The Sentencing Of Butch And Willie Bosket

2687 words - 11 pages

The similarities in the lives of this father and son are uncanny. I will look at the murders committed by both Butch and Willie. They both committed two murders. I will look at the correlation between the two men and the murders they committed. I will touch on their lives and their treatment at home. In addition, how that eventually affected them and the eventual murders they both committed. Their mother has sent them both away. They were both sent to the same juvenile detention centers at different times. This affected both men differently. The psychologists gave them the same diagnosis at different times, but no one realized this at the time. It is astonishing that there was no connection made between the two men. There was bound to be tragedy in their lives given the history in this family. Butch and Willie both committed heinous crimes, but for different reasons. I will look at why I think they killed and what sentences I believe they should have gotten for killing.

When Butch was nine years old, his mother sent him away with a quarter and told him never to come back. He rode the subway for days, until he was picked up by the police and taken to court. This was in August 1950, he was sent to the Children’s Center. It would be the beginning of a lifetime of institutions for Butch. Butch had to learn at a young age to defend himself. To be the toughest kid in the institution. He had to strike first or he would get hurt. He was all he had. His mother did not want him. He learned early “that a willingness to fight was essential to survival.” (1) Butch became hard to handle at the Children’s Center. He was then sent to Wiltwyck, another institution for boys. “Wiltwick had become nationally renowned school, officially called a “residential treatment center” for emotionally disturbed boys most of them black or Hispanic.” (2) Butch had a hard life, having been in several homes for boys. His father had been in jail then went AWOL from the Army. His father had beaten him severely. He was taken back to family court after an incident with a cousin and stealing from an old woman. “Both sets of grandparents work during the day, and, apart from not being able to physically look after the defendant, they also felt they could not control him.” (3) Eventually, he was sent back to his mother in New York City. She is the one who gave him a quarter and told him to “never darken this door again”. (4)
Butch was suffering from strain, frustration-aggression theory when he committed his murders. “The concept of frustration-aggression has had a powerful influence on the field of criminology. In 1939, a group of Yale University psychologists focused on the effects of frustration-an unpleasant psychological state resulting from the failure to satisfy some need or desire-on aggressive behavior. They proposed that frustration and aggression are inextricably connected. In what became famous as the “frustration-aggression hypothesis,” they...

Find Another Essay On The Sentencing of Butch and Willie Bosket

Depictions of Self Image: A comparison of gender and persona in Butch Mystique and Rehearsing a Dream.

1048 words - 4 pages Being someone or defining who to be can be a tremendous task that can take years to accomplish. Some of us are lucky enough to be born into what we want to be and fit it correctly; others have a hard time searching and adapting to an ever changing definition of what the world would like them to be. This is the main themes of Butch Mystique by Debra A. Wilson and Rehearsing a Dream by Karen Goodman and Kirk Simon. Through this essay I will show

The Effects of Race on Sentencing in Capital Punishment Cases

1185 words - 5 pages Columbus is not alone: "A 1990 report prepared by the government's General Accounting Office found 'a pattern of evidence indicating racial disparities in the charging, sentencing and imposition of the death penalty."In an article by Seligman (1994), Professor Joseph Katz of Georgia State "and other scholars have made a separate point about bias claims based on the 'devalued lives' of murder victims." Seligman also asserts that those claiming bias

Willie Loman’s Corrupted View of the American Dream in Death of a Salesman

1075 words - 4 pages can get some attention and feel like “part of the group.” Bernard is not "well liked." by his former class mates at all. He is the total opposite of Biff. Bernard and Willie run into each other at the end of the play at Charlie’s office. Bernard tells him that he has a case in Washington and Willy says “How did you? Why didn’t he ever catch on?”(Miller 92) Miller says this because he is amazed that Bernard got as far as he did. He doesn’t

“Sleeping With The Devil” by Robert Baer: Discussion on Themes and Points Willie Williams

1145 words - 5 pages it includes; that America’s corruption on cheap oil and political stability in the Middle East was also a lucrative business relationship, America is vulnerable to economic disaster and risks of terrorism, and that America is blinded by low prices and are not seeing how culturally bribing Saudia Arabia is along with its Islamic beliefs. Corruption In the book it showed that America had a deal with the Saudi’s to get oil at the cheapest and most

Evaluate the argument that sentencing for certain types of crime is increasingly being influenced by the principles of 'retribution' and 'deterrence'.

1572 words - 6 pages A criminal justice system exists so that those who commit a crime are punished. Each type of crime carries a certain punishment or, 'sentence' that is supposed to fit the crime accordingly. Sentencing criminals to particular punishments is intended to deter them from committing more crimes and to serve as an example to others to put them off committing crimes of a similar nature. Other reasons for sentencing criminals is to gain a sense of

Truth In Sentencing Policies and the Effects on Courts and Prisons

1637 words - 7 pages . This crime act included an incentive formula grant program to build or expand correctional facilities and jails (Office of Justice Programs, 2010). According to Brian J. Ostrom, Truth in sentencing is the most prominent sentencing reform movement of the 1990s (2001). Truth in sentencing was designed to closely align the sentence imposed by the judge with the actual amount of time served in prison by restricting or eliminating parole

The mayor of casterbridge and

1206 words - 5 pages The Return of the Native and The Mayor of Casterbridge both consist of plot twists, coincidences, and a series of minor and major climaxes. However, the time involved in the novels is very different. The Return of the Native may at first seem long because it contains many plot twists, but is it in fact very compact. The whole story takes place in only about a year. In contrast, The Mayor of Casterbridge takes place over a span of twenty years

The Climax of Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom

1571 words - 6 pages The Climax of Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom Steven Spielberg directed "Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom" in 1984. It is an action/adventure movie and is set in the year 1935. The main character that plays a big part in the movie is Indiana Jones (played by Harrison Ford) who is an archaeologist with a difference. Indiana's sidekicks through out the film are Willie Scott (played by Kate Capshaw) who is a

The Causes and Effects of the Crusades

644 words - 3 pages If you ask someone if they ever heard of the Crusades the answer will most likely be yes. Does that mean that they know what the Crusades are? No. Many Jewish people who don’t know much about the Crusades assume it was merely targeted against the Jews and it resulted in the death of countless Jews. Other than that they are oblivious to the true facts. So what were the Crusades? The Crusades were great military missions embarked on by the

The Identity and History of the Caribbean

2174 words - 9 pages The Identity and History of the Caribbean The Caribbean is a vastly diverse area representing the effects of colonialism, slavery, and the combination of many cultures. Since the arrival of Europeans the Caribbean islands have been going through constant change. The loss of native peoples and the introduction of the plantation system had immediate and permanent reprocussions on the islands. The Plantation system set up a society which

The Soul and Role of the Museum

1259 words - 5 pages The soul of a museum is the essence of identity by which it is defined; it is that which makes a museum a museum. The museum has identifiable requisites without which it would not be a museum. By using creative methods of exhibition, interpretation, and education as well as effective methods of collection and conservation, the museum becomes an integral aspect and a valuable resource in society. There are unique distinctions between the museum

Similar Essays

Butch Cassidy And The Sundance Kid

3473 words - 14 pages One of the more popular movies of the 1960s was Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid , which featured Paul Newman and Robert Redford as the two titled Western outlaws. The film portrays the careers of Butch and Sundance, and how they were forced by the law to leave the Wild West for South America. In the last scene of the movie, the two bandits are shown surrounded by a bunch of South American soldiers after a robbery-gone-bad. Facing

U.S. Supreme Court And The Impact Of Sentencing

1753 words - 7 pages . (Peter Finn and Dale Parent, June 1993) One of the sentencing provisions that are mandated in the jurisdiction of Georgia includes a standardized set of standards. These standards are an attempt to minimize recidivism and maintain control of the court mandated conditions. The surveillance standards for the probation officers are as follows: ? Five face-to-face contacts per week ? Mandatory community service ? Mandatory employment ? Mandatory

Butch Cassidy And The Sundance Kid Movie Review

625 words - 3 pages that Butch had described at all. This is a time where Sundance could have left with Etta and never talked to Butch again, but he stuck through it as a good friend always does. This shows how strong the bonds of friendship are in this movie and shows how it can affect their lives both negatively and positively.Butch Cassidy and The Sundance Kid was directed by George Roy Hill in October of 1969. Paul Newman and Robert Redford star in this modern

The Basic Procedures Of A Standard American Criminal Trial...Covers Everything Between Indictment And Sentencing.

2633 words - 11 pages not occur and the subject goes directly to a sentencing hearing, or he may plead not guilty, and trial preparations will proceed. In very rare cases the defendant will not enter a plea, and is said to 'stand mute.' Directly after entering a plea of not guilty, the defendant must decide on one, if any, of many courses of defense to follow. A plea of guilty or no contest that is withdrawn by the defendant cannot be used as evidence against the