The So Called 'road Map To Peace' Looks In Many Ways More Like A 'road Map To War'. How Far Would You Agree With This Assessment Of Us Efforts To Settle The Palestinian Question?

2845 words - 11 pages

On September 17 2002 the Bush Administration made the unprecedented move of acknowledging the Palestinian right to a state - the first time any US government had done so, and with the backing of the UN, the EU and Russia (the 'quartet') the 'Road Map to Peace' was shaped - a plan that would result in an independent Palestinian state alongside Israel. It is no secret that the US have been a strong supporter of Israel. The legitimacy of a US-backed peace plan, then, can be seriously questioned. The 'Road Map to Peace' is clearly biased, and while Israel ignore and refuse to adhere to elements of the 'Road Map' the US look the other way and in some instances actually validate Israel's actions. The peace plan puts a high amount of pressure on Palestinians who clearly don't have the strength or resources to carry out the plan. The plan states that Palestinian militant groups must disarm, but if the Palestinian Authority (PA) tried to enforce this it could lead to civil war. The road map specifies that by 2005, the Palestinians would have their own state. It is now nearing 2006 and any vision of a Palestinian state is looking more remote as Israel usurp more land by the day. Since the introduction of the road map the country has continued to see the endless cycle of suicide bombings and Israeli retaliation - the violence that permeates everyday life in Israel/Palestine, but no road to peace.Only war.The aim of the Road Map to Peace is to end the Israeli occupation of Palestinian territory that began in 1967, in accordance with UN Security Council resolutions 242 and 338. The Road Map is divided into three phases- the first phase states that Palestine are to cease all acts of violence, and Israel are to immediately withdraw from settlements built since March 2001. Israeli forces are also to withdraw from the Occupied Territories. During phase two, which was expected to be implemented by December 2003, a Palestinian state was to emerge, and by 2005 phase three would see a peace treaty to settle the most contentious aspects of the conflict, namely control of Jerusalem, the Palestinian capital, and the right of return for Palestinian refugees. At the present time the 'road' to peace has only been travelled so far as a little way into phase one.From the outset the road map was internationally criticised. Even a US official believed that the odds of success were 'not that good'. The language has been described as 'vague' and 'non constraining on Israel', it does not specify where the road map is leading and hence offers no incentive for completion. The International Crisis Group (ICG) have said that elements of the peace plan 'lack definition', and each element could easily provoke 'interminable disputes between the two sides'. Furthermore, the ICG claim the peace plan does not even offer a cessation of conflict. Rabbi M. Lerner asserts that another major weakness in the road map is the provision that there be an end to all violence. This, he claims, allows...

Find Another Essay On The so-called 'Road Map to Peace' looks in many ways more like a 'Road Map to War'. How far would you agree with this assessment of US efforts to settle the Palestinian Question?

"The Catholics were never a serious threat to Elizabethan Church and State." How far do you agree with this statement?

1773 words - 7 pages it. It could be that by this point in the reign, its effective incitements of civil war were unpalatable to the weakened religious minority, with the 1569 Northern Rebellion fresh in their minds as an example of how disorganised and scattered they had become. The execution of Mary Queen of Scots in 1587, when the Catholics lost their figurehead, and the hope of regaining the throne, could be seen as the final nail in their coffin, but in truth

"The real interest in Medea is that Euripides can make Medea so appalling without losing our sympathy for her." How far would you agree with this comment?

715 words - 3 pages despise his character, leading to more sympathy for Medea.Although the act of infanticide shocks us all, we are able to form an understanding of why she commits the murderous acts. Medea's fall into the bottomless pit of vengeance is all due to the unfaithful and selfish acts of Jason. We are able to sympathize with Medea for all tragedies that have been bought upon her and acknowledge the pain she suffers as a betrayed wife, an insulted princess, an exiled mother and a despised foreigner. Euripides truly succeeds in attaining our sympathy for Medea despite her horrendous acts of infanticide and murder.References:Euripides, Medea

March 2nd 2004 "The weakness of peace treaties is that they tend to address the past war rather than the future peace." With reference to WWI, show how far you concur with this assertion?

1145 words - 5 pages provisions surrounding the Versailles treaty included reparations of 33 billion US Dollars and that the Saar Basin, an industrial region with many natural resources in southern Germany, was given to France for 15 years. The fact that Germany was not invited to this treaty shows that the war victors were more interested in punishing Germany and influencing the way that Germany would be run than assuring a long lasting peace for Europe and the world.The

"Ideological differences played little part in the origin of the Cold War." How far do you agree with this judgment?

645 words - 3 pages opposite to communist ideology, which was about a one-party state where all was state-owned. A communist Russia would be a threat to the interests of the West. Although ideology was an important factor here, to say that this sole event was the origin of the Cold War would be ignoring significant events that occurred in following years.In 1933, Roosevelt became president of the US and recognized the USSR. If ideology were so important, would the

"The English Teacher" by RK Narayan: How far would you agree with the statement: "Dr. Shankar is to be blamed for Susila's death"?

871 words - 3 pages instances in the novel which showcases Dr. Shankar's foolhardy ways. One classic example is his reply to Krishna's plea for him to pay Susila a visit. His presumptuousness shone through as he snapped "Oh, no, it is just malaria. I have fifty cases like this on hand, no need to see her. Just peep into that room and see how many persons with fever have come here." Dr. Shankar had implied that he is very sure Susila's illness is no different from the fifty

"The Soviet Union should be responsible for the Cold War, instead of the USA." How far do you agree to this statement?

1287 words - 5 pages economy so that it could resist communism. In theory, East European nations could join the plan but Americans made it clear that communist states were not welcomed. The Truman Doctrine and Marshall Plan were aimed to minimize influence of communism from spreading into Eastern Europe. More importantly, this indirectly condemned communist ideals of Russia, posing a direct threat to Russia's spread of communism. This inevitably created tension and

"The Wingfields and their gentleman caller are all dreamers." How far do you agree with this assessment of the characters in "The Glass Menagerie"?

1263 words - 5 pages :"One Sunday afternoon in Blue Mountain, your mother received- seventeen!- gentleman callers."The word "dreamer" in this instance implied that she regularly "dreams" about her past in order to escape the reality of her financial situation and her frustration with Laura. Therefore, in this context, Amanda is a "dreamer". On the other hand, in regards to Amanda wanting Laura to get married, is not quite a dream, but more of an "obsession", as

C.W.E. Bigsby suggests the Glass Menagerie asserts that people 'desire to live with comforting fictions, rather than confront brutal truths.' How far do you agree with this?

1663 words - 7 pages C.W.E. Bigsby suggests that the play asserts that people 'desire to live with comforting fictions, rather than confront brutal truths, a doomed and ultimately deadly strategy. It is a bleak vision of life.'How far do you agree with this evaluation of 'The Glass Menagerie'?In The Glass Menagerie none of the characters are capable of living completely in their present circumstances. They all retreat into their own little worlds to escape the

"Hamlet": how would you do the film? what would you change?.. Introduction question to the play

650 words - 3 pages you trust the ghost? How would you check out his story? What would you do about bringing the murderer to justice?I think that I will trust the ghost but I will try to find a way to resolve this mistery. I will try to find a legal way to find justice about my father's death and make this person pay for what he/she did.3. You are a young woman very much in love with your boyfriend who, you have always believed, returns your love. You are confident

Robert N. Watson suggests that Volpone exposes ‘the fundamental human tendency […] to live in grandiose egoistical fantasies rather than in the real world’. How far do you agree with the suggestion...

1625 words - 7 pages Robert N. Watson suggests that Volpone exposes 'the fundamental human tendency […] to live in grandiose egoistical fantasies rather than in the real world'. How far do you agree with the suggestion that this is the source of the play's comedy?Ben Jonson frames Volpone by reminding the reader of its didactic value. In the Prologue, he wishes 'To mix profit, with our pleasure' (8), a line which puns comedy as a form of moral instruction

Justice and Peace: The Road to Christian Salvation

1734 words - 7 pages Justice and Peace: The Road to Christian Salvation War appears to be the most vicious and unpleasant form of human interaction. No other setting allows people to kill each other in such substantial numbers or to cause such incredible and extensive distress. Wars often take many years to develop and they can last for years longer than that and the effects duplicate for decades and even centuries afterwards. A question that is frequently

Similar Essays

The United States Road Map To World Peace And Security

1100 words - 4 pages , France, China, Russia, and United Kingdom. Today, there are 188 parties to the treaty that agreed not to develop nuclear weapons nor be a recipient of these weapons. In September 26, 2009, the President of the United States, Mr. Barack Obama addressed the United Nations and promised to negotiate with Russia for more nuclear weapons reduction, end nuclear testing, and reduce the role of nuclear weapon in the defense and security policies of the

Metternich Has Been Referred To As The Greatest Challenge To German Nationalism In The So Called 'vormarz' Years. How Far Would You Agree?

1014 words - 4 pages of the Holy Alliance summarises his involvement during the 'Vormärz' years.However, the reason Metternich opposed a united Germany was because the Austro-Hungarian Empire did not embrace a single people speaking one language, but many peoples speaking different languages. The empire would not easily fit into a united Germany and if nationalism spread in neighbouring Germany it would surely spread into Austria and not only present a threat to

'the Aristodikos Is So Convincingly Realistic And Looks So Much Like A Living Man...' [Woodford]. How Far Do You Agree With Woodford's Opinion?

1082 words - 4 pages taken by the sculptor of the Aristodikos which bring it closer to looking like a real person in comparison to other Archaic statues is the way the hair has been sculpted. Previous sculptures like the New York Kouros and even the more naturalistic Anavyssos have long beaded hair, a feature taken from Egyptian sculpture. This way of portraying the hair was un-naturalistic to the Greek sculptors and the creator of the Aristodikos has dealt with this in

"In This War With No Front Lines On A Map, Never Was Intelligence More Essential But Seldom Has Intelligence Performed So Poorly." Discuss In Regard To Vietnam, 1962 72.

2856 words - 11 pages "In this war with no front lines on a map, never was intelligence more essential - but seldom has intelligence performed so poorly." Discuss in regard to Vietnam, 1962-72.Even though the US had some of the finest intelligence services in the world, the disaster at Pearl Harbour on Sunday 7 December 1941 took the Americans completely by surprise even though they were listening to Japan's most secret radio traffic and there were many signs that