This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Scarlet Letter: Are The Puritans Really Like That?

716 words - 3 pages

The Scarlet Letter: Are the Puritans really like that?

Nathaniel Hawthorne accurately portrayed the colonial Puritans of Boston in his book, The Scarlet

Letter, and what their actions and reactions would have been to Hester Prynne committing adultery, and the

events thereafter, which also conform to what we know about the Puritans and how they were fastidiously

against sex in any form.

     Not hardly.

In The Scarlet Letter, we see Hester Prynne, who is put on trial for committing adultery (from which

came a baby girl, Pearl) after her husband had been missing for four years, and presumed lost and drowned at

sea. This fits our thoughts of the Puritans and what they thought of sex, and how they probably would have

reacted to Hester’s committing adultery. Hester Prynne is led from a prison door, carrying an infant and wearing

a scarlet "A" she has meticulously embroidered. She stands on the scaffold in the public square of Salem,

Massachusetts, where she is ridiculed and scorned by the townspeople.

That’s extremely doubtful.

It was actually the 19th Century American Victorians, at the exact same time in which Nathaniel

Hawthorne wrote The Scarlet Letter, who were prudish to a point beyond belief, especially in things about sex in

any form. As an example of the extent of their prudishness, to the Victorians, words such as legs, breasts, and

bulls became limbs, bosoms, and male or gentlemen cows. In fact, in the years before the Civil War, a South

Carolina newspaper refused to print birth notices, and a woman in New Orleans never changed her clothes

without turning her picture of Andrew Jackson to the wall. Many reviewed Dickens and Dumas (and some even

The Scarlet Letter itself) as “Trashy Literature”.

The Puritans would have, quite frankly, been aghast at this. In fact, the Puritans were quite forthcoming

in things involving sex- they expressed themselves frankly, not shyly. Of course, the Puritans did have a strict

moral code; however, this mostly centered around them finding religious purity in their lives. To be sure,

chastity before marriage was an unbroken rule, and faithfulness to one’s spouse in marriage was as well.


Find Another Essay On The Scarlet Letter: Are the Puritans Really Like That?

Was the punishment that Hester Prynne recieved in The Scarlet Letter a fair punishment?

534 words - 2 pages that simply wearing a scarlet letter for life was not a harsh enough sentence. This is a perfect example of how common it was to be punished for committing a sin in the Puritan society; Hester's punishment did not surprise the women even slightly. Because of the society in which Hester lived, she deserved to be punished for her sin. However, under her circumstances, Hester deserved a lesser punishment.When Hester became involved with Reverend

The Scarlet Letter By Nathaniel Hawthrone. This is a report that descrbes all the symbolism throughout the book

582 words - 2 pages brought the characters to life. He often used symbolism to justify a point or to describe and idea. Hawthorns' symbolism also helped with understanding the character's emotions at that particular time.The Scarlet Letter is about sin. The rosebush growing at the prison door symbolizes beauty in the midst of evil. The scarlet letter upon Hester Prynne's bosom, that is so beautifully embroidered, represents sin cloaked in beauty, and a secret for Pearl

What are the "crimes" committed in "The Scarlet Letter" by Nathaniel Hawthorne and how are they punished? In your opinion, how "just" are these punishments?

1051 words - 4 pages herself but also her husband and the rest of the Puritan society. The scarlet letter and the puritans’ reaction against is a constant reminder of her failure.Years later, the Puritan’s are ready to discuss whether they should let Hester take the scarlet letter off her breast. They feel she has done much good to the community: regularly feeding the poor and caring for the sick. Many have already forgotten the true significance of the letter

Are Christianity and Islam really that different?

3890 words - 16 pages and Muslims. Are Christianity and Islam really that much different from each other?In Israel, 2,000 years ago, a child was born to a Jewish couple. Jesus grew to be a captivating preacher, gathering disciples as he went. The Son of God performed miracles, they said: raising the dead, calming the waters of Galilee. Jerusalem's authorities, perceiving a threat, had Jesus executed. His followers, taking up the cross, built the world's largest

Are disaster movies really that popular?

2268 words - 9 pages looking at any list of top box office draws of all time or even of the last few years, one instantly notices that they are often populated by movies which had a disaster of some sort. For years, James Cameron’s “Titanic” held the distinction of the highest grossing movie ever. However, other movies in the disaster genre also hold a distinction for having earned record amounts for their particular time frames. Starting with Apollo 13 in 1995, which

Why is the U.S. really considering waging "pre-emptive" war on Iraq? Is it really the solution? Do you think that it is really terrorism that we are after?

657 words - 3 pages destruction that Saddam is producing?Suppose we do conquer Iraq and then Iran and then North Korea, and then Sudan and Libya and Syria, and whatever other countries are designated as terrorist states, will terrorism end? The answer is no. Terrorism is born of grudge and grievance. We have to face the fact that dislocation, pandemonium, helplessness and secrecy nourish terrorism. Reducing functioning societies like Iraq to anarchy by destroying their

An intersting perspective on character analysis, as seen by consideration being given to decisions that characters make. ("The Scarlet Letter", "Hunger of Memory" and "Catch-22")

1607 words - 6 pages positive manner and ultimately could change the course of events radically or insignificantly. An analysis of the choices made and how the characters came about to making those choices reveals a great wealth of information and provides an avenue into the psyche of the character and the situation they are in. Catch-22 by Joseph Heller, The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne, and Hunger of Memory by Richard Rodriguez are three very different books

Intertextuality essay choosing one chapter from Foster's HOW TO READ LITERATURE LIKE A PROFESSOR to help illuminate the meaning of Nathaniel Hawthorne's SCARLET LETTER. Analyze the occurrence of this...

1066 words - 4 pages Dimmesdale. By adding Biblical references to The Scarlet Letter, Nathaniel Hawthorne adds depth to the Puritan storyline. It more clearly explains the consequence of Hester and Reverend Dimmesdale's fall. Again, their fall can be alluded to The Fall of humanity with Adam and Eve. Foster elaborates on that in his book, as well, "Every story about the loss of innocence is really about someone's private reenactment of the fall from grace

Stories that make us Question who we really are

1054 words - 5 pages ? That their life is ending? Where do we go when we die? Maybe it is the fact that we don’t know what happens and it makes us fear death. But would knowing make us fear it more or less? Yet, how is living different from being dead? Are we really living or is it all just one big dream? How can we tell if it is a dream? We live in this world where we do the same thing over and over again. We get up, go to work or school, go home and sleep until we

The title of the essay is: Hester Prynne and her Subconscience. This is an essay which describes how the id, ego, and superego are used in the book The Scarlet Letter, by Nathaniel Hawthorne

708 words - 3 pages occur consciously and with knowledge of the consequences. The superego is the part of the brain that holds a person back from committing an action. Both the action and consequences are thought about before the act is done. These three mental states occur in all people, but especially within Hester Prynne from The Scarlet Letter. Throughout the story her mindset changes many times. It starts out in the id phase and works its way to the superego

Everyone wishes that they had their families in the 1950's, things were simpler the 1950's are like any other decade, with its own problems

1086 words - 4 pages Coontz and Crittenden both, in their own essays, agree that the 1950's were a time of optimism about marriage, although, they disagree with each other on the motivation and outcome of that optimism. The 1950's are looked back upon as the "Golden" family years. Everyone wishes that they had their families in the 1950's, things were simpler, there were less temptations for their kids, but the reality is, the 1950's are like any other decade, with

Similar Essays

Puritans And The Scarlet Letter Essay

926 words - 4 pages Nathaniel Hawthorne was not a Puritan, but he had deep bonds back to this religion, and had ancestors that were in charge of the Salem Witch Trials, a fact that Hawthorne always felt remorse for. In choosing this time period as the setting for The Scarlet Letter, a classic story of love, betrayal and religion, he showcased both the weakness and strengths of this time period and religion. Like the Pilgrims, the Puritans were from England, and

Impure Puritans Exposed In The Scarlet Letter And The Crucible

867 words - 3 pages lies when he says in court, "I can only say, I never found any of them naked" (Miller 115) referring to Betty, Abigail and other girls he had seen in the forest one night. By saying this, Parris shows that anyone, even the people who are supposed to safeguard the Puritans from wrongdoing, can and do commit sinful acts. As in The Crucible, in The Scarlet Letter some people are not punished by the public for their sins. One such example is with

Puritans In The Scarlet Letter By Nathaniel Hawthorne

673 words - 3 pages author in the United States, Nathaniel changed his last name by adding a ‘w’ to distance himself from his family's past. He later published The Scarlet Letter, which can be described as an attack on the Puritan religion and their behavior. Nathaniel contrasts Puritan and Romantic characteristics to highlight the close minded thinking and behavior of the Religious community in the 1600’s, while allowing Hawthorne to expose the ignorance that

A Good Story With A Setting In The Middle Ages. Teachers Really Like Things That Are Written From The Middle Ages. Very Educational And Entertaining

6963 words - 28 pages hear was the wind whipping in the dawn trees, and I found I was cold. Cold from the sweat that poured down my face."Was that really him? I never knew he had the power to speak like that out of no where."I started walking the way I was going, the coldness wearing off. Rio said I needed rest, but I didn't pay attention, I just kept on walking."Jake look out!" All I felt was something hard hit my head, heard a spurting sound, and I was out