The Spirit In Context Essay

2428 words - 10 pages

What are the possible points of agreement and points of tension between different religious schools of thought on the body, in relation to the Holy Spirit? How might Christians respond to these?

Introduction
Scripture seems to contradict itself with regard to the human body. Sometimes the body is seen as precious, for instance in 1 Cor 6:19-30, and sometimes as a hinderance to unity with Christ, 2 Cor 5:6-8. This seeming ambiguity within scripture has created distinct and conflicting schools of thought among Christian thinkers regarding the body and spirituality. Some advocate that the body is an essential part of our spirituality and should be embraced; others that the body is a hinderance to it, and should be approached with suspicion and contempt.

The subject of the body and spirituality is vast. Therefore, this essay will focus on two differing schools of thought pertaining to the body: Dualism and Holism. After defining each and giving examples from history, the tensions and agreements between the two theories will be discussed. Finally, I will suggest how Christians might respond in a balanced way.

Dualism: The division of a thing into two contrasting or opposed elements. In terms of body Dualism, the separation of the human being into two opposing parts - body and spirit.

The Greek philosopher Plato viewed the body as something which contaminated the soul with it’s imperfection. It was a hinderance to attaining truth and should be avoided except where absolutely necessary. The pursuit was to become purified from it ‘until God himself gives us deliverance’.1
Early Christian writers, such as Philo of Alexandria, were influenced by Plato’s school of thought and, in his attempt to marry Greek and Jewish philosophy, developed a dualistic interpretation of body-related scripture, advocating that purification occurs in mind, leaving man with no need for the body.2 Philo influenced later writers such as Clement of Alexandria and Origen.3 While not a full proponent of developing Gnosticism movement, which taught that communion with God was only possible apart from the body, Clement taught that Jesus did not inhabit a physical body, ‘but rather a heavenly one that was free of all bodily needs and passions’.4

Dualism can also be seen in monastic history. Anthony of the Desert, who is considered to be the father of Christian monasticism, is said to have experienced overwhelming shame at the prospect of food, rest and other bodily needs, so that he would not be seen taking care of his physical needs by others.5
St Francis of Assisi was equally undermining of his bodily needs. Even when close to death, he feared that accepting necessary treatment was an indulgence. It was only at the last minute that he was successfully persuaded to serve his body by caring for it in the same way that it had cared for him, by which point it was too late.

Dualism continued through the ages in various forms, but was specifically revived during the Age of...

Find Another Essay On The Spirit In Context

The Importance of Context in Understanding Literature

3857 words - 15 pages an attempt to discover the meaning of a word in a poem or the poem as a whole does one thing- that is, he substitutes one word for another or indulges in a play with words. Reader Response critics believed that the meaning lies not in the texts but in the minds of the reader. For them, a text does not exist without a reader. They, too, focused on a context but from a point of view of the reader. The readers according to his/her own experience

The Subjection of Women: In Today’s Context

1339 words - 5 pages education, women conform into believing that conventional “womanly” characters were most desirable. Mill’s analysis is grounded in the context of Victorian period Britain, where conservative ideals were common in practice and in law. Mill’s analysis of the subjection of women can most clearly be seen through Victorian conservatism. In mid-Victorian Britain women were denied entry into higher education, many male professions and completely from

The Five Precepts in the Context of The Eightfold Path

2484 words - 10 pages The Five Precepts in the Context of The Eightfold Path Both 'The Five Precepts' and 'The Eightfold Path' are significant elements of the Buddhist religion. The precepts act as a guide for the average everyday lay Buddhist on how to create the least amount of karmic energy possible. It by no means is the way directly to reaching Nirvana. The Eightfold Path however, is known as "the way." It is, in itself, the Fourth

The Rise of Asian Women in the Context of Globalization

1055 words - 4 pages overcome their "future shock" aroused by globalization, some Asian women have already risen to the positive and negative challenges of globalization, and they have become role models for a new generation in the context of globalization. Globalization is characterized by the worldwide development of technology and economy to make the whole world into a global village. This knowledge-based context underscores the importance of education. The Asian woman

Historical Context of The Jewel in the Crown

801 words - 3 pages Historical Context of The Jewel in the Crown   The historical context of Paul Scott's novel - The Jewel in the Crown - serves to explain and interpret a tragic love story between two characters; Daphne Manners and Hari Kumar. The love story serves to clarify and interpret the social/racial and historical significance of the time period in which it is set - 1942.  Their love - a product as well as a victim of the time and events

The significance of Reparations in the context of mass atrocity

5086 words - 20 pages Hugh Munro 73876776 DIPL403: Ethics and International Relations Research PaperThe Significance of Reparative Justice in the Context of Mass Atrocity:By Hugh MunroReparations are often described as those measures which are taken to eliminate the moral dissonance that exists between perpetrator and victim after the former acts in a way that harms or violates the rights of the latter. The perpetrator of such an act is said to have an obligation to

The Efficacy of Deposit Insurance in the Australian Context

5068 words - 20 pages insurance) is the subject of sharp debate between policy-makers and academics. While the former believe that deposit insurance is crucial to saving depositors from failed banks, the latter counter this by citing cases were the introduction of deposit insurance has led to the increased bank risk-taking and moral hazard. This paper seeks to clarify the applicability of this research in the local context, showing that the Australian banking system

Discuss the importance of context in understanding language play.

1582 words - 6 pages In understanding the importance of context within language play I would like to define and explain exactly what language play encompasses. Beard (2007, p.83) defines language play as a feature of many types of discourse, both spoken and written. It can be found in several arenas such as general conversation, literature, advertising, news and song. Cook (2000 p.122) splits the features of language play into three categories: linguistic form

The Universe in a Cultural Context by Gumerman and Warburton

1591 words - 6 pages In the Essay written by Gumerman, George J. and Warburton, Miranda 'The Universe in a Cultural Context: An Essay', in Fountain, John W. and Sinclair, Rolf M (eds.) Current Studies in Archaeastronomy : Conversations Across Time and Space, Durham NC.; Carolina Academic Press 2005 pp 15-24, the authors Gumerman and Warburton have presented a paper promoting the value of Archaeoastronomical studies being integrated into the

Concept of Security in the Context of International Relations

2287 words - 9 pages ) and free from doubt. National Insecurity In the context of the international security system is the ability of states and societies to maintain the identity and integrity of their functional independence. To achieve security, sometimes the state and society are in a state of harmony or otherwise. In the study of international relations and international political, security is an important concept that is always used and seen as an exclusive

Educational Literacy in the Context of Environmental Ethics

3559 words - 14 pages Educational Literacy in the Context of Environmental Ethics ABSTRACT: I explore the concept of literacy and the role it might play in environmental ethics. One of the goals of environmental ethics is to describe and contribute to the creation of an ecologically responsible culture. The creation of such a culture requires the development of knowledge and abilities that will help sustain such a culture. Since education is one of the key

Similar Essays

The Value Of Unity In Spirit

2678 words - 11 pages more than a restatement of American history. It is a penetratingly tragic reality that awakens the human heart. Through foreshadowing and the harsh realities of California, Steinbeck develops Tom Joad as a tragic hero illustrating the value of unity in spirit; the holiness that is found within men when they share in common purpose to create harmony. Traveling home with the expectation of seeing his family as he left them, Tom comes across a turtle

The Founding Fathers In Context Essay

2212 words - 9 pages Marx without looking at the context in which his ideas were born. “The vocabulary that served to describe traditional social relationships simply could not grip the experience of the present with any precision”(Abrams, 1972, p. 26), so Marx had to create this own. He witnessed the Industrial Revolution and was horrified by what he came to see. This was in large part due to the concept he focused a lot his attention on alienation. The dramatic

Differences In The Father, The Son, And The Holy Spirit

751 words - 3 pages Differences in the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit The disciples of Jesus Christ were called to ?baptize all nations in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit (Matt 28:19)?. The book made it clear that God exists as three Persons, which is known as the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. There are some differences between These Three but they are one and united. We are asked by God to bring His message of

The Methodology Of Context In Photography

1849 words - 8 pages , is the context in which it is meant to be viewed by a particular audience. One single picture, after all, could appear drastically different alongside an article in a newspaper than it would if it were to be framed and hung alongside other photos on a museum wall. This idea is especially prevalent in the pieces shown in the exhibition Freedom Now! Forgotten Photographs of the Civil Rights Struggle, wherein several photos are both seen as a