The Simulation Theory And Explanations That Make Sense Of Behavior

3569 words - 14 pages

The Simulation Theory and Explanations that ‘Make Sense of Behavior’

ABSTRACT: Underlying the current debate between simulation theory and theory theory is the assumption that folk psychological explanations of behavior are causal. Simulationists Martin Davies, Tony Stone, and Jane Heal claim that folk psychological explanations are explanations that make sense of another person by citing the thoughts important to the determination of his behavior on a given occasion. I argue that it is unlikely these explanations will be causal. Davis et al. base their claim on the assumption that a certain isomorphism obtains between the cognitive mechanisms of human beings. Investigation into the nature of the isomorphism required reveals that it is of a sort that is unlikely to obtain. I suggest that in order to maintain their challenge to theory theory, simulationists must either motivate and describe a non-causal simulation-based account of folk psychological explanation or else delineate a causal account that attributes a nonessential, heuristic role to simulation.

I. Introduction

Much interest has been raised recently in cognitive science and in the philosophy of mind by a debate that focuses on the nature of the cognitive mechanism that underlies our folk psychological practices. One side in this debate is represented by proponents of the reigning paradigm, the theory theory. Theory theorists say that our ability to give explanations, predictions and interpretations of intentional behavior is subserved by tacit knowledge of an internally-represented theory of commonsense psychology (Fodor 1987). The simulation theory challenges this view on the grounds that there is no evidence to support the suggestion that we have such knowledge and some evidence to suppose that we do not (Gordon 1986: Goldman 1989). It is more likely, say simulationists, that these abilities are simply underpinned by the innate capacity to simulate others.

Simulationists argue that a compelling case can be made against the theory theory. I do not discuss that case here. Instead I address an issue which, although crucial to the outcome of the debate, has not yet been examined. This issue concerns the nature of the commonsense psychological explanations produced by the mechanism whose functioning both theories claim to describe.

Two assumptions bring the issue of explanation to the fore. One of these pertains to the range and the other to the type of event that the theories are adduced to account for. The merits of the theory theory and the simulation theory are usually discussed in relation to the practice of the prediction of intentional behavior. The reasonable assumption, (assumption A), is that the mechanism that is deployed in prediction will be the same one that is deployed in the explanation, the description and the interpretation of our own and others’ behavior. The second assumption, (assumption B), is that the two theories offer competing accounts of the...

Find Another Essay On The Simulation Theory and Explanations that Make Sense of Behavior

Can We Make Sense of the World Without a Deity?

1373 words - 6 pages and very hot mass) that rapidly began to expand, and is still expanding to this day. Once the universe began to cool down, energy started to transform into subatomic particles, then atoms, eventually creating the elements necessary to form large planets, solar systems and galaxies. Combinations of complex mathematics, physics, and astronomy were used in the creation of this theory, allowing to make sense of the origin of space and time without a

Theory of Criminal Behavior Essay

949 words - 4 pages crime and easy apprehension of criminals due to the ability to detect their next move. 5.0 Conclusion Form the research carried out, it is evident that there is no single theory which can adequately provide all the explanations in relation to crime since a crime patterns entail several phenomena. It is important to note that much as criminological theories attempt to explain the causes of criminal behavior, other measures that are not necessarily theoretical, can be employed in order to fight and reduce crime rates. On the same note, further research has to be carried out so that crime rates can be further reduced.

Effect of Male Stream Knowledge on Sociological Explanations of Behavior

3688 words - 15 pages Effect of Male Stream Knowledge on Sociological Explanations of Behavior One effect of male stream knowledge in sociological explanations of behaviour is that men tend to be very much in favour of positivist methods, like scientific research and proof. Whereas feminists think that the sympathetic approach is better therefore using things like observations, this mainly due to the fact that positivist research has

Examine Functionalist and Marxist explanations of the family.

662 words - 3 pages Functionalists and Marxist diverse had views on the family. Functionalist theory asserts that there will be a specific pattern of family organisation corresponding to different types of society. Hence there is a particular family form that best suits the conditions of industrial society.The family described by modern functionalists is very much a description of the sort of families they might have been brought up within and formed them. This is

The Psychological Explanations of Rape

1005 words - 4 pages . This proves problematic as many people's explanations and definitions of rape are quite different to that of the law. Social science theorists argue that rape is a learned action with which society plays a crucial role, Ellis (1989). Based on this theory it seems only logical to propose that there should be differing definitions and explanations of rape from generation to generation. A good example to consider is that of older generations who

Overview of Social Structural Explanations and Cultural Explanations

1672 words - 7 pages into, make it very hard for them to achieve the same level of education that someone born in a more privileged social world would have. The other main method of explaining societal problems is looking at “cultural” explanations and forces. Culture is commonly defined as “the sharing of outlooks and modes of behaviors that are sustained through social interaction within a community and often transmitted from generation to generation” (Williams

The explanations of Gluten Intolerance.

814 words - 3 pages are appropriate for different types of food. Thus soft flour is used for cakes, harder flour for pastry, hard flour for bread and hardest or durum for pasta.Gluten Intolerance or Celiac disease is a digestive disease that damages the small intestine and interferes with absorption of nutrients from food. People who have celiac disease can not tolerate a protein called gluten that is found in wheat, rye and barley. Gluten is found in mainly in foods

Consider the amount of price variation that you have found. Discuss possible explanations and include those relating to "tourist trap" or other models based on imperfect consumer information.

1806 words - 7 pages an analysis to describe a market with limited information about a product's quality is Akerlof's (1970) classic analysis of the market for lemons. It is shown that in a market where sellers have perfect information and consumers have extremely limited information, a market may not exist, or only the lowest-quality product may be sold. By applying Akerlof's theory, *sellers knows whether a camera rarely needs repairs (a good camera) or frequently

Explore the question "what is psychology?" Provide clear definitions and explanations that demonstrate your knowledge of it's historical development then conclude with a definition.

1528 words - 6 pages This essay will explore the question of what psychology is and how it became what it is. Of course there is no universally accepted answer to this ongoing question of how to define the subject. The British Psychological Society, for instance, state on their website that "psychology is the scientific study of people, the mind and behaviour" (1), whereas the American Psychological Association define it as "the scientific study of the behavior of

Strategic Management Accounting and the Contributions that It Can Make to the Success of Organizations

1837 words - 7 pages During the late 1980s, criticisms of traditional management accounting practices were widely publicized and new approaches, which were more in tune with the current competitive and business environment, emerged (Drury, 2002, p923). A particularly effective approach was strategic management accounting (SMA). However, Tomkins and Carr (quoted in Drury, 2008, p.570) note that there is no comprehensive definition of SMA, even though it has received

Definition of Organizational Behavior. How most people think OB is common sense and the study of OB. It is a 600 word paper, in ARP format.

609 words - 2 pages This paper is basically about what I have learned in this first week of class, "Organizational Behavior", an issue I will carry with me throughout my life. Organizational Behavior, as defined in the book, states: "OB is the study of what people think, feel, and do in and around organizations." There is really no better way of saying that, but in my own works, I think a definition for OB could state- "A field of study that looks at the impact

Similar Essays

The Use Of Psychoanalysis To Make Sense Of Human Behavior

2711 words - 11 pages is just extremely difficult to confirm. This essay discusses whether the story of psychoanalysis, used to make sense of human behaviour, can ever be confirmed as a story of truth. Freud’s psychoanalytic theory showed how the mind can be seen as three parts, the ‘id’ (the primitive unconscious part of the personality that deals with pleasure), the ‘ego’ (dominates the conscious mind and carries out ‘secondary process thinking’) and the

There Are Two Methods – Common Sense Explanations And Social Science Theories – By Which Human Behavior Can Be Explained. Which Method Do You Think Is Better In Accounting For Human Behavior And Why?

789 words - 3 pages people are using common sense explanation to interpret human behavior, while social scientists will explain our world by social science theories. What are they? And which one can give a more reliable and accurate account for human behavior?Common Sense Explanations are formed basing on individual's past experiences or were passed down from the last generations. It is the most basic and simple form of knowledge that helps us to survive. For

Psychoanalytic And Phenomenological Explanations Of Persistent Antisocial Criminal Behavior

2209 words - 9 pages persistent antisocial criminal behavior remains to be explained with concrete facts. Both the phenomenological and psychoanalytic theories offer reasonable explanations of the causes of such criminal behavior. While each has its own strengths and weaknesses, I find the phenomenological theory to provide a better explanation because I believe that one's upbringing and surrounding environment play a bigger role in life than the unconscious, as

Using Accounts That You Are Familiar With Examine And Assess Sociological Explanations Of The Underclass.

1070 words - 4 pages unable to take advantage of any opportunities that may occur in their lifetime.Charles Murray (1990) developed a New Right underclass theory based on the findings of Lewis and his belief that that there was a culture of welfare dependency within the underclass system. Murray suggested that single parents were at the heart of the problem as they were enforcing their children with ideals of an anti-education culture and argues that the main