The School And Society: The Schools We Need

3493 words - 14 pages

The School is an embedded institution. We talk about the "School in Society" rather than "the School and Society." Social change influences the School. We can't understand school without its societal context, which is a complex one.Does the school merely reflect society or can it be an agent for change, giving direction to the larger society of which it is a part? The Schools We Need And Why We Don't Have Them begins in much the same way as many educational reform books of recent years. All is not well with our K-12 public schools. American students would be better equipped in the schools of Asia or Europe. E.D. Hirsch, after citing studies to substantiate these claims, proceeds to tie this reality with that which he purports to be the underlying cause; the philosophy of education called progressivism and the naturalistic educational theories and practices associated with it.The author is a self-described political liberal (Hirsch, 1996, p. 6). He bemoans the fact that traditional, educationally conservative practices are inappropriately catalogued as an ideological subspecies of politico-socio-economic conservatism. He insists that political and educational ideologies are not related in this way. If they were, he argues, the progressive educational theories developed at Teachers College (Columbia), promoted in the first half of the last century and implemented ubiquitously throughout the 15,000 independent public school districts in the United States over the last 50 years would have resulted in the lifting up of the social and economic underclass. Hirsch cites studies showing that precisely the opposite has happened. There is actually a widening gap between the economically disadvantaged and the advantaged, resulting in growing inequality and social injustice.Hirsch (1996) therefore argues for an inverse relationship between educational and social progressivism: Educational progressivism is a sure means for preserving the social status quo, whereas the best practices of educational conservatism are the only means whereby children from disadvantaged homes can secure the knowledge and skill that will enable them to improve their condition. (p. 7) The author presents his theory as neither traditional nor progressive, but pragmatic: "¦ the best guide to education on a large scale is observation of practices that have worked well on a large scale, coupled with as exact an understanding as possible of the reason why those practices have succeeded in many different contexts. (Hirsch, 1996, p. 8) As discussed in class, minority viewpoints are typically repressed within institutions. Hirsch certainly espouses a minority opinion in the field of education. By suggesting that traditional, knowledge-based transmission of culture is the primary function of education it should come as no surprise that Hirsch has been debunked and ridiculed. He acknowledges that his earlier book, Cultural Literacy (1987) "became the subject of intense controversy"...

Find Another Essay On The School And Society: The Schools We Need

We don't need the death penalty

1016 words - 4 pages persons executed. When the consequences are life and death, we need to demand the same standard for our system of justice as we would for our airlines... It is a central pillar of our criminal justice system that it is better that many guilty people go free than that one innocent should suffer... Let us reflect to ensure that we are being just. Let us pause to be certain we do not kill a single innocent person. This is really not too much to ask for

We Need Diversity in the Workplace

1462 words - 6 pages cultural diversity through the recognition of cultural and religious holidays, observances, practices, and diet restrictions. We are not where we once were, but we are not yet where we should be. In an ideal world, every person is treated equally when it comes to receiving a job, advancing in their career, and being treated fairly in the workplace. In reality, we know this is not the case. Unfortunately our reality is unfair treatment in regards to

The Need for Choice: A Healthier Society

1740 words - 7 pages . There are already millions of people suffering from hunger all around the country, and worrying eating healthy should be the last thing on their minds. Though not exactly ideal, our food situation in this country is not as bad as it may seem. Also, as a capitalist society, we have many choices as to what we buy. This should not be limited in order to make the country potentially healthier. Both large-scale factory farms and smaller organic farms have

Why and How We Need to Improve the Environmental Impact of Automobiles in the US

3820 words - 15 pages not everyone will purchase a new car at once. Also, people will still purchase used cars that have been in the fleet for a while, so these cars still do not meet the currently imposed laws. To improve Corporate Average Fuel Economy, the manufacturers need to want to meet the standards. If it is too costly to sell automobiles in America, then the manufacturers will leave, and jobs will be lost. America cannot afford to lose any more jobs than we

The Need for Character Education in Public Schools Today

1955 words - 8 pages of control until parents and educators together began making demands for reform. The moral illiteracy had indeed become a menace to society. This indicated the need for public schools to again incorporate character education in their programming. A society needs values education to survive and thrive and everything a school does teaches values. There is growing support for values education and a variety of programs are being instituted all

The Inevitability of School Violence: No Need for School Reform

832 words - 3 pages the human heart, the internal person. We need to understand that the problem is bigger than a trench coat or a gun; therefore, dress codes or metal detectors cannot solve it. These reforms are often vain attempts at prevention. They hinder education and provoke students. Policy makers and schools need to be aware that no simple public mandate can suffice as a solution. In response to the massacres, school security has become an increasing

Letter to EPA about the Savannah Biome and why we need to protect it

669 words - 3 pages Environmental Protection Agency,Human activities are creating more and more problems for different biomes around the world. Because we share the world with many other species of plants and animals, we must consider the consequences of our actions. Over the past several decades, increasing human activity has rapidly destroyed or polluted many ecological habitats throughout the world. It is important to preserve all types of biomes as each houses

Understanding the Relationship Between American Schools and Society: A look at how society and curriculum are based upon each other

1815 words - 7 pages individuals as well. His point of view showed both concern for solidity and order, as well as for social mobility, which was believed to be achieved by means of free public education. Mann's beliefs of education helping to achieve social mobility helped to support the development of America's public school systems as we know them today.The effect of schooling began to play a major role in determining who would get ahead in society and who will not

Necessity of the Internet - Reasons why and how we need the Internet plus things it has changed.

834 words - 3 pages the monitor for the user view. That eventually evolved into other applications and lead to programs such as instant messaging and email. The Internet soon augmented into what we have today, a massive media and communications system. Email is the most frequently used form of communication and the most used form of the Internet. The Internet now obviates old forms of mail. Because of the ability to email someone at any time and at any place, many

Are we categorized in society by the way we dress?

857 words - 3 pages Are we categorized in society by the way we dress?The way we dress does have an impact on how we are viewed and categorized in society. Whether we are at work, school, the mall, or simply taking a stroll in the park, we are judged because of our clothing. We are a society quick to judge because of the outside, which denies us the opportunity to get to know a person at times from the inside. The fact of the matter is clothing plays a key role in

Society Through the Ages: Have We Changed?

2458 words - 10 pages lesson we can take from this is we need to stand up for what is right and truthful. Society is comprised of individuals; individuals that are not perfect, therefore society is not perfect and sometimes falls short of what is moral and right. It is our duty as people that live in this society to stand up for what is right, and correct the shortcomings we see. In Oedipus Rex, Creon is falsely accused by Oedipus of wanting his throne. Oedipus thinks he

Similar Essays

A Psychology Abstract On The Article "Thinning Down School Food." Talks About Increasing Childhood Obesity, And What Schools Need To Do To Change It.

576 words - 2 pages classroom, away from home. Probart offers that after World War II, many programs on school nutrition were started in order to give kids bigger portions and better nutrition. Nowadays, school food lines are once again the leaders in promoting healthy eating habits. Instead of saving children from scarcity of food, they need to save them from excess of it.Even as juniors, when we're in the last years of our education, school food still plays a big part of

We Need To ‘Bump’ Up Sex Education In Schools, To Reduce Teenage Pregnancies And Std’s.

747 words - 3 pages the future, the families, and the love between two couples. Pornography doesn’t portray sex the way it actually is; the way we need to teach teenagers about. We could blame the teenagers, of course. They are irresponsible, drunken and sexually uncontrollable. But school is what raises them. School is what teaches them all the things they need to get good GCSE, which will lead on to good college grades. If they can do that, then surely they can

We Need Mandatory Random Drug Testing In Public Schools

1888 words - 8 pages facts are the cold, hard truth; moreover, students have a higher rate of using drugs than studying for a test in school (Sznitman 146). On the other hand, each view can reach an agreement that all drug rates throughout the United States are drastically increasing. There are drug programs already being practiced in public schools. Students will feel safer and perform better academically without the presence of drugs (Russell 170). Although

Why Do We Need To Go To School?

991 words - 4 pages Good morning, class! Today, I am here to tutor you because your professor can not attend the class.Continuing the last dialogue, today's topic is the supporting reasons about why we really need to go to school. In this meeting, I will cover some points, which are the things that schools offer us and the pro and contra about home schooling and internet-schooling.Well class, what do you think about life when we relate it with school? Yes, right