sources for the information in this paper referred to the same study by James O. Finckenauer. Few studies have been done on this topic, but many of the references discuss problems and positives of the Finckenauer study.
The Lifers' Group originally consisted of inmates in the New Jersey Rahway State Prison who were sentenced to twenty-five years or more. The original president and creator of the Lifer's Group was Richard Rowe (Finckenauer 1982, pg. 67).
The Lifers' Group was created in part to counteract what these inmates saw as a stereotyped, Hollywood-type image of prisons and convicts held by the general public. This image, they felt stigmatized convicts as immoral and inhuman. In order to dispel what they saw as a false image, the Lifers' wanted to try to prove that they could be useful and worthwhile people even though locked up in a maximum-security prison. (Finckenauer 1982, pg. 67).
September of 1976 was the first time the program occurred. According to the Lifers' group own letter to parents of adolescents who took part in the program (copy of form letter on...

Find Another Essay On The Scared Straight Program

Crime after Adolescence Essay

736 words - 3 pages which have all shown promise in some way. In the meantime practices such as Formal System Processing for Juveniles, Juvenile Awareness programs (like Scared Straight), Juvenile Boot Camps have shown no positive effects on juvenile delinquency. The only program that has shown true effects is the Targeted Truancy Interventions program. This program not only helps adolescence obtain a proper education but it also helps keep them off the streets

Future of the Juvenile Justice System

2125 words - 9 pages behavior modification courses and activities will be the main objective for youth. However if these programs also fail a more "tough love" type of program will be enforced. Programs like "Scared Straight" where at risk youth are taken to prisons to see what awaits them if they continue in their ways. On this same vein, juvenile correction centers will be strict and more like adult prison. Instead of making it easy or dorm like, it will be a place

BASIC Programming Language Introduction - This is an explanatory report on what I've learned about BASIC (from a book) and may need improvements.

1599 words - 6 pages Armen MelidonianBASIC Programming02-19-04Period 4Chapter 01-07 ReportTo start off with, in Chapter 01 you will be using such keywords as RUN, PRINT,LPRINT, LIST, LLIST, END, and etc..... In order to instruct the program to do thingsthat you want it to do from your program list which you would like it to do, you must usekeywords and run it then when you have completed your program list that you would likethe computer/PC/etc. to run when you are

the god box

654 words - 3 pages other allies decided to start a gay-straight alliance club (GSA) at school, before the principal could go absolutely numb, they were challenged to find a staff or teacher as sponsor. Most of them were scared to lose their job, or kicked out of town, etc. And when you compare their situation to the kids in “Geography Club”, it’s very similar. The only difference is that the kids in “Geography Club” had an easy start. They didn’t have to go to

The Effective Rehabilitation Of Violent Juveniles

2394 words - 10 pages ). Deterrence programs would include programs such as Scared Straight and juvenile boot camps, which both rely on intimidation as a general rule and specialize in trying to break the perceived rebellious spirit of the juvenile offender. These types of intimidation programs did not even show "statistically significant or consistent mean effects" (Lipsey, et al., 2000, p. 4). One must wonder then, why intimidation programs seem so attractive to

Use of Characterization in Truman Capote's In Cold Blood

971 words - 4 pages ,' having distinguished herself as a straight-A student, the president of her class, a leader in the 4-H program and the Young Methodists League, a skillful rider, an excellent musician..." (Reed 104). Capote's details show that Kenyon Clutter was also well-liked. His "crew-cut hair is hemp colored: he was six feet tall and lanky, though hefty enough to have once rescued a pair of full grown sheep" (38). A year younger than Nancy, he was

The Komodo Dragon

1207 words - 5 pages on his journey hoping to bring back three monitors. When they arrived at Komodo, they went straight to work. They set up traps and snares, baited with dead animals. They had no luck until a small six foot lizard sized up the trap. As the lizard was about to seize the bait a large nine foot, battle scared monitorclaimed the prize. He Komodo grabbed the dead goat with his serrated teeth, tearing and ripping at the goat. The Komodo dislocated its

"Crazy Halloween": Personal Paper, but good ideas for other stories- How to write a paper and be yourself.

642 words - 3 pages neck, blood dripping from his mouth. I was walking very slowly to see if he would make any movement, but wasn't. At that point I wasn't to sure I wanted to go in that haunted house. If the creepy creature in the parking lot scared me, I wondered what would be lurking inside.As we neared the entrance, Charles was sure to point out my fear of haunted houses and costume clad ghouls. "Don't be scared, it's not real" he said pushing me around, laughing

I'm not scared: Discuss the role fear plays in the actions and motivation of the villagers.

561 words - 2 pages Fear has brought its way into a little town called Aqua traverse, motivating them into cold blooded kidnappers. The role of fear appears in many of the villagers in particular Michele, Felice and Pino as they show numerous areas of fear throughout the novel I'm not scared. An innocent young boy Michele takes his fears on head first and motivates himself on with his comic book character Tiger Jack to try and free another innocent boy in


814 words - 4 pages effects, concerns, or unintended consequences were identified" with the program, and finds that D.A.R.E. is scientifically proven to improve four different student outcomes: alcohol, cigarette, and marijuana use; anti-substance use attitudes; normative beliefs about substance use; and substance use resistance. The D.A.R.E. program is using a drug prevention program that has been proven to work for eight years straight. Though D.A.R.E. has only

Evidence Based Practice (EBP) in Juvenile Justice Systems

1164 words - 5 pages Evidence Based Practice emerged in the late 20th century, becoming widespread in the 21st century. According to Research and Practice: The Role of Evidence-Based Program Practices in the Youth Mentoring Field ( 2009) “The concept of Evidence Based Practice (EBP) actually has its roots in the medical field, where the work of Archie Cochrane (1972) and others examined the key role that the substantial body of medical research and literature could

Similar Essays

A Report On The Australian Aboriginal And Torres Straight Islander Sexual Health Program

2357 words - 9 pages . INTRODUCTIONThe Aboriginal and Torres Straight Islander Program was developed through a project undertaken jointly by the Department of Corrective Services (DCS) and Queensland Health. According to Turgeon (199: 2), the department aimed to provide sexual health education which would be equally applicable to Queensland Aboriginal prisoners from all community backgrounds. With the knowledge that this form of education was not readily available on home

Deterrence, Rational And Restorative Justice Theories

1902 words - 8 pages the scared straight, and boot camps programs indicates not only its ineffective but increases the risk of offending. The programs have been misused, the basis of the program attempted to decrease crime among offenders, particularly youth, the failed to encounter the flaws within the program. Also rational choice theory assumes that individuals will calculate their action before balancing the cost and benefits, but offenders don’t really

The Right Choice? Essay

781 words - 3 pages …""They're pretty expensive""I realize. But maybe I can get a lot of money…""I looked at colleges too, BCC has the same program you want."Right then and there I knew where I was going. The place the 11th grade Cooper would never have dreamed (or nightmared) to go. I guess I thought that Broome was going to restrict me from being what I want to be, and pigeon hole me into being an "average kid". In a word, I was scared. How was SUNY

The Right Choice?... Essay

781 words - 3 pages …""They're pretty expensive""I realize. But maybe I can get a lot of money…""I looked at colleges too, BCC has the same program you want."Right then and there I knew where I was going. The place the 11th grade Cooper would never have dreamed (or nightmared) to go. I guess I thought that Broome was going to restrict me from being what I want to be, and pigeon hole me into being an "average kid". In a word, I was scared. How was SUNY