The Scottish Parliament Essay

1290 words - 5 pages

For more than three hundred years, Scotland has been an active member of a union with Wales, England and Northern Ireland but recently this partnership has come under threat due to nationalist views from a group of deluded self-serving failed councillors better known as the SNP. The ideals of these individuals threaten the very fabric of this hub of culture and enterprise that we know and love as Scotland. With the tricentennial anniversary of union, the idea of Scottish independence has again come up for fierce debate. How, I ask myself, did Alex Salmond and his nationalist cronies manage to concoct such a specious solution to Scotland's problems? A question easily answered: on the basis of false, misinterpreted and corrupt data.

In 2007, the SNP scraped a narrow election victory in the Scottish Parliament of 1 seat, holding 47 to Labour's 46 out of 129. This forced the SNP to form a minority government, being a pathetic 18 seats short of a majority but the result still caused uproar in the media. The SNP's decision-making power may be seen as weak due to its minority status. However, being in government has given the nationalists centre stage in the media for promoting their principal policy of independence for Scotland from the rest of the UK. Whether or not this conjecture has any feasibility remains to be seen. Which begs the question, what plans could the SNP have for Scotland that would supposedly improve the welfare of every citizen in the nation, be they laird or lavvy cleaner?

To begin with, if they achieve their ultimate aim of Scottish independence, the SNP want to withdraw public spending from what they consider “unessential” expenses, e.g. the military, with particular emphasis on Trident, our nuclear deterrent. The last UK budget put defence expenditure at £36.9 billion which is 1.7% of the UK's GDP of £2.2 trillion. To many this may seem extortionate but it is nothing out of the ordinary relative to similar sized countries in Europe such as France and Germany. Such a great sum of money is not merely for defence but rather to stress Britain's role as a leading power. With our blue water fleet, nuclear deterrent, large land army and technologically advanced air force, Britain possesses the power to engage in world affairs politically and militarily, something a nation of five million would never be able to achieve on its own.

So, how else would the SNP's independent Scotland be able to bring about its utopia of marble roads and gold-plated pavements? It is one thing to cut expenses in our country's essential defence budget but where else would they get the income to achieve their aims? Black gold seems to be the SNP's answer to every question posed regarding revenue. Party members continually fantasise about the UK's £10 billion annual income from North Sea oil being just for Scotland, where, they argue, it could be put to better use.

The SNP's policy regarding “Scottish” oil is a strange axiom to follow in the...

Find Another Essay On The Scottish Parliament

Modern Scotland Essay

990 words - 4 pages Both the Scottish Parliament and Visit Scotland show two different images of modern Scotland. The parliament appeals to the Scottish people and try to improve the Scottish economy. Visit Scotland directed at tourists and is rather stereotypical. They do not convey a true image of modern Scotland. They are trying to appeal to two different audiences but they are making mistakes and this is causing Scotland to suffer. Throughout this essay is

Origins of the First World War

1971 words - 8 pages again began to discuss devolution, coming to positive agreements. These agreements were the will to campaign for devolution, and for John Smith to take the leading role of the Labour party. The Labour party was then driven forward by Tony Blair after the unexpected death of John Smith, who was not only able to win the next election in 1997 and establish the Scotland Act in 1998, but was also able to blossom the Scottish Parliament through a

Absolutism: Describe and analyze the changes in the role of Parliament in English politics between the succession of James and the Glorious Revolution

547 words - 2 pages taxes in turn for funding from Parliament. Afterwards, he abolished the Parliament to pursue his own endeavors. Furthermore, during Charles tenure, the English Civil War took place as a result from the lack of amity between Charles and Parliament. The Scottish invaded England, but Parliament refused to allow Charles to raise an army, because they feared he would abuse his powers and assail English citizens who opposed him. Charles I was

How the U.K. was formed

1413 words - 6 pages search of better opportunities. As the twentieth century came around, there was a slow movement to bring back Scotland’s domestic affairs. This formed the establishment of the new Scottish Parliament in 1999, just about three-hundred years after signing the Treaty of Queen Anne. This however was not as powerful as expected, only giving Scotland more control over her domestic policy while remaining in the United Kingdom, and still having to abide by

Scottish Separatist Movement - Yes Scotland vs. Better Together

2291 words - 10 pages confidence” from Scottish members of parliament. Devolution finally became reality in the 1997 referendum (which was unanimous), leading to the passing of the Scotland Act in 1998, with it coming into effect by 1999. The party which is in power now (the Scottish National Party) are the ones mainly leading the charge for a full secession from the United Kingdom. The ruling party is termed as a “social-democratic” party, which leans more on the

Why Parliament diskliked Charles I

540 words - 2 pages unjust, illegal fashion.Charles's biggest mistake was imposing Archbishop Laud's Arminian prayer books on his English and Scottish subjects. Although the English grudgingly accept, the Presbyterian Scots were outraged when Charles tried to make changes in the Scottish church, and many riots broke out in protest. When Charles called up Parliament 1640, aptly called the "Long Parliament," he asked for more money to aid in suppressing the Scots. However, the members of Parliament then expressed their opposition to the Laudian reforms, and demanded that Charles get rid of the Laudian reforms and change the English church back to Anglican.

A Historic Referendum

868 words - 4 pages Salmond, and the Prime Minister of Great Britain, David Cameron. This ensured that the referendum had a clear legal base, be legislated for by the Scottish Parliament, it determined the date of the referendum, and more. The SNP was formed in 1934 and never was a mainstream political party until the late 1990’s, and in 2009 it became the main opposition for the Labour Party. Finally in 2007, under Alex Salmond, the party formed a minority

"Will the UK Constitutional reform programme 'save' the state or hasten its demise."

3972 words - 16 pages IntroductionThe United Kingdom has seen more constitutional reform under the first New Labour government of Tony Blair than in the previous century. Power has been devolved away from Westminster to the Scottish Parliament, and to the assemblies of Wales and Northern Ireland. The Upper Chamber of the Westminster Parliament itself, the House of Lords, has seen major constitutional change, and Greater London is receiving a Mayor and a new assembly

Presbyterianism in Scotland

729 words - 3 pages parliament on 13 June 1640, the first in England for 11 years.Charles believed that due to old Scottish rivalries, by calling parliament he would find support. However unfortunately for Charles many MP's sympathised with the Scots and they refused to give him any support. All he enabled was unhappy MP's to voice there opinions about events over the 11 years. Charles dismissed parliament after 3 weeks and later became known as the short parliament. This

Growth Of Limited Monarchy In England

1240 words - 5 pages Queen Elizabeth's reign, up until the Stuart family took up the thrown. In the 17th century, England developed into a limited monarchy.Queen Elizabeth was the last successful monarch to rule alongside the English Parliament. Elizabeth had a lot of control over England and was generally a good ruler, yet she was not an absolute monarch. Elizabeth worked well with Parliament and allowed them to be involved in her reign. When Elizabeth died, Parliament

The role played by John Pym ensured that Parliament was always likely to win the first Civil War of 1642

896 words - 4 pages Ordinance of February 1643 which was proportional to wealth also meant that the taxation was not too unpopular as it seemed fair.Furthermore, the Impressments Ordinance of 1643 introduced conscription meaning that Parliament had a lot of troops who were paid and were therefore loyal and better trained. Even more troops were given to Parliament as a result of the Scottish alliance; the Solemn League and Covenant organised by Pym; the Scots sent

Similar Essays

The Scottish Parliament Essay

3843 words - 15 pages INDRODUCTION:The creation of a new Scottish Parliament has, undeniably, a serious impact on the people of Scotland - the strength of devolution lying in all three areas; administrative, financial and legislative - the only area of the devolved United Kingdom to hold such powers.The Scottish form of devolution was drafted upon the 1997 referendum which resulted in a 74.3% agreement on the creation of the Parliament and a 63.5% agreement that a

Devolution: Compare Differences Between Scottish Parliament And Westminster

1209 words - 5 pages Labour's Landslide Victory in the elections of 1997, led to a referendum being held in September 1997 at which the vote for devolution for Scotland was secured. Elections were then held in May 1999 and the newly created Scottish Parliament gained Power in July 1999. This essay will explore Scottish Devolution and compare the differences between the different political systems that have developed in Westminster and in Scotland. Voting systems

Organizations Of A Business Essay

2213 words - 9 pages our secondary goals would be "Inspiring With Every Individual." This goal is about all of us making a difference, raising aspirations, motivating, empowering and encouraging. 3. Scottish Enterprise Borders has many stakeholders. The most prominent of those are: Scottish Parliament/Scottish Executive - The Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Executive are responsible for Scottish councils and other

Uk Political Devolution And Scottish Independence

2267 words - 9 pages thinking, the survey showed the vast majority opted for separate parliament. Scotland at this point did not want to be independent only separate parliaments, therefore they were not in favour of any parties which were devoted to home rule or independence. Although in 1947 a Scottish convention was formed in hope of gaining the support needed in parliament for the separation it was not something Westminster seen as a priority therefore it was