The Short Story ‘This Is What It Means To Say

904 words - 4 pages

The short story 'This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona,' has various locations or settings. These include different locations on the reservation, the airplane, the trailer in Phoenix, and the long road through Nevada. Do these settings have any influence on the character actions? To further understand how each of the different settings affects the story's plot we can look at each individual location in detail. As we read the book we are left to wonder if the characters are led to act as they did and whether or not crises or conflicts are also created because of the settings.The first setting is at the reservation and this occurs after Victor loses his job and his luck takes the nastiest of turns when he is told that his father had died. When Victor, approaches the tribal council and informs them that he needs financial assistance and they offer him what they have available, we get the impression that he objects.When one thinks about how the people on this particular reservation have no use for money, why would Victor who apparently has no form of savings feel like he deserves more than he was offered? His statement 'that's not even enough for a plane ticket' leaves us wondering if he is difficult to please or if he is just being unreasonable in this situation? When he is at the Trading Post and is waiting in line, Thomas approaches Victor and starts to talk to him, Victor is embarrassed because all the other Indians are staring at them. One is left to wonder if this because Thomas happens to be the community's 'outcast', or if Victor is afraid that the people will say he finally talked to a man (Thomas) he had ignored for years because he is hoped that Thomas had the finances to get him to Phoenix. Maybe in this case the saying 'desperate times call for desperate measures', is a very good example, after all this is a man who he had mistreated for years.When two men are finally aboard the plane, coach section and on their way to Phoenix, Thomas strikes up a conversation with a woman who happens to be a gymnast is in the seat next to them.When she mentions how the government had boycotted the 1980 Olympic Games, Thomas tells her that she apparently has a lot in common with the Indians even though she does not realize it and even though he is considered one of the wisest people in Spokane, I guess even the wisest mind has something to learn. He gets his lesson when Victor goes on to tell him that her conversing with them was all...

Find Another Essay On The short story ‘This Is What It Means to Say

“This I Believe” about the Good Life: What it Means to an Immigrant

2793 words - 11 pages people are motivated and productive. This is the attitude that governs the decision that I make in my everyday life. On the opposite end of the spectrum, Americans follow the proverb ‘time is money.’ Everyone works hard and people are motivated to achieve their goals. Although, in every country the rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer. It is possible to change that by working hard. One can live a good life if he or she

"What is Democracy" This is an essay written about democracy. It a reaction of an average person as to what democracy means to them. This is not a step by step definition of the political system

1354 words - 5 pages ironies of these facts is that most citizens of democratic countries do not know what the word democracy means and what it represents. "A citizen of America will cross the ocean to fight for democracy, but wont cross the street to vote in a national election." Bill VaughanThe Oxford dictionary defines democracy as government by the people, direct or representative. In Canada we have a representative democracy that allows us to pick our political

This short story is called "Fight For Justice". it is a story about war and the horror of battle

1117 words - 4 pages bomb go off. When we looked into our binoculars, we saw that the building was blown to little bits and there wasn't one part that stayed. While meticulously scouring the area, I found the impossibly hard to find goldish-yellowish light again. This light helped save 3 lives in this brutal and hard-core war between the national army and the state security. I wonder, will this war ever be over? Who would win? Well, after everything is done with, I will write another short story about the tales of the battle of hope and encouragement.

This is an essay about what golding is trying to say abot human nature in lord of the flies

700 words - 3 pages survive.First, looking at the setting for the book, one can see that it has its non-civilized qualities. It is an island. There is neither order nor rules. This set the stage for the boys to become the savages they do. Without the rules and order of society what will young, unlearned boys do? They will lose what little knowledge of society they had at their age. This is very, very evident at the end of the book. By the end of the book, Jack and his

This essay is called "to build or not to build" it is talking about the log house in the short story "shiloh" by Bobbie Ann Manson. it is 4 pages and includes themes of love and marriage

944 words - 4 pages taking the time to ask, Leroy does not understand why Norma Jean would not want to live in this log house. He never reveals the true reason of why he wants to build this house; however, it is clearly obvious that he believes that it would be the key to saving their marriage. Despite Leroy's strong determination to build this log house, his wife on the other hand, has extremely contradicting wishes.Norma Jean is a very unhappy woman, she wants to

Puritan Law as Hawthorne Views it. What is Hawthorn trying to say about puritan law? The Scarlet Letter Nathaniel Hawthorn

769 words - 3 pages , purposely implanted in them, thereby insulting their beloved God rather than following Him and all of His decisions. It is generally believed that Puritan culture is exceedingly religious in all aspects of their community. Why then would a culture so God-focused attempt to change the very thing that makes them God's creatures: human nature? But to know the "why," the "what" must be known and understood. In this case, the "what" would be: how the

This essay is about the short story "the test".

762 words - 3 pages it shouldn't be accepted. Given the times (1940's), Mrs. Ericson would have risked quite a bit (status, friends, acceptance) had she stood up for Marian; however I believe that is part of what teaching is all about.I believe that people are still fighting in this societal war. Going against the mass majority of your peers is never easy; however when a child is involved, the consequences are trivial. Mrs. Ericson failed Marian is so many ways. Pre-service teachers, who read this story, should take away the importance of supporting your students. Every student deserves to feel believed in.

"The Definition of Life (Or is it?)" Question: What does it mean to say something is alive, conscious, and/or intelligent? Requirements: 1000-2000 words

1529 words - 6 pages machine consciousness could be met and machines could finally be considered alive. Testing for this could be a major problem, though. With a person, we could ask questions like, "Are you conscious? Do you understand what it means to be conscious?" However, with machines, this process would be very difficult because the machine could just be engineered to simply state the right answers. We also can’t detect consciousness from nonverbal actions

An essay on a short story from the "riverside reader". This essay is a responce to the short story Harrison Bergeron By Kurt Vonnegut.

737 words - 3 pages Vonnegut and forced him to develop it into a short story. Those who are familiar with Kurt Vonnegut's writing will certainly recognize some other themes of this story. For example the fear of de-humanization of human beings, being stuck in amber (Harrisons inability to overthrow the system) and so forth. In "Harrison Bergeron", Kurt Vonnegut presented a scary view of a future society, where everyone was equal. "Nobody was smarter than anybody else

What It Means To Be A Man

869 words - 3 pages taught the physical characteristics of a man and we were to accept that as what a man truly was. This is where I start my definition far longer than the two previous.In my short-lived life to the best of my knowledge I have come up with what I believe is the true definition of a man. I've narrowed it down to what some would say is a symbol, but I would say is so much more. I've come to realize that there is no age limit or requirement for one to

how accurate is it to say Eisenhower

1165 words - 5 pages How accurate is it to say that Eisenhower's 'New Look' foreign policy increased tensions between the superpowers in the period 1953-60?Tensions had begun to arise between the Soviet Union and the West even before World War II was over. The Soviets had soon developed a powerful nuclear arsenal whilst Stalin's death in 1953 resulted in there being increased uncertainty as to the relations between the communists and capitalists. However, whilst it

Similar Essays

Camaraderie In "This Is What It Means To Say Phoenix"

743 words - 3 pages Thesis: In, This is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona, Victor's father's death leads to the many stories about their childhood that makes them reconsider their friendship. I. Mother Theresa once said, "Kind words can be short and easy to speak but there are truly endless." A. As Victor and Thomas approached the door to the trailer Victor says, "I never told you I was sorry for beating you up that one time." B. He does not

This Is What It Means To Say Phoenix, Arizona: Stereotypes

1356 words - 5 pages cardboard box which contained half of his father”(Alexie). This quote shows that Victor and Thomas share the same father. By inflicting violence towards his brother, whom they share blood, Victor is establishing a separation between him and his family. Not only does Victor express anger towards his heritage, but Victor also expresses feelings of hatred toward his father. The title of the short story, “This Is What It Means To Say Phoenix, Arizona

This Is What It Means To Say Pheonix, Arizona: Theme Paper

623 words - 2 pages if my father had died, just because it was so ridiculous.In closing, I think that this was a story that was meant to teach you something: optimism is one of the only effective weapons against depression and the troubles that cause it. I think that without Thomas in this story, it would have been a lot harder for Victor to make it through in one piece. We can all learn from Thomas's example and I think that Sherman Alexie did a very good job of displaying the theme that I found throughout the story.

This Is Waht It Means To Say Pheonix, Arizona, By Sherman Alexie

874 words - 3 pages In “This Is What It Means To Say Phoenix Arizona,” found in The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven, by Sherman Alexie, we are reintroduced to Victor and learn that his father has passed away. Victor and his childhood friend Thomas Build-the-Fire’s embark on a journey to Arizona to obtain Victor’s father’s ashes. Thomas reveals that he had made an assurance to Victor's father years before to help him when the time came. Although Victor had