The Significance Of Reparations In The Context Of Mass Atrocity

5086 words - 20 pages

Hugh Munro 73876776 DIPL403: Ethics and International Relations Research PaperThe Significance of Reparative Justice in the Context of Mass Atrocity:By Hugh MunroReparations are often described as those measures which are taken to eliminate the moral dissonance that exists between perpetrator and victim after the former acts in a way that harms or violates the rights of the latter. The perpetrator of such an act is said to have an obligation to pay some form of reparation to the victim who has a corresponding entitlement to that reparation. But what about acts so atrocious that no amount of reparation could possibly make up for the loss suffered by the victims? Acts of torture and mass murder seem to create a moral gulf so deep that rather than being reparative, reparations can appear insulting or meaningless. My aim in this essay is to consider what meaning and significance programs of reparative justice can hope to aim for in situations which involve mass murder, torture, or any other atrocious act that can be deemed beyond the scope of full compensation. I will start by discussing what constitutes a relevant relationship when considering reparative justice and suggest that the passage of time and state-continuity have a significant impact on perpetrator - victim based relationships. I will use arguments made by Thompson (2002), who suggests we must take an 'obligations-dependent' approach to reparative justice, and Waldron (1992), who emphasises the need to see justice as a prospective enterprise, to suggest that the relevant relationship is not strictly between perpetrator and victim. My next section will build on this assertion and argue that the relevant relationship in reparative considerations needs to be based on relations of respect between individuals in the present who have inherited an unjust past rather than on perpetrator-victim based relationships. I will explain that this shift in the relevant relationship for reparative justice is accompanied by a change in the form that reparation programs will take by pointing out a shift in the literature which focuses on more symbolic reparative measures as opposed to pure compensation. I will argue that a focus on symbolic reparations does not preclude the need for monetary or material reparations and that when the harm is nonmonetary, monetary repair takes on a symbolic role. My next section will then introduce an argument made by Adrian Vermeule that provides a defence for the intuition that even though a first-best, fully compensatory reparative program may be impossible, it may nevertheless be prudent, or indeed mandatory, to enact some form of compensation anyway. Vermeule calls this intuition 'Rough Justice'. I will end this section by pointing out that ultimately the force of the 'Rough Justice' intuition is negative and is therefore too vague to make a meaningful contribution to reparative justice. It is at this point that I will suggest that the focus of reparations must be shifted...

Find Another Essay On The significance of Reparations in the context of mass atrocity

The Significance of the Players in Hamlet

935 words - 4 pages The Significance of the Players in Hamlet      Most characters in Hamlet present themselves as something other than themselves or how as we, the audience, or another character thinks they should appear.  Two of the main characters in this play, Hamlet and King Claudius, are constantly acting as something other than their true nature.    Ironically, the characters that invoke changes in Hamlet and King Claudius to reveal their real

The Significance of the Handkerchief in Othello

1079 words - 4 pages How can one small piece of fabric manifest so much havoc? In William Shakespeare’s Othello, there is great significance of a powerful symbol that completely alters the fate of the story. “In the case of the handkerchief, it stands for several things, things that cannot be seen” (Hacht 663). This symbol, the handkerchief, is given to Desdemona by Othello, as a token of his love, and to their new beginnings as husband and wife. However, the

The Significance of Forests

1158 words - 5 pages Introduction Forests can shape our landscape; they can provide immeasurable appeal to rural and peri-urban areas, defining the inherent landscape character. Furthermore, the significance of design interpretation can facilitate management objectives and outcomes; particularly in proximity to centers of population. Wherein, the community has an affinity, vested interest, general interest or typically a fear of change. Historic landscape design

The Significance of Childhood

1227 words - 5 pages The Significance of Childhood “No dictator, no invader, can hold an imprison population by force of arms forever.” – J. Michael Straczynski. Equality 7-2521 is imprisoned under the Council’s rule, along with the rest of his society, where being different and defying the brotherhood could lead to death. Anthem by Ayn Rand is about Equality 7-2521 discovering himself as an individual, and rebelling against the conformist strategies of the

The Significance of Style

1277 words - 5 pages The Significance of Style Robert Burton, lifelong scholar and librarian in the 16th century, wrote: “It is most true, stylus virum arguit,--our style betrays us” (qtd. in Bartlett). Whether inserting the most complicated words possible in order to sound scholarly, littering sentences by overusing slang and contractions, or keeping every sentence to a tight structure of subject, verb, object with no variation—these elements of

The Significance of ?Xenia?

1435 words - 6 pages custom is seen when Menelaus sends Telemachus and Nestor's son on their way. He gives them precious and expensive gifts. What is the reason for this customs? What is their meaning and significance? If this friendliness did not exist among the characters in the book, Odysseus would never be able to go to his homeland, Ithaca. There would not have been a homecoming that long, and may be the plot of the story would have been different, if Homer did

the significance of suffering

1567 words - 6 pages When comparing and contrasting the novel, My sister's keeper written by Jodi Piccoult and the film The fault in our stars directed by Josh Boone, there are both differences and similarities in the techniques used to explore the theme of purposeful and necessary suffering. Both authors display the impact on cancer sufferers inevitably bound up with the conundrum of why sickness, suffering and grief exist. The theme of purposeful suffering has

The Significance of Family

2218 words - 9 pages The first topic for this paper will be to discuss the significance of family. Early on in the course, class began with an exercise presented in which we were instructed to define “family”. Almost immediately it was clear that individuals each have their own definitions of what they hold as their belief of family. There were also strong opinions with regard to how the textbook defined family. There were lengthy discussion on different types

The Significance of Language in Dramatic Productions

2043 words - 8 pages The Significance of Language in Dramatic Productions The significance of language in any dramatic production, or indeed any piece of performance art, be it song, poetry or whatever, is undoubtedly of great importance, as it is not only the medium through which

Significance of the Women in Sophocles' Antigone

2556 words - 10 pages Significance of the Women in Antigone                 Michael J. O’Brien in the Introduction to Twentieth Century Interpretations of Oedipus Rex, maintains that there is “a good deal of evidence to support this view” that the fifth century playwright was the “educator of his people” and a “teacher” (4). Sophocles in his tragedy Antigone teaches about “morally desirable attitudes and behavior,” (4) and uses a woman as heroine and another

The Significance of Rhetoric in Music.

621 words - 2 pages other. As I shed some light on the subject, I hope you will come to agree that rhetoric is important in music.To start off, music is a communicative language. Music is a language that can be understood without uttering a single word. Yet sometime we find it necessary to add a bit of poetry to it. Rhetoric comes into context as soon as communication is involved. Musical communication comes to us in the form of melody and/or lyrics. Music tells us

Similar Essays

The Methodology Of Context In Photography

1849 words - 8 pages , is the context in which it is meant to be viewed by a particular audience. One single picture, after all, could appear drastically different alongside an article in a newspaper than it would if it were to be framed and hung alongside other photos on a museum wall. This idea is especially prevalent in the pieces shown in the exhibition Freedom Now! Forgotten Photographs of the Civil Rights Struggle, wherein several photos are both seen as a

The Importance Of Context In Understanding Literature

3857 words - 15 pages an attempt to discover the meaning of a word in a poem or the poem as a whole does one thing- that is, he substitutes one word for another or indulges in a play with words. Reader Response critics believed that the meaning lies not in the texts but in the minds of the reader. For them, a text does not exist without a reader. They, too, focused on a context but from a point of view of the reader. The readers according to his/her own experience

The Subjection Of Women: In Today’s Context

1339 words - 5 pages education, women conform into believing that conventional “womanly” characters were most desirable. Mill’s analysis is grounded in the context of Victorian period Britain, where conservative ideals were common in practice and in law. Mill’s analysis of the subjection of women can most clearly be seen through Victorian conservatism. In mid-Victorian Britain women were denied entry into higher education, many male professions and completely from

The Significance Of The Blues In History

2204 words - 9 pages music. According to Douglas Henry Daniels in his “The significance of Blues for American History,” the blues are singular significance for understanding the American historical experience, which has the tragi-comic characteristics of music (Daniels 14). The blues are a truthful depiction of the spirit of the American experience. The blues will continue to inform future generations of how we as Americans have moved forward and how the blues