This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Shepherd's Passionate Heartbreak...Or Is It?

1217 words - 5 pages

Written only a year apart, Christopher Marlowe's The Passionate Shepherd to His Love (1599) and its seemingly-contradictory retort, Sir Walter Raleigh's The Nymph's Reply to the Shepherd (1600), collectively set a fascinating scene. During my first read through of each of the poems, the plot seemed fairly clear to me. My ignorance allowed me to believe that Marlowe's poem was simply about a confession of love in an eloquent fashion and that Sir Walter Raleigh's reply was merely a rejection of that very confession. I was even entertained by the conviction of The Nymph's Reply to the Shepherd in that every line of The Passionate Shepherd to His Love was individually countered and shut down. For example, "...we will sit upon the rocks," and "See[] the shepherds feed their flocks" being replied to with "Time drives the flocks from field to fold, when rivers rage and rocks grow cold;" which I interpreted as "the birds flew away and the rocks are going to get cold because I'm not going to sit with you". I can honestly say that my initial reaction was relating this to the Elizabethan Era equivalent of a modern day "internet troll" on an online blog where someone rejects every word another says just for the heck of it. After committing to the poems and deciphering some of the actual meanings of the lines, I was not only able to come to the realization that there is significantly more value within each poem, but that I was possibly even wrong about the nymph's reply being a rejection.
When reading these two poems, even someone as full of ignorance as myself can realize that the two drastically different tones. The Passionate Shepherd to His Love describes everything with most optimistic, paint a happy picture in your head sort of way, while The Nymph's Reply to the Shepherd leaves you feeling cold and lonely (which goes to show without saying that the imagery of both poems is compelling). Both poems are written with the same AABB rhyming scheme with quatrains and closed form. The second matching the first most likely being done to make it clear that it was a response to the first, as if the title wouldn't be enough. The use of rhetorical devices occurs throughout each poem as well, such as the alliteration "Time drives the flocks from field to fold," found in the reply. After going through this closer examination of the poems, I came to the realization that Sir Walter Raleigh's poem may not have been a rejection to the first after all. Despite the entire poem leading up to seem as it were that way, the last stanza reads:
"But could youth last and love still breed,
Had joys no date nor age no need,
Then these delights my mind might move
To live with thee and be thy love."
and after reading over this more carefully, I began to interpret this as the Nymph putting everything else mentioned aside and the "delights" of being able "to live with thee and be thy love" would be enough to change her mind. This effect seemed to take the role of a...

Find Another Essay On The Shepherd's Passionate Heartbreak...Or is it?

The Internet: Is it Helping or Hurting Us

888 words - 4 pages damaging the mental faculties we need to process and understand lengthy textual information.” In Nicholas Carr’s, The Shallows, he writes, “Over the past few years I’ve had an uncomfortable sense that someone, or something, has been tinkering with my brain, remapping the neural circuitry, reprogramming the memory.”(Shallows). That is what technology has done to all of us over the years. It has shaped the way we look at articles and the way

The Nature of Aggression (or is it Nurture?)

1439 words - 6 pages The Nature of Aggression (or is it Nurture?) Every night on the news there are reports about murders, wars, and rapes. But the news isn't the only place where people encounter violent or aggressive behavior. Driving home from work, people get cut off and cussed at on a daily basis. At school, children fight over who will be the first in the lunch line. On the street, people get pushed out of the way if they are not walking fast enough. The

The evils of technology or is it our choice?

1653 words - 7 pages undesirable consequences. Whether a technology is for good or for ill must be our choice. We can use it to enrich our lives or to let our lives lose all meaning. Sometimes a technology is so pervasive that we cannot escape it, but often we have the freedom to choose. The microwave oven is a good example of a technology whose unanticipated consequences can be rejected if we so choose. We don't always have to accept the fast food approach if we choose

News Is it prime time or all the time?

1174 words - 5 pages News Is it prime time or all the time? Media influence has become a social mainstay in contemporary society. Not only do newspapers, radio, television and magazines strive to inform and entertain, but they also hold a significant power over what people believe. Since its inception, the standard of media presence was long a tool of integrity and fairness. Newspersons and entertainers may have embellished here and there in order to put more

Power is essentially the ability to act or do, it

1414 words - 6 pages Power is essentially the ability to act or do, it warrants a mechanical advantage, influence or authority. Both Brave New World and Animal Farm are dystopian novels in which a fundamentalist extremist society takes over. In such societies conformity is essential, consequently conformity and power are inextricably linked, thus power has an unavoidable shadow…struggle.In both novels the society is born out of some form of anarchy or

SB 1070; Is It The Right Law or Not?

1331 words - 5 pages that all illegals can be caught and deported. The only way this poses a threat is if you refuse to hand over or argue you thta you don’t have to Give your documents to the officer. The next question is why is racial profiling is used in identifying illegal immigrants. As a matter fact, it is the most effective way to identify illegal immigrants. In 1954 US INS began “Operation Wetback, which was intended for to remove one million illegal immigrants

Homework: Is It Busy Work Or Really Worth The Time?

1882 words - 8 pages given homework packets, which only help them understand specific terms. This type of homework leaves a student feeling unmotivated to complete the assignment or they do not particularly care what they write for the definition so they do not actually learn the material. While this type of assignment may or may not be completed by students in the way it was intended, it is still widely used in classrooms. From my own experiences, I remember

Should We Abolish the Death Penalty, or is it Reliable?

1086 words - 5 pages the Washington Post further continues this reason by asserting that, “Those who oppose the death penalty or think it's imposed too frequently don't disagree that terrible crimes deserve severe punishment. But this is not about absolving criminals. It's about our nation's core values and how the rest of the world sees us” (Dionne). The opposing side agrees with the need for punishment. However, it claims that the way the punishment is conducted

The Internet, is it a privilege or a necessity?

1053 words - 5 pages The Internet, is it a privilege or a necessity? Dyson contends that there is an unequal access to computers because the computer and software industries are being forced to “upgrade their products constantly and new products remain out of the reach of the poor.” (Dyson, 1997) Barbour’s article simply states, “once we allow technology to define the good life, we have excluded many important human values from consideration.” (Barbour, 1993) The

A look into the Matrix. Is it science fiction or is it Fantasy?

650 words - 3 pages As I sat in my nightmare and vision class, and watched the move The Matrix with the rest of my peers, I couldn't help but wonder if The Matrix was a work of science fiction, or if it was more a fantasy movie. It wasn't until I was done watching the movie did I realize that it was indeed a science fiction movie. Although many might disagree, I feel that the matrix is science fiction for many reasons. The film The Matrix is science fiction

Hamlet: "Madness, or Is it?"

914 words - 4 pages act mad, but that?s all it will be, an act. Only a sane person could devise a plan to convince other people he or she is mad when he or she is actually in total control of his or her mind.Only in the presence of certain characters does Hamlet take up his act of madness. When Hamlet is around Polonius, Claudius, Gertrude, Ophelia, Rosencrantz, and Guildenstern, he turns on the madness act to perfection. When he is around Horatio, Marcellus

Similar Essays

Is It The Author, Or His Content?

1788 words - 8 pages literature from authors such as “Plato, Aristotle, Euclid, Plutarch, and many other writers of the ancient world” (“About”). Today, much of Card’s interests as a child still coincide with his interests as an adult, and typically can be found in most of his literary work. Card once wrote that “there is always moral instructions whether the writer inserts it deliberately or not… but when [he] write[s] without deliberately expressing moral teachings

Is It Cute Or Crossing The Line?

1146 words - 5 pages audience and give young girls a sense of maturity. Witnesses of the photograph understood Morin’s intent, but most of the concern arises from the fact, that if an individual were to have taken the photo in different circumstances, it would be identified at child pornography. Personally, it does not seem as though Morin wanted to sexually promote her child-based line, but coincidentally, she did this. Knowing it is a lingerie line for young girls

This Essay Is About The Novel "Until They Bring The Streetcars Back" By Auther Stanley Gordon West. It Is A Very Interesting Story Of Love, Heartbreak, And Saving One Young Girls Life

663 words - 3 pages didn't want her to be with anyone who was in jail. The next week he heard even worse news. Tom and Lola were back together again. He thought then that he should just give up on Lola because it would only end in heartbreak. When Cal got out of jail he tried to call Lola and disguise his voice but her mom said that she wasn't allowed to talk to him. Even when Cal stopped by the school to try and talk to her she said that she wasn't allowed to talk

The Retorical Triangel: Is It Effective Or Not?

995 words - 4 pages The Rhetorical Triangle: Is it Effective or Not? The rhetorical triangle is a technique used to utilize and compose thoughts in a way that appeal to and persuade an audience. The three components that base these persuasions are pathos (emotions), ethos (creditability), and logos (reasoning). Many creditable people have used the rhetorical triangle in their speeches showing this technique to be effective. Abraham Lincoln, the nation’s sixteenth