The Spirit Versus The Word Of The Law: The Consequences Of Sherlock Holmes's Criminal Characteristics

2049 words - 8 pages

To even consider Sherlock Holmes, the most magnificent criminal investigator and analytical thinker ever written about, a mastermind criminal may be proclaimed preposterous blasphemy by many. Upon further investigation, however, one finds that Holmes possesses many characteristics that would make him the ideal criminal. For example, Holmes has the intellectual ability and savvy to pull off an elaborate crime with enough misdirection and confusion to not only avoid his own arrest but also produce more than sufficient evidence to incarcerate any number of perfectly innocent individuals. This capacity of Holmes's genius, along with his innate ability to disguise his physical being and transform his mannerisms, removing his individualism and making him just another face in the crowd, would make any legal pursuit impossible. Furthermore, his stature in the minds of the public as a keeper of peace who remains loyal to the spirit of the law and protects what is principally important cannot be underestimated. The most telling characteristic, however, is that Holmes appears to consider himself above the law and shows the willingness in some of his cases to engage in criminal activity as he deems necessary. The implausible assertion then becomes a feasible possibility that through his brilliant intellect, furtive disguising, and familiarity with the criminal underground of England, Sherlock Holmes could become the greatest criminal mastermind to ever live. The prospect of Holmes as a criminal, therefore, illustrates that the intention of Holmes's practice deviates from that of the appointed law enforcement, in that Holmes enforces the spirit of the law, even at the sacrifice of upholding the written law.Holmes's extensive knowledge and keen intellect are significant factors in what make him a great detective, but they are also characteristics that would serve him well as a criminal genius. As Stephen Knight observes, "the overt techniques of science, the careful collection and rational analysis of information, were realised in Sherlock Holmes" (369). This ability to collect information and analyze it scientifically would allow Sherlock Holmes as a criminal to conspire and plan methods of intrusion that would go virtually undetected. As in "Charles Augustus Milverton," when Holmes collects information for days prior to breaking in, he could indelibly find a way to put himself in the positions necessary to solve the case at hand. This differs from the routine of traditional law enforcement where more direct, legal methods would be used to gather information and there would be little use for covert operation.Another advantage of his knowledge and experience is that Holmes almost always knows the result before he tests his hypotheses. This is similar to the procedure used by many detectives except that, unlike his counterparts, Sherlock Holmes very rarely confers any colleagues in the formation of his assessments. For example, in "A Scandal in Bohemia," he...

Find Another Essay On The Spirit versus the Word of the Law: The Consequences of Sherlock Holmes's Criminal Characteristics

The Personality of Sherlock Holmes Essay

916 words - 4 pages possesses a very interesting set of personality and his distinctive characteristics plays a big role in captivating the heart of the audience. So, who is Sherlock? What kind of person could draw many people’s attention? Early In “A Scandal in Bohemia”, Dr Watson, Sherlock’s faithful companion, describes Sherlock as “bohemian” in habits and lifestyle. He loathed from every form of society by burying among his old books, and alternating

The Influence of Sherlock Holmes Essay

1503 words - 7 pages , there have been more than fifty film adaptations of the Sherlock Holmes stories, and over one hundred adaptations in books and novels. One hundred and seven actors have played the famous detective, and seventy-seven actors have played the role of the detective’s assistant Dr. Watson. Many fans are waiting for the release of the third Sherlock Holmes movie, directed by Guy Ritchie and starring Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law as the famous duo

The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

1794 words - 8 pages The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes is one of those well-written fictions which can drive the readers right into the plot and can make you dissolve into the whole plot. It becomes really difficult to stop going through the whole plot once you have started reading it. It is that strength of words which has been efficiently utilized by the author making this whole book a real adventure for the readers. Once the readers have started the book, it

Spirit Of The Game

673 words - 3 pages The Spirit of the Game This was one of the most inspiring books I have ever read. It spoke about periods of time throughout the evolving of one of Americas most intense and loved games. The book was split up into two large sections and then divided into chapters inside the sections. The first section was called The Spirit. The first chapter of this section deals with the early stages of development in the game. From the beginning hockey was

The Spirit of Life

3012 words - 12 pages their own limbs off. Destruction defies “real” organisms’ capacity for logic. The emotional component of the spirit of Life The picture begins with Professor Hobby (William Hurt) addressing his team of robot designers and challenging them to create a robot child that is truly capable of loving; a robot that goes beyond sensations and can express, and understand emotions. Professor Hobby’s point is made when he pricks the robot Sheila (Sabrina

The Consensus Theory of Criminal Law

870 words - 3 pages The consensus theory of criminal law contents that society finds its own way and it is product of social needs and values, it also serves the interest of society at large. Rules are for the community to control themselves and to put order. If a crime is committed it is punished by what the society considers appropriate. The significance of that crime has to be evaluated by the same society as well as the punishment

The spirit of the human

1097 words - 5 pages Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power. As Abraham Lincoln has stated, the human soul has and can survive many atrocious and scarring things. It is also stated that to find to true intent of a person’s heart is by providing an individual with power. People have been able to overcome many hard and “impossible” obstacles in this life. It is the human spirit that pushed and pushed to use those

The Spirit Of The Coin

8854 words - 35 pages The Spirit of the Coin"You've gone mad, haven't you?" Amy squealed. Rachel looked towards the cheer squad indifferently. Amy looked at Rachel in complete disbelief. Amy held the Chemistry paper that belonged to Rachel swiftly in front of her. Amy has lost her will to tell Rachel to try harder. Amy sat down dismally, and turned her head to Rachel who didn't look back. She shook her head slowly.Rachel had always been Amy's best friend since

Sherlock Holmes: The Hounds Of The Baskervilles

812 words - 3 pages Sherlock Holmes, The Hound of the Baskervilles.Author: Arthur Conan Doyle.Does this book have an introduction? No this book does not have an introduction.Does it have a preface? No this book does not have a preface.After reading the preface, what you learn? Although there was not a preface to this book, I learned from the retrospection and after-word that Mr. Stapleton was the killer of Sir Charles Baskerville. In a retrospection it told you the

Sherlock Holmes' The Hound of the Baskervilles

2874 words - 11 pages Sherlock Holmes' The Hound of the Baskervilles Introduction Sherlock Holmes story, 'The Hound of the Baskervilles' was popular when published and still remains so today for a variety of reasons. Back in the Victorian period crimes stories were very well-liked by the general public. A police force had just been formed and many people didn't yet know how it worked. Crime was on the rise and it wasn't safe to walk

The Power of School Spirit

962 words - 4 pages What do student athletes and coaches desire more of? What do teachers and administrators demand more of? School spirt answers both questions. Many schools across the nation do not grasp the importance of school spirit. School spirit has the power to perform miracles in the athletic and educational world, and schools have taken notice. Student athletes and coaches crave more school spirit because enthusiasm from a crowd provides a team with

Similar Essays

Comparison Of Characteristics And Perceptions Of The Qld Criminal Justice System, Aboriginal Customary Law And Islamic Criminal Law According To Crime And Punishment Procedures

2946 words - 12 pages 1.0 INTRODUCTIONThis report is focused on a comparison of three criminal justice systems. The model systems are the Queensland Criminal Justice System, Islamic Law and Australian Aboriginal Customary Law.Each criminal justice system model has been researched according to their Origin and Characteristics, standard and Burdon of proof, presumption of innocence, punishments for crimes committed with particularreference to retribution, deterrence

Sherlock Holmes's The Speckled Band Essay

1099 words - 4 pages Sherlock Holmes's The Speckled Band Sir Arthur Conan Doyle wrote many fictional detective stories. His first story "A Study in Scarlett" was published in 1887. Since then he has written many more. The famous detective in all his stories is Sherlock Holmes who also has an associate called Dr Watson. Sherlock Holmes became a household name usually pictured with a hat and magnifying glass. "The Speckled Band" was one of

The Spirit Of The Law Essay

1221 words - 5 pages wanted to place Tracy out of her misery. Jean Jacques Rousseau, a famous French philosopher, based a handful of his theoretical perspectives on the Spirit of the Law. He believed that people deserved freedom. Laws are vague and rely on the interpretation of individuals. It is evident that the sentence given to Mr. Latimer was not interpreted through the eyes of a father but a criminal. Although he did break the laws against euthanasia and

The Consequences Of Being A Criminal

1348 words - 5 pages Why obey the law? A better question would be: why not obey the law? All our lives we have been taught to do the right thing in bad situations. As children, this worked well; but, as we got older, we found that doing the wrong thing pays off. As they say, crime pays. This may be true in the short run, but it isn't so in the long run. Straying from crime not only keeps you out of jail, but it can help build better relationships, create a more