The Sedition Acts: Was Eugene Debs Rightly Convicted?

1859 words - 7 pages

In 1919, the Supreme Court erroneously ruled the Espionage Act of 1917 and the Sedition Act of 1918 were constitutional under Schenck v. United States.1 This was a false premise and those convicted under these acts, including Eugene Debs, were tried under an unconstitutional law. The unconstitutional nature of the law aside, the Supreme Court failed to properly interpret the Sedition Act under which he was convicted.
The Sedition Act of 19182 consisted of several provisions to restrict speech during wartime, including “willfully obstruct[ing] the recruitment or enlistment service of the United States.” Eugene Debs was convicted for violating this provision during his Canton, OH speech in June 19183. In Debs v. United States,4 the courts inferred certain statements made by Debs demonstrated intent to obstruct recruitment efforts. The Court also concluded these inferences posed a “clear and present danger” to the country under a precedent established months before in Schenck v. United States.
The precedent from the related Schenck v. United States trial has essentially been overturned by the Supreme Court in later decisions, and although many aspects of the Sedition Act were later repealed and are now considered unconstitutional, I will focus my arguments on why I believe the Supreme Court wrongly affirmed the judgment against Debs under this act at the time the ruling was given. I will assess statements made by Debs with the Sedition Act and explain why he did not violate the “obstruction of recruitment” provision for which he was convicted. In addition, I will examine three related Supreme Court cases on sedition during WWI: Schenck v. United States, Debs v. United States, and Abrams v. United States5 to demonstrate that Judge Oliver Wendell Holmes, who wrote on each case, contradicts the legal reasoning of his Schenck decision in his Abrams dissent.
Schenck v. United States and Debs v. United States were both argued before the Supreme Court in January 1919. Schenck was convicted of manufacturing and distributing pamphlets that encouraged people to oppose the draft. In Schenck v. United States, the Supreme Court held that during times of war, restrictions on speech were permissible because “many things that might be said in time of peace are such a hindrance to its efforts…that no Court could regard them as protected by any constitutional right.” Holmes further established a “clear and present danger” test to evaluate speech during times of war. He writes, “The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent. It is a question of proximity and degree.”
The Schenck decision was used to dismiss Debs’ legitimate First Amendment claim. The court concluded the facts and circumstances in the Debs case were similar to the Schenck case and...

Find Another Essay On The Sedition Acts: Was Eugene Debs Rightly Convicted?

Biography Of Eugene Victor Deb Essay

806 words - 3 pages Eugene Victor Debs      Eugene Victor Debs was the most well known as a leader of the American Socialist Party. Eugene Debs had no executive positions but he was most popular leader of the socialist movements in American history. He was a revolutionary and he wanted to establish a socialism in America. Eugene V. Debs was born on fifth of the November, 1855. His father Jean Daniel Debs small storekeeper was originally

Eugene Debs Essay

5023 words - 20 pages Eugene Debs was one of the most intriguing figures in American History. He was a union worker who rose through the ranks to become a union leader. As he sought to better the working conditions for his fellow workers he branched out to become an unlikely presidential candidate for the Socialist Party. Eugene Debs stands out as an example of how power in the workplace can turn into power on a political level, even if that person is locked up in

Freedom from Governmental Espionage

1278 words - 5 pages his battled release and character defamation, Assange is still is carrying out what he believes to be his mission as he has made well known his belief, the important information in the world that is being concealed can achieve reform and do some good (Assange, 2010c) The day that Eugene Debs was arrested for sedition he was charged with ten separate counts including as stated in The New York Times, “Uttering disloyal language about the form of

eugene v. Debs

2046 words - 8 pages Eugene V. Debs Citizen and Socialist Nick Salvatore’s book Eugene V. Debs Citizen and Socialist provides a very detailed account of the life and times and Eugene Debs. Debs was born in Terre Haute Indiana and Salvatore emphasizes the important role that this played in Debs upbringing. Terre Haute was ripe with religious fundamentalism from its founding. Religion permeated everyday life throughout Terre Haute. Salvatore writes that, “In

Andrew Carnegie, Eugene V. Debs, and Horatio Alger

557 words - 2 pages Andrew Carnegie, Eugene V. Debs, and Horatio Alger During the late nineteenth century rapid industrialization paved the way for extreme economical wealth of many business. In accordance with the overflowing wealth in the nineteenth century many individuals held similar but yet contrasting views toward the wealth that was created in the United States. Among these individuals were Andrew Carnegie, Eugene V. Debs, and Horatio Alger. One of

Oliver Wendell Holmes and Free Speech

3577 words - 14 pages party, for president. After delivering an anti-war speech in Ohio, he was arrested, charged, and convicted of violating the Sedition Act of 1918. Debs argued that the free speech protection given in the 1st amendment barred any such conviction. Once again Schenck is cited as controlling, and once again the conviction is upheld. The reoccurrence even more striking is the absence of the clear and present danger test. The vestiges of the bad

Alien and Sedition Acts

597 words - 2 pages . The Attorney General charged seventeen people with sedition, and ten were convicted. The Sedition Act was the first example of a Constitutional crisis in that is violated the First Amendment. People were upset that their freedom of speech and the press was infringed upon. They wanted to be able to express their ideas and feelings even if it criticized the government. Democracy was threatened.In conclusion, The Alien Acts were never enforced, but

Effect of World War I on The United States

972 words - 4 pages threat to taking the U.S. out of the war was seen as illegal. Kate Richards O’Hare was one of these people who led a rebellion against the war (Doc. F). She was convicted for going against the Espionage Act although it was seen unfair by several citizens including Eugene Debs who created a whole speech against it. He was later convicted for violating the Sedition Act. The Sedition Act stated that no American citizen could do anything that went

Final Exam

1064 words - 5 pages return from Europe, he fired the union workers and replaced them with non-union workers; most of the union workers got their jobs back. Eugene Debs Debs was the secretary of the brotherhood society, by 1883; Debs resign from his position and organize industrial union railroad workers. Debs started the American Railway Union Eugene Debs a “socialist and a labor organizer got involved with the strike in Chicago, Burlington, and Quincy

Red Scare Describes the causes and consequences of the Red Scare of 1919

1128 words - 5 pages directed against subversives and, therefore, cast a very broad net. Because of the Sedition act, many individuals were arrested for distributing media that criticized the American military (Eugene Debs, head of the Socialist Party, was one of them). It was in response to this act that Justices Oliver Wendell Holmes set forth the "clear and present danger" doctrine and marked the beginning of modern First Amendment jurisprudence. Therefore, the Sedition

Schenck v. US

1025 words - 4 pages used in freedom of speech challenges. There were two similar cases that year surrounding the Espionage Act. In 1918, Eugene V. Debs gave a speech in Ohio “giving praise to those who had refused the draft”. Debs was arrested for violating the Espionage Act. Debs contested the charges against him, claiming that the Espionage Act infringed upon his First Amendment rights. In the case of Debs v. United States, the Supreme Court voted unanimously in

Similar Essays

The Alien And Sedition Acts Essay

961 words - 4 pages The Alien and Sedition Acts were passed by the Federalists mainly to strengthen their position in the government and to limit and control the growing number of Republicans in the country. These acts grant lots of power to the government, i.e. president and Congress, which at that time were controlled by the Federalists. These acts lengthened the naturalization process for foreigners, gave the president enormous powers to deal with aliens, and

Compare And Contrast The Attitudes Of Andrew Carnegie, Eugene V. Debs And Booker T. Washington Towards The New Wealth Created In America During The Late Nineteenth Century Bibliography Included!

1415 words - 6 pages The late nineteenth century was a period of rapid industrialization and extreme economical expansion and wealth for America. Many businessmen such as J.P. Morgan, John D. Rockefeller and Cornelius Vanderbilt among others reached the pinnacle of wealth and amassed huge amounts of money. Many individuals developed contrasting attitudes and views on this newly created wealth. Among these individuals were Andrew Carnegie, Eugene V. Debs, and Booker

"The Effects Of Sin" This Paper Gives A Detailed Account Of How Each Character Was Effected By Hester Prynee's Adulterous Acts.

861 words - 3 pages punishment and shame that the guilty couple felt following their acts of indiscretion. As shown throughout the novel, the "scarlet letter" controls the lives of the individuals involved as they struggle to accept and/or hide their sin. To Hester Prynne, it bore the full weight of her shame until she was able to reconcile herself to God and to the rest of the puritan community and to Arthur Dimmesdale, it burned into his heart the secret of his unbearable guilt and contributed to his eventual demise.Works CitedHawthorne, Nathaniel. The Scarlet Letter. New York: Dover Publications Inc., 1994.

Eugene V. Debs Essay

2783 words - 11 pages by President Grover Cleveland. Debs and seven others (known as the 'Woodstock Eight') were convicted of contempt of court for refusing to obey a court order to end the strike. In Debs' six month stay in the jail at Woodstock, Illinois, he converted to Socialism (A Short Look..., 1).Eugene Debs' conversion to Socialism was a slow, but interesting one. His first contact with the labor movement, which is the basis of Socialism, was in the