This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Resource Curse: Democracy And The Developing World

1666 words - 7 pages

When a country strikes oil, or some other valuable natural resource, they may take it as a blessing; however, this discovery is often very destructive. Recent studies in social sciences suggest that developing countries with resource wealth tend to have political crises. This paradox is called the resource curse- the political counterpart of the infamous Dutch disease (Lam et al., 2002)*. In this paper I will argue how this phenomenon not only impedes the development of liberal democracies in non-democratic regimes, but also how it actively destroys liberal values in developing democracies. In specific, I will discuss how political instability, socio-economic disparities and political appeasement produced by resource wealth tend undermine the values of liberal democracy in the developing world.

Special attention must be given to the claim that weak institutions are to blame for this decrease in democracy rather than resource wealth in itself (Lam et al., 2002). I concede that this is partially true, however, weak institutions and the resource curse are by no means mutually exclusive. By definition, undeveloped countries have weak institutions; likewise, countries with weak institutions are generally undeveloped. Since this paper focuses particularly on developing resource rich states, this criticism is not detrimental- but rather complimentary to my argument.

When it comes to undeveloped countries, the discovery of valuable resources can easily lead to resource dependence (Wantchekon, 1999: Anderson, 1995, p. 33 *; Robinson, 2006). As a result, political repression and political laziness often run rampant. Under these circumstances the incumbent party is almost always re-elected because of the appeasive payoffs that they are able to finance from resource wealth (Wantchekon, 1999, p. 20). Unreasonably low taxes, subsidized employment and other such policies are the usual culprits (Anderson, 1995, p. 32; Robinson, 2006 *) . Furthermore, these types of policies are almost always adverse to the long-term interests of the economy and society- yet somehow they are still almost always employed. This has the eventual effect of creating voter apathy- or at least citizen apathy.
Because the incumbent leadership tends to stay in control, power is consolidated into one group, effectively creating a single-party dictatorship (Wantchekon, 1999, p.20-21 *: Robinson, 2006). Dictatorial regimes trivially make transitions to democracy very hard, therefore, this consolidation of power impedes the development of democracy.
In such cases, it is not uncommon for the ruling regime to forgo constitutional measures in to accumulate personal wealth... (Caselli, 2006; Lam et al., 2002, p. 10). Even under benevolent leadership, the government may see to forgo constitutional measures to expedite production in an attempt to boost economic growth- an act that in their view would be in the best interest of society (Norman, 2001, p. 11).

Find Another Essay On The Resource Curse: Democracy and the Developing World

Curse of the Pharaoh Essay

1361 words - 6 pages The Curse of the Pharaoh, King Tutankhamen, is world renowned and a very popular book and movie topic. Although these works are interesting, they do not cover the entire story. There is so much more to the curse that many people do not know. As you read this paper, you will begin to understand the truth of the curse, not what Hollywood wants you to know. So, what is the curse? The Curse of the Pharaoh was uncovered after the discovery of

Curse of the Pyncheons Essay

822 words - 4 pages The House of The Seven Gables by Nathaniel Hawthorne chronicles the generations of a Puritan family and the curse which haunts their fates. Although the Pyncheons are a respected family in their small Massachusetts town, their past is riddled with secrets, mysterious deaths, and the curse of a dying man. Few in the family ever believed in the curse, giving the generational disasters of the family the name of coincidental misfortunes, the simple

The Presidency and Democracy

1469 words - 6 pages The Presidency and Democracy To evaluate the position of the president, the concept of democracy must first be considered. Most Americans simply assume that the United States is a democracy. However, before such an assumption is made it is wise to understand the common definition of the word democracy. The Random House College Dictionary defines democracy as, “Government by the people; a form of government in which the supreme

The Internet and Democracy

970 words - 4 pages voting discriminates against societies have-nots, as well as those citizens that are not technically savvy; namely the older generation. It is also apparent that Internet voting is not one hundred percent secure, and that voting results can be manipulated. However her boldest claim by far is that Internet voting is a detriment to the traditional definition of representative democracy. Her reason for this is that though Internet voting has the

Democracy and the Internet

1559 words - 6 pages As the times change, so does the latest technology. In the mid-1900's it was the television, before that the radio, and now in the late-20th and 21st century we have the internet. With the coming of every new media outlet audiences and media moguls migrate. Along with the migrations are the politicians who try to use the new form of media to more easily reach the public. It's come to the point where the internet increasingly work with democracy

Andre Dubus' The Curse

979 words - 4 pages Andre Dubus' The Curse 'The Curse'; by Andre Dubus is about Mitchell Hayes, a forty-nine year old bartender who is witness to a rape. The rape occurs right before closing when five bikers rape a young woman while holding Mitchell at bay. After the rape, Mitchell is distraught over his decision of not making a stronger attempt to help the girl. Police, family and friends try to comfort Mitchell by telling him he made the right decision

Breaking The Curse

670 words - 3 pages Breaking The Curse Smoking is one of the biggest problems globally. There are nearly 1 billion smokers in the world, and the number is increasing every year. Smoking can lead to really bad health consequences, but the curse can be broken through several steps such as acknowledging the consequences, improving mentally, and keeping yourself busy. First of all, smoking causes a lot of cancers diseases such as Leukaemia, tongue cancer, and lung

The Media and Democracy

727 words - 3 pages In the McChesney reading, he takes on the role of media in the process of democracy. In modern times Americans are more glued to media than they have ever been. At the time when McChesney wrote his book, he states that the average person consumed 11.8 hours of media per day. While some people may find this number high, it is a realistic number. Between audio and visual media, it is hard to totally disconnect from whatever the media wants you

The Dreaded Curse

815 words - 3 pages The Dreaded Curse The dark and dingy room swayed before his bloodshot eyes, he had not been sleeping for days. The trees outside shook in the strong wind as though their arms were waving helplessly. The cracked glass in the window was razor sharp: daring somebody to come and test its sharpness. The sofa was black with grime and incredibly sunk in; the putrid smell that wafted in the air was almost unbearable, the wallpaper was peeling off the

The Curse of Artemis

1120 words - 5 pages , folding one of his jumpers. “I guess eating didn’t cross anyone’s mind.” Harry sorted his own clothes into a pile. “But a tent and healing supplies. She thought further ahead then we did.” Harry nudged Ron. Ron picked up a bottle, “Dittany,” he read aloud. “I know what you’re thinking Ron, to use the cloak to steal food.” “We haven’t got any choice Hermione. I know we’re meant to be saving the world and all, but you can’t forget basic things

The Curse of Competition

1987 words - 8 pages future. Clearly, the curse of competition is a farce. In a variety of aspects of life, competition continues to play its role. Most importantly, a competitive nature is known to keep all competitors at their personal best. As long as there is competition, the world will continue to grow and change for the better. Despite potential downfalls, competition has proven to be essential in the world today. Works Cited Bannister, Robert C. "Social

Similar Essays

The Resource Curse And Development Essay

2175 words - 9 pages In another study by Arezki and van der Ploeg provide a new cross-country empirical proof for resource curse effect. They cast a research based on World Bank’s World Development Indicators and conclude that there is a strong negative relationship between natural resources and income per capita. However de jure openness—which means ‘the number of years that a country is rated open to international trade’—and de facto trade openness—which means

Developing The Third World Essay

2218 words - 9 pages population in developing nations, live below the poverty line (United Nations, 2009). Therefore it can be suggested that 1-3 billion people live in poverty or about 20% of the global population (the World Bank Group). Poverty is an issue as the poor are deprived of their basic needs and resources needed in order to survive, such as lack of food, shelter, clothing, and clean drinking water as well as access to health care, education and employment. It

Food Security In The Developed And The Developing World

1661 words - 7 pages 2050(Global Food Security A, ND). This will negatively affect food security. The purpose of this essay is to compare and contrast food security in the developed and the developing world. The essay is organized as follows; elaborating on developed and developing countries, focusing on three main factors which impact on food security will be evaluated respectively. Specific examples will also be provided with the similarities and differences

The Oil Curse Essay

2866 words - 11 pages as the “resource curse”. The resource curse is commonly defined as the relationship between a country’s excessive amount of natural resources and slow economic growth and developmental outcomes as opposed to other developing nations with less natural resources. In Saudi Arabia, it is oil that holds this debilitating effect, and like so many other countries plagued by the “resource curse”, the country has seen little liberal institutional reform