The Self Medication Hypothesis Essay

2317 words - 9 pages

Myth or RealityDeveloping Professional Practice in Dual DiagnosisLevel 2The aim of this piece of work is to appraise Khantzian's (1985) hypothesis relating to the relationship between substance misuse and mental illness. It is well reported that psychoactive substances generally have a negative effect on the central nervous system, changing mood and behaviour (Rassool, 2002b), often to an extent that behaviour is uncontrollable by the individual. However knowing this many individuals choose to use substances whether for recreational reasons or for other reasons which will be explored within this piece of work.We know that substance abuse among those with a mental illness is a common occurrence and it is said to be one of the biggest challenges faced by mental health services (Department of Health, 2003).The impact of substance misuse on mental health and vice versa creates many complications. It is associated with the increased risk of suicide, violence (Peterson, 2002), relapse (Kavanagh et al, 2002) and readmission (Rassool, 2002a). Mental health services know all to well the implications that arise as a result of dual diagnosis and deal with such on a regular basis. However there are individuals diagnosed with a mental illness that will state that they use substances to 'self medicate' and there are several theorists that would support this rationale.One of the theorists is Khantzian (1985). His theory of self-medication believes that individuals with a mental illness use substances to relieve the symptoms of the illness or to counteract the unwanted side effects of antipsychotic medications, but in reality and from experience we know that substance abuse generally leads to a deterioration of the condition with symptoms exacerbated and poorer long-term prognosis (Negrete, 2003).When we examine Khantzian's hypothesis in the light of current research and available evidence, are we able to state its validity or are we trying to justify why those with a mental illness use substances, thus enabling them to continue doing so under a 'label'. Are we to some extent condoning the use of substances by reducing the stigma, in essence allowing this behaviour to be socially acceptable? Substance misuse alone is widely frowned upon, often associated with criminal activity.When exploring Khantzian's hypothesis Negrete (2003) emphasizes that to validate it we must be able to state several basic premises. Firstly that the use of substances is needed to alleviate the distress of the mental illness and secondly that the choice of substance used is not random, the choice of substance needs to reflect efficacy in the specific symptoms it is to alleviate.There are some that oppose the theory of self-medication and believe that those with mental illness misuse substances for the very same reasons as those without mental illness (Mueser et al 1998). Meuser et al (1998) stated that choice of substance is frequently made according to availability rather than the...

Find Another Essay On The Self-Medication Hypothesis

The Ethics of Giving Children ADHD Medication

2180 words - 9 pages disorder the capacity to self-regulate that is absent in them but all their peers accomplish done by the medication helping to control their impulsiveness, emotional reactions, their poor focus and distractibility (180). Not giving the medication to children diagnosed with the ADHD disorder would then lead them to fall behind their classmates and put them at a great disadvantage. As well as the negative effect just described, not allowing children

Cognitive Research and Reasons Schizophrenics Have Auditory Hallucinations

2144 words - 9 pages overall death rate is double expected. Frequently, when schizophrenic patients take their prescribed medication they take other medication that either compound or negate their prescribed medication effects. There is currently no cure for the disorder, although medicines often help, especially with positive symptoms. Some positive symptoms include “Form” or disorganization of ideas and speech so that the listener cannot understand, or incoherence

Psychiatric Disorders, Diseases, and Drugs

1027 words - 4 pages Psychiatric Disorders, Diseases, and DrugsPsychiatric disorders are devastating disorders that often leave a person unable to lead an ordinary life. In this paper, you will learn about schizophrenia, depression, mania, anxiety disorder, and Tourette Syndrome, and any treatment through medication that helps a patient live normally with the disorder. Causes for these mental disorders and treatments for are paving the way for normalcy for those who

Translating Research into Practice

1425 words - 6 pages , B. A. (2005). Determinants of self management strategies to reduce out-of-pocket prescription medication expense in homebound older people. The Geriatrics Society, 53(4), 664-674. Spinewine, A., Schmader, K. E., Barber, N., Hughes, C., Lapane, K. L., Swine, C., et al. (2007). Appropriate prescribing in elderly people: how well can it be measured and optimised? Lancet, 370(9582), 173-184. Tseng, C., Dudley, R. A., Brook, R. H., Keeler, E

A Study Of Depression And Relationships

1065 words - 4 pages functioning, and both exert a reciprocal influence on each other in adulthood. The researchers of this study wanted to examine all the correlation's between type of care, attachment style, depression, and relationship functioning. They proposed a three part hypothesis: 1. A less positive childhood would result in an insecure attachment style and depression, 2. Depressives would exhibit a preoccupied or fearful style of attachment, and 3. attachment style


914 words - 4 pages ultimately result in their medication adherence are as variable as the individuals themselves. Patients’ age, sex, culture, symptom severity, worldview, socioeconomic status, opinion of mental illness, and self-image influence their individual decisions on adhering to a prescribed medication regimen. Conceptually, these can be divided into patient-related, medication-related, and provider-related risk factors (5). Among patient characteristics that

Against Psychotropic Drugs for Children

999 words - 4 pages differ from each individual, ranging from nervous breakdowns, inadequacy, mania, delusions, physical harm, self harm and possible attempted suicide. These symptoms can be treated with even more medication. Other side effects include: headache, stomach ache, dry mouth, constipation, gas, weight loss/gain, and acne. These symptoms might go away or are tolerable. New symptoms are hard to determine whether or not they are due from a new illness, the

History, causes, and symptoms of Schizophreina

1696 words - 7 pages become more apparent once the positive symptoms have responded to medication.(DSM-IV)The normal requirements for a diagnosis of Schizophrenia are the clear presence of two or more positive or negative symptoms for a duration of at least one-month. For a significant portion of the time since the onset of the disturbance, one or more major areas of functioning such as work, interpersonal relations, or self-care must have declined. Continuous signs

Insomnia and Cognitive Behavior Therapy

2574 words - 10 pages patient is instructed to remain in bed only as long as he is actually sleeping, stimulus control no activities in the bedroom except sleep and sex, and a variety of relaxation methods, particularly in the circumstance of multimodal sleep clinics (Rowe, 1995). While sleeping medication is big business, research has shown that the most successful treatment for insomnia is really cognitive behavioral therapy. This approach to psychotherapy was first

Patients' Perspectives on Medication Related Problems

595 words - 3 pages experience medication related problems was not included in the findings. The findings cannot be generalized beyond this specific group since the information gathered was dependent upon what/how the selected participants behave, feel or think. The findings featured potential implications for the success of medicine use as they created barriers to adherence. The study could have explored patients’ expectations during consultation with regards to drug therapy which would help with self management of medicines and aid adherence.

The Gaia Hypothesis

2665 words - 11 pages entity with self-regulating abilities." (University, p.2). The hypothesis interweaves various explanations of the Earth's functions as they relate to various philosophical evaluations and scientific rationale. The hypothesis can be defined through metaphors, religious beliefs, and scientific rationale. The most common metaphor is "The Earth is a single living entity." (Oceans, p. 1). Lovelock recognizes that this metaphor is a convenient way

Similar Essays

The Hmong, The Lees' Experience, And The Conflict Of Cultures

652 words - 3 pages The Hmong are a group of people who originally lived in the mountains overlooking Laos, China, Vietnam, and Thailand-- though most have since emigrated to other countries and areas due to political conflict. They have valued self-sufficiency and resisted authority throughout history, as they have constantly been the minority and often seen as the Other and persecuted for being such. Still, many have managed to survive and preserve much of their

Showing Signs Of Major Depressive Disorder

1362 words - 5 pages sleep does not help. She wants to go away where she can be by herself and not be a negative influence or burden on anyone else’s life. She is determined that she has ruined the lives of her children and her husband. Although she wants very much to return to her “old self,” she feels that this is impossible. To further prove my hypothesis I asked Mrs. M about her family history of mental illness since mood disorders greatly involves genetics

Bulimia And Depression Essay

2378 words - 10 pages using standardized psychological tests, and treatments with antidepressant medication. Supporters of the affective variant of depression hypothesis state that five different studies performed by Johnson et al. (1982), Fairburn and Cooper (1982), Abraham and Beaumont (1982), Herzog (1982), and Hatsukami et al. (1984) show that the phenomenology of bulimia suggests that bulimia is a symptom of depression. The collaboration of these studies

Theory Of Acute Pain Management Essay

1319 words - 5 pages decrease in side effects. These outcomes can be studied further or more detailed concepts can be deduced from them. Major Concepts The major concepts deduced from the hypothesis fall under three categories: (1) multimodal intervention, (2) attentive care, and (3) patient participation. Multimodal intervention includes the concepts of potent pain medication, pharmacological adjuvants, and non-pharmacological adjuvants. Attentive care relates