The Scientific Account Of Inductivism Vs. Falsificationism: Is Science Objective?

1023 words - 4 pages

The following essay aims to discuss whether science is objective or subjective in light of two competing theories: inductivism and falsificationism. Addressing the main quote, I will state how Popper would respond to two of Chalmers’ core ideas, before providing my own opinions and justification on the matter.

Chalmers account of science is from an inductivist’s perspective. He believes that science is achieved through justifying universal statements from singular statements. (Chalmers, 1976) Thus, leading to believe that these statements can be proven. Falsificationists disagree with the view that scientific knowledge is proven knowledge. They reason that no number of observations will sufficiently prove a claim. On the contrary, it only requires one observation to sufficiently disprove a claim. Popper would respond that it is greater than probable that a claim will be false. He would conclude that scientific knowledge is not proven knowledge but rather the best justification of our understanding of the world at any given time.

I further this opinion of Popper; nothing in science can be seen as an unquestionable truth. It is illogical for any singular statement to be considered a universal statement. By analogy, it is illogical to presume all dogs are brown because, through observation, you’ve only ever seen brown dogs. This logic predisposes science for failure. An excellent example of such is the paradigm shift away from Newtonian physics in light of Einstein’s discoveries. Einstein presented a new context for motion that was otherwise not considered by Newton. The fact is that almost every scientific ‘truth’ to be presented throughout history has been falsified, which is an inherent flaw within the notion of induction.

However, I do concur with Chalmers in that scientific knowledge is reliable (Chalmers, 1976) even whilst I don’t believe scientific knowledge to be an unquestionable truth. If scientific knowledge is yet to be falsified after being subjected to rigorous testing, it then represents an accurate generalization in-line with current observations of a particular phenomenon. Referring back to Newtonian physics, even whilst it was generally proven to be false, it was more than sufficient in being applied to most Earth-bound phenomena - in other words, phenomena with speeds insignificant compared to the speed of light.

Chalmers then claims that science is objective. (Chalmers, 1976) This further implies that inductive inference in itself is objective. Falsificationists disagree with this view. They reason there are two ways in which induction could possibly be justified: either priori or posteriori, in other words, logically or scientifically. First, it seems as if any surmountable evidence is immaterial compared to the universal claim. This suggests that induction cannot be proved logically. Second, it is paradoxical to attempt to prove a method of proving scientific using the very claim you are trying to prove. This...

Find Another Essay On The Scientific Account of Inductivism vs. Falsificationism: Is Science Objective?

Psuedopsychology vs the Scientific Method Essay

2681 words - 11 pages Humans have inhabited the Earth for thousands of years and it is perceived by many that we are among the most intellectual species on this planet. Although having lived on this planet for so long, being able to distinguish fact from fiction has escaped the minds of many. People of today’s society are easily influenced by what is told to them instead of what can be proven. Believing in something that has no scientific evidence is

The Effect of the Social Context of Scientific Work on the Methods and Findings of Science

930 words - 4 pages The Effect of the Social Context of Scientific Work on the Methods and Findings of Science The world society is in a constant state of fluidity regarding everything from social customs and slang to technology and inventions. With even more abundance, scientific understanding and questioning evolve as time progresses. As the human race changes and grows, scientific knowledge of the world and universe must expand to

The Extent to Which the Study of Management is Scientific

3417 words - 14 pages The Extent to Which the Study of Management is Scientific To what extent is the study of Management scientific? If it is not a science, then what is it? Introduction It is broadly agreed that certain aspects of management study are perfectly scientific, for example computer and mathematical solutions to management problems subject to quantitative constraints. This essay however, is mainly concerned with

Does science consist in the progressive development of objective truth? Contrast the views of Kuhn with one other writer on this topic.

1422 words - 6 pages Does science consist in the progressive development of objective truth? Contrast the views of Kuhn with one other writer on this topic. The philosopher and historian of science Thomas Kuhn introduced the term paradigm as a key part of what he called “normal science”: In normal (that is non revolutionary) periods in a science, there is a consensus across the relevant scientific community about the theoretical and methodological rules to be

The Objective of Total Quality Management

1322 words - 5 pages The Objective of Total Quality Management Total Quality Management(TQM) is an organisational process that actively involves every function and every employee in satisfying customers needs, both internal and external. TQM works by continuously improving all aspect of work through structured control, improvement and planning activities that are carried out in concern with guiding ideology that focuses on Quality and Customer Satisfaction

What is the Scientific Method?

2285 words - 9 pages the Earth's fluctuating magnetic field, weather, and pressure aren't taken into account, all of which can effect the number of radioactive isotopes in an object. As has hopefully been shown, evolution is not scientifically possible. Despite this, the theory continues to be taught as fact. It is time to change this, children are constantly being taught this, even though it is wrong. Should children be taught to listen to scientists and trust

"Science alone cannot decide the question of moral status of the very early embryo. But nor can the question be decided without taking account of science." Discuss

779 words - 3 pages been quite common ever since the first test tube baby in 1978 was born. Here is where science enters the issue. There is nothing immoral about these two activities as they can have many benefits for the people involved such as give the opportunity of a family even to those who are infertile. However, issues start to arise when a surplus of embryos is used. The success rate of such activities is only around 25% and so in order to increase chances a

The Role of Art vs. the Role of Science

1609 words - 6 pages The Role of Art vs. the Role of Science “art upsets [and] science reassures.” - Georges Braque Before beginning, it is important to clarify that the quote is referring to shock as causing anger or upset. In using reassuring, Georges Braque is referring to comforting. That said, this statement by Braque is true to a point, because the statement also works in reverse. Throughout the history of man, art has been a method for

Is science the supreme form of knowledge?

1459 words - 6 pages hypothesis. This form of knowledge is influenced by emotion wanting the experiment to work in one way when actually there are other results too. Hence, the reasoning process of science which is to find a scientific proof isn't always accurate as it could be altered by various scientists. The scientific theory which is concluded is only based on the subjective viewpoint of the scientist rather than an objective point of view which is abolished due

Science vs the Ebola Virus

1057 words - 4 pages something as deadly as Ebola upon us? Leopold bases his theory of "violence" upon the assertion that nature, acting as a network, will not be able to compensate for quick, drastic changes and would universally fail should one happen. Obviously, this suggests that science should not create new technologies but work very hard to preserve the current status quo. Thus science is presented with a dilemma: it can either save human lives or save the balance

Review of the Objective of Norm in American

952 words - 4 pages The objective of norm in American, by Michael Schudson, explores how and why the objective norms developed in American journalism. Objective is one of the most important occupational values of American journalism, it can be identified by following measures: express allegiance, ethnographers’ observations and occupational routines, resist with the challenging behaviour, impersonality and non-partisanship in news content. Differencing from some

Similar Essays

Is Social Science Scientific Essay

824 words - 3 pages , sociology is not scientific. Auguste Comte regularly compared sociology to other familiar forms of science, like biology, physics, and chemistry. In doing so, he made the assumption that others believed sociology to be scientific. Comte, unintentionally, provided adequate evidence as to why sociology is scientific, while at the same time simply describing sociology as a whole. Much like Comte, Friedrich Engels also found social sciences to be

Profit Maximisation Is Not The Sole Objective Of Business.

1090 words - 4 pages Profit maximisation has been one of the main aims of the firms. The generally accepted view is the long run will wish to maximize profit. Marginal Cost and Marginal Revenue can be used to find the profit maximising level of output. Marginal cost is the addition to total cost of one extra unit of output. Marginal revenue is the increase in total revenue resulting from an extra unit of sales. Economic theory predicts that profits will be maximised

Teaching The Philosophy Of Science With Non Scientific Examples

3662 words - 15 pages . This is a problem particularly acute in teaching the philosophy of science, moreover, since the average college student's generally low levels of instruction in science, let alone the history of science, will render the majority of real-life scientific examples as opaque as the philosophical issues they were supposed to make clear! In this essay, one possible strategy for overcoming this obstacle, which has been culled from personal

Cultural Relativism Vs. Ethnocentism Which Is More Objective?

1023 words - 4 pages controls on bodily hair and gender segregation, although strange to a Western observer, are just symptoms of a society’s survival mechanisms. Through relativism, logical and objective deductions can be made about practices that would be seemingly inferior from a partisan, ethnocentric viewpoint. The radical implication of cultural relativism is that every cultural practice or belief requires an attempt to understand it from a sympathetic