The Stakeholder Society: A Rawlsian Interpretation

1591 words - 6 pages

In Bruce Ackerman and Anne Alstott’s The Stakeholder Society, a sweeping proposal is introduced to tackle what the authors view as a widening inequality of opportunity within a system that reinforces this disparity. They claim that these growing economic disparities are “profoundly shaping the future of the next generation,” and that, without intervention, long-held distinctly American tenets will disappear from the moral horizon. The authors’ proposed solution is a stakeholding program, whereby all adults upon reaching the age of twenty-one would be guaranteed a sum of eighty thousand dollars, to be spent as they see fit. While the initial goal of the plan is to address economic inequality through redistribution, the authors extend this hope, asserting, “Through stakeholding, Americans can win a renewed sense that they do indeed live in a land of equal opportunity, where all have a fair chance.” This speaks more to a revival of a common citizenship rather than a mere redistribution. This paper will evaluate the proposal of a stakeholder society from the perspective of John Rawls’s work, A Theory of Justice, where Rawls introduces his notion of justice as fairness as a means to determine the moral validity of society’s basic institutions. This paper will attempt to reflect that, while influenced by a Rawlsian ideology, there are certain key differences between the ideals espoused by Rawls and by the authors. Moreover, it will show that while the plan would indeed serve to address certain societal issues, an assessment of its feasibility will prove critical.
Prior to a discussion of the plan’s value, it is necessary to more completely flesh out a description of the proposal. Firstly, the plan would be funded by an annual two percent tax on the nation’s wealth, and by repayments of the eighty thousand dollars upon death by those financially able to do so. Within ninety days of graduation, each person would be required to apply for his or her stake by presenting a diploma and other documentation to the stakeholding office. For three years thereafter, the individual would be unable to touch the money, however it would be invested in treasuries growing at market interest. Upon reaching twenty-one, each person would be allowed access to the first installment of twenty thousand dollars, with subsequent payments continuing for three years thereafter. Those who do not graduate high school would only be allowed to an annual market return of four thousand dollars, and would not be granted access to the principle save for certain endeavors, such as buying a house or returning to school. In addition, the proposal also includes a flat basic retirement pension based not on a person’s work history or wage rate.
For the authors, the plan is rooted in the ideal of fair and equal opportunity, which would appear to be motivated by Rawls’s Second Principle demand of fair equality of opportunity. Specifically, it would seem that this plan addresses the notion...

Find Another Essay On The Stakeholder Society: A Rawlsian Interpretation

Ethics and Social Responsibility/ Explain the role of ethics and social responsibility in developing a strategic plan while considering stakeholder needs and agendas.

753 words - 3 pages to be lost.The role of ethics and social responsibilityCorporations have a great deal of responsibility to their stakeholders to make the best decisions for them as possible. However, the decisions should not be unethical that the reputation of the corporation is jeopardized. "Ethical responsibilities of an organization's management are to follow the generally held beliefs about behavior in society (Wheelen and Hunger, p. 58)." The courtesy to the

The Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States. by Charles A. Beard

1231 words - 5 pages Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the U.S.The Constitution of the United States is a document that I have studied many times throughout my schooling in historical context. I never thought that the Constitution could be studied as an economic document with the reasons for its ratification being based on the economic interests of those writing it instead of the beneficial interests of the entire country. Charles A. Beard's, An

Hololiterature, a Holographic Interpretation of the "Scarlet Letter", by Nathaniel Hawthorne

1063 words - 4 pages an object moves during exposure in the resulting hologram there will be a black 'hole' where it was. Just as if someone rattles Puritan society a hole conveniently opens beneath their feet.The 'life-light' from the village and that from the forest are totally different. The hard coherent 'light' from the village marches on the forest, but the border between them refracts (bends) the 'light' and each tree attenuates (scatters) it until it is no

The Interpretation of the Catcher in Rye, including a characterisation of Holden, and many symbolic aspects of the book.

1038 words - 4 pages Adolescence is the most awkward time in one's life. Teens are on the brink of adulthood, but not yet fully emotionally developed. They experiment with dangerous substances such as drinking, smoking and sex in order to test their boundaries as individuals in society. Most of one's early life is spent being protected from the "real world" but inevitably the "real world" works its way into one's consciousness. Everyone experiences a day when they

The Society Lies Within a Mask

1886 words - 8 pages Sundaram 6Sharmindran1410C27488ENG4UMr. Colin Boucher6/11/2014The Society Lies within a MaskA society has the power and potential to influence an individual's mindset and behavior. Globally, each and every individual plays an important role in the society. In addition, the society also has the biggest potential to influence on an individual's life. Khaled Hosseini, the author of 'A Thousand Splendid Suns', his characters were given their own

The teacher in a developing democratic society

2482 words - 10 pages The teacher in a developing democratic societySouth Africa has not yet reached the level of democracy that should have reached after the 1994 elections. There are still major challenges experienced by the 21st Century society which some of them the country tried to overcome. These include inequality, globalization, unemployment, defence of freedom and knowledge society. These challenges have a major impact on the provision of education as well

The teacher in a developing democratic society

2482 words - 10 pages The teacher in a developing democratic societySouth Africa has not yet reached the level of democracy that should have reached after the 1994 elections. There are still major challenges experienced by the 21st Century society which some of them the country tried to overcome. These include inequality, globalization, unemployment, defence of freedom and knowledge society. These challenges have a major impact on the provision of education as well

The Colonies by 1763--A New Society

852 words - 3 pages colonies. The South was influenced by Anglicanism while the New England colonies were influenced by the Puritan Congregation. Although there were tax-supported churches in the colonies, there was still a degree of separation between church and state. However, in England, many aspects of society were still dominated by the powerful Anglican society. This religious disparity between old England and the new colonies served as a key in creating a new

The Effects of Media: A Brainwashed Society.

1309 words - 5 pages There is a power that the media holds that goes unnoticed by many people. Only 12% of the public thinks that media influences them (Johnston). Media should not have the power to set the standards for society because it influences our sense of appropriate expectations, it creates ideals for love and lifestyles, and it can expand or constrain our dreams for opportunity and self-actualization in people of all ages. Everyone has expectations in life

Role of the Majority in a Society

1142 words - 5 pages One of the defining principles of democratic society is the idea that “majority rules.” Despite the fundamental nature of this principle, it has been challenged by some of the greatest thinkers in history. Henry David Thoreau, Emmeline Pankhurst and Karl Marx are among these great thinkers who have commented on the role of the majority in different political and social situations. In works such as, “Civil Disobedience,” “Why We Are Militant

Plagiarism - A Severe Threat to the Society

1161 words - 5 pages Plagiarism - A Severe Threat to the Society Every day throughout the world, teachers strive to attain the most from their students in every aspect of life, from effective communication and language skills, to the development of individualism and the concept of being the best that you could be. With the use of exams, class discussions, and written assignments, educators subconsciously reinforce the idea that success can only be

Similar Essays

What Is The Role Of A Stakeholder In A Company?

986 words - 4 pages A stakeholder is “a person, group or organization that has interest or concern in an organization.” http://www.businessdictionary.com. Stakeholders are affected by the operations of the business and if the business is successful or unsuccessful. Internal Stakeholders Internal stakeholders are stakeholders who “benefit directly from their contributions to the growth of the company.” http://www.investorwords.com The internal stakeholders in

How Does Cloud Atlas Offer An Interpretation Of Marxism In A Highly Technological Society?

1490 words - 6 pages ‘From each according to his ability, to each according to his need’ is a slogan popularised by Karl Marx to illustrate a communist society which will produce an abundance of goods and services to satisfy everyone’s needs. It is important to note the significance of differing time periods – Marx wrote in the 19th century, whilst Cloud Atlas was written in 2004. Whilst Mitchell utilises aspects of Marxist theory in his novel; unlike Marx, he

Facing The Shadow: A Freudian And Jungian Dream Interpretation

1366 words - 5 pages Undiscovered Self with Symbols and the Interpretation of Dreams, Jung states that, "The archetype is...an inherited tendency of the human mind to form representations of mythological motifs - representations that vary a great deal without losing their basic pattern" (108). The description of archetypes given by Jung in this book certainly open the door for several other theories about the nature of dreams, since Freud's highly generalized "wish

The Fates Of Visionaries And The Nature Of Society Interpretation On Lord Of The Flies By William Golding

947 words - 4 pages concept of conventional slavery, the Pharaoh didn’twant to acknowledge a being higher than himself. If the idea of a person does not conform withthe rest of society or superiors, they are subject to be outcast.William Golding’s novel, Lord of the Flies, uses Simon a “Skinny, Vivid little boy” (24) torepresent Visionaries in our Society. Simon from the start of the novel was different, which did notsit well with the boys