The Sin Of The Scarlet Letter

638 words - 3 pages - cullionssecure ✓ Expert Reviewed

Hester Prynne's adulterous affair in The Scarlet Letter has made the book a controversy since its publication. Many conservative critics have challenged its morality and its effects on literature. A year after the book was published, Reverend Arthur Coxe, a church pastor who believes that the book degrades our literature, strongly criticizes how the author depicts sin in a sympathetic, positive light. Although I accept his statements that the book sympathizes with Hester and her sin, I also believe The Scarlet Letter denounces sin by exploring the struggles and hardships that both Hester and Dimmesdale have to confront throughout the novel.
In The Scarlet Letter, Hawthorne tells the story of Hester Prynne, who struggles because of the public denunciations that she faces for committing the sin of having an extramarital affair. As the story progresses, the perception of her sin grows less severe, until the symbol that represents her sin no longer carries its immoral meaning. The townspeople “[refuse] to interpret the scarlet A by its original signification...it meant Able; so strong was Hester [Prynne’s] strength” (Hawthorne 148). Therefore, Coxe’s point is valid when he argues that Hawthorne shines a positive light upon her iniquity, which is reflected in his argument that in The Scarlet Letter, “the whole tendency of the conversation is to suggest sympathy for their sin” (2).
Although the readers sympathize with the characters, it is because Hester and Dimmesdale are suffering for their sin and not “wallowing in their filth” (Coxe 2). Coxe states that Hawthorne “[creates] unavoidable sympathy with unrepenting sorrow, and deliberate, premeditated sin” (2). However, I believe that Coxe is mistaken because he overlooks the fact that both Hester and Dimmesdale have to bear their sins throughout the whole novel. Throughout The Scarlet Letter, Hester is mistreated and discriminated because of her sin, which is distinguished by a bright red letter on her bosom. She has to confront the whispers, the criticism,...

Similar Essays

Resolution of Sin in The Scarlet Letter.

542 words - 2 pages of their daughter, Pearl. This sin had a huge impact on them and changed their lives forever. It is what the book The Scarlet Letter is all about and how different the characters dealt with it.Hester Prynne has a strength of character. She is very honest so she openly acknowledges her sin. Hester stands on the scaffold, exposed to public humiliation...

Analysis of Sin in The Scarlet Letter

1683 words - 7 pages is vast; Hawthorne critically explores the strict, inflexible Puritanical approach to sin and its implication for individuals and society. Hawthorne investigates the intent behind sin in The Scarlet Letter using Dimmesdale and Chillingworth in order to criticize the Puritan Code and to demonstrate the ramifications intent can have on the sinner’s ability to earn forgiveness and gain redemption. Dimmesdale’s and Hester’s sin of adultery serves...

The Nature of Sin in The Scarlet Letter

867 words - 3 pages Sin is defined as a transgression of a religious or moral law especially when deliberate. In The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne one of the main points in the book is relating to sin and how it can affect people. Hawthorne uses several methods to convey the nature of sin through his characters and symbolism in The Scarlet Letter. The scarlet A on the chest of Hester Prynne and Hester herself represent known sin. She commits adultery...

The Concepts Of Morality And Sin In The Scarlet Letter

1250 words - 5 pages The Concepts of Morality and Sin in the Scarlet Letter Many interpret The Scarlet Letter as a story based on love and passion. In his Criticism "The Scarlet Letter as a Love Story" Ernest Sandeen writes about the "erotic passion" and "courtly love" displayed in the novel, and he calls it "Hawthorne's own version of the...